NON-COMPETE & TRADE SECRETS | 2026-11-03

Employee Non-Solicitation Agreements Void in California 2026: AMN v. Aya

California treats a covenant barring a former worker from recruiting the company's employees as an unlawful restraint of trade under Business and Professions Code section 16600.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

Many employers assume that even in California, where non-compete agreements are void, they can at least stop a departing employee from recruiting their workforce. California law in 2026 says otherwise. Under AMN Healthcare v. Aya Healthcare Services and Business and Professions Code section 16600, a

California's baseline rule against restraints on trade

California's hostility to post-employment restrictions is statutory and emphatic. Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600 declares that, except as provided by statute, every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void. The statute reflects a settled public policy favoring open competition and employee mobility: California wants workers free to move to better opportunities and wants businesses to compete for talent on the merits rather than through contractual handcuffs.

The recognized statutory exceptions are narrow — principally the sale of a business's goodwill and the dissolution or dissociation of a partnership or limited-liability company — and they do not cover ordinary employee restrictive covenants. California's approach is often described as the strongest pro-mobility policy in the country, and it is frequently credited as one legal ingredient in the dynamism of the state's technology and professional-services economy, where talent and ideas move freely between firms.

This baseline matters because employers accustomed to other states often draft agreements that would be routine elsewhere — a two-year non-compete, a bar on soliciting clients, a promise not to recruit former colleagues — and assume at least some of those provisions will hold in California. The starting presumption here is the opposite: a restraint on a lawful trade is void unless it fits a specific statutory exception, and the employer bears the burden of fitting within one.

Edwards v. Arthur Andersen closed the narrow-restraint loophole

For years some employers argued that a covenant was enforceable if it only partially restrained competition — the so-called narrow-restraint exception that some federal courts had read into California law. The California Supreme Court rejected that argument in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) 44 Cal.4th 937. The court held that section 16600 means what it says: a contract that restrains a person from engaging in a profession, trade, or business is void unless it fits a statutory exception, and California has not adopted a judicial narrow-restraint exception. After Edwards, the fact that a covenant only modestly limits a former employee is no defense; a restraint is a restraint.

Edwards involved covenants restricting a departing accountant's ability to serve and solicit clients. Its reasoning — that section 16600 is to be read broadly to protect the right to pursue a lawful calling — set the stage for extending the rule to covenants aimed not at clients but at the employer's own workforce. The decision deliberately refused to soften the statute's text with a judge-made reasonableness test, which is the single most important reason California restrictive-covenant law looks so different from the law in states that balance reasonableness case by case.

The practical consequence of Edwards is that California courts do not ask whether a restraint is reasonable in duration, geography, or scope. Those questions, central elsewhere, are beside the point here. The only questions are whether the provision restrains a lawful trade and, if so, whether it fits a statutory exception. If it restrains and does not fit, it is void, however modest it may appear.

AMN Healthcare v. Aya: employee non-solicitation covenants fall

The decisive case for employee non-solicitation is AMN Healthcare, Inc. v. Aya Healthcare Services, Inc. (2018) 28 Cal.App.5th 923. AMN, a healthcare staffing company, required its travel-nurse recruiters to sign an agreement promising not to solicit AMN employees for a period after leaving. When several recruiters left for a competitor, Aya, and began recruiting AMN's travel nurses, AMN sued to enforce the covenant. The Court of Appeal held the employee non-solicitation provision void under section 16600.

The court reasoned that for these recruiters, soliciting and recruiting nurses was the very essence of their profession. A covenant forbidding them from doing so restrained them from engaging in their chosen trade, squarely within section 16600's prohibition as interpreted in Edwards. The court expressly declined to follow older authority that had upheld employee non-solicitation clauses under a reasonableness standard, treating that approach as inconsistent with the Supreme Court's rejection of the narrow-restraint exception.

The practical upshot is that California employers can no longer rely on a stand-alone promise not to poach the workforce to keep a departing employee from recruiting former colleagues. A provision that once seemed like a modest, reasonable protection — far short of a full non-compete — is now understood to be a void restraint, because it limits the former employee's ability to build a team, staff a competing venture, or simply bring talented people with them to a new job.

Why the holding reaches beyond recruiters

Although AMN involved recruiters for whom soliciting workers was the core job, the decision's logic — that section 16600 broadly voids restraints on a lawful trade and that there is no reasonableness escape hatch — has been read to cast serious doubt on employee non-solicitation covenants generally, not just those imposed on recruiters. Courts and practitioners have treated AMN as signaling that these provisions are presumptively void across industries, because any such clause restrains the former employee's ability to build a team, start a competing venture, or move with colleagues to a new employer.

