SECURITIES | 2026-11-20
Exclusive-Forum Bylaws and the Internal-Affairs Doctrine: How Delaware Forum-Selection Provisions Bind Shareholders and Play Out in California Courts
Why boards adopt bylaws channeling fiduciary and derivative suits to Delaware, how Boilermakers v. Chevron and Section 115 made them enforceable, where federal-forum provisions for Securities Act claims differ, and how California courts enforce them
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
A shareholder of a Delaware corporation headquartered in California wants to sue the board for breach of fiduciary duty — and files in California state court, close to the company and the alleged misconduct. The company moves to dismiss or stay, pointing to a single provision buried in its bylaws:...
What an Exclusive-Forum Bylaw Does
An exclusive-forum bylaw (or charter provision) is a corporate governance provision that designates a specific court — most often the Delaware Court of Chancery — as the exclusive venue for certain categories of litigation against the corporation and its directors and officers. The claims typically covered are internal-affairs disputes: derivative actions brought on the corporation's behalf, claims for breach of fiduciary duty by directors or officers, claims arising under the Delaware General Corporation Law or the corporation's charter or bylaws, and other claims governed by the internal-affairs doctrine. The purpose is twofold. First, boards want these distinctively corporate disputes decided by the courts with the deepest expertise in the governing law — the Delaware Court of Chancery and the Delaware Supreme Court, which have developed the nation's most sophisticated body of corporate jurisprudence. Second, boards want to avoid multi-forum litigation, in which the same merger or transaction spawns parallel suits in several states, multiplying cost and the risk of inconsistent rulings. By channeling internal-affairs claims to one forum, the bylaw promotes efficiency and predictability. For a shareholder, the bylaw means that a claim they might prefer to bring in their home state can be moved to Delaware, which is why the enforceability and scope of these provisions matter so much in practice.
The Internal-Affairs Doctrine
Exclusive-forum bylaws rest on the internal-affairs doctrine, a bedrock principle of corporate law holding that the law of the state of incorporation governs the internal affairs of a corporation — the relationships among the corporation, its directors, its officers, and its shareholders. The United States Supreme Court recognized the doctrine in Edgar v. MITE Corp. (1982) 457 U.S. 624 and CTS Corp. v. Dynamics Corp. of America (1987) 481 U.S. 69, explaining that only one state should have the authority to regulate a corporation's internal affairs to avoid conflicting demands. Because the vast majority of large U.S. public companies are incorporated in Delaware, Delaware law governs their internal affairs regardless of where they are headquartered or operate. The internal-affairs doctrine is the conceptual link between a corporation's state of incorporation and the forum-selection bylaw: if Delaware law governs the internal affairs of a Delaware corporation, it is coherent to channel the litigation of those internal-affairs claims to Delaware courts. California recognizes the internal-affairs doctrine as well, though California's Corporations Code section 2115 purports to apply certain California governance rules to "pseudo-foreign" corporations with strong California ties — an important wrinkle in disputes involving Delaware companies with heavy California contacts. Its reach is limited: section 2115 exempts corporations whose shares are listed on certain national securities exchanges, and in VantagePoint Venture Partners 1996 v. Examen, Inc. (Del. 2005) 871 A.2d 1108 the Delaware Supreme Court refused to apply it to a Delaware corporation's internal affairs, holding that Delaware law governed.
Boilermakers v. Chevron and the Validity of Forum Bylaws
The foundational decision upholding exclusive-forum bylaws is Boilermakers Local 154 Retirement Fund v. Chevron Corp. (Del. Ch. 2013) 73 A.3d 934. Chevron and FedEx had adopted board-enacted bylaws designating Delaware as the exclusive forum for internal-affairs claims, and shareholders challenged the bylaws as beyond the board's authority and unenforceable. Then-Chancellor Strine upheld the bylaws, holding that they were statutorily valid under 8 Del. C. 109(b), which permits bylaws regulating the business of the corporation and the rights of its stockholders, and that forum-selection provisions regulate exactly the kind of intra-corporate litigation that bylaws may address. The court further held that such board-adopted bylaws are contractually binding on shareholders, because shareholders of a Delaware corporation are on notice that the board may unilaterally adopt and amend bylaws under authority granted in the charter — the shareholders' relationship with the corporation is contractual and incorporates this reserved power. The court left open the possibility that a forum bylaw could be unenforceable as applied in specific circumstances under ordinary forum-selection principles, but it rejected the facial challenge. Boilermakers established that exclusive-forum bylaws are a legitimate exercise of corporate power, and the decision was followed by a wave of adoptions across Delaware corporations.
