MESOTHELIOMA | 2026-11-20

Asbestos Gaskets and Packing in Valves and Pumps: Proving Exposure and Overcoming the Component-Parts Defense in California

How machinists, pipefitters, boilermakers, and Navy and refinery workers were exposed to asbestos gaskets and rope packing, what product-identification evidence a mesothelioma case requires, and how O'Neil v. Crane and the component-parts defense are met

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

For much of the twentieth century, asbestos was the material of choice for sealing the industrial systems that moved steam, water, oil, and chemicals under heat and pressure. Valves, pumps, boilers, turbines, and piping systems relied on asbestos-containing gaskets — flat sheets compressed between...

Where the Exposure Came From

Asbestos gaskets and packing were ubiquitous in industrial and marine machinery because asbestos resists heat, chemicals, and pressure. A gasket is a seal placed between two surfaces — typically compressed between the flanges of a pipe joint, a pump casing, or a valve bonnet — to prevent leakage; asbestos sheet gaskets were cut to size and bolted into place. Packing is material compressed into the space around a moving part — the stem of a valve or the rotating shaft of a pump — to seal it against leakage; asbestos rope, braided packing, and packing rings were wound or stuffed into the packing gland. The danger arose chiefly during maintenance. Over time, gaskets baked onto flanges and had to be scraped, wire-brushed, or ground off, and old packing had to be dug out and replaced — operations that released clouds of asbestos dust. Cutting new gasket material to size and installing new packing also generated fibers. Workers performed this maintenance repeatedly over careers spanning decades, often in confined spaces — ship engine rooms, boiler rooms, pump houses, refinery process units — where the dust was concentrated and ventilation was poor. The result was substantial, cumulative exposure to asbestos fibers, which decades later can cause mesothelioma and other asbestos diseases. Identifying exactly where, when, and how a worker encountered asbestos gaskets and packing is the foundation of the case.

Who Was Exposed

A wide range of trades worked with asbestos gaskets and packing. Machinists and machinist's mates maintained pumps, valves, and turbines, replacing gaskets and packing as a core part of their job. Pipefitters and steamfitters broke and remade flanged joints, scraping old gaskets and installing new ones. Boilermakers worked on boilers and their associated valves and fittings. Insulators and laggers worked alongside, and were exposed to, the dust these operations created. In the Navy and the maritime trades, engine-room and fire-room personnel maintained the vast arrays of pumps and valves aboard ships, often in tight, poorly ventilated spaces. In refineries, chemical plants, and power plants, operators and maintenance crews serviced the process equipment that depended on asbestos seals. Bystanders — workers performing other tasks nearby — were exposed to the dust as well, and family members could be exposed to fibers carried home on work clothes (so-called take-home exposure). Because mesothelioma has a long latency period — often 20 to 50 years between exposure and diagnosis — the workers being diagnosed today were frequently exposed decades ago, which makes reconstructing their work history and the products they encountered a central and sometimes difficult task in the case.

Product Identification: The Threshold Requirement

To hold a manufacturer liable, a California plaintiff must prove product identification — that the worker was exposed to that manufacturer's asbestos-containing product. California does not apply market-share or industry-wide liability to asbestos (Mullen v. Armstrong World Industries (1988) 200 Cal.App.3d 250); the plaintiff must tie the exposure to specific products. The governing standard comes from Lineaweaver v. Plant Insulation Co. (1995) 31 Cal.App.4th 1409, which explained that a plaintiff must show exposure to the defendant's product and, through competent expert testimony, a reasonable medical probability that the exposure was a substantial factor in causing the injury, with the frequency, regularity, and proximity of the exposure as relevant factors. In McGonnell v. Kaiser Gypsum Co. (2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 1098, the court affirmed summary judgment where the evidence that the plaintiff encountered the defendant's product was too speculative to support an inference of exposure. Product identification in gasket and packing cases typically comes from the worker's own testimony about the brands they used and the equipment they serviced, from co-worker testimony, from procurement and specification records, from equipment manuals and parts lists, and from evidence about which gaskets and packing a given pump or valve required. Because the exposures occurred long ago and the products were often generic in appearance, assembling credible product-identification evidence is one of the most important — and most contested — parts of a gasket and packing mesothelioma case.

Causation: The Rutherford Substantial-Factor Standard

California applies a distinctive causation standard in asbestos cases, set out in Rutherford v. Owens-Illinois, Inc. (1997) 16 Cal.4th 953. Because mesothelioma results from the cumulative effect of asbestos exposure and medical science cannot identify which particular fiber caused the cancer, the California Supreme Court held that a plaintiff need not prove that a defendant's product was the sole or even the primary cause. Instead, the plaintiff must show that exposure to the defendant's asbestos-containing product was a substantial factor in contributing to the aggregate dose of asbestos the plaintiff inhaled, and therefore to the risk of developing the disease. This substantial-factor standard is well suited to gasket and packing cases, where a worker was typically exposed to many asbestos products over a career: each product that contributed meaningfully to the cumulative dose can be a substantial factor. The plaintiff supports causation with evidence of the frequency and regularity of exposure to the defendant's gaskets or packing and the worker's proximity to the dust-generating work, together with expert testimony on how those exposures contributed to the aggregate dose and the risk of mesothelioma. The Rutherford framework means that a defendant cannot escape liability merely by pointing to other sources of exposure; if its product was a substantial contributing factor, it can be held responsible, subject to the apportionment of noneconomic damages discussed below.

