CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT | 2026-10-15
EAPA Evasion Investigations in California: How the Enforce and Protect Act (19 U.S.C. § 1517) Works, What Triggers an Investigation, and How Importers Defend Against Allegations of Antidumping Duty Evasion
A single competitor allegation can put a California importer under a formal U.S. Customs and Border Protection evasion investigation, freeze its merchandise with interim measures, and expose it to years of retroactive antidumping and countervailing duties. Understanding how the Enforce and Protect Act process works — the deadlines, the evidence standard, the due-process rights, and the appeal path — is essential to defending the company.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
For a California importer, few customs problems are more serious than a formal evasion investigation under the Enforce and Protect Act (EAPA), codified at 19 U.S.C. § 1517 . Enacted as part of the Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act of 2015, EAPA gave U.S. Customs and Border Protection a de
The Enforce and Protect Act changed the landscape for importers of goods that compete with merchandise subject to antidumping and countervailing duty orders. Before EAPA, allegations that a company was evading AD/CVD duties — by transshipping Chinese goods through a third country, misdescribing the merchandise, or misstating the country of origin — were difficult for domestic industry to pursue and slow for Customs to act on. EAPA created a transparent, deadline-driven administrative process with real consequences: formal investigations, interim measures that bite quickly, and determinations that can impose years of retroactive duties. For a California importer, understanding that process is the first step to surviving it.
What EAPA Is and Why It Exists
EAPA, codified at 19 U.S.C. § 1517 and implemented through regulations at 19 C.F.R. part 165, authorizes U.S. Customs and Border Protection to investigate allegations that merchandise covered by an AD or CVD order entered the United States through evasion. Congress enacted it in 2016 because the United States was losing substantial revenue — and domestic industries were losing the protection the trade-remedy laws were meant to provide — when importers avoided AD/CVD duties through schemes that were hard to detect and harder to prove. EAPA gives domestic manufacturers and other interested parties a formal mechanism to bring evidence of evasion to CBP, and it gives CBP a structured timeline and clear authority to act. The statute is enforcement-oriented and, by design, favors prompt protective action: interim measures can be imposed on a relatively low showing well before the agency reaches a final conclusion.
What Counts as “Evasion” Under the Statute
Evasion has a specific statutory meaning. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(a)(5), evasion is the entry of covered merchandise into the United States by means of a material false statement or act, or a material omission, that results in the reduction or avoidance of applicable antidumping or countervailing duties. Three elements matter. First, the merchandise must be covered merchandise — goods within the scope of an existing AD/CVD order. Second, there must be a false statement, act, or omission that is material. Third, that falsity or omission must have caused the reduction or non-payment of AD/CVD duties. Common fact patterns include transshipment (routing Chinese-origin goods through a third country and declaring that country as the origin), misclassification or misdescription of the merchandise to place it outside the order’s scope, and undervaluation or false manufacturer identification. Notably, EAPA evasion does not require proof of intent to defraud in the criminal sense; it is an administrative determination about whether covered merchandise entered through a material misstatement or omission.
How an Investigation Begins: Allegations and Initiation
An EAPA case usually starts with an allegation filed by an interested party — typically a domestic producer of the competing product, but also a trade association, a union, or a wholesaler or retailer of a domestic like product (19 U.S.C. § 1517(a)(6)). CBP may also initiate on a referral from another federal agency. Once a properly filed allegation is received, CBP has 15 business days to decide whether to initiate an investigation, and it initiates if the allegation reasonably suggests that covered merchandise entered through evasion. The importer named in the allegation is not necessarily notified at the moment of initiation; in practice, importers often first learn of an investigation when interim measures appear or when CBP issues requests for information. Because the allegation frames the entire investigation, a California importer that receives any CBP request for information touching AD/CVD scope, origin, or supply chain should treat it as potentially connected to an EAPA proceeding and respond carefully.
Interim Measures: The 90-Day Freeze
The feature of EAPA that most alarms importers is interim measures. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(e), if CBP determines within 90 calendar days of initiating an investigation that there is a reasonable suspicion that the importer entered covered merchandise through evasion, it must impose interim measures. These measures can include suspending liquidation of the importer’s unliquidated entries of the covered merchandise, extending the period for liquidating entries, requiring cash deposits of estimated AD/CVD duties on the entries, and taking other actions CBP considers appropriate to protect the revenue. The “reasonable suspicion” threshold is low, and interim measures can be imposed long before any final determination. For a company bringing in containers of the covered merchandise, interim measures can mean sudden cash-deposit demands and suspended entries that disrupt the entire supply chain. Contesting the factual basis for interim measures early — by showing, for example, legitimate third-country manufacturing — is often the most urgent task in an EAPA defense.
The Investigation Timeline and the Evidentiary Record
EAPA runs on statutory deadlines. CBP must generally make its final determination as to evasion within 300 calendar days of initiating the investigation, a period that may be extended to 360 days in complex cases (19 U.S.C. § 1517(c)(1)). During the investigation, CBP gathers evidence through requests for information to the importer and to foreign suppliers, questionnaires, site-visit reports, and submissions from the alleging party. The parties to the investigation — the importer and the alleger — may submit factual information and written arguments to the administrative record on a schedule CBP sets. CBP’s determination must be based on substantial evidence on that record. A crucial point for importers is that the record closes: facts and arguments not timely submitted generally cannot be considered later, including on appeal. This makes disciplined, well-documented participation during the investigation — complete responses, supporting business records, and clear legal argument on scope and origin — essential rather than optional.
Adverse Inferences for Non-Cooperation
EAPA contains a powerful tool that punishes silence. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(c)(3), if the importer or a foreign producer fails to cooperate by not acting to the best of its ability to comply with a request for information, CBP may apply an adverse inference in selecting the facts used in reaching its determination. In practice, this means that an importer who ignores or inadequately answers CBP’s questionnaires can have the agency assume the worst — for example, that the merchandise was transshipped — even without direct proof, simply because the importer did not provide the records that would show otherwise. This is one of the most common ways importers lose EAPA cases: not because the evidence of evasion was strong, but because they failed to respond fully and the agency filled the gaps with adverse inferences. A central principle of EAPA defense is therefore to cooperate completely and document that cooperation.
Covered-Merchandise Referrals to Commerce
Sometimes the real dispute in an EAPA case is not whether goods were transshipped but whether the merchandise is within the scope of the AD/CVD order at all — a legal question about the order’s coverage. EAPA addresses this through a covered-merchandise referral. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(b)(4), if CBP cannot determine whether the merchandise at issue is covered by the order, it refers that question to the U.S. Department of Commerce, which administers the AD/CVD orders and decides scope questions. Commerce’s scope determination then binds CBP’s evasion analysis. For an importer, recognizing when a case is really a scope dispute — and pressing for a covered-merchandise referral or a separate scope ruling from Commerce — can be decisive, because if the goods are outside the order, there is no covered merchandise and therefore no evasion as a matter of law.
Due Process After Royal Brush
For years, importers complained that EAPA was fundamentally unfair because CBP would rely on confidential business information submitted by the alleging party without giving the importer meaningful access to it, leaving the importer unable to see and rebut the evidence against it. The Federal Circuit addressed this in Royal Brush Manufacturing, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2023) 75 F.4th 1250, holding that CBP’s failure to provide the importer access to the confidential information on which it relied violated due process. The decision pushed CBP toward an administrative-protective-order (APO) framework that allows parties’ counsel to access confidential record information, more like the process used in Commerce’s AD/CVD proceedings. For California importers, Royal Brush is an important shield: it establishes that an importer has a constitutional right to see and respond to the evidence used against it in an EAPA case, and a determination made without that access is vulnerable on appeal.
Administrative Review and the De Novo Appeal to the CIT
An importer that loses before CBP has two layers of further review. First, EAPA provides an administrative review of the initial determination within CBP (handled by a different office than the one that made the initial determination), on request filed within the regulatory deadline. Second, and critically, EAPA grants judicial review: under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(g), a party may appeal to the U.S. Court of International Trade (CIT), which reviews whether CBP’s determination was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law, and whether it was supported by substantial evidence on the record. A further appeal lies to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Because judicial review is generally confined to the administrative record, the arguments and evidence an importer preserves during the CBP investigation define what the courts can later consider — another reason the investigation stage is where EAPA cases are won or lost.
What the Consequences of an Adverse Determination Are
A final affirmative evasion determination has serious and lasting consequences. CBP will suspend liquidation (or continue the suspension) of the affected entries, require cash deposits of AD/CVD duties at the applicable rates, and ultimately liquidate the entries with the full antidumping and countervailing duties owed — amounts that can reach well over 100% of the entered value for some orders, applied retroactively to the entries covered by the investigation. CBP may also take additional enforcement action and refer matters for penalty proceedings under separate statutes (such as 19 U.S.C. § 1592) where warranted. For a California importer, the combined exposure — retroactive duties on many entries, disrupted supply, and potential follow-on penalties — can threaten the viability of the business. That is why an EAPA allegation should never be treated as routine correspondence.