Section 115 Codifies Forum Bylaws for Internal-Corporate Claims
In 2015, the Delaware legislature codified and bounded the Boilermakers rule by enacting 8 Del. C. 115. Section 115 expressly authorizes the certificate of incorporation or the bylaws to require that "internal corporate claims" be brought solely and exclusively in the courts of Delaware — and, importantly, it prohibits a provision that would bar internal corporate claims from being brought in Delaware (i.e., a company cannot designate some other state as the exclusive forum to the exclusion of Delaware). The statute defines "internal corporate claims" as claims, including derivative claims, that are based on a violation of a duty by a current or former director, officer, or stockholder in that capacity, or as to which the Delaware General Corporation Law confers jurisdiction on the Court of Chancery. Section 115 thus provides a clear statutory foundation for exclusive-forum provisions covering fiduciary and derivative claims, while ensuring that Delaware remains an available forum. Amendments effective August 1, 2025 expanded Section 115 to permit forum provisions for certain claims that are not internal corporate claims but relate to the business of the corporation, the conduct of its affairs, or the rights or powers of the corporation or its stockholders, directors, or officers — so long as stockholders may bring such claims in at least one court in Delaware. For practitioners, Section 115 is the governing authority: a forum bylaw that channels internal corporate claims to Delaware is expressly permitted, and its validity as a facial matter is settled. The remaining questions are about scope — which claims count as internal corporate claims — and enforcement in the courts where a plaintiff files.
Federal-Forum Provisions Are a Different Animal
A crucial distinction must be drawn between exclusive-forum bylaws for internal-affairs claims and federal-forum provisions (FFPs) for federal securities claims. A federal-forum provision designates the federal courts as the exclusive forum for claims under the Securities Act of 1933. These arose in response to Cyan, Inc. v. Beaver County Employees Retirement Fund (2018) 583 U.S. 416, in which the U.S. Supreme Court held that state courts retain concurrent jurisdiction over class actions alleging only 1933 Act claims, and that such claims are not removable to federal court — exposing companies to duplicative state and federal Securities Act litigation after an IPO. In Salzberg v. Sciabacucchi (Del. 2020) 227 A.3d 102, the Delaware Supreme Court held that federal-forum provisions directing 1933 Act claims to federal court are facially valid under Delaware law. But FFPs are not internal-affairs provisions — a 1933 Act claim is a federal statutory claim, not a claim governed by the internal-affairs doctrine — so they rest on a different legal footing and raise different enforcement questions in other states. The two kinds of provisions are often confused, but the analysis is distinct: a Delaware-forum bylaw sends fiduciary/derivative/internal-affairs claims to Delaware courts, while a federal-forum provision sends Securities Act claims to federal courts. A company may adopt both, and the enforceability of each is analyzed separately.
How California Courts Enforce Delaware Forum Bylaws
Because many Delaware corporations are headquartered or heavily active in California, the question of whether California courts will enforce a Delaware exclusive-forum bylaw is of great practical importance. California generally enforces forum-selection clauses unless enforcement would be unreasonable or would substantially diminish the plaintiff's unwaivable statutory rights under California law. The leading California decision enforcing a Delaware forum bylaw is Drulias v. 1st Century Bancshares, Inc. (2018) 30 Cal.App.5th 696, in which the Court of Appeal enforced a board-adopted Delaware exclusive-forum bylaw and stayed a California shareholder action challenging a merger, holding that such a bylaw is enforceable and that the shareholder was bound by it even though the board adopted it at the same time it approved the challenged merger. The court reasoned that the timing of a bylaw's adoption does not determine its validity, treated the bylaw as a valid provision under Delaware law consistent with the shareholder's reasonable expectations, and found no reason it was unreasonable to enforce. California courts analyze enforceability of forum-selection clauses under Smith, Valentino & Smith, Inc. v. Superior Court (1976) 17 Cal.3d 491, which ordinarily places the burden on the party resisting the clause to show that enforcement would be unreasonable. Verdugo v. Alliantgroup, L.P. (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th 141 recognizes an important exception: where the claims rest on unwaivable California statutory rights, the burden shifts to the party seeking enforcement to show that litigating in the chosen forum will not diminish those rights. For internal-affairs claims governed by Delaware law, that exception often does not apply, so California courts have generally enforced Delaware forum bylaws and sent the dispute to Delaware.