Employers who continue to paper their agreements with workforce-non-solicitation language do so at real legal risk. The risk is no longer merely that the clause will not be enforced; after the 2024 legislation discussed below, including a void restraint and attempting to enforce it can itself generate liability. The sensible reading of AMN for 2026 is that an employee non-solicitation covenant is a liability, not an asset, in a California agreement.

SB 699 and AB 1076: the 2024 reinforcement and new duties

In 2024 the Legislature strengthened section 16600 twice over. AB 1076 added Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.1, which declares it unlawful to include a void non-compete clause in an employment contract or to require an employee to enter one, and which imposed an affirmative notice obligation: employers were required to notify, in writing, current and certain former employees whose contracts contained void non-compete clauses that those clauses are void. Failure to provide the required notice was designated an act of unfair competition, exposing the employer to the remedies that designation carries.

SB 699 added Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.5, which provides that a non-compete agreement that is void under the law is unenforceable regardless of where and when the contract was signed, bars an employer from attempting to enforce such a void agreement even if the employment was maintained outside California, and makes an attempt to enforce a void provision a violation. It also authorizes a current, former, or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief, actual damages, or both, and provides for the recovery of attorney's fees by a prevailing employee.

Together these statutes put teeth behind section 16600: an unlawful restraint is not just unenforceable but can expose the employer to affirmative liability and to the payment of the employee's fees. The out-of-state reach of section 16600.5 is particularly significant, because it targets the common tactic of signing a worker to an agreement in another state and then invoking that state's law to enforce a restraint against a worker who has since come to California.

What California employers can still lawfully protect

None of this leaves employers defenseless. The law voids restraints on the employee's trade; it does not license theft of the employer's property. An employer may still protect genuine trade secrets through the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act and through carefully drawn confidentiality agreements that protect truly secret information without functioning as a disguised non-compete. An employer may protect the sale-of-business goodwill it bought through the statutory exception. And an employer competes for retention the lawful way — by offering compensation, culture, and opportunity that keep employees from wanting to leave.

The critical drafting caution is that a confidentiality agreement cannot be used as a backdoor non-compete. A clause so broad that it effectively prevents the former employee from working in the field, by defining confidential information to include the employee's general skills and industry knowledge, risks being struck down as a void restraint in the same way an express covenant would be. Legitimate protection is narrow and tied to genuinely secret information. For a detailed treatment of the protection that survives, see our companion article on trade-secret misappropriation under the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act.

What a California worker should do when asked to sign

If you are presented with an agreement containing an employee non-solicitation clause, a customer non-solicitation clause, or a non-compete, understand that under section 16600 and AMN v. Aya such restraints on your trade are generally void and that SB 699 bars an employer from trying to enforce them against you even if you move out of state. You may still be bound by legitimate confidentiality obligations protecting real trade secrets, so read carefully for the difference between a genuine secrecy promise and a disguised restraint.

If a current or former employer threatens to enforce a void covenant, or if your contract still contains one and you received no notice of its voidness, you may have affirmative claims under § 16600.5 and § 16600.1, including injunctive relief, damages, and attorney's fees. Preserve the agreement, any notice you did or did not receive, and the threat itself, and get advice before you act in reliance on — or in fear of — the covenant. Keep developments in view on our California employment law news page.

What a California employer should do now

Employers should audit every template offer letter, employment agreement, and handbook for non-compete, customer non-solicitation, and employee non-solicitation language and remove or revise provisions that restrain a departing worker's trade. Confirm that the AB 1076 notice obligation was satisfied for affected current and former employees, and keep records demonstrating that the required notices were sent.

Replace overbroad covenants with narrowly tailored confidentiality and trade-secret protections that guard specific, genuinely secret information rather than restrain competition. Train managers not to threaten enforcement of void covenants, which can itself be actionable under SB 699, and to route any concern about a departing employee's use of confidential information through counsel and the trade-secret framework rather than through an unenforceable restraint. The compliance cost of cleaning up agreements now is small compared with the exposure that comes from including and attempting to enforce a void clause.

The bottom line for 2026

California's policy choice is clear and, after SB 699 and AB 1076, more forcefully enforced than ever: employees are free to leave, to compete, and to recruit their former colleagues, and employers may not use contractual restraints to stop them. AMN Healthcare v. Aya confirmed that even the modest-seeming promise not to poach the workforce is an unlawful restraint under § 16600 as construed in Edwards. Protection of legitimate business interests runs through trade-secret and confidentiality law, not through covenants that handcuff the worker.