The O'Neil Component-Parts Defense

The central legal battleground in gasket and packing cases is the component-parts defense established in O'Neil v. Crane Co. (2012) 53 Cal.4th 335. There, the California Supreme Court held that a product manufacturer generally may not be held liable in strict liability or negligence for harm caused by another manufacturer's product — such as asbestos-containing replacement gaskets and packing made and supplied by others and used with the defendant's pumps and valves. In O'Neil, the original asbestos gaskets and packing had been replaced before the worker's exposure, and the Court found that the mere compatibility of the pumps and valves with asbestos components did not make them defective. O'Neil is the defense that equipment makers raise to escape liability for the asbestos gaskets and packing a worker actually handled. But O'Neil has important limits. The Court recognized that a manufacturer can be liable when (1) its own product contributed substantially to the harm — for example, where the worker handled asbestos gaskets or packing the defendant itself made or supplied; or (2) the defendant participated substantially in creating a harmful combined use of the products. The Court also noted that a stronger argument for liability might be made where a product required the use of a defective part to operate, but it expressly left that question open, and it distinguished Tellez-Cordova v. Campbell-Hausfeld/Scott Fetzger Co., where tools whose only intended use released harmful dust were held subject to a duty to warn. Taylor v. Elliott Turbomachinery Co. (2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 564 and later decisions explore these boundaries. The practical consequence is that the case often turns on whether the defendant made or supplied the asbestos the worker handled, or otherwise substantially participated in the harmful use — which is why the evidence about the product's original components and specifications is so important.

Strict Liability, Failure to Warn, and Negligence

A gasket and packing mesothelioma case is typically pleaded on multiple theories. Under strict products liability, a manufacturer is liable for a product that is defective, including a failure to warn of known or knowable dangers. In Anderson v. Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corp. (1991) 53 Cal.3d 987, the California Supreme Court held that in a strict-liability failure-to-warn case, the manufacturer is liable for failing to warn of risks that were known or knowable in light of the scientific knowledge available at the time — and that evidence of the state of the art is admissible on that question. Under negligence, the plaintiff shows that the manufacturer failed to exercise reasonable care in designing, manufacturing, or warning about its asbestos-containing products. Both theories can be pursued, and the state-of-the-art evidence — what the industry knew, and when, about the hazards of asbestos — is often central, because the asbestos industry had substantial knowledge of the dangers long before it warned workers. For gaskets and packing specifically, the plaintiff shows that the manufacturer knew its asbestos-containing seals would release fibers when handled and maintained, and failed to warn the workers who would do that work. The combination of strict liability (defect and failure to warn) and negligence gives the plaintiff multiple paths to liability against the companies that made, supplied, or required the asbestos gaskets and packing the worker handled.

Apportionment, Bankruptcy Trusts, and Multiple Defendants

Because a worker was typically exposed to many asbestos products, gasket and packing cases usually involve multiple defendants and apportionment. Under Proposition 51, Civil Code section 1431.2, liability for noneconomic damages (pain and suffering) is several — each defendant pays only its proportionate share based on its comparative fault — while economic damages (medical expenses, lost earnings) remain joint and several. Many of the companies that made asbestos gaskets and packing have gone bankrupt and established asbestos bankruptcy trusts under 11 U.S.C. section 524(g) to pay current and future claims. A complete recovery strategy therefore pursues both the solvent defendants in the tort case and claims against the applicable trusts, with the interplay of trust recoveries and tort apportionment handled under California's setoff and good-faith-settlement rules (Code of Civil Procedure sections 877 and 877.6). Identifying every source of exposure — every manufacturer of gaskets, packing, valves, pumps, and related products the worker encountered — helps ensure that the burden of a largely bankrupt industry does not fall on a single solvent defendant or leave the worker undercompensated. This multi-defendant, multi-trust structure is a defining feature of asbestos litigation and requires a careful accounting of the worker's full exposure history.

