CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT | 2026-11-20

Gray-Market Goods and Customs Border Enforcement: Section 1526, the Lever Rule, and Material Differences for California Importers

How U.S. Customs blocks parallel imports of genuine trademarked goods, when the common-control and authorized-use exceptions let gray-market products through, and what California importers must prove to clear a detention under 19 U.S.C. 1526 and Part 133

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

A California distributor buys authentic, brand-name goods abroad at a lower price and imports them to resell at a discount in the United States. The products are genuine — made by or for the same trademark owner — yet they can be stopped at the border, detained, and even seized by U.S. Customs and...

What "Gray-Market Goods" Means

Gray-market goods — also called parallel imports — are genuine products that bear a genuine trademark but are imported into the United States without the authorization of the U.S. trademark owner. They are fundamentally different from counterfeit goods, which bear a spurious mark that copies a registered trademark. A counterfeit handbag is a fake; a gray-market handbag is the real thing, manufactured by or under license from the same brand, but destined originally for a foreign market and diverted into the United States through unauthorized channels. The "gray" in gray market captures this ambiguity: the goods are authentic, so the transaction is not outright illegal in the way counterfeiting is, but the importation may still infringe the U.S. trademark owner's rights and may be barred at the border. The economic driver is simple — price differences between markets. When a brand sells the same product more cheaply abroad, arbitrageurs buy there and import to resell here below the authorized U.S. price. Brand owners resist this because it undercuts their U.S. distribution, pricing, warranty, and quality-control systems. The legal framework that governs whether these genuine-but-unauthorized goods can be stopped at the border is the subject of Section 1526, the Lanham Act, and CBP's Part 133 regulations.

Section 1526 of the Tariff Act

The principal statute is Section 526 of the Tariff Act of 1930, codified at 19 U.S.C. 1526(a), which makes it unlawful to import into the United States any merchandise of foreign manufacture that bears a trademark owned by a U.S. citizen or corporation and registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, and recorded with CBP, unless written consent of the trademark owner is produced at the time of entry. On its face, the statute is sweeping: it appears to bar any foreign-made goods bearing a recorded U.S. mark without the owner's consent. But the statute has never been applied so broadly. In K mart Corp. v. Cartier, Inc. (1988) 486 U.S. 281, the United States Supreme Court upheld CBP's regulatory interpretation that creates important exceptions — most significantly the common-control exception, under which goods are admissible when the U.S. and foreign trademarks are owned by the same person or by entities under common ownership or control. The Court reasoned that where the same economic enterprise controls both marks, the policy of Section 1526 — protecting an independent U.S. trademark owner from unauthorized imports — is not implicated in the same way. At the same time, the Court invalidated the former "authorized-use" exception, which had admitted goods bearing a mark applied abroad by an independent licensee of the U.S. owner, as inconsistent with the statute. The result is that Section 1526's border bar applies most forcefully to the classic case: an independent U.S. trademark owner whose mark is being used on foreign goods it did not authorize.

The Lanham Act and CBP's Part 133 Regulations

Beyond Section 1526, the Lanham Act provides separate protection. Section 42 of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1124, bars importation of goods that "copy or simulate" a registered U.S. trademark, and Sections 32 and 43(a) (15 U.S.C. 1114, 1125(a)) provide infringement and unfair-competition remedies. CBP administers border enforcement of recorded marks through 19 C.F.R. Part 133, which sets out the procedures for recording trademarks and trade names with CBP, the restrictions on gray-market imports, and the exceptions. Under 19 C.F.R. 133.23, "restricted gray market articles" are foreign-made articles bearing a genuine trademark or trade name identical with or substantially indistinguishable from one owned and recorded by a U.S. citizen or U.S. entity, imported without the U.S. owner's authorization — including goods whose mark was applied by an independent licensee or by a foreign owner that is not the U.S. owner or under common ownership or control with it. Goods whose mark was applied under the authority of the U.S. owner or a commonly owned or controlled party are generally not restricted, implementing the K mart framework. The regulation also permits a trademark owner to restrict even common-control goods if they are physically and materially different from the authorized U.S. products — the key doctrine discussed below. For a California importer, the practical significance is that the admissibility of gray-market goods depends on a specific analysis of ownership, control, authorization, recordation, and material differences under both the statute and the regulations.

The Material-Differences Doctrine and the Lever Rule

The most consequential development in gray-market law is the material-differences doctrine, often called the Lever rule after Lever Brothers Co. v. United States (D.C. Cir. 1989) 877 F.2d 101 and (D.C. Cir. 1993) 981 F.2d 1330. The D.C. Circuit held that the Lanham Act bars the importation of foreign goods that bear a genuine U.S. trademark but are materially different from the U.S. trademark owner's authorized products, even when the U.S. and foreign marks are under common ownership. The rationale is consumer protection: when gray-market goods differ materially from the U.S. versions — different formulation, ingredients, packaging, labeling, warranties, or regulatory compliance — consumers who buy them believing they are getting the authorized U.S. product are deceived, and the trademark's function as a guarantee of consistent quality is undermined. CBP implemented the Lever rule in 19 C.F.R. 133.2(e) and 133.23: a trademark owner may record its mark and obtain "Lever-rule protection" by demonstrating to CBP that its authorized U.S. goods differ physically and materially from the gray-market goods; once granted, CBP will restrict the materially different gray-market articles unless they bear a conspicuous label stating that the product is not authorized by the U.S. trademark owner and is physically and materially different. In Lanham Act litigation, many courts treat the threshold for "material difference" as low — a difference that consumers would likely consider relevant to a purchasing decision — and have considered differences in ingredients, net weight, language of labeling, warranty coverage, and regulatory markings. CBP's Lever-rule protection is narrower: under 19 C.F.R. 133.2(e), the trademark owner must describe physical and material differences with particularity and support them with competent evidence, and CBP may consider factors such as chemical composition, product construction, performance characteristics, and differences resulting from legal or regulatory requirements.

How CBP Enforces at the Border

When goods arrive, CBP compares the entry against its database of recorded marks and Lever-rule determinations. If a shipment appears to contain restricted gray-market goods — a recorded mark, no common-control exception, or a material difference with Lever protection and no required label — CBP may detain the shipment under 19 C.F.R. Part 133 and 19 U.S.C. 1499. Under 19 C.F.R. 133.23(d), restricted gray-market goods are detained for 30 days from the date they are presented for examination, during which the importer may establish admissibility: by producing the trademark owner's written consent, demonstrating common control, showing that the goods are not materially different, or applying the required Lever label. If the goods are not released within the detention period, they are seized and forfeiture proceedings begin under 19 C.F.R. 133.23(f); Section 1526(b) makes merchandise imported in violation of the statute subject to seizure and forfeiture. (Section 1526(e), by contrast, addresses merchandise bearing a counterfeit mark, and Section 1526(f) imposes civil fines on those who facilitate importation of seized counterfeit goods.) The importer receives notice and may file a petition for relief under 19 C.F.R. Part 171 or contest the forfeiture. Because detention and seizure can destroy the commercial value of a time-sensitive shipment, the ability to respond quickly and accurately — with evidence of consent, common control, or lack of material difference — is critical. A California importer who understands the framework before shipping can structure the transaction to avoid a detention in the first place.

Common Control, Authorized Use, and Consent

Three related concepts determine admissibility in most gray-market disputes. First, common control: under 19 C.F.R. 133.23(d), goods are generally admissible when the U.S. and foreign trademarks are owned by the same person or by a parent, subsidiary, or commonly controlled entity — the K mart exception — subject to the Lever material-differences overlay. Second, authorized use is not by itself enough: in K mart the Supreme Court struck down the former authorized-use exception, and under 19 C.F.R. 133.23(a) goods bearing a mark applied by an independent licensee of the U.S. owner are restricted gray-market articles unless another exception, such as written consent, applies. Third, written consent: Section 1526(a) itself admits goods when the written consent of the U.S. trademark owner is produced at entry. Each of these turns on documentary proof. An importer claiming common control must show the ownership or control relationship; an importer claiming consent must produce the owner's written authorization. The burden falls on the importer to establish admissibility, and a bare assertion will not suffice against a recorded mark. The analysis is further complicated where corporate structures involve multiple affiliates, licensing arrangements, and distribution agreements, which is why the ownership and authorization chain must be mapped carefully before importing goods bearing a recorded U.S. mark.

Responding to a Detention or Seizure

When CBP detains an alleged gray-market shipment, time is short. Under 19 U.S.C. 1499, CBP must generally decide whether to release or seize detained merchandise within specified periods, and an importer should respond promptly with evidence of admissibility. If CBP seizes the goods, the importer receives a notice of seizure and may pursue several paths: file a petition for relief under 19 C.F.R. Part 171 asking CBP to mitigate or remit the forfeiture, or contest the forfeiture in judicial forfeiture proceedings in federal district court. The importer may also seek to establish that the goods are not restricted — that they fall within the common-control exception, are not materially different, or bear the required Lever label. Where the dispute concerns a CBP classification or admissibility ruling, the importer may seek a binding ruling from CBP under 19 C.F.R. Part 177 before importing, which can provide greater certainty about how specific goods will be treated. And where CBP denies a protest concerning the exclusion of merchandise, the importer may have recourse to the Court of International Trade under 28 U.S.C. 1581(a). Each avenue has strict deadlines and evidentiary requirements, and the right strategy depends on the posture of the shipment, the strength of the admissibility arguments, and the commercial stakes.

Practical Compliance for California Importers

For a California importer considering parallel imports, the lesson is to analyze admissibility before shipping, not after a container is detained. The importer should determine whether the mark on the goods is recorded with CBP; whether the U.S. and foreign marks are under common control; whether the goods are materially different from the authorized U.S. versions and whether the owner holds Lever-rule protection; and whether written consent is available. If material differences exist and Lever protection is in place, the importer may still be able to import by applying the required disclosure label. The importer should also assess parallel exposure under state law — California's unfair-competition and false-advertising statutes, Business and Professions Code sections 17200 and 17500, can reach the resale of materially different goods marketed as if they were the authorized U.S. product. Brand owners, conversely, should record their marks with CBP, seek Lever-rule determinations where their U.S. and foreign products differ, and monitor for unauthorized parallel imports. In every case, documentation is decisive: the ownership chain, the authorization and consent documents, and side-by-side product comparisons establishing the presence or absence of material differences. An importer who assembles this record in advance is far better positioned than one scrambling to answer a detention notice while a shipment sits at the port.

Why Gray-Market Enforcement Is Contested

Gray-market disputes are contentious because the goods are genuine, so the equities are not as one-sided as in counterfeiting cases. Importers argue that they are reselling authentic products and that consumers benefit from lower prices and competition; brand owners argue that unauthorized parallel imports undermine their quality control, warranties, pricing, and distribution systems, and deceive consumers who expect the authorized U.S. product. Courts and CBP have struck the balance through the material-differences framework: where the gray-market goods are identical to the authorized U.S. versions and the marks are under common control, the goods are generally admissible, reflecting the view that consumers are not harmed; but where the goods are materially different, the law restricts them to protect consumers and the trademark's quality-guarantee function. This is why the material-differences analysis is the heart of most gray-market cases, and why the outcome often turns on fine distinctions in formulation, labeling, warranty, and regulatory compliance. For importers and brand owners alike, the practical consequence is that a careful, documented comparison of the U.S. and foreign products — not a general sense that the goods are "the same brand" — determines whether a shipment clears or is seized.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are gray-market goods?

Gray-market goods, or parallel imports, are genuine products bearing a genuine trademark that are imported into the United States without the authorization of the U.S. trademark owner. They are authentic — not counterfeit — but may still be barred at the border under 19 U.S.C. 1526 and the Lanham Act.

How are gray-market goods different from counterfeits?

Counterfeit goods bear a spurious, copied mark and are fakes; gray-market goods bear a genuine mark and are authentic products originally intended for a foreign market. The legal analysis is different: counterfeits are categorically barred, while gray-market goods may or may not be admissible depending on ownership, control, and material differences.

What is Section 1526?

Section 526 of the Tariff Act, 19 U.S.C. 1526, bars importation of foreign-made goods bearing a U.S.-owned, registered, and CBP-recorded trademark without the written consent of the trademark owner. The Supreme Court in K mart Corp. v. Cartier (1988) 486 U.S. 281 upheld CBP's common-control exceptions but struck down the former authorized-use exception.

What is the common-control exception?

Under 19 C.F.R. 133.23 and K mart, gray-market goods are generally admissible when the U.S. and foreign trademarks are owned by the same entity or by entities under common ownership or control. This exception is subject to the Lever material-differences rule.

What is the Lever rule?

The Lever rule, from Lever Brothers Co. v. United States (D.C. Cir. 1989/1993), bars importation of gray-market goods that are physically and materially different from the authorized U.S. products, even under common ownership, to protect consumers from deception. CBP implements it through 19 C.F.R. 133.2(e) and 133.23, allowing restriction unless the goods bear a required disclosure label.

What counts as a "material difference"?

In Lanham Act cases, many courts treat a difference as material if consumers would likely consider it relevant to a purchasing decision, and have considered ingredients, formulation, net weight, labeling language, warranty coverage, and regulatory markings. For CBP Lever-rule protection, the trademark owner must prove physical and material differences with particularity under 19 C.F.R. 133.2(e).

What happens if CBP detains my gray-market shipment?

CBP may detain the goods and give you an opportunity to establish admissibility by producing the trademark owner's written consent, showing common control, demonstrating the goods are not materially different, or applying a required Lever label. Restricted goods are detained for 30 days under 19 C.F.R. 133.23(d); if they are not released, they are seized under 19 C.F.R. 133.23(f) and 19 U.S.C. 1526(b), and you can file a petition for relief under 19 C.F.R. Part 171.

How can I avoid a gray-market detention?

Analyze admissibility before shipping: check whether the mark is recorded with CBP, whether the U.S. and foreign marks are under common control, whether the goods are materially different and whether the owner holds Lever-rule protection, and whether written consent is available. A binding ruling under 19 C.F.R. Part 177 can provide greater certainty before importing.

Protecting Your Import Business

Gray-market enforcement sits at the intersection of customs law and trademark law, and a mistake can mean a detained container, a seizure, and a forfeited shipment. Whether you are an importer sourcing genuine goods abroad or a brand owner protecting your U.S. market, the key is to analyze admissibility under Section 1526, the Lanham Act, and 19 C.F.R. Part 133 before the goods move — mapping ownership and control, securing consent or authorization, and comparing the U.S. and foreign products for material differences. If you are facing a CBP detention or seizure of alleged gray-market goods, or you need to structure an import program or record and enforce your marks, our firm can help you navigate the statute, the regulations, and the Lever-rule framework. For related guidance, see our international trade and customs practice. Call (213) 645-2246 to discuss your gray-market or parallel-import matter with an attorney who handles customs border-enforcement issues for California importers and brand owners. You can also read about our customs defense practice.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301