CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT | 2026-10-10
EAPA Evasion Investigations: How California Importers Face CBP Allegations of Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Evasion
Under the Enforce and Protect Act, a competitor’s allegation can trigger a Customs investigation that suspends your entries, imposes bonding requirements, and ends in a finding of duty evasion — often before you have said a word. Understanding the EAPA process under 19 U.S.C. § 1517 is essential for any California importer of goods subject to antidumping or countervailing duty orders.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
For a California importer bringing in goods that compete with domestic industry, few letters are more alarming than a notice that U.S. Customs and Border Protection has initiated an investigation under the Enforce and Protect Act (EAPA). Enacted as part of the Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcemen
The United States imposes antidumping and countervailing duties to offset unfairly low-priced or subsidized imports that injure domestic industry. Those duties can be steep — sometimes exceeding 100% of the goods' value — which creates a powerful incentive to evade them by transshipping goods through third countries, misdescribing merchandise, or falsifying country-of-origin declarations. The Enforce and Protect Act was Congress's answer: a formal, time-bound mechanism that lets CBP investigate and penalize evasion. For the honest importer caught in an EAPA investigation, the stakes are high and the process is unforgiving of delay.
What Antidumping and Countervailing Duties Are
Antidumping duties address "dumping" — the sale of imported goods in the United States at less than fair value, typically below the price in the exporter's home market. Countervailing duties offset foreign government subsidies that lower the cost of exported goods. These duties are imposed through orders issued after investigations by the U.S. Department of Commerce and the International Trade Commission, and they apply to specific products from specific countries. Because the duty rates can be very large, the difference between goods that are "subject merchandise" and goods that are not can be enormous. Evasion schemes exploit that difference — for example, by routing Chinese goods subject to an AD/CVD order through a third country and declaring that country as the origin, so the goods appear not to be subject to the order. EAPA exists to detect and punish exactly this conduct.
How an EAPA Investigation Begins
An EAPA investigation typically starts with an allegation filed with CBP by an interested party — often a domestic competitor or trade association — claiming that a specific importer has entered covered merchandise through evasion. CBP's Trade Remedy Law Enforcement Directorate (TRLED) reviews the allegation. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(b)(1), CBP has 15 business days to decide whether to initiate an investigation, and it does so when the allegation "reasonably suggests" that covered merchandise entered through evasion. Importantly, "evasion" under EAPA is defined broadly to include entering covered merchandise by means of material false statements or omissions that result in AD/CVD cash deposits or other security not being applied. The importer frequently does not receive detailed notice at the outset; much of the allegation and the evidence can be treated as business confidential, and the accused importer's access to the record is limited compared to ordinary litigation. This asymmetry is one of the defining — and most criticized — features of the EAPA process, and it makes an early, organized response critical.
Interim Measures Within 90 Days
EAPA's most immediate practical impact comes from interim measures. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(e), if CBP determines there is a reasonable suspicion of evasion, it must impose interim measures no later than 90 calendar days after initiating the investigation. These measures can include suspending liquidation of the importer's entries, extending liquidation for earlier entries, and requiring cash deposits or single-transaction bonds sufficient to cover the AD/CVD allegedly owed. CBP issues notice of its interim-measures decision within five business days of making it. For an importer, interim measures can be devastating to cash flow long before any final finding: goods may be held, bonding requirements may spike, and capital may be tied up for the duration of the investigation. Because the reasonable-suspicion threshold for interim measures is low, importers often face these consequences based on a preliminary assessment rather than a full adjudication — which is why building and submitting a strong factual record early, within the investigation's deadlines, matters so much.
The Final Determination Within 300 Days
Under 19 U.S.C. § 1517(c)(1), CBP must issue its final determination as to evasion no later than 300 days after initiating the investigation, extendable to 360 days in extraordinarily complicated cases. The determination must be based on substantial evidence — a meaningful but deferential standard. If CBP finds evasion, it will suspend or continue to suspend liquidation, require the applicable AD/CVD cash deposits, and collect the duties owed on the covered entries. A finding of evasion can reach back over the entries at issue and impose very large liabilities, and it can also expose the importer to further enforcement, including potential penalty actions under other customs statutes. The regulations governing the process are found at 19 C.F.R. Part 165, which sets out the submission deadlines, the handling of confidential information, and the mechanics of the investigation. Throughout, the importer's ability to shape the outcome depends on timely, well-documented submissions within the regulatory windows.