Scope, Adoption, and As-Applied Limits
Even a facially valid forum bylaw can be contested on scope and as-applied grounds. On scope, the bylaw reaches only the claims it describes — typically internal corporate claims under Section 115 — so a plaintiff may argue that a particular claim (for example, a claim that sounds in general contract or tort rather than fiduciary duty) falls outside the bylaw. On adoption, the bylaw must have been validly enacted under the charter and Delaware law; a board-adopted bylaw is binding because the charter reserves the board's power to adopt bylaws, but a provision adopted in a manner inconsistent with the governing documents could be challenged. On as-applied enforceability, Boilermakers left open that a forum bylaw could be unenforceable in specific circumstances under ordinary forum-selection analysis — for instance, if enforcement would be fundamentally unfair or would deprive the plaintiff of a remedy. And a special tension arises with claims that are not exclusively within Delaware's competence: a federal claim with exclusive federal jurisdiction cannot be forced into the Court of Chancery, and a claim implicating unwaivable California statutory rights may resist a forum clause. These doctrines mean that the application of a forum bylaw to a specific case still requires analysis of the claims pleaded, the manner of adoption, and the enforcing court's forum-selection principles — the provision is powerful but not self-executing.
Practical Guidance for Shareholders and Boards
For shareholders and their counsel, an exclusive-forum bylaw should be checked at the outset of any contemplated governance litigation: the corporation's charter and bylaws should be reviewed for a Delaware-forum provision, a federal-forum provision, or both, because filing in the wrong forum invites a motion to dismiss or stay and can forfeit time and leverage. Where a Delaware-forum bylaw applies to the claims, the practical choice is usually to litigate in the Court of Chancery, which offers expert adjudication of fiduciary and derivative claims. For boards and companies, adopting a valid forum provision means grounding it in Section 115 and the charter's reserved bylaw power, drafting the scope carefully to cover internal corporate claims (and, if desired, separately adopting a federal-forum provision for 1933 Act claims consistent with Salzberg), and understanding that the provision will generally be enforced in California and elsewhere but may be tested on scope and as-applied grounds. In all cases, the interaction between the internal-affairs claims that belong in Delaware and the federal securities claims that belong in federal court must be kept distinct, because conflating the two leads to filing and enforcement errors. A clear understanding of which provision governs which claims is the foundation of handling corporate-governance litigation involving Delaware companies with California ties.
The Rationale: Expertise, Predictability, and Efficiency
The spread of exclusive-forum bylaws reflects a considered judgment about where corporate disputes are best resolved. The Delaware Court of Chancery is a specialized business court whose judges decide corporate-governance questions daily and whose decisions, reviewed by the Delaware Supreme Court, form the most developed body of corporate law in the country. Channeling internal-affairs claims to that forum produces expert adjudication and predictable outcomes, which benefit shareholders and companies alike by reducing uncertainty about how fiduciary and derivative claims will be decided. The provisions also combat the problem of multi-forum and duplicative litigation, in which a single merger generates near-identical suits in several states, driving up defense costs, inviting a race to settlement, and risking inconsistent rulings on the same transaction. By consolidating these claims in one court, a forum bylaw lowers cost and the risk of conflicting judgments. Critics counter that the provisions can burden shareholders by forcing them to litigate far from home, which is why courts police the provisions through scope and as-applied analysis and decline to enforce a clause that would be fundamentally unfair or would defeat an unwaivable right. The prevailing view, however, is that forum bylaws covering internal corporate claims advance legitimate interests and are generally enforceable, so long as they are validly adopted and reasonably applied. This balance — strong enforcement of a provision that serves efficiency and expertise, tempered by limits that protect against unfairness — defines the modern law of forum-selection bylaws.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an exclusive-forum bylaw?
It is a corporate governance provision designating a specific court — usually the Delaware Court of Chancery — as the exclusive forum for internal-affairs claims such as derivative suits and breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims against directors and officers. Its purpose is expert adjudication and avoiding duplicative multi-forum litigation.
Are forum-selection bylaws enforceable?
Yes. In Boilermakers Local 154 Retirement Fund v. Chevron Corp. (Del. Ch. 2013) 73 A.3d 934, the Delaware Court of Chancery upheld board-adopted forum bylaws as valid under 8 Del. C. 109(b) and contractually binding on shareholders, and the Delaware legislature codified them in 8 Del. C. 115 in 2015.
What is the internal-affairs doctrine?
It is the principle that the law of the state of incorporation governs a corporation's internal affairs — the relationships among the corporation, its directors, officers, and shareholders. The U.S. Supreme Court recognized it in Edgar v. MITE Corp. (1982) and CTS Corp. v. Dynamics Corp. (1987). It links a Delaware corporation's internal-affairs claims to Delaware law and courts.
What does 8 Del. C. 115 do?
Section 115 expressly authorizes the charter or bylaws to require that "internal corporate claims" be brought solely and exclusively in Delaware courts, while prohibiting a provision that would bar such claims from being brought in Delaware. It provides the statutory foundation for exclusive-forum provisions covering fiduciary and derivative claims.
How is a federal-forum provision different?
A federal-forum provision designates federal courts as the exclusive forum for Securities Act of 1933 claims — a response to Cyan, Inc. v. Beaver County (2018), which held state courts have concurrent, non-removable jurisdiction over 1933 Act claims. The Delaware Supreme Court upheld federal-forum provisions as facially valid in Salzberg v. Sciabacucchi (2020). These are federal securities claims, not internal-affairs claims.
Will a California court enforce a Delaware forum bylaw?
California courts have generally done so. In Drulias v. 1st Century Bancshares, Inc. (2018) 30 Cal.App.5th 696, the California Court of Appeal affirmed an order enforcing a Delaware exclusive-forum bylaw and staying a California shareholder action. California enforces forum-selection clauses unless enforcement is unreasonable or would diminish unwaivable California statutory rights, an exception that often does not fit internal-affairs claims governed by Delaware law. Each case still turns on its own claims and facts.
Can a company force federal securities claims into Delaware Chancery?
Not for claims within exclusive federal jurisdiction, such as Securities Exchange Act of 1934 claims, which cannot be channeled to the Court of Chancery. Securities Act of 1933 claims may be heard in state or federal court under Cyan, and companies that want them in federal court typically adopt a separate federal-forum provision. Internal-affairs claims and federal securities claims must be kept distinct.
Can a forum bylaw adopted at the same time as a merger bind shareholders?
It can. Drulias enforced a Delaware forum bylaw that the board adopted at the same time it approved the challenged merger, reasoning that the timing of adoption does not determine a bylaw's validity and that shareholders of a Delaware corporation can expect the board to adopt bylaws under authority reserved in the charter. A provision can still be tested on scope and as-applied grounds, but timing alone did not defeat it in that case.
Navigating Corporate-Governance Litigation
Exclusive-forum bylaws have reshaped where shareholder disputes are litigated, channeling fiduciary and derivative claims to Delaware while federal-forum provisions route Securities Act claims to federal court. Whether you are a shareholder deciding where to file, a director or officer facing a derivative or fiduciary claim, or a board adopting governance provisions, the analysis turns on the internal-affairs doctrine, Section 115, Boilermakers, Salzberg, and the forum-selection principles California courts apply under Drulias. Getting the forum right at the outset avoids costly motions and preserves leverage. Our firm advises on the enforceability and scope of forum-selection provisions and litigates corporate-governance disputes involving Delaware companies with California ties. For related guidance, see our securities and governance practice. Call (818) 514-7680 to discuss a corporate-governance or forum-selection matter with an attorney experienced in shareholder and fiduciary-duty litigation. You can also read about our corporate finance practice.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301