WAGE & HOUR | 2026-11-09

Earned Bonus Forfeiture in California: Schachter v. Citigroup Explained for 2026

Contingent restricted stock can be forfeited on resignation, but a truly earned commission or bonus cannot.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

If you leave a job before a bonus vests, can your employer keep it? California law gives a nuanced answer. In Schachter v. Citigroup, the California Supreme Court held that forfeiting unvested restricted stock on a voluntary resignation is lawful because the employee already received the agreed wage

The Question: When Can a California Employer Keep Your Unpaid Bonus?

Few wage questions generate more confusion than the fate of a bonus or incentive award when an employee leaves before a payout or vesting date. Employers often insert plan language forfeiting unpaid amounts if the employee is not employed on the vesting date or resigns before a set time. Employees often believe that because the award relates to work they performed, it is a wage that cannot be forfeited.

The truth lies in a distinction California law draws carefully: between compensation that has been earned, which is a protected wage, and compensation that remains genuinely contingent on a future condition, which is not yet a wage at all. The California Supreme Court drew that line in Schachter v. Citigroup, Inc. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 610. The case is the leading California authority on when incentive compensation can lawfully be forfeited, and its reasoning turns on exactly what the employee had and had not already received in exchange for the work performed.

What Schachter v. Citigroup Decided

In Schachter, a brokerage firm offered a voluntary incentive-compensation plan under which employees could elect to receive a portion of their annual pay in the form of restricted company stock purchased at a discount from market price, rather than in cash. The restricted stock vested only if the employee remained employed for a specified period. If the employee voluntarily resigned or was terminated for cause before the stock vested, the unvested shares were forfeited and the employee received back the portion of cash compensation that had been directed into the stock purchase, but not the discount or the appreciation.

The employee argued that forfeiting the unvested stock was an unlawful forfeiture of earned wages. The California Supreme Court rejected the argument. It reasoned that the employee had already received the wages he bargained for: he elected to take part of his pay as restricted stock at a discount, and that election was itself the consideration. Because the agreed wages were received at the time of the election, the later forfeiture of the unvested portion upon voluntary resignation did not take away earned wages. It merely enforced the condition the employee had voluntarily accepted. The forfeiture was therefore lawful and did not violate the Labor Code. The decision emphasized that the employee was not deprived of anything he had earned; he was held to the bargain he chose, which exchanged a discount and potential upside for the risk that leaving early would forfeit the unvested shares.

Why the Stock Was Not Earned Wages

The key to Schachter is that the restricted stock was contingent compensation. Vesting depended on continued employment, a condition that had not been satisfied when the employee resigned. Under California law, compensation becomes a wage protected by the Labor Code only once it has been earned, meaning all the conditions for payment have been met.

Until vesting, the employee had no earned right to the unvested shares; he had a contractual expectancy conditioned on staying. By choosing to leave, he failed the condition, and the expectancy lawfully lapsed. Because he received exactly what the plan promised in exchange for his work at the time he elected the stock, nothing earned was taken from him. The distinction is subtle but decisive. The law does not protect expectancies; it protects earned wages. An award that still depends on a future event the employee has not yet satisfied is an expectancy, and an employer may condition it on continued service without running afoul of the wage statutes.

The Statutory Framework: Labor Code §§ 200, 201, and 219

The analysis rests on the Labor Code's definition of wages and its anti-waiver rules. Labor Code § 200 defines wages to include all amounts for labor performed, whether fixed or ascertained by the standard of time, task, piece, commission basis, or other method of calculation. Labor Code § 201 requires that an employee who is discharged be paid all earned and unpaid wages immediately, and the companion provision requires prompt payment when an employee quits.

Labor Code § 219 provides that these wage-payment protections cannot be waived by private agreement. The crucial word throughout is earned. These protections attach to wages that have been earned. They do not convert a genuinely contingent, unvested expectancy into an earned wage. Schachter applies these statutes faithfully: because the unvested stock was not yet earned, sections 201 and 219 did not require its payment and did not bar its forfeiture. The anti-waiver principle in section 219 is powerful, but it protects only what qualifies as an earned wage in the first place. It does not create a wage where the conditions for earning one have not been met.

The Flip Side: Truly Earned Commissions and Bonuses Cannot Be Forfeited

The limiting principle is just as important as the holding. If compensation has actually been earned, an employer cannot use forfeiture language to take it away. Once a commission is earned under the terms of the commission agreement, it is a wage that must be paid even if the employee later leaves. Plan language purporting to forfeit an already-earned commission because the employee is not employed on the payout date is generally unenforceable, because it would operate as a prohibited waiver of earned wages under Labor Code § 219 and an unlawful taking of wages under Labor Code § 221.

The decisive question is always whether, under the agreement, the employee had completed everything required to earn the payment before leaving. If the answer is yes, the money is a protected wage and no forfeiture clause can defeat it. If the answer is no, because some genuine condition remained unmet, the award may be contingent and forfeitable under Schachter. This is why the same label, a bonus, can describe both protected and forfeitable compensation depending entirely on how the right to it accrues under the governing document.

How to Tell Earned From Contingent Compensation

Drawing the line requires reading the plan or agreement closely. Compensation is more likely to be earned, and therefore protected, when the agreement ties the right to payment to the completion of identifiable work, such as closing a sale, booking revenue, or hitting a defined metric, and when nothing beyond the employee's performance remains to be done.

Compensation is more likely to be contingent, and therefore forfeitable, when payment or vesting depends on a future condition independent of the work already performed, such as remaining employed through a vesting date, the employer's later exercise of discretion, or the continued existence of a customer relationship. Discretionary bonuses the employer may grant or withhold at will are generally not earned until declared. A signing or retention bonus conditioned on staying a set period is contingent until the period is served. A production commission for a completed sale is typically earned when the sale closes, regardless of a later payout date. Courts examine the specific accrual language, and they look past formalities to how the compensation actually operates, so a clause that says earnings vest only on a future date will be read in light of what the employee actually had to do to earn the money.

Discretionary Versus Nondiscretionary Bonuses

The discretionary-nondiscretionary distinction matters here and elsewhere in wage law. A nondiscretionary bonus is one promised according to a formula or defined criteria, so that once the criteria are met the employee has a vested right to it; such a bonus is typically earned when its conditions are satisfied. A discretionary bonus is one the employer retains unfettered discretion to award or not, both as to whether to pay and how much; it is generally not earned until the employer exercises that discretion in the employee's favor.

Employers sometimes label a bonus discretionary while treating it as a guaranteed formula in practice, and courts look past the label to the actual operation of the plan. If employees are told they will receive a set percentage for hitting defined targets and the employer pays it reliably every period, calling it discretionary will not necessarily make it so. Whether a bonus is discretionary also affects the regular rate for overtime, because nondiscretionary bonuses must be folded into the overtime calculation, but for forfeiture purposes the central question remains whether the right to the money had vested before separation.

Practical Effects at Separation

At the end of employment, the earned-versus-contingent line determines what the employer must pay. Earned and unpaid wages, including earned commissions and nondiscretionary bonuses whose conditions were met, must be paid at the times required by Labor Code § 201 for discharge and its companion for resignation. Failure to pay earned wages promptly can trigger waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203, up to thirty days of wages, and may produce wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226.

Contingent, unvested awards that fail their condition on a voluntary departure, by contrast, can lawfully be forfeited under Schachter, and the employer owes nothing beyond what the plan returns. Because employers sometimes mislabel earned commissions as contingent to avoid payment, each case turns on the specific plan language and the facts of performance. Improper forfeiture often travels with other pay violations, including the unlawful deductions we discuss in our guide on unlawful wage deductions under Labor Code 221. A worker who suspects a forfeiture was improper should treat the plan documents as the starting point and work outward to the actual pay history.

Deadlines, Remedies, and What to Gather

If you believe an earned commission or bonus was wrongly forfeited, preserve your offer letter, the full incentive-compensation or commission plan, any addenda, and records showing the work you completed, such as closed sales or achieved metrics. Statutory wage claims generally reach three years, while pursuing the conduct as an unlawful business practice under Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 can extend restitution to four years.

You may file with the Labor Commissioner or in court, and representative civil penalties may be available under the Private Attorneys General Act after the required agency notice. For ongoing developments on commissions, bonuses, and wage protections, follow our California employment-law news page. An early review of your plan documents is the surest way to learn whether your compensation was earned and protected or genuinely contingent, and it is far easier to assemble the key records while you still have access to your employer systems and emails.

Stock Options, Restricted Units, and Deferred Compensation

The Schachter framework extends naturally to the equity instruments that dominate modern compensation. Stock options, restricted stock units, performance shares, and deferred-compensation accounts typically vest over time and condition the right to the award on continued employment. Under the earned-versus-contingent analysis, the unvested portion of such an award is generally contingent: the employee has not yet satisfied the service condition, so the Labor Code does not treat the unvested award as an earned wage that must be paid on separation. Forfeiting the unvested portion on a voluntary resignation is therefore ordinarily lawful, consistent with Schachter. The analysis can shift, however, where vesting has already occurred, where the award is structured as compensation for work already completed with no genuine forward-looking condition, or where the plan uses vesting language as a device to recapture pay the employee had actually earned. Because equity plans are drafted by sophisticated employers and often span many pages of defined terms, the precise vesting and forfeiture provisions, and any change-in-control or good-reason exceptions, must be read carefully before concluding that a forfeiture was proper.

What Happens on Involuntary Termination

The manner of separation can change the result. Schachter involved a voluntary resignation and a termination for cause, both of which left the service condition unmet by the employee's own doing or fault. Many plans treat an involuntary, no-fault termination differently, providing for accelerated vesting, a pro-rata payout, or continued vesting for a period, and some distinguish between a termination without cause, a layoff, a retirement, and a death or disability. Where the plan itself grants rights on an involuntary termination, those contractual rights are enforceable according to their terms. Separately, if an employer terminates an employee specifically to prevent a commission or bonus from vesting or being paid, that conduct can raise claims beyond the wage statutes, including breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The key is to read what the plan says about each type of separation and to scrutinize the timing and stated reason for any termination that conveniently precedes a vesting or payout date.

Reading Your Plan: Clauses That Signal Contingency

Certain plan features reliably signal that compensation is contingent rather than earned. Language stating that an award is not earned until a specified vesting date, that the employee must be employed and in good standing on the payment date, or that the award remains subject to the employer's discretion until declared all point toward contingency. Conversely, language tying payment to the completion of a defined, measurable event, such as a closed and non-cancelable sale or a met production threshold, with payment merely deferred to a later administrative date, points toward an earned wage that cannot be forfeited. Watch for the difference between a condition on earning the money and a mere schedule for paying money already earned, because employers sometimes blur the two to make an earned wage look forfeitable. Also note any clause purporting to waive Labor Code protections, which is unenforceable as to earned wages under Labor Code § 219. When the language is ambiguous, California courts tend to construe it against the employer that drafted it and in favor of protecting earned compensation.

Forfeiture Clauses That Collide With Section 16600

Some compensation plans try to make a bonus or equity grant forfeitable if the employee later competes with the company or joins a rival. In California those clauses face a second obstacle beyond the earned-wage rules. Business and Professions Code § 16600 voids contracts that restrain a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business, and in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) the California Supreme Court confirmed that the state rejects the narrow-restraint exceptions other jurisdictions tolerate. A forfeiture provision that functions as a penalty for competing can be an unlawful restraint even when it is dressed up as a condition on compensation.

The Legislature sharpened this rule with recent amendments that declared noncompete clauses void regardless of where they were signed and required employers to notify current and former employees that such clauses are unenforceable. The practical lesson for a worker is that a plan paragraph stripping a vested bonus because you went to a competitor may be doubly defective: it can run into both the Schachter v. Citigroup (2007) earned-wage analysis and the § 16600 prohibition. An employer cannot use a forfeiture label to accomplish indirectly a noncompete that California law forbids directly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Schachter say all bonus forfeitures are legal?

No. Schachter v. Citigroup held only that forfeiting unvested, contingent restricted stock on a voluntary resignation is lawful because the employee already received the agreed wages. It did not authorize forfeiting compensation that has actually been earned.

Can my employer refuse to pay a commission I earned because I quit before payday?

Generally no. If the commission was earned under your agreement before you left, it is a wage that must be paid. Plan language forfeiting an already-earned commission for not being employed on the payout date is usually unenforceable under Labor Code §§ 219 and 221.

What makes a bonus earned rather than contingent?

A bonus is earned when you have satisfied all the conditions the agreement requires, so nothing beyond your completed performance remains. It is contingent when it depends on a future condition, such as remaining employed through a vesting date or the employer's later discretion.

Is a retention bonus forfeitable if I leave early?

Typically yes. A retention or signing bonus conditioned on staying a set period is contingent until you serve that period, so leaving early can lawfully forfeit it, consistent with the reasoning in Schachter.

What can I recover if an earned bonus was wrongly withheld?

You can recover the earned and unpaid wages, and you may be entitled to waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203, wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226, and restitution reaching four years under the Unfair Competition Law. If your California employer refused to pay a commission or bonus you believe you earned, Trembach Law Firm can analyze your plan documents and tell you whether your pay was protected. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential, no-cost review of your incentive-compensation claim.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301