FAMILY & MEDICAL LEAVE | 2026-11-18

CFRA Has No Key-Employee Exception: Reinstatement Rights in California 2026

Unlike the federal FMLA, the California Family Rights Act gives even the highest-paid workers a right to their job back after protected leave that does not depend on their salary.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

The California Family Rights Act promises eligible workers up to twelve weeks of job-protected leave and the right to return to the same or a comparable job. Unlike the federal FMLA, California eliminated its key-employee exception effective January 1, 2021, so even a company's highest earners c

The California Family Rights Act and the Promise of a Job to Return To

The California Family Rights Act, codified at Gov. Code § 12945.2, gives eligible California workers up to twelve workweeks of job-protected leave in a twelve-month period to bond with a new child, to care for a family member with a serious health condition, or to recover from the employee's own serious health condition. The statute does far more than grant unpaid time away from work. Its central guarantee is the right of reinstatement: when the leave ends, the employee must be restored to the same position, or to a comparable position with equivalent pay, benefits, shift, and working conditions. The implementing regulation, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11089, treats the denial of that guaranteed reinstatement as itself an unlawful interference with a protected right.

For high earners, the single most important feature of CFRA is one the statute contains by omission. CFRA once contained a key-employee escape hatch modeled on federal law, but SB 1383 deleted it effective January 1, 2021, and that choice changes everything for a salaried manager, a commissioned sales leader, or a senior professional who fears being shut out while on leave.

What a Key-Employee Exception Means Under Federal Law

The federal Family and Medical Leave Act, at 29 U.S.C. § 2614(b), allows a covered employer to deny reinstatement to a salaried employee who is among the highest-paid ten percent of the workforce within seventy-five miles, when restoring that employee would cause substantial and grievous economic injury to the employer's operations. The federal regulations at 29 C.F.R. §§ 825.217 through 825.219 fill in the definition and the mechanics. The employer must notify the employee of the key-employee status when it learns the employee intends to take leave or when leave begins, must explain the potential consequences, and must give the employee a chance to return once it decides it will deny restoration. In practice, the FMLA key-employee rule is a lawful way for a large employer to refuse to give a highly compensated worker the same job back.

CFRA Has No Key-Employee Exception at All

California made a different policy judgment. Nothing in Gov. Code § 12945.2, and nothing in the governing regulations at Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11089, permits an employer to deny reinstatement because the returning employee is highly paid or because restoring the position would be economically painful. The regulation lists the narrow defenses on which an employer may rely to decline reinstatement, and compensation level is not among them. A California employer that tries to borrow the federal key-employee defense is asserting a right that state law has not granted since 2021. That is the practical headline for anyone in the top tier of a company's pay scale: in California, your salary is not a reason you can be denied your job after protected family or medical leave.

Who Is Eligible for CFRA Leave

Since the 2021 expansion, CFRA applies to employers with five or more employees, a far broader reach than the FMLA threshold of fifty employees within seventy-five miles. To be eligible, a worker must have worked for the employer for more than twelve months and have logged at least 1,250 hours of service during the twelve months before leave begins. The twelve months of service need not be consecutive. Because the small-employer threshold is so low, many California workers who have no FMLA rights at all still have the full suite of CFRA protections, including the ironclad reinstatement right.

Qualifying Reasons for Protected Leave

CFRA leave is available to bond with a child within one year of birth, adoption, or foster placement; to care for a family member with a serious health condition; and for the employee's own serious health condition that makes the employee unable to perform essential job functions. The definition of family member is broad and includes a child, parent, spouse, domestic partner, grandparent, grandchild, sibling, and a designated person. Pregnancy disability is handled separately under Gov. Code § 12945, and CFRA bonding leave stacks on top of pregnancy disability leave, so a new parent can combine both. Readers weighing how the expanded family definition interacts with leave rights can review our discussion in our guide to domestic partner and expanded family-member leave under CFRA.

