WAGE & HOUR | 2026-11-02

California Executive Exemption 2026: Heyen and the Primarily Engaged Test

A salaried manager who spends most of the shift on rank-and-file work is owed overtime.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

California retailers and restaurants often classify store managers as exