CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT | 2026-11-10

EAPA Evasion Investigations: How CBP Polices Antidumping Duty Evasion and What California Importers Must Do to Defend Themselves

How the Enforce and Protect Act under 19 U.S.C. 1517 lets CBP investigate transshipment and duty evasion, and the due-process rights importers gained after Royal Brush

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

A California importer can receive goods for years, pay every invoice, and still wake up to a Customs and Border Protection notice alleging it evaded antidumping duties, with its entries suddenly subject to cash deposits, live-entry requirements, and withheld liquidation. The vehicle for that upheava

Antidumping and countervailing duty orders only work if importers actually pay the duties. When foreign producers and their U.S. customers try to dodge those duties, by routing goods through a third country to disguise their origin, misdescribing the merchandise, or falsely claiming an exclusion, the whole remedial system is undermined. Congress responded in 2016 by enacting the Enforce and Protect Act, codified at 19 U.S.C. 1517, which gives Customs and Border Protection a formal, deadline-driven process to investigate alleged evasion. For a California importer, an EAPA investigation can be as disruptive as the underlying duty order itself.

What Counts as Evasion Under 19 U.S.C. 1517

EAPA defines evasion as entering covered merchandise into the United States through a material and false statement or act, or a material omission, that results in the reduction or avoidance of applicable antidumping or countervailing duties. The classic example is transshipment: Chinese-origin goods subject to a high antidumping order are shipped to a third country, lightly processed or simply relabeled, and then entered into the United States as a product of that third country to escape the order.

But evasion is broader than transshipment. It can include misclassifying merchandise under a tariff heading not covered by the order, undervaluing or misdescribing goods, falsely certifying that merchandise falls outside the scope of an order, or using a producer or exporter identity to obtain a lower cash-deposit rate than the goods actually warrant. The common thread is a material misstatement or omission at entry that reduces the AD/CVD duties owed. Importantly, CBP treats EAPA as a strict-liability statute, and the Court of International Trade has upheld that reading, for example in Ikadan System USA, Inc. v. United States (CIT 2023): a material false statement that results in duty avoidance can support an evasion finding without proof of intent to defraud, although the statute excludes genuine clerical errors that are not part of a pattern of negligent conduct.

How an EAPA Investigation Begins and Proceeds

An EAPA proceeding usually starts with an allegation filed by an interested party, often a domestic producer or a competitor, or a referral from within the government. Once CBP acknowledges a properly filed allegation, it has 15 business days to decide whether to initiate an investigation. The regulations implementing EAPA appear at 19 C.F.R. Part 165 and set out the timeline, the parties, and the evidentiary framework.

The statute imposes tight deadlines on CBP. Ordinarily, CBP must make its final determination as to evasion within 300 calendar days of initiation, extendable to 360 days in complex cases. Along the way, the parties may submit factual information and written arguments. If CBP finds evasion, it takes steps to collect the duties that should have been paid, including suspending or extending liquidation of the affected entries, requiring cash deposits at the appropriate rate, and referring the matter for possible penalty action.

What makes EAPA so consequential is what happens before any final determination. If CBP has a reasonable suspicion of evasion early in the investigation, it must impose interim measures.

Interim Measures: The Early Blow

Within 90 calendar days of initiating an investigation, if CBP determines there is a reasonable suspicion that the importer entered covered merchandise through evasion, it imposes interim measures under 19 U.S.C. 1517(e). These measures can include suspending the liquidation of unliquidated entries, extending liquidation on entries that would otherwise liquidate, requiring cash deposits of estimated duties, and implementing additional measures such as single transaction bonds or live-entry requirements.

For a California importer, interim measures can be devastating even before any finding of wrongdoing, because they tie up cash, disrupt the supply chain, and signal risk to lenders and customers. And because the standard for interim measures, reasonable suspicion, is far lower than the standard for a final evasion determination, importers are often hit with these measures on a thin early record. That is precisely why early and informed participation in the investigation matters so much.

The Due-Process Problem and Royal Brush

For years, importers complained that EAPA investigations were fundamentally unfair because CBP relied on confidential business information submitted by the accusing party without giving the accused importer meaningful access to that information or a chance to rebut it. Unlike antidumping proceedings at the Commerce Department, EAPA as administered by CBP had no robust administrative protective order system allowing counsel to see the business proprietary information underlying the allegations.

The Federal Circuit addressed this in Royal Brush Manufacturing, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2023). The court held that CBP violated an importer's constitutional due-process rights by relying on confidential information without providing the importer adequate access to it, and that the agency could not cure the problem simply by offering public summaries. The decision confirmed that importers in EAPA proceedings are entitled to the basic due-process protections of notice and a meaningful opportunity to respond, including access, under appropriate safeguards, to the information used against them.

Royal Brush was a significant win for importers. It did not abolish EAPA or make evasion findings harder to justify on the merits, but it forced CBP to confront the procedural fairness of its process and gave importers a concrete basis to challenge determinations built on information they were never allowed to see. California importers facing an EAPA investigation should insist on the access that Royal Brush recognizes and should preserve the issue for appeal if CBP withholds it.

Appealing an EAPA Determination

An importer dissatisfied with CBP's final evasion determination has two sequential levels of review. First, within 30 business days of the determination, it may request de novo administrative review by Regulations and Rulings in CBP's Office of Trade, which must complete the review within 60 business days. Second, within 30 business days after that administrative review is completed, it may challenge both the determination and the review in the U.S. Court of International Trade, which examines whether CBP fully complied with the required procedures and whether any determination, finding, or conclusion was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law. From the CIT, further appeal lies to the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, as Royal Brush itself demonstrates.

These appeals are technical and deadline-driven, and they turn heavily on the administrative record. Because the CIT generally reviews the record CBP compiled, the importer's submissions during the investigation, its factual evidence of legitimate sourcing, its challenges to the accuser's allegations, and its objections to procedural unfairness, become the raw material for any appeal. An importer that treats the CBP investigation as a mere formality, and fails to build the record, will find its options on appeal correspondingly narrow.

How California Importers Defend Themselves

The best defense to an EAPA allegation is a documented, legitimate supply chain. Importers who maintain complete records of production, including mill certificates, production records at the actual factory, shipping documentation showing the true country of origin, and evidence of substantial manufacturing in the claimed country of origin, can rebut transshipment allegations with facts. Where the merchandise genuinely falls outside the scope of an order, a scope ruling from the Commerce Department can head off or resolve an evasion claim, because EAPA evasion depends on the goods being covered merchandise in the first place.

Practically, a California importer should respond to an EAPA notice immediately, retain counsel experienced in trade enforcement, demand access to the information underlying the allegation consistent with Royal Brush, and submit a thorough factual response within the regulatory deadlines. Equally important is managing the downstream exposure: because evasion findings can lead to penalties under 19 U.S.C. 1592 and to referrals for civil or even criminal liability, the importer's response strategy should account for the full range of consequences, not just the immediate duty bill.

EAPA in the Broader Enforcement Landscape

EAPA does not operate in isolation. It sits alongside CBP's traditional penalty authority under 19 U.S.C. 1592, the False Claims Act exposure that can arise when importers knowingly underpay duties, and the Commerce Department's scope inquiries under 19 C.F.R. 351.225 and circumvention inquiries under 19 U.S.C. 1677j. A single sourcing problem can trigger several of these mechanisms at once, which is why a coordinated legal response is essential. An importer that resolves an EAPA investigation without considering parallel 1592 penalty exposure, or a potential qui tam action, may solve one problem while leaving others unaddressed.

For California's import-dependent economy, from the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach to inland distribution hubs, EAPA enforcement is a permanent feature of the compliance landscape. Understanding the statute, the interim-measures trap, and the due-process protections of Royal Brush is the foundation of any effective defense. The importers who fare best are those who build compliance and documentation into their sourcing before an allegation ever arrives, and who engage knowledgeable counsel the moment one does.

Covered Merchandise and the Scope Threshold

An EAPA case cannot exist unless the goods are covered merchandise, meaning merchandise subject to an antidumping or countervailing duty order. This threshold requirement is both a vulnerability for the government and an opportunity for the importer. If the imported product falls outside the scope of the order, there can be no evasion, because there were no applicable duties to evade. That is why a scope ruling from the Department of Commerce under 19 C.F.R. 351.225 can be decisive: a determination that the merchandise is not within the order’s scope removes the foundation of the evasion allegation.

Because scope and evasion are decided by different agencies, Commerce for scope and CBP for evasion, coordination is essential. CBP may refer a scope question to Commerce during an EAPA investigation and suspend its own timeline while Commerce rules. A California importer convinced that its goods are outside the order should consider seeking a scope ruling proactively, rather than waiting for CBP to frame the question. A favorable scope determination not only defeats the EAPA case but can prevent future allegations on the same product.

The scope inquiry also illustrates why precise product knowledge matters. Small differences in composition, dimensions, or processing can place a product inside or outside an order. Importers who understand exactly where their goods fall relative to the scope language are far better equipped to respond to an evasion allegation, and to document, in advance, why their entries are lawful.

Single Transaction Bonds, Live Entry, and Cash-Flow Survival

Among the harshest practical effects of an EAPA investigation are the enhanced bonding and entry requirements CBP can impose as interim or final measures. A single transaction bond requires the importer to post a bond for each individual shipment, rather than relying on a continuous bond that covers a year of imports, dramatically increasing transaction costs and tying up credit. Live-entry requirements force the importer to present documentation and deposits before merchandise is released, slowing the supply chain to a crawl.

For many importers, these cash-flow effects, not the ultimate duty bill, are what threaten the business. A company operating on thin margins can be pushed toward insolvency by the working-capital demands of per-shipment bonding and extended liquidation, even before any final evasion finding. This is why challenging interim measures, and demonstrating a legitimate supply chain early, is not merely a legal nicety but a matter of commercial survival. An importer that can promptly rebut the reasonable-suspicion basis for interim measures may avoid the cash-flow squeeze that does the real damage, and counsel experienced in trade enforcement can press CBP to narrow or lift measures that are not supported by the record.

Who Is an Interested Party, and What the Allegation Must Show

EAPA proceedings are usually set in motion by an interested party, a category that includes domestic manufacturers and producers of like merchandise, trade associations, and unions, among others. These parties have a competitive stake in enforcing AD/CVD orders and may file allegations identifying importers they believe are evading duties. The allegation must be accompanied by information reasonably available to the filer, and CBP initiates an investigation only if that information reasonably suggests that covered merchandise was entered through evasion.

For the targeted importer, understanding who filed the allegation and on what basis is an early strategic priority. The accuser’s submission frames the investigation, and testing its factual and legal assumptions, whether the merchandise is truly covered, whether the alleged transshipment actually occurred, whether the identified entries are the importer’s, is central to the defense. Because much of the accuser’s information may be submitted as business proprietary information, the access principles confirmed in Royal Brush are directly relevant: an importer cannot meaningfully rebut an allegation it is not permitted to see. Insisting on appropriate access, and holding CBP to the reasonably-suggests standard at initiation, the reasonable-suspicion standard for interim measures, and the substantial-evidence standard at the final determination, is how a well-represented importer keeps the process fair and the record honest.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Enforce and Protect Act?

The Enforce and Protect Act, codified at 19 U.S.C. 1517, is a 2016 law that created a formal administrative process for Customs and Border Protection to investigate whether merchandise was entered into the United States through evasion of antidumping or countervailing duty orders.

What does evasion mean under EAPA?

Evasion is entering covered merchandise through a material false statement or act, or a material omission, that results in the reduction or avoidance of applicable AD/CVD duties. Transshipment through a third country is the classic example, but misclassification, undervaluation, and false scope claims also qualify. The Court of International Trade has held that a finding does not require proof of intent to defraud, although isolated clerical errors are excluded.

What are interim measures?

If CBP finds a reasonable suspicion of evasion within 90 days of initiating an investigation, 19 U.S.C. 1517(e) requires it to impose interim measures, which can include suspending liquidation, requiring cash deposits, and imposing single transaction bonds or live-entry requirements, all before any final finding.

How long does an EAPA investigation take?

CBP generally must issue its final determination within 300 days of initiation, extendable to 360 days in complex cases. The implementing regulations are at 19 C.F.R. Part 165.

What did Royal Brush decide?

In Royal Brush Manufacturing, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2023), the Federal Circuit held that CBP violated an importer's due-process rights by relying on confidential information without giving the importer adequate access to it, and that public summaries alone did not cure the violation.

How can an importer appeal an evasion finding?

An importer may first request de novo administrative review by CBP's Regulations and Rulings (Office of Trade) within 30 business days of the determination, and then, within 30 business days after that review is completed, challenge the determination and the review at the U.S. Court of International Trade, with further appeal to the Federal Circuit. Review focuses on the administrative record, so building that record during the investigation is critical.

How do importers defend against an EAPA allegation?

By documenting a legitimate supply chain, mill certificates, factory production records, and true country-of-origin shipping documents, demanding record access consistent with Royal Brush, and submitting a thorough, timely response. A Commerce scope ruling can also resolve whether the goods are covered merchandise at all.

Can an EAPA case lead to other penalties?

Yes. Evasion findings can lead to penalties under 19 U.S.C. 1592, False Claims Act exposure, and Commerce scope inquiries under 19 C.F.R. 351.225 or circumvention inquiries under 19 U.S.C. 1677j. A coordinated response should address all parallel exposure, not just the immediate duty bill.

Related Guides

If your California business has received an EAPA evasion notice, been hit with interim measures, or needs to defend its sourcing against a transshipment allegation, the trade attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can protect your record and your rights. Call (213) 645-2246 for a consultation on your customs enforcement and duty-evasion exposure.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301