The Reinstatement Guarantee in Detail

Under Gov. Code § 12945.2 and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11089, the employee is entitled to the same or a comparable position on return. Comparable means virtually identical in pay, benefits, and other terms, involving the same or substantially similar duties and responsibilities, requiring substantially equivalent skill, effort, and authority, and performed at the same or a geographically proximate worksite, usually on the same shift. A demotion, a pay cut, a transfer to a dead-end role, or the loss of a bonus opportunity can all be interference with reinstatement, even when the employer calls the move a reorganization.

The Narrow Situations Where Reinstatement May Be Refused

The regulations recognize limited defenses. An employer need not reinstate an employee who would have been laid off or whose position would have been eliminated for legitimate business reasons unrelated to the leave, and the employer carries the burden to prove the employee would have lost the job anyway. An employee who fraudulently obtained or used leave also loses the job-restoration protection, with the employer bearing the burden of proving the fraud, and an employee still unable to work when CFRA leave runs out turns to FEHA disability-accommodation rights instead. None of these defenses turns on how much the employee earns, which is precisely why the missing key-employee exception matters.

How CFRA and the FMLA Run Together

When an employee is covered by both laws, the two generally run concurrently, and the employee gets the benefit of whichever law is more protective on any given point. On reinstatement of a highly paid worker, CFRA is categorically more protective, so the federal key-employee defense is unavailable even when the FMLA technically applies in parallel. An employer cannot use the concurrent-leave structure to smuggle the federal exception into a California claim. The California right controls because it gives the employee more. The two laws also diverge on covered relationships and on some medical-condition definitions, and where they diverge the employee again receives the more generous treatment.

How Employers Improperly Deny the Highly Paid Their Jobs

In the field, denial of reinstatement to a senior employee rarely announces itself. It looks like a sudden restructuring that happens to eliminate only the person on leave, a replacement hired at a lower cost and then kept on, a comparable role that is comparable in title only, or a claim that performance concerns predating the leave justify the change. Each of these can be unlawful interference under Gov. Code § 12945.2 if the real reason is the leave or the cost of the returning worker. Documentation matters: the timing of the decision, who made it, and what the employer said in writing often reveal that the economic-injury rationale the federal law would have allowed is doing improper work in a state the law did not authorize it in.

How Intermittent and Reduced-Schedule Leave Works

CFRA leave need not be taken in a single continuous block. For a serious health condition, the employee's own or a family member's, leave may be taken intermittently or on a reduced work schedule when medically necessary, and the twelve-week entitlement is measured by the actual time used rather than by the calendar. An employer may temporarily transfer an employee taking foreseeable intermittent leave to an alternative position with equivalent pay and benefits that better accommodates the recurring absences, but the transfer may not be used to punish the employee or to strip away the reinstatement right. Bonding leave may be taken intermittently by agreement, and the employer may require that bonding leave be used in minimum increments. None of these scheduling rules permits an employer to treat a highly paid worker worse because the intermittent absences are inconvenient, because the statute contains no cost-based carve-out.

Notice, Certification, and the Employer Recordkeeping Duty

An employee must provide reasonable advance notice of the need for CFRA leave when it is foreseeable, generally thirty days, and as soon as practicable when it is not. For leave based on a serious health condition, the employer may require a certification from a health care provider supporting the need for leave, but the certification rules are limited and the employer may not demand more than the certification regulation, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11091, allows. The employer must designate the leave as CFRA-qualifying and notify the employee of the designation and of the employee's rights and obligations. An employer that fails to give the required notices, or that botches the designation and then uses its own error to deny leave or reinstatement, interferes with the employee's rights under Gov. Code § 12945.2. Because the employer controls the paperwork, its records often become the strongest evidence that a denial had nothing to do with the leave itself.

Health Benefits Must Continue During Leave

During CFRA leave the employer must maintain the employee's group health coverage on the same terms as if the employee had continued working, for up to the duration of the protected leave. The employee remains responsible for any portion of the premium previously paid by payroll deduction. An employer that cancels a senior employee's health coverage during leave, or that forces the employee onto less favorable terms, commits an independent violation separate from any reinstatement dispute. For a highly compensated worker whose benefits package is substantial, improper interruption of coverage can generate its own measure of damages.

Interference and Retaliation Are Two Distinct Claims

CFRA supports two kinds of claims, and a denied-reinstatement case often involves both. An interference claim asks simply whether the employer denied, restrained, or interfered with the exercise of a protected right, such as the right to reinstatement; the employee need not prove the employer harbored a bad motive, only that a protected right was denied without a lawful justification. A retaliation claim asks whether the employer took an adverse action because the employee exercised CFRA rights, which turns on motive and uses the burden-shifting framework in which the employee shows a prima facie case, the employer offers a legitimate reason, and the employee proves pretext. A highly paid worker denied the same job can frame the refusal as interference, forcing the employer to prove a leave-neutral reason, and as retaliation, pointing to the suspicious timing. Pleading both maximizes the pressure on the employer's thin, cost-based rationale.

Remedies When Reinstatement Is Denied

CFRA is enforced through FEHA. A prevailing employee may recover back pay and front pay, the value of lost benefits, emotional-distress damages, and, where the conduct is malicious or oppressive, punitive damages, along with attorney fees and costs under Gov. Code § 12965. Reinstatement itself is an available equitable remedy. Because wrongful denial of a senior role can involve large compensation, the back-pay and front-pay exposure for an employer that wrongly refuses to restore a highly paid worker is often substantial. Back pay includes base salary, bonuses, commissions, equity vesting, and the value of lost benefits the worker would have earned, and front pay can span years when reinstatement is impractical.

Stacking CFRA Leave With Pregnancy Disability Leave

CFRA bonding leave is in addition to Pregnancy Disability Leave under Gov. Code § 12945. A birth mother may take up to four months of pregnancy disability leave for the period she is actually disabled by pregnancy, childbirth, or a related condition, and then take up to twelve weeks of CFRA bonding leave afterward. The reinstatement right attaches to each. A highly paid birth parent therefore has a layered set of job-protected absences, and the absence of a key-employee exception means the employer cannot deny restoration at the end of either leave on the ground that the worker is too expensive to bring back. Employers that miscount these entitlements, or that treat the end of pregnancy disability leave as the end of all protection, routinely create liability.

Deadlines and How to Bring a Claim

A CFRA interference or retaliation claim is a FEHA claim. The employee files a complaint with the Civil Rights Department and, under Gov. Code § 12960 and § 12965, generally has three years from the unlawful act to file that administrative complaint, after which the employee may request an immediate right-to-sue notice and then has one year to file a civil action. Preserving evidence early, including leave paperwork, the reinstatement communications, and any restructuring records, is critical, because the employer's burden to prove a leave-neutral reason is only as answerable as the contemporaneous record allows. If an employer refuses to restore you to the same or a comparable position, do not sign a severance release before you understand the claim you may be giving up.

CFRA Reaches More Relationships Than the FMLA

One more structural difference reinforces how much more protective CFRA is than the federal law. The family members for whom a worker may take CFRA leave under Gov. Code § 12945.2 include not only a spouse, child, and parent, as the FMLA allows, but also a domestic partner, a grandparent, a grandchild, a sibling, a parent-in-law, and a designated person the employee identifies at the time leave is requested. A worker caring for a sibling or a grandparent has protected CFRA leave even though the FMLA would not cover that relationship at all. For a highly compensated worker who takes leave to care for one of these broader-category relatives, the same no-key-employee reinstatement guarantee applies, and the employer cannot point to the worker's salary to deny the job back.

Fitness-for-Duty Certification on Return

When leave was for the employee's own serious health condition, an employer may, under a uniformly applied policy, require a fitness-for-duty certification confirming the employee can return to work. But the certification requirement is limited: the employer may seek confirmation only as to the condition that caused the leave and only where it applies the policy to all similarly situated employees. An employer may not use a return-to-work exam as a pretext to probe unrelated matters, to delay reinstatement of a highly paid worker, or to manufacture a reason to deny the same job. A fitness-for-duty demand that strays beyond the leave condition, or that is imposed selectively, is itself evidence of interference under Gov. Code § 12945.2.

Anti-Retaliation Protection During and After Leave

CFRA forbids an employer from retaliating against an employee for requesting or taking protected leave. Retaliation can take forms short of outright termination: a sudden poor performance review after a spotless record, exclusion from meetings and projects, a reduction in responsibilities, or a transfer that strips a senior worker of a team. Because adverse treatment tied to leave is unlawful regardless of pay level, a highly compensated worker who returns to find the role hollowed out has a retaliation claim even if the formal title is unchanged. The proximity of the adverse treatment to the leave, and any contrast with how the employer treated the worker before leave, are central evidence.

Severance Releases and the Waiver of CFRA Claims

An employer that wrongly denies reinstatement to a senior worker often pairs the denial with a severance offer and a broad release of claims. Signing that release can extinguish a valuable CFRA interference claim. A worker should never sign a severance agreement under time pressure without understanding what is being given up, and should pay particular attention to any clause waiving FEHA and CFRA rights. The value of a wrongful-reinstatement claim for a highly paid employee frequently exceeds the severance offered, which is precisely why employers package the two together.

Why Small Employers Are Often Caught Off Guard

Because CFRA now reaches employers with five or more employees, many small companies that have no FMLA obligation nonetheless owe the full CFRA reinstatement guarantee. Small employers frequently assume, incorrectly, that they can decline to bring back a highly paid manager whose absence proved disruptive, borrowing a federal concept that does not exist in state law. That assumption is a trap. The absence of a key-employee exception in Gov. Code § 12945.2 binds the small employer just as firmly as the large one, and the small employer that fires or demotes a returning worker on cost grounds faces the same FEHA exposure, including attorney fees under Gov. Code § 12965.

Talk to a California employment lawyer before you accept a lesser role. If you took family or medical leave and your employer refused to give you the same or a comparable job, or tried to justify the refusal by pointing to your salary, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate your reinstatement rights under the California Family Rights Act and the remedies available to you. For a confidential consultation, call (213) 645-2246. You can also follow developments across California leave and workplace law on our employment law news page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my employer refuse to give my job back because I am one of its highest-paid workers?

No. Since January 1, 2021, California law has not included a key-employee exception like the federal one. Gov. Code § 12945.2 and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11089 give you the right to the same or a comparable position regardless of your pay level, so your salary alone is never a lawful reason to deny reinstatement.

Does the federal FMLA key-employee rule ever apply to allow a worker to be denied reinstatement in California?

Even when the FMLA runs concurrently with CFRA, the more protective state rule controls on reinstatement. Because CFRA grants a stronger right with no highly paid exception, the federal defense under 29 U.S.C. § 2614(b) cannot be used to defeat a California reinstatement claim.

What counts as a comparable position when I return?

A comparable position must be virtually identical in pay, benefits, duties, skill, authority, shift, and worksite. A new title with reduced responsibility, a lower bonus opportunity, or a transfer to a dead-end role can be an unlawful denial of reinstatement even if the base salary stays the same.

My employer eliminated my position while I was on leave. Is that legal?

Only if the employer can prove you would have lost the position for a legitimate, leave-neutral reason even if you had never taken leave. The employer carries that burden, and a restructuring that conveniently removes only the employee on leave invites close scrutiny of its timing and motive.

How long do I have to file a CFRA claim?

A CFRA claim is enforced under FEHA. You generally have three years from the unlawful denial to file an administrative complaint with the Civil Rights Department, and one year from a right-to-sue notice to file suit. Acting early preserves the records that decide these cases.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301