EXPORT CONTROLS | 2026-11-11
The EAR De Minimis Rule: When Foreign-Made Products Become Subject to U.S. Export Controls Because of Their U.S. Content
How 15 C.F.R. 734.4 and the 25 percent and 10 percent thresholds decide whether a foreign-manufactured item is caught by the Export Administration Regulations when it is reexported
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
A manufacturer in Germany or Singapore can build a product entirely on foreign soil, sell it to a foreign customer, and still violate U.S. law if it ships that product to the wrong destination, because the item contains more than a threshold amount of controlled U.S.-origin content. That counterintu
Most exporters understand that shipping a controlled item from the United States to a foreign country requires attention to U.S. export controls. Far fewer understand that a product made entirely outside the United States can also be subject to those same controls, long after it leaves American hands, because it contains U.S.-origin parts, components, materials, software, or technology. The rule that governs this extraterritorial reach is the de minimis rule at 15 C.F.R. 734.4, part of the Export Administration Regulations administered by the Bureau of Industry and Security. For California suppliers whose products travel through foreign factories and into global markets, understanding de minimis is a core part of export controls compliance and essential to knowing where their legal exposure ends.
Why Foreign-Made Products Fall Under U.S. Jurisdiction
The Export Administration Regulations assert jurisdiction over several categories of items, defined at 15 C.F.R. 734.3. These include items in the United States, items of U.S. origin wherever located, and, crucially, certain foreign-made items that incorporate, are bundled with, or are commingled with more than a de minimis amount of controlled U.S.-origin content. This last category is what allows U.S. controls to follow American technology and components into foreign products. The policy rationale is straightforward: if a small amount of sensitive U.S. content could strip an entire foreign product of U.S. jurisdiction, the controls would be trivially easy to evade by assembling abroad.
At the same time, asserting jurisdiction over every foreign product containing any trace of U.S. content would be difficult to administer and could encourage foreign manufacturers to design out American components to avoid the regulatory burden. The de minimis rule strikes a balance by setting content thresholds below which the U.S. content is disregarded and the foreign product is not subject to the EAR on that basis.
The 25 Percent and 10 Percent Thresholds
The core of 15 C.F.R. 734.4 is a set of percentage thresholds. For most destinations, a foreign-made item is not subject to the EAR by reason of its U.S. content if the controlled U.S.-origin content does not exceed 25 percent of the total value of the item. In other words, if controlled American content is 25 percent or less of the finished foreign product value, the de minimis level is not exceeded and the product generally escapes EAR jurisdiction on the content theory.
A stricter 10 percent threshold applies when the destination is a country listed in Country Group E:1 (terrorist supporting countries) or E:2 (unilateral embargo) of Supplement No. 1 to Part 740, which currently lists Cuba, Iran, North Korea, and Syria. For those destinations, if the controlled U.S. content exceeds 10 percent of the item value, the foreign product is subject to the EAR. And for certain especially sensitive items and destinations listed in 15 C.F.R. 734.4(a), no de minimis level is available at all, meaning any amount of the relevant U.S. content subjects the foreign product to the regulations. Examples include foreign-made items incorporating U.S.-origin 9x515 or “600 series” items described in paragraphs .a through .x of those ECCNs when destined for a Country Group D:5 country, and foreign-produced encryption technology that incorporates U.S.-origin encryption technology controlled under ECCN 5E002. California exporters must therefore ask not only how much U.S. content a product contains, but where that product is ultimately headed.
What Counts as Controlled U.S. Content
A critical and often misunderstood point is that only controlled U.S.-origin content counts toward the de minimis calculation. The analysis focuses on the U.S.-origin content that would itself require a license to the destination in question. U.S.-origin content that could go to the specific destination without a license (NLR) or under License Exception GBS is not counted in the numerator of the de minimis calculation; for most destinations that excludes items designated EAR99, although EAR99 content can require a license, and therefore count, for embargoed destinations. This means the same physical product can have different de minimis results for different destinations, because the licensing status of its U.S. content varies by where it is going.
