DISABILITY ACCOMMODATION | 2026-11-11
The Direct-Threat Defense in California Disability Cases Under FEHA (2026)
An employer may exclude a disabled worker on safety grounds only after an individualized assessment showing a significant risk of substantial harm.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California employers sometimes justify excluding a disabled worker by claiming the worker is a safety risk. The law allows this defense, but only under strict conditions. Known as the direct-threat defense, it requires an individualized medical assessment showing a significant risk of substantial ha
What the Direct-Threat Defense Is
The Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) generally forbids discriminating against a qualified worker because of disability. But the law recognizes a narrow safety-based exception: an employer may lawfully exclude an employee from a particular job if, because of the disability, the employee cannot perform the essential functions of the job in a manner that would not endanger the employee's own health or safety or the health or safety of others, even with reasonable accommodation. This is the direct-threat defense. It is an affirmative defense, which means the employer must plead and prove it; it is not a gap the worker must fill. The underlying anti-discrimination duty arises under Government Code § 12940, and the safety exception is a carefully cabined limit on that duty.
The Regulatory Standard
The FEHA regulations define the standard with precision. California Code of Regulations, title 2, § 11067 addresses the health-and-safety defense and requires that any exclusion be based on an individualized assessment of the employee's present ability to safely perform the essential functions of the job. The assessment must rest on a reasonable medical judgment that relies on the most current medical knowledge or the best available objective evidence. The regulation makes clear that the inquiry is individualized and evidence-based; a blanket policy excluding everyone with a particular diagnosis, or a decision grounded in generalized fears about a condition, does not satisfy the standard.
Significant Risk of Substantial Harm
To establish a direct threat, the employer must show more than some theoretical possibility of harm. The risk must be a significant risk of substantial harm. Both words carry weight. The harm that is feared must be substantial, not minor, and the likelihood that it will occur must be significant, not remote or speculative. A small chance of a minor injury does not justify exclusion. An elevated, well-documented probability of serious injury might. Courts and agencies assess the duration of the risk, the nature and severity of the potential harm, the likelihood that the harm will occur, and the imminence of the potential harm. Each factor must be supported by objective evidence rather than assumption.
The Assessment Must Be Individualized
The single most important feature of the direct-threat defense is that it must be individualized. The employer cannot rely on how the condition affects people in general; it must evaluate this particular worker, with this worker's actual abilities, limitations, treatment, and job. A diabetic worker, a worker with a seizure history, a worker with a back condition, or a worker with a psychiatric diagnosis cannot be excluded simply because the employer imagines what might happen. The employer must obtain and consider current, specific medical information about the individual. A defense built on a stale evaluation, a generic policy, or a decisionmaker's untrained intuition will fail. This is where many employer defenses collapse, because the individualized assessment was never genuinely performed.
No Speculation, No Stereotype
FEHA is designed to dismantle exactly the kind of reasoning the direct-threat defense is often misused to smuggle back in. The defense cannot rest on speculation about future risk, on fears that the worker might someday be injured, on stereotypes about a disability, or on a paternalistic desire to protect the worker from herself without an objective basis. The law places the dignity and autonomy of the disabled worker at the center. An employer that says it was only trying to protect the worker, without objective evidence of a significant risk of substantial harm, has not met the standard. The focus is on current ability and objective evidence, not on worst-case imagination.
The Employer Bears the Burden
Because the direct-threat defense is an affirmative defense, the employer carries the burden of proving it. The worker does not have to prove she is safe; the employer must prove she is not, under the significant-risk-of-substantial-harm standard, after an individualized assessment. This allocation is decisive in litigation. An employer that excluded a worker on a hunch, or that cannot produce the medical evidence and the individualized analysis the regulation demands, will lose the defense. Workers and their counsel should press hard on what assessment was actually done, who performed it, what current medical evidence it relied on, and whether accommodation was considered.
Reasonable Accommodation Still Applies
The direct-threat defense does not switch off the duty to accommodate. Before excluding a worker on safety grounds, the employer must consider whether a reasonable accommodation would eliminate or sufficiently reduce the risk. Modified equipment, a schedule change, additional safety measures, a reassignment of a particular hazardous task, or a transfer could all neutralize a safety concern. Only if no reasonable accommodation would reduce the risk below the significant-risk threshold may the employer invoke direct threat. This ties the defense to the broader accommodation framework, including the duty to consider reassignment to a vacant position the worker could perform safely. An employer that skips accommodation and jumps straight to exclusion has not done what the law requires.
The Interactive Process and Direct Threat
The interactive process remains in play even when safety is at issue. The employer should engage the worker in a good-faith dialogue about the nature of the concern, the medical evidence, and possible accommodations. Often the worker can provide treating-physician information that rebuts the employer's concern or identifies a workable accommodation. An employer that reaches a direct-threat conclusion without ever talking to the worker or her providers, and without exploring accommodation, exposes itself to liability for both failure to accommodate and failure to engage in the interactive process, independent of the merits of the safety claim.
