SECURITIES | 2026-11-21

The Section 3(a)(10) Fairness-Hearing Exemption: Issuing Securities Without Registration in Exchanges, Settlements, and Reorganizations

How the Securities Act fairness-hearing exemption lets companies issue stock in exchange for claims, securities, or property without an S-1, the five conditions that must be met, and how California's own qualification-by-hearing under Corporations Code 25142 works alongside it

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

When a company wants to issue stock — to acquire another company, to settle litigation, to exchange debt for equity, or to reorganize — the default rule under federal law is that the securities must be registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission, an expensive and time-consuming process,...

The Registration Requirement and Why Exemptions Matter

The Securities Act of 1933 requires, as a general rule, that any offer or sale of a security be registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) unless the security or the transaction is exempt. Registration under Section 5 of the Securities Act is a demanding process — preparing a registration statement, responding to SEC review, and incurring substantial legal, accounting, and time costs. For many transactions in which a company issues stock, registration is impractical or unnecessary, so the Securities Act provides a series of exemptions. Among the most valuable is the fairness-hearing exemption in Section 3(a)(10), codified at 15 U.S.C. § 77c(a)(10). Unlike the private-placement exemption under Section 4(a)(2) (and Regulation D), which limits who can be offered securities and generally produces restricted securities subject to resale limits, the Section 3(a)(10) exemption can be used in public transactions and generally produces securities that are freely tradable (subject to affiliate limits) because they are issued in a transaction that a court or agency has approved as fair. This makes the exemption especially attractive where the recipients are numerous, where the securities need to be liquid, and where a registered offering would be too slow or costly. The trade-off is that the transaction must be structured to meet the exemption's specific conditions and must involve a genuine fairness hearing.

The Text and Purpose of Section 3(a)(10)

Section 3(a)(10) exempts from registration "any security which is issued in exchange for one or more bona fide outstanding securities, claims or property interests," where the terms and conditions of the issuance and exchange are approved, after a hearing upon the fairness of such terms and conditions at which all persons to whom the securities will be issued have the right to appear, by a court or by an official or agency of the United States or of a State that is expressly authorized by law to grant such approval. The purpose of the exemption is to substitute a fairness hearing — an impartial review of the fairness of the exchange by a court or authorized agency — for the disclosure protections of registration. The theory is that when a neutral tribunal, after notice and an opportunity for the recipients to be heard, determines that the terms of the exchange are fair, the investors receive protection comparable to what registration would provide. The SEC staff has provided guidance on the exemption's requirements, most prominently in Staff Legal Bulletin No. 3 issued by the Division of Corporation Finance, which sets out the conditions the staff views as necessary. The exemption is self-executing — no application to the SEC is required — but the parties bear the burden of ensuring that each condition is satisfied, because an issuance that fails a condition is an unregistered, non-exempt sale of securities in violation of Section 5.

The Five Conditions

To qualify for the Section 3(a)(10) exemption, the transaction must satisfy several conditions, commonly distilled into five. First, the securities must be issued in exchange for outstanding securities, claims, or property interests — the exemption does not cover a sale for cash; there must be a genuine exchange. Second, a court or authorized governmental entity must approve the fairness of the terms. Third, the approving court or agency must find the terms and conditions of the exchange fair to those who will receive the securities, after holding a hearing on fairness. Fourth, the fairness hearing must be open to everyone who will receive securities in the exchange, with adequate notice to them of the hearing. Fifth, the court or agency must be advised before the hearing that the issuer will rely on the Section 3(a)(10) exemption based on the approval, so that the tribunal understands it is being asked to approve fairness for purposes of the federal exemption. Each condition is strictly construed, because the exemption substitutes the hearing for registration and the protection it affords depends on the hearing being genuine, open, and fair. A transaction that, for example, mixes a cash sale with the exchange, that uses a tribunal lacking express legal authority to approve fairness, or that fails to give adequate notice to all recipients, will not qualify, and the issuance will be an unregistered sale.

Common Uses of the Exemption

Section 3(a)(10) is used across a range of corporate transactions. In litigation settlements, a defendant may issue stock to a class or group of claimants in settlement of claims, with the settlement court approving the fairness of the terms after a hearing — a classic fairness-hearing transaction that produces freely tradable securities for the claimants. In debt restructurings and workouts, a company may issue equity to creditors in exchange for outstanding debt, with a court or authorized agency approving the exchange; this is distinct from a bankruptcy reorganization, which has its own exemption under Section 1145 of the Bankruptcy Code. In business combinations and exchange offers, a company may issue securities in exchange for the securities or assets of another company, using a fairness hearing to avoid registration. And in various reorganizations and recapitalizations, the exemption allows the issuance of new securities in exchange for old ones. A distinctive and historically important use arises where a state agency authorized to conduct fairness hearings — notably California's securities regulator — approves the fairness of an exchange, supporting the federal exemption. Across all of these uses, the common thread is an exchange (not a cash sale) whose fairness is approved after an open hearing by a qualified tribunal, which is what the exemption requires.

California's Qualification by Permit and Hearing

California has a particularly important role in fairness-hearing transactions because its securities regulator is expressly authorized to approve the fairness of securities exchanges after a hearing, which can satisfy the Section 3(a)(10) condition of approval by a "State agency expressly authorized by law." Under the Corporate Securities Law of 1968, California requires that an offer or sale of securities in the state be qualified unless exempt, and it provides for qualification by permit. In particular, Corporations Code § 25121 addresses qualification of securities issued in certain exchanges and reorganizations, and Corporations Code § 25142 authorizes the Commissioner (now within the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation) to hold a hearing on the fairness of the terms and conditions of an exchange and to issue a permit upon finding the terms fair, just, and equitable. A California fairness hearing under this procedure can both qualify the securities under California law and support the federal Section 3(a)(10) exemption, because California's regulator is a state agency expressly authorized to approve fairness after a hearing. This dual function has made California a favored forum for fairness-hearing transactions, particularly for business combinations and exchanges, allowing parties to obtain both a California permit and the federal exemption from a single hearing. Companies using this route must satisfy California's procedural and substantive requirements, including adequate notice and the fairness standard, which parallel the federal conditions.

Resale and Freely Tradable Securities

A principal advantage of Section 3(a)(10) is that securities issued in a qualifying transaction are generally freely tradable by non-affiliates, rather than restricted securities subject to the resale limitations of Rule 144. Because the securities are issued in a transaction whose fairness a court or agency has approved after a hearing, they are not considered to have been acquired in a private placement, so the recipients can generally resell them without a holding period or the other Rule 144 conditions — a significant benefit over a Section 4(a)(2) or Regulation D private placement, which produces restricted securities. There is an important qualification: recipients who are affiliates of the issuer (such as officers, directors, or control persons) remain subject to the resale restrictions applicable to affiliates, and securities issued to affiliates are generally treated as control securities resellable only under Rule 144's affiliate provisions or another exemption. For the typical non-affiliate recipient, however — a claimant in a settlement, a creditor in a workout, or a target shareholder in a combination — the freely tradable nature of Section 3(a)(10) securities is a major attraction, because it gives them liquid securities without the cost of a registered offering or the lock-up of restricted stock. This resale advantage is one of the principal reasons parties choose the fairness-hearing route over other exemptions.

Pitfalls and Strict Construction

Because Section 3(a)(10) substitutes a fairness hearing for registration, courts and the SEC construe its conditions strictly, and several pitfalls can defeat the exemption. The transaction must be a genuine exchange for securities, claims, or property — not a disguised cash sale; adding a cash-investment component can take the issuance outside the exemption. The approving tribunal must have express legal authority to approve the fairness of the exchange; a court's approval of a settlement for other purposes, without a fairness determination directed at the securities issuance, may not suffice, and an agency without express fairness-approval authority cannot support the exemption. The hearing must be open to all recipients with adequate and timely notice; excluding recipients or giving deficient notice defeats the exemption. The tribunal must be advised in advance that its approval will be the basis for the federal exemption, so that it understands the nature of what it is approving. And the fairness approval must address the terms and conditions of the exchange as they affect the recipients. A failure on any of these points means the securities were issued in an unregistered, non-exempt transaction, exposing the issuer to Section 5 liability, including rescission rights for the recipients under Section 12(a)(1) of the Securities Act. Because the stakes are high and the conditions technical, fairness-hearing transactions require careful structuring and attention to each requirement from the outset.