Administrative Review and CIT Appeal
An importer dissatisfied with CBP's determination has avenues to challenge it. First, a party may seek administrative review of the evasion determination with CBP's Office of Regulations and Rulings, which conducts a de novo review of the record determination. If the administrative review does not resolve the matter favorably, the importer may file suit in the Court of International Trade to contest the determination. The CIT is the specialized federal court with jurisdiction over customs and trade disputes — the same court at the center of the broader tariff litigation we discuss in our article on residual jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1581(i). On appeal, the court reviews whether CBP's determination was supported by substantial evidence and otherwise in accordance with law. The layered review process means that an unfavorable interim or final determination is not necessarily the end of the road, but each stage has its own deadlines and record requirements, and missing them can forfeit the right to review.
How Evasion Differs From Ordinary Customs Disputes
EAPA sits alongside, but is distinct from, the ordinary customs machinery of entry, liquidation, and protest. An ordinary disagreement over classification or valuation is resolved through the protest process and the finality rules we describe in our articles on the finality of liquidation under 19 U.S.C. § 1514 and the "pay first" rule of 28 U.S.C. § 2637. EAPA, by contrast, is an enforcement proceeding aimed at intentional or material evasion of trade-remedy duties, with its own accelerated timeline, its own confidentiality rules, and its own review path. An importer should not assume that the familiar protest process will cure an EAPA problem; the two tracks operate differently, and an evasion finding carries consequences — financial and reputational — that a routine classification dispute does not. Recognizing which process you are in, and responding within that process's rules, is a threshold strategic decision.
Why Importers Get Caught Without Intending to Evade
Not every importer named in an EAPA allegation set out to cheat. Evasion findings can ensnare companies that relied in good faith on suppliers' representations about the origin or nature of goods, that misunderstood the scope of an AD/CVD order, or that failed to recognize that a product fell within an order's coverage. Because EAPA's definition of evasion focuses on material false statements or omissions that result in duties not being applied, an importer can face liability even where the false information originated with a foreign supplier, if the importer's entries conveyed it. This is why supply-chain diligence is not optional for importers of goods in AD/CVD-sensitive categories: verifying the true country of origin, obtaining and retaining manufacturing records, scrutinizing suspiciously low prices, and confirming scope coverage before entry are the practices that prevent an evasion problem — and the documentation that defends against one. An importer who can produce a clean, verifiable record of where goods were actually made and how they were described is far better positioned than one relying on a supplier's word.
Building the Defense: Documentation and Scope
Defending an EAPA investigation turns heavily on two things: documentation and scope. On documentation, the importer must be able to show the genuine supply chain — production records, mill certificates, shipping documents, and factory information that establish where and how the goods were actually made. On scope, the question is often whether the merchandise is even "covered" by the AD/CVD order in the first place; if the goods fall outside the order's scope, there can be no evasion of it. Scope questions can sometimes be resolved through a separate scope-ruling request to the Department of Commerce, which determines whether particular merchandise is within an order. A coordinated defense considers both tracks — the EAPA investigation at CBP and any scope question at Commerce — because a favorable scope ruling can undercut the premise of an evasion allegation. Given EAPA's compressed deadlines and limited record access, assembling this material quickly and presenting it effectively within the regulatory windows is the core of a successful defense.
Common Evasion Schemes CBP Targets
Understanding the schemes EAPA is designed to catch helps importers see where honest supply chains can look suspicious and where real evasion occurs. The most common is transshipment: goods subject to an AD/CVD order are shipped from the country of origin to a third country, lightly processed or simply relabeled, and then exported to the United States declared as products of the third country, so they appear outside the order. CBP looks for tell-tale signs — a sudden surge of imports from a country with no real manufacturing capacity for the goods, shipping records inconsistent with genuine production, and prices that track the subject-country market rather than the declared origin. A second scheme is misclassification or misdescription, entering covered merchandise under a tariff description that falls outside the order's scope. A third is undervaluation or false manufacturer identification designed to reduce or avoid the applicable cash deposits. For the honest importer, the danger is that a legitimate third-country supply chain can superficially resemble transshipment; the defense is documentation that proves genuine manufacturing — factory records, production capacity, raw-material sourcing, and a consistent shipping trail. An importer who can show real production in the declared country rebuts the inference that drives most evasion allegations.
Penalties Beyond the Duties
An EAPA evasion finding is often not the end of an importer's exposure. The same conduct can give rise to separate penalty liability under 19 U.S.C. § 1592, which penalizes entering merchandise by means of material false statements or omissions, whether done fraudulently, with gross negligence, or with negligence. Section 1592 penalties are tiered by culpability and can reach substantial multiples of the loss of duties or the value of the merchandise, independent of the AD/CVD duties themselves. This means an importer found to have evaded can face both the back duties collected through the EAPA process and a separate penalty action for the false statements that accomplished the evasion. California importers should also be aware of prior disclosure: when a company discovers its own compliance error, voluntarily and fully disclosing it to CBP before an investigation begins can substantially reduce potential § 1592 penalties. The existence of this parallel penalty regime is another reason to take EAPA risk seriously and to correct problems proactively rather than waiting for an allegation. A compliance program that catches and discloses errors early is far cheaper than defending an evasion finding and a penalty case at the same time. It also signals good faith to CBP, which can matter if a question about a shipment later arises, and it builds the very documentation — origin records, scope analyses, supplier certifications — that forms the backbone of any EAPA defense.
What California Importers Should Do
If you import goods in categories subject to AD/CVD orders — steel and aluminum products, chemicals, hardware, furniture, tires, and many others — treat EAPA risk as a live compliance issue, not a remote possibility. Before any problem arises, conduct origin and scope diligence and retain the records that prove lawful entry. If you receive notice of an EAPA investigation or interim measures, act immediately: the 90-day and 300-day clocks run from initiation, submission windows are short, and the record you build early shapes every later stage, including any CIT appeal. Because the process gives the accused limited visibility and imposes real consequences before any final finding, experienced trade counsel can be the difference between a manageable response and a business-threatening liability. The importers who fare best are those who prepared their documentation before the allegation and who respond within the deadlines, not after them.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Enforce and Protect Act (EAPA)?
EAPA, enacted in 2015 and codified at 19 U.S.C. § 1517, is a formal CBP process for investigating allegations that an importer evaded antidumping or countervailing duty orders. It operates on strict statutory deadlines and can impose interim measures and a final determination of evasion.
How does an EAPA investigation start?
Usually with an allegation filed with CBP by an interested party, such as a domestic competitor. Under § 1517(b)(1), CBP has 15 business days to decide whether to initiate, and it does so when the allegation reasonably suggests that covered merchandise entered through evasion.
What are interim measures and when are they imposed?
Under § 1517(e), if CBP finds a reasonable suspicion of evasion, it must impose interim measures within 90 calendar days of initiating the investigation. These can include suspending liquidation, extending liquidation, and requiring cash deposits or single-transaction bonds — all before any final finding.
How long does CBP have to decide?
Under § 1517(c)(1), CBP must issue its final determination as to evasion within 300 days of initiating the investigation, extendable to 360 days in extraordinarily complicated cases. The determination must be based on substantial evidence.
Can I appeal an evasion determination?
Yes. You may first seek administrative review with CBP's Office of Regulations and Rulings, and then file suit in the Court of International Trade to contest the determination. Each stage has its own deadlines and record requirements.
What if my goods aren't even covered by the order?
Scope is a core defense. If the merchandise falls outside the AD/CVD order's scope, there is no duty to evade. A scope-ruling request to the Department of Commerce can determine whether particular goods are covered, and a favorable ruling can undercut an evasion allegation.
Can I be found to have evaded without intending to?
Potentially. EAPA's definition of evasion focuses on material false statements or omissions that result in duties not being applied. An importer can face liability even where false origin information came from a foreign supplier, if its entries conveyed that information. Supply-chain diligence and documentation are the best protection.
What should I do if I receive an EAPA notice?
Act immediately. The deadlines run from initiation, submission windows are short, and the record you build early shapes every later stage, including any CIT appeal. Gather supply-chain documentation and get experienced trade counsel involved at once. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246.
Talk to a California Customs Lawyer About an EAPA Investigation
An EAPA evasion investigation moves fast, gives the accused limited visibility, and can impose bonding and liquidation consequences within 90 days — long before any final finding. If your company imports goods subject to antidumping or countervailing duty orders, or you have received notice of an EAPA allegation, the time to act is now. Trembach Law Firm, led by Anatolii Trembach (LL.M. in international trade; admitted in California), defends importers in EAPA investigations, challenges interim measures and evasion determinations, and pursues administrative and Court of International Trade review. Call (213) 645-2246 to protect your import business.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301