Deadlines and Building the Case

California provides a plaintiff-protective statute of limitations for asbestos disease. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 340.2, a personal-injury asbestos claim must be brought within one year after the later of the date the plaintiff first suffered disability (defined as loss of time from work that precludes performing the plaintiff's regular occupation) or the date the plaintiff knew or reasonably should have known that the disability was caused or contributed to by asbestos exposure — a discovery-based trigger that accounts for the long latency of mesothelioma. For a wrongful-death claim, the period is one year after the later of the date of death or the date the plaintiff knew or reasonably should have known that the death was caused or contributed to by asbestos exposure. Building a gasket and packing case requires assembling a detailed work history — every job, employer, worksite, and piece of equipment — and matching it to the products the worker encountered, often with the help of co-workers, union and employment records, equipment specifications, and historical product information. Given the latency of the disease and the age of many plaintiffs, California also provides for trial preference under Code of Civil Procedure section 36 in appropriate cases, allowing a seriously ill plaintiff's case to be expedited. Because so much depends on reconstructing exposures that occurred decades ago, and because a mesothelioma diagnosis is often accompanied by a limited life expectancy, prompt action to preserve testimony and evidence is critical. A worker or family facing a mesothelioma diagnosis linked to gaskets, packing, valves, or pumps should seek advice quickly to protect the claim and to begin the work of identifying the responsible manufacturers. The reconstruction effort often draws on union hiring-hall records, Social Security earnings statements, military service and ship records, and the memories of co-workers who performed the same maintenance, each of which can help place the worker at a specific site, with specific equipment, handling specific brands of gaskets and packing. The sooner this evidence is gathered, the stronger and more complete the exposure history, and the better positioned the worker or family is to hold every responsible manufacturer and trust accountable.

Frequently Asked Questions

How were workers exposed to asbestos gaskets and packing?

Asbestos gaskets sealed flanged joints in pumps, valves, boilers, and piping, and asbestos packing sealed valve stems and pump shafts. During maintenance, old gaskets were scraped or ground off and old packing was dug out and replaced, releasing respirable asbestos fibers that nearby workers breathed, often in confined spaces.

Who is most at risk from gasket and packing exposure?

Machinists, pipefitters, steamfitters, boilermakers, insulators, Navy machinist's mates, and refinery and power-plant workers who maintained pumps, valves, and related equipment. Bystanders working nearby and family members exposed to fibers carried home on work clothes can also be at risk.

What is product identification and why does it matter?

Product identification is proof that the worker was exposed to a specific manufacturer's asbestos product. California does not allow market-share liability for asbestos (Mullen v. Armstrong), so under Lineaweaver v. Plant Insulation the plaintiff must show exposure to the defendant's product measured by frequency, regularity, and proximity.

What causation standard applies?

Under Rutherford v. Owens-Illinois (1997) 16 Cal.4th 953, the plaintiff must show that exposure to the defendant's asbestos product was a substantial factor contributing to the aggregate dose of asbestos and thus to the risk of mesothelioma — not that it was the sole cause. This fits cases with exposure to many products over a career.

What is the O'Neil component-parts defense?

In O'Neil v. Crane Co. (2012) 53 Cal.4th 335, the California Supreme Court held that a pump or valve maker generally is not liable for harm caused by asbestos replacement parts made and supplied by others. A manufacturer can still be liable if its own product contributed substantially to the harm or if it participated substantially in creating a harmful combined use; the Court left open whether a product that required asbestos parts to operate could support liability.

How do plaintiffs overcome the component-parts defense?

By showing that the defendant made or supplied the asbestos gaskets or packing the worker actually handled, or that it participated substantially in creating the harmful combined use. Evidence about the product's original components, specifications, and required replacement parts is central to defeating the defense.

Can I recover if some manufacturers are bankrupt?

A manufacturer's bankruptcy does not necessarily end the claim. Many asbestos manufacturers established bankruptcy trusts under 11 U.S.C. section 524(g) to pay claims. A complete strategy pursues both solvent defendants in the tort case and claims against the applicable trusts, with California's apportionment (Prop 51) and setoff rules governing how the recoveries interact.

What is the deadline to file a mesothelioma claim?

Under Code of Civil Procedure section 340.2, a personal-injury asbestos claim must be filed within one year after the later of the date of disability or the date the plaintiff knew or should have known the disability was caused by asbestos; a wrongful-death claim must be filed within one year after the later of the date of death or the date the plaintiff knew or should have known the death was caused by asbestos. Seriously ill plaintiffs may obtain trial preference under section 36.

Help for Workers and Families Facing Mesothelioma

A mesothelioma diagnosis tied to asbestos gaskets and packing is the delayed consequence of exposures that often occurred decades ago, in the engine rooms, boiler rooms, and process units where valves and pumps were maintained. Building the case means identifying the responsible manufacturers, developing product-identification and exposure evidence, applying Rutherford substantial-factor causation, and meeting the O'Neil component-parts defense by showing the defendant made or supplied the asbestos the worker handled or substantially participated in its harmful use — all while pursuing both solvent defendants and bankruptcy trusts. If you or a family member has been diagnosed with mesothelioma linked to gaskets, packing, valves, pumps, or related equipment, our firm can investigate your exposure history and pursue the compensation the law allows, and the statute of limitations makes prompt action important. For related guidance, see our California mesothelioma lawyers and our Los Angeles mesothelioma practice. Call (213) 645-2246 to discuss an asbestos gasket or packing mesothelioma matter with a California attorney.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301