Structuring a Fairness-Hearing Transaction

Using Section 3(a)(10) effectively requires planning the transaction around its conditions. The parties must confirm that the issuance is a genuine exchange for securities, claims, or property, and avoid structuring it as a cash sale. They must select a qualified tribunal — a court with authority to approve the fairness of the exchange, or an authorized state agency such as California's securities regulator under the Corporations Code § 25142 procedure. They must arrange a fairness hearing with adequate notice to all recipients and an opportunity for them to appear and be heard. They must advise the tribunal in advance that the approval will support the Section 3(a)(10) exemption. And they must ensure the approval constitutes a finding that the terms are fair to the recipients. Where California's procedure is used, the parties must also satisfy the state's qualification requirements, obtaining a permit after the fairness hearing. Throughout, counsel should document compliance with each condition, because the burden of establishing the exemption rests on the issuer. Done correctly, a fairness-hearing transaction can issue freely tradable securities to numerous recipients without the cost and delay of SEC registration, which is why the exemption remains a valuable tool for settlements, restructurings, and combinations. Done carelessly, it can result in an unregistered securities offering with serious liability, which is why the conditions must be respected in full. Counsel should also consider the state securities laws of every jurisdiction where recipients reside, because the federal exemption does not automatically satisfy state blue-sky requirements, and a transaction that qualifies federally under Section 3(a)(10) may still need a state exemption or qualification for recipients outside the state whose agency conducted the hearing. In addition, the parties should plan the notice program carefully — the manner, content, and timing of notice to recipients must be sufficient to give everyone a genuine opportunity to appear, because a defective notice program is one of the most common ways a fairness-hearing transaction fails. Finally, the parties should document the tribunal's fairness findings on the record, so that the basis for the exemption is clear if the issuance is later questioned.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Section 3(a)(10) exemption?

Section 3(a)(10) of the Securities Act, 15 U.S.C. § 77c(a)(10), exempts securities issued in exchange for outstanding securities, claims, or property interests when the fairness of the terms is approved, after a hearing, by a court or an authorized governmental agency. It substitutes a fairness hearing for SEC registration.

What are the conditions for the exemption?

The securities must be issued in a genuine exchange (not for cash); a court or authorized agency must approve the fairness of the terms after a hearing; the hearing must be open to all recipients with adequate notice; and the tribunal must be advised in advance that its approval will support the federal exemption.

When is the exemption used?

It is used in litigation settlements where stock is issued to claimants, debt restructurings and workouts exchanging equity for debt, business combinations and exchange offers, and reorganizations and recapitalizations — situations where a company issues securities in exchange for claims, securities, or property.

Are Section 3(a)(10) securities freely tradable?

Generally yes for non-affiliates. Because the securities are issued in a transaction whose fairness a court or agency approved after a hearing, they are not restricted securities under Rule 144 and can usually be resold freely — a key advantage over a Regulation D private placement. Affiliates remain subject to resale limits.

How does California's procedure fit in?

California's securities regulator is expressly authorized to approve the fairness of securities exchanges after a hearing. Under Corporations Code §§ 25121 and 25142, a California fairness hearing can both qualify the securities under state law and support the federal Section 3(a)(10) exemption, making California a favored forum for these transactions.

Can I use the exemption for a cash offering?

No. The exemption requires a genuine exchange for outstanding securities, claims, or property interests. A sale for cash does not qualify, and adding a cash-investment component can take the issuance outside the exemption.

What tribunal can approve the fairness?

A court, or an official or agency of the United States or a State that is expressly authorized by law to approve the fairness of the exchange after a hearing. The tribunal must have express fairness-approval authority and must be advised that its approval will support the federal exemption.

What happens if a condition is not met?

The securities are treated as issued in an unregistered, non-exempt transaction in violation of Section 5, exposing the issuer to liability, including rescission rights for recipients under Section 12(a)(1). The conditions are strictly construed, so careful structuring is essential.

Using the Exemption Safely

The Section 3(a)(10) fairness-hearing exemption is a powerful tool for issuing securities in settlements, restructurings, and combinations without the cost and delay of SEC registration, and for producing freely tradable securities — but only when its conditions are strictly satisfied: a genuine exchange, approval by a qualified tribunal, a fairness finding, an open hearing with adequate notice, and advance notice to the tribunal of the exemption. For California companies, the state's qualification-by-hearing procedure under Corporations Code § 25142 offers a route that can satisfy both state and federal requirements from a single hearing. If you are structuring an exchange, settlement, or reorganization and want to use the fairness-hearing exemption, our firm can help you meet its conditions and avoid the serious liability that an unregistered offering would create. For related guidance, see our securities and governance practice. Call (818) 514-7680 to discuss a securities-exemption or capital-markets matter with an attorney.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301