How California courts analyze a disputed restrictive covenant

When a covenant reaches a California court, the analysis is strikingly short compared with the multi-factor balancing used in states that enforce reasonable non-competes. The court asks first whether the provision restrains the former employee from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business. If it does, the court asks whether the restraint fits one of the narrow statutory exceptions to Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600 — principally the sale of business goodwill or the dissolution of a partnership or limited-liability entity. If the provision restrains a trade and fits no exception, it is void under § 16600 as construed in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) 44 Cal.4th 937, and the inquiry ends. The court does not rescue the clause by trimming its duration or geography, because there is no reasonableness exception to apply.

Against that backdrop, AMN Healthcare, Inc. v. Aya Healthcare Services, Inc. (2018) 28 Cal.App.5th 923 is simply an application of the rule to a particular kind of clause: a promise not to recruit the former employer's workforce restrains the former employee's ability to practice a trade that often depends on building and moving teams, so it is void. The same logic voids a traditional non-compete and a customer non-solicitation covenant that functions as a restraint. Employers sometimes argue that a particular clause is a mere protection of confidential information rather than a restraint, and that argument can succeed only if the clause genuinely protects trade secrets and does not operate to bar competition itself.

Severability, choice-of-law, and the limits of workarounds

Employers facing § 16600 have tried several workarounds, and the Legislature and courts have closed most of them. Choice-of-law clauses selecting another state's more permissive law are a prime example: Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.5, added by SB 699, makes a void restraint unenforceable regardless of where and when it was signed and bars enforcement even where the employment was maintained outside California, which undercuts the strategy of signing a worker to an out-of-state agreement and invoking that state's law. Attempts to enforce such a void clause can themselves violate the statute and expose the employer to an action for injunctive relief, damages, and attorney's fees.

Severability clauses — the familiar provision saying that if one part of a contract is invalid the rest survives — do not transform a void restraint into a valid one; they merely allow the remainder of the agreement to stand after the offending covenant is struck. And Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.1, added by AB 1076, makes the mere inclusion of a void non-compete unlawful and required employers to affirmatively notify affected current and former employees that the clause is void, turning a dormant, unenforceable provision into an affirmative compliance obligation. The combined message of these provisions is that there is no clever drafting path around California's policy: the lawful route to protecting a business is trade-secret and confidentiality law, not a restraint dressed up to survive review.

It is worth underscoring how different this makes California from most of the country. In states that evaluate non-competes for reasonableness, an employer can often salvage an overbroad covenant by narrowing its duration or geography, and courts routinely blue-pencil the terms to make them enforceable. California rejects that entire approach. Under Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600, as the Supreme Court made clear in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) 44 Cal.4th 937, a restraint on a lawful trade is void, not merely reformed, and the 2024 statutes Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.1 and Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.5 add affirmative liability for using and attempting to enforce one. A multistate employer that treats California like every other jurisdiction therefore faces not just an unenforceable clause but a potential lawsuit from the very worker it tried to restrain, which is why a careful California-specific review of every restrictive covenant is now a necessity rather than a formality.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are employee non-solicitation agreements enforceable in California?

Generally no. Under AMN Healthcare v. Aya Healthcare Services and Business and Professions Code section 16600, a covenant barring a former employee from recruiting the company's workers is void as an unlawful restraint on the former employee's trade. California does not apply a reasonableness exception to such clauses.

What did Edwards v. Arthur Andersen decide?

In Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) 44 Cal.4th 937, the California Supreme Court held that section 16600 broadly voids restraints on a lawful profession, trade, or business and rejected the narrow-restraint exception some courts had recognized. AMN v. Aya applied that reasoning to employee non-solicitation covenants.

What do SB 699 and AB 1076 change?

AB 1076 (section 16600.1) makes including a void non-compete unlawful and required employers to notify affected current and former employees that such clauses are void. SB 699 (section 16600.5) makes void non-competes unenforceable regardless of where signed, bars attempts to enforce them, and lets employees sue for injunctive relief, damages, and attorney's fees.

Can my employer still protect its trade secrets?

Yes. Section 16600 voids restraints on your trade, but it does not permit misappropriation of the employer's property. Employers may protect genuine trade secrets under the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act and through narrowly drawn confidentiality agreements that do not operate as disguised non-competes.

What if my old employer threatens to enforce a non-solicitation clause?

Because such covenants are generally void and SB 699 bars attempts to enforce them even across state lines, a threat to enforce one may give you affirmative claims for injunctive relief, damages, and attorney's fees. Preserve the agreement and the threat and consult an employment lawyer promptly.

Whether you were asked to sign a non-solicitation or non-compete covenant, or you need agreements that protect your business without violating section 16600, Trembach Law Firm can help. Call Trembach Law Firm today at (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation about restrictive covenants and trade-secret protection in California.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301