The calculation requires the exporter or reexporter to identify each U.S.-origin item incorporated into the foreign product, determine its Export Control Classification Number and whether it would require a license to the destination, value that controlled content, and compare it to the total value of the foreign-made product. BIS provides detailed instructions for this calculation in Supplement No. 2 to Part 734 of the EAR, which walks through how to identify controlled content, how to value both the U.S. content and the foreign-made item, and when a one-time report to BIS is required. The recordkeeping requirement for the calculation itself appears at 15 C.F.R. 734.4(g).
Reexports and the General Prohibitions
The de minimis rule matters most in the context of reexports. A reexport is the shipment of an item subject to the EAR from one foreign country to another. If a foreign product is subject to the EAR because it exceeds the de minimis threshold, then shipping it from one foreign country to another can require a BIS license, just as if it were being exported from the United States. The General Prohibitions in 15 C.F.R. 736.2 apply to reexports of items subject to the EAR, including prohibitions on reexporting to embargoed destinations, prohibited end users, and prohibited end uses without authorization.
For a California component maker, this means that even after it sells parts to a foreign original equipment manufacturer, the finished products incorporating those parts may remain tethered to U.S. law. If the foreign manufacturer later ships the finished goods to a sanctioned country or a listed entity, and the product is subject to the EAR because of its U.S. content, an unlicensed reexport has occurred, and both the foreign reexporter and, in some fact patterns, the U.S. supplier can face scrutiny.
How to Perform a De Minimis Calculation
A defensible de minimis analysis follows the structure BIS sets out. First, classify each U.S.-origin item that is incorporated into the foreign product, assigning each its correct Export Control Classification Number. Second, for the specific destination at issue, determine which of those U.S.-origin items would require a license to that destination; only those controlled items count. Third, calculate the value of the controlled U.S. content and divide it by the total value of the foreign-made commodity, software, or technology. Fourth, compare that percentage to the applicable threshold, 25 percent, 10 percent, or zero, for the destination. Fifth, document the entire analysis and retain it in accordance with the EAR recordkeeping requirements.
Because the classification and licensing determinations drive the result, errors at the classification stage propagate through the whole analysis. A product that appears to pass a 25 percent test can flunk a 10 percent test for an embargoed destination, and a misclassification that treats controlled content as EAR99 can produce a dangerously wrong conclusion that a product is not subject to the EAR when it actually is. This is why careful, destination-specific analysis is indispensable.
Common Mistakes California Exporters Make
One frequent error is treating de minimis as a single fixed number. Because the threshold and the counted content both depend on the destination, there is no one de minimis percentage for a product; the answer changes with where the product is going. A second mistake is counting all U.S. content rather than only controlled U.S. content, which overstates the percentage and can cause a company to wrongly conclude that a product is subject to the EAR when it is not, needlessly forgoing sales. A third mistake is the opposite error, assuming that assembling abroad automatically launders away U.S. jurisdiction; it does not when the controlled content exceeds the threshold.
A fourth and serious mistake is ignoring software and technology. The de minimis rules apply not only to hardware but also to U.S.-origin software bundled with or incorporated into foreign items and to U.S.-origin technology commingled with or drawn into foreign technology, and these categories have their own rules in 15 C.F.R. 734.4 and Supplement No. 2 to Part 734. For example, before relying on de minimis for foreign technology commingled with controlled U.S.-origin technology, a company must file a one-time report with BIS and, if BIS does not contact it within thirty days, may then rely on its calculations. Conversely, Supplement No. 2 provides that technology and source code used only to design or produce a foreign-made item are not considered incorporated into it for de minimis purposes. A company that carefully tracks hardware content but overlooks embedded U.S. software can misjudge jurisdiction entirely. Finally, companies often fail to keep contemporaneous records supporting their de minimis conclusions, leaving them unable to defend a determination years later if BIS asks how they reached it.
The Foreign Direct Product Rule Is a Separate Trap
Exporters should not confuse de minimis with the foreign direct product rule. The de minimis rule asks whether enough controlled U.S. content is physically incorporated into a foreign product. The foreign direct product rules in 15 C.F.R. 734.9 are a different basis for jurisdiction that can capture a foreign-made item that is the direct product of specified U.S. technology or software, or that is produced by a complete plant or major component of a plant that is itself the direct product of specified U.S. technology or software, even if the finished item contains no U.S. parts at all. A product that passes the de minimis test can still be subject to the EAR under the foreign direct product rule. A complete jurisdictional analysis for a foreign product therefore examines both theories, because clearing one does not clear the other.
Penalties and the Value of Voluntary Self-Disclosure
Violations of the EAR, including unlicensed reexports of foreign products that are subject to the regulations because of their U.S. content, can carry severe penalties. Under the Export Control Reform Act enforcement provisions at 50 U.S.C. 4819, civil penalties can reach the greater of a statutory maximum per violation, adjusted periodically for inflation and currently $374,474 under 15 C.F.R. 6.3, or twice the value of the transaction, and willful violations can bring criminal fines of up to $1,000,000 and, for individuals, imprisonment of up to 20 years. The government can also revoke licenses and prohibit a person from exporting or reexporting controlled items, which is commercially catastrophic for a company that depends on global sales.
When a company discovers a potential violation, a voluntary self-disclosure to BIS under 15 C.F.R. 764.5 can be an important mitigating step. Under the BIS penalty guidelines in Supplement No. 1 to Part 766, the base penalty in a non-egregious case that is voluntarily disclosed is up to one-half of the transaction value, rather than up to the full transaction value. For a California exporter that uncovers a de minimis miscalculation leading to unauthorized reexports, early legal advice about whether and how to disclose is worth seeking, although the result in any matter depends on its facts.
Building a De Minimis Compliance Program
Sophisticated exporters build de minimis analysis into their compliance programs rather than treating it as an occasional exercise. That means classifying U.S.-origin products at the point of sale, giving foreign customers accurate classification information so they can perform their own de minimis analyses, embedding destination screening into order processing, and maintaining calculation records that can be produced on demand. It also means training the engineering and procurement teams, because de minimis exposure is often created at the design stage, when a product is built around a controlled U.S. component, long before anyone in the trade compliance department sees the transaction.
For California technology and manufacturing companies whose components and software are designed into products assembled around the world, and whose trade and customs obligations follow those products abroad, the de minimis rule is not an abstraction; it determines whether their global customers can lawfully move the resulting products and whether the company itself has downstream exposure. A disciplined, destination-specific, well-documented de minimis practice is the difference between confident global sales and unwelcome surprises from the Bureau of Industry and Security. If your products carry U.S. content into foreign supply chains, call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246 for a focused review of your de minimis exposure and reexport compliance.
Recordkeeping and the De Minimis Statement
A de minimis determination is only as good as the records that support it, and the Export Administration Regulations impose recordkeeping obligations that reach de minimis analyses. Under the recordkeeping requirements at 15 C.F.R. Part 762, and 15 C.F.R. 734.4(g) specifically for the method used to determine U.S. content in foreign software or technology, parties to transactions subject to the EAR must retain the records that document their export and reexport decisions, and a company that relies on a de minimis conclusion to ship a foreign product should be able to produce the classification of each U.S.-origin input, the licensing analysis for the destination, the valuation of the controlled content, and the resulting percentage calculation. These records are what allow a company to defend its conclusion if the Bureau of Industry and Security later asks how it decided that a product was or was not subject to the EAR.