How the Federal ADA Standard Compares
The federal Americans with Disabilities Act has a parallel direct-threat concept, which can inform California analysis though FEHA is often more protective. Under 42 U.S.C. § 12113, an employer may apply a qualification standard that an individual not pose a direct threat to the health or safety of others, and the implementing regulation, 29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(r), defines direct threat as a significant risk of substantial harm that cannot be eliminated or reduced by reasonable accommodation, assessed through an individualized evaluation of the person's present ability to safely perform essential functions, based on reasonable medical judgment and the best available objective evidence. California courts frequently look to this framework while applying FEHA's own, often broader, protections. Workers should remember that FEHA, not the ADA, usually sets the governing standard in a California case.
Practical Guidance
For workers: if you are excluded on safety grounds, ask for the specific medical basis, provide your treating physician's current assessment, and request accommodation that would address the concern. Do not accept a vague claim that you are a risk without an individualized evaluation. For employers: never exclude a disabled worker on a generalized fear. Obtain current, individualized medical evidence, document the significant-risk-of-substantial-harm analysis, consider and attempt reasonable accommodation first, and engage the interactive process. A direct-threat defense built on a real, individualized, evidence-based assessment can succeed; one built on stereotype will not. For more on California disability rights, visit our employment law news page.
Medical Examinations and Inquiries Have Their Own Limits
An employer that wants to assess a supposed safety risk cannot simply demand unlimited medical information. FEHA restricts when an employer may require a medical or psychological examination or make disability-related inquiries. Under Government Code § 12940(e), an employer generally may not require a pre-employment medical examination or make disability-related inquiries before a conditional offer, and Government Code § 12940(f) permits examinations of current employees only when the examination is job-related and consistent with business necessity. A fitness-for-duty evaluation used to support a direct-threat determination must fit within these limits. An employer that orders a sweeping medical exam without a job-related, business-necessity justification may violate FEHA independent of whether a genuine safety concern existed.
Confidentiality of Medical Information
Medical information gathered during a safety assessment must be kept confidential. FEHA and related California privacy law require that medical information about an employee be maintained separately from the ordinary personnel file and disclosed only to those with a legitimate need to know, such as a supervisor who must implement a restriction or a safety official. An employer that broadcasts a worker's diagnosis, discusses her medical restrictions with coworkers, or files medical records in the general personnel file can create additional liability. A worker subjected to a direct-threat process should expect her medical information to be handled discreetly, and a breach of confidentiality is itself a potential claim.
Direct Threat Compared to Business Necessity
Employers sometimes blur the direct-threat defense with the separate concept of business necessity. They are distinct. Direct threat concerns safety: whether the worker poses a significant risk of substantial harm. Business necessity, by contrast, concerns a qualification standard or screening practice that tends to exclude people with disabilities and that the employer must justify as job-related and consistent with the needs of the business. An employer defending a safety-based exclusion must meet the demanding individualized direct-threat standard; it cannot substitute a vaguer appeal to business necessity. Keeping the two doctrines separate helps workers hold employers to the correct, more rigorous test when safety is the stated reason.
Who Should Perform the Assessment
The individualized assessment the regulation requires should rest on reasonable medical judgment, which generally means input from a qualified medical professional, not a lay manager's guesswork. The best practice is for the employer to obtain current information from the worker's own treating provider, or from an appropriately qualified evaluating physician, focused on the specific essential functions of the job and the specific feared harm. The decisionmaker should then weigh that medical input together with the realities of the job and any available accommodations. An assessment conducted by an untrained supervisor, or one that ignores the treating physician entirely, is unlikely to satisfy the standard and is a frequent weakness that workers and their counsel can exploit.
Documenting a Defensible Determination
Because the employer bears the burden, documentation is decisive. A defensible direct-threat determination records the essential functions at issue, the specific harm feared, the current medical evidence relied on, the individualized analysis of the duration and likelihood of the risk and the severity and imminence of the potential harm, the accommodations considered and why each was or was not sufficient, and the conclusion that no accommodation would reduce the risk below the significant-risk threshold. An employer that can produce this record has a real chance of prevailing. An employer that excluded a worker on an unwritten hunch, with no medical foundation and no accommodation analysis, will usually lose, and the exclusion will expose it to the full range of FEHA remedies under Government Code § 12940.
The Direct-Threat Defense Within the Overall FEHA Framework
To understand the direct-threat defense, it helps to place it within the structure of a FEHA disability claim. A worker first shows she has a protected disability and is a qualified individual who can perform the essential functions of the job with or without reasonable accommodation. The employer may then raise the direct-threat defense to argue that, notwithstanding the worker's qualifications, she cannot perform those functions without creating a significant risk of substantial harm that accommodation cannot eliminate. Because this is an affirmative defense under Government Code § 12940, the employer must both plead it and prove it; the worker does not have to disprove a safety risk as part of her own case. The defense therefore does not change who the law protects; it carves out a narrow, safety-based justification that the employer must substantiate with individualized, objective medical evidence. An employer that treats the defense as a shortcut, skipping the individualized assessment and the search for accommodation, forfeits it and remains liable for the underlying disability discrimination. The practical effect is that safety concerns, however sincere, must be channeled through a rigorous, documented process rather than used as an all-purpose reason to exclude a disabled worker.
Reasonable Accommodation and Monitoring Can Neutralize Risk
A central reason the direct-threat defense is narrow is that reasonable accommodation can frequently reduce or eliminate a safety concern, defeating the defense before it is reached. Depending on the job and the condition, accommodations might include additional safety equipment, a modified or reduced schedule, periodic medical monitoring, a reassignment of a particular hazardous task to another worker, restrictions on specific high-risk duties while retaining the rest of the job, or a transfer to a role without the hazard. The employer must consider these options as part of the interactive process before concluding that the worker poses a direct threat. Only if no reasonable accommodation would bring the risk below the significant-risk-of-substantial-harm threshold may the employer rely on the defense. This requirement forces employers to think creatively about how a disabled worker can be kept safely employed, which is precisely what the statute intends, rather than defaulting to exclusion whenever a condition raises any conceivable concern.
Common Conditions Where the Defense Is Litigated
The direct-threat defense arises across a wide range of conditions, and the pattern of litigation is instructive. Employers have invoked it against workers with epilepsy, diabetes, cardiac conditions, musculoskeletal injuries, visual impairments, and psychiatric diagnoses, often in jobs involving driving, machinery, heights, or public safety. The recurring lesson is that the diagnosis alone never decides the question. Two workers with the same condition may present very different risk profiles depending on treatment, control of symptoms, and the specific demands of the job. An employer that excludes every worker with a given diagnosis, rather than evaluating the individual in front of it, has substituted a stereotype for the individualized assessment the law demands. A worker facing exclusion should insist that the employer explain, with current medical evidence, why she in particular poses a significant risk of substantial harm that accommodation cannot address.
Timing of the Assessment and Changing Conditions
The direct-threat inquiry asks about the worker's present ability, which makes the timing of the assessment important. A risk that existed months ago may no longer exist after treatment, surgery, medication, or recovery, and an employer that relies on a stale evaluation rather than the worker's current condition has not performed the individualized assessment the regulation requires. By the same token, a worker whose condition has improved should bring current medical evidence to the table, because the question is whether she can safely perform the essential functions now, not whether she once could not. Because conditions change, a one-time determination should not be treated as permanent, and an employer that permanently excludes a worker based on an outdated snapshot risks liability under Government Code § 12940. Keeping the assessment current and tied to present ability protects both the worker, whose improvement must be recognized, and the employer, whose defense must rest on up-to-date objective evidence rather than a historical concern.
The Worker's Own Medical Evidence Can Rebut the Defense
Because the inquiry is evidence-based, the worker is not a passive bystander. She can and should marshal her own medical evidence, typically from her treating physician, addressing her present ability to perform the essential functions safely, the effectiveness of her treatment, and any accommodations that would reduce risk. When a treating physician who knows the worker's actual condition opines that she can safely perform the job, that evidence can directly rebut an employer's more generalized concern. The decisionmaker is not free to ignore credible, current medical evidence from the worker; doing so undermines any claim that the assessment was genuinely individualized and based on the best available objective evidence as the regulation requires. This is often the moment a weak direct-threat defense collapses.
Remedies When an Exclusion Was Unjustified
A worker excluded on an invalid direct-threat theory may pursue the full range of FEHA remedies under Government Code § 12940, including lost wages from the exclusion, reinstatement or front pay, emotional distress damages, attorney's fees, and, where the employer acted with malice, oppression, or fraud, punitive damages. The exclusion is treated as an adverse employment action taken because of disability unless the employer proves the defense, so the stakes for an employer that cannot substantiate its safety claim are significant. As with other FEHA claims, the worker must first exhaust her administrative remedy with the Civil Rights Department and then file suit within the statutory period. A worker who believes she was removed from a job on an unsupported safety rationale should preserve the employer's stated reasons, any medical correspondence, and the record of whether accommodation was ever discussed.
Talk to a California employment lawyer about a safety-based exclusion. If an employer removed you from a job or refused to hire you by claiming you were a safety risk because of a disability, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate whether the required individualized assessment under Government Code § 12940 and the FEHA regulations was ever performed. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my employer bar me from working because of a disability for safety reasons?
Only under the direct-threat defense, which requires an individualized assessment showing a significant risk of substantial harm that cannot be eliminated by reasonable accommodation. A general fear or a diagnosis alone is not enough.
Who has to prove the safety risk?
The employer. Direct threat is an affirmative defense, so the employer bears the burden of proving a significant risk of substantial harm based on current, objective medical evidence under California Code of Regulations, title 2, § 11067.
Does the risk have to be to others, or can it be to me?
Under FEHA, the defense can apply to a significant risk of substantial harm to the employee's own health or safety or to others, but either way it must rest on an individualized, evidence-based assessment, not paternalism or speculation.
Does my employer have to try accommodation first?
Yes. Before excluding you, the employer must consider whether a reasonable accommodation would eliminate or reduce the risk below the significant-risk threshold. Skipping accommodation undermines the defense.
Is the California standard the same as the federal ADA?
They are similar. The ADA direct-threat standard appears in 42 U.S.C. § 12113 and 29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(r), but FEHA is often more protective, and FEHA usually governs a California case.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301