How a California Importer Defends an EAPA Case
A sound EAPA defense is built on several fronts at once. The importer should promptly map its supply chain and gather documentary proof of genuine manufacturing in the declared country of origin — production records, mill certificates, factory photographs, utility and payroll records, and shipping documents that trace the goods from raw material to export. It should respond completely and on time to every CBP request to avoid adverse inferences, and coordinate with foreign suppliers to ensure they cooperate as well. Where the real issue is scope, it should press for a covered-merchandise referral or obtain a scope ruling from Commerce. It should invoke its Royal Brush due-process rights to access and rebut confidential information, and it should contest the factual basis for interim measures as early as possible to relieve the cash-deposit burden. Finally, it should preserve every legal and factual argument on the administrative record so that, if necessary, the determination can be challenged de novo at the CIT. Experienced customs counsel coordinates these fronts so that the company’s position is documented, consistent, and preserved at each deadline-driven stage.
Prevention: Compliance Before an Allegation Arrives
The best EAPA defense is a compliance posture that makes evasion allegations easy to refute. Importers of goods that compete with AD/CVD-covered merchandise should conduct origin due diligence on their suppliers, obtain and retain manufacturing documentation, verify that country-of-origin declarations reflect substantial transformation in the declared country, and periodically audit their classifications and valuations against the scope language of relevant orders. Where there is genuine doubt about whether merchandise is covered, seeking a scope ruling from Commerce in advance converts an ambiguous risk into a documented answer. A company that can produce a clean, well-organized evidentiary file on short notice is far better positioned to defeat an allegation at the interim-measures stage — or to avoid initiation altogether — than one that must reconstruct its supply chain under the pressure of a 90-day clock.
Related Guides
- California International Trade & Customs Lawyers
- Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Scope Rulings and Circumvention in California
- Customs Penalties Under 19 U.S.C. § 1592 and Prior Disclosure for California Importers
- Customs Liquidation, Reliquidation, and Deemed Liquidation for California Importers
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Enforce and Protect Act (EAPA)?
EAPA, codified at 19 U.S.C. § 1517 and implemented by 19 C.F.R. part 165, is a law enacted in 2016 that authorizes U.S. Customs and Border Protection to investigate allegations that merchandise subject to an antidumping or countervailing duty order entered the United States through evasion. It created a formal, deadline-driven administrative process with interim measures, final determinations, and a right of appeal to the Court of International Trade.
What does “evasion” mean under 19 U.S.C. § 1517?
Evasion is the entry of covered merchandise by a material false statement or act, or a material omission, that results in the reduction or avoidance of applicable antidumping or countervailing duties. It requires covered merchandise, a material misstatement or omission, and a resulting reduction or non-payment of the duties. It does not require proof of criminal intent to defraud.
How does an EAPA investigation start?
Usually with an allegation filed by an interested party, such as a domestic producer of the competing product. CBP has 15 business days to decide whether to initiate, and it initiates if the allegation reasonably suggests that covered merchandise entered through evasion. Importers often first learn of an investigation when interim measures or requests for information appear.
What are interim measures and how fast can they be imposed?
Interim measures are protective actions — suspending liquidation, extending liquidation, and requiring cash deposits of estimated AD/CVD duties — that CBP must impose within 90 days of initiation if it finds a reasonable suspicion of evasion. The threshold is low, so these measures can freeze entries and impose cash-deposit burdens well before any final determination of wrongdoing.
How long does an EAPA investigation take?
CBP must generally make its final determination as to evasion within 300 calendar days of initiation, extendable to 360 days in complex cases. During that time the parties submit factual information and arguments to an administrative record, and CBP’s determination must be supported by substantial evidence on that record.
What happens if I do not fully respond to CBP’s requests?
Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(c)(3), if an importer or foreign producer fails to cooperate to the best of its ability, CBP may apply an adverse inference in selecting the facts for its determination — effectively assuming the worst. Many importers lose EAPA cases not because evasion was proven but because they failed to respond fully and the agency filled the gaps against them.
What did Royal Brush decide about due process?
In Royal Brush Manufacturing v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2023) 75 F.4th 1250, the Federal Circuit held that CBP violated due process by relying on confidential business information without giving the importer meaningful access to it. The decision pushed CBP toward an administrative-protective-order framework and established that an importer has a right to see and rebut the evidence used against it.
Can I appeal an adverse EAPA determination?
Yes. EAPA provides an internal administrative review and then judicial review under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(g) at the U.S. Court of International Trade, with a further appeal to the Federal Circuit. Because review is generally confined to the administrative record, the arguments and evidence preserved during the CBP investigation define what the courts can consider. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246 to discuss an EAPA matter.
Talk to a California Customs Lawyer About an EAPA Investigation
An EAPA allegation can freeze a California importer’s entries and expose it to years of retroactive antidumping and countervailing duties, but the process is deadline-driven and the outcome often turns on how thoroughly the importer participates. Trembach Law Firm, led by Anatolii Trembach (LL.M.; admitted in California), defends importers across the full EAPA process — contesting interim measures, building the supply-chain record, asserting Royal Brush due-process rights, pursuing covered-merchandise referrals, and challenging adverse determinations at the Court of International Trade. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301