Because foreign manufacturers depend on their U.S. suppliers for the classification information that drives de minimis, some suppliers provide a de minimis statement or classification letter to downstream customers, identifying the Export Control Classification Number of the supplied content and the information needed for the customer to run its own calculation. Done carefully, these statements help the whole supply chain stay compliant; done carelessly, they can spread an incorrect classification across many transactions. A supplier that issues classification information should stand behind it with the same analysis it would use for its own exports, because downstream parties will rely on it when they decide whether a reexport needs a license.
Practical Scenarios That Catch Exporters Off Guard
Consider a California semiconductor company that sells controlled chips to a contract manufacturer in Asia, which assembles them into finished modules and ships those modules worldwide. Whether a given shipment of modules to a particular destination requires a license can depend entirely on whether the controlled U.S. chips exceed the de minimis threshold for that destination, a question neither party can answer without a disciplined calculation. Or consider a software company whose controlled code is embedded in a foreign-developed platform; the software provisions of 15 C.F.R. 734.4 and Supplement No. 2 to Part 734 govern how that U.S. software is counted, and overlooking it can lead to an unlicensed reexport of a platform the company assumed was free of U.S. jurisdiction. These everyday supply-chain structures are exactly where de minimis exposure hides, which is why the analysis belongs in the design and sales process rather than as an afterthought at the point of shipment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the de minimis rule apply to products made entirely outside the United States?
Yes. That is precisely its purpose. Under 15 C.F.R. 734.4, a foreign-made product can be subject to the Export Administration Regulations if the controlled U.S.-origin content it incorporates exceeds the applicable threshold, even though the product was manufactured abroad.
What are the de minimis thresholds?
For most destinations the threshold is 25 percent controlled U.S. content by value. For destinations in Country Group E:1 or E:2, currently Cuba, Iran, North Korea, and Syria, the threshold is 10 percent. For certain sensitive items and destinations, no de minimis level is available, so any controlled U.S. content subjects the foreign product to the EAR.
Do I count all U.S. content or only some of it?
You count only controlled U.S.-origin content, meaning U.S. content that would itself require a license to the destination in question. U.S. content that would not need a license to that destination is excluded from the calculation; for most destinations that includes EAR99 content, but EAR99 content can count for embargoed destinations.
Can the same product have different de minimis results for different countries?
Yes. Because both the threshold and the counted content depend on the destination, a product can pass the de minimis test for one country and fail it for another. There is no single universal de minimis percentage for a given product.
How is the de minimis percentage calculated?
You identify and classify each U.S.-origin item in the foreign product, determine which items would require a license to the destination, value that controlled content, and divide it by the total value of the foreign-made item. BIS sets out the methodology in Supplement No. 2 to Part 734.
Is de minimis the same as the foreign direct product rule?
No. De minimis looks at U.S. content physically incorporated into a foreign product. The foreign direct product rules can capture a foreign item that is the direct product of specified U.S. technology or software, or of a plant that is itself such a direct product, even with no U.S. parts inside. A product can clear one test and still be caught by the other, so both must be checked.
What happens if I get the calculation wrong and a reexport occurs without a license?
An unlicensed reexport of an item subject to the EAR can bring civil penalties under 50 U.S.C. 4819, potential criminal liability for willful violations, and loss of export privileges. A voluntary self-disclosure to the Bureau of Industry and Security is treated as a mitigating factor under BIS penalty guidelines.
Why should a California supplier care if its customer is the one reexporting?
Because the supplier furnishes the U.S. content that creates jurisdiction. If foreign-assembled goods remain subject to the EAR because of that content and are then shipped to a prohibited destination, the transaction can draw scrutiny to the entire supply chain. Suppliers protect themselves by classifying their products, informing customers of classifications, and documenting their own compliance.
Trembach Law Firm counsels California exporters and technology companies on the Export Administration Regulations, de minimis analysis, reexport licensing, and voluntary self-disclosures. To evaluate whether your U.S. content subjects foreign products to U.S. export controls, call (213) 645-2246. Related guides: International Trade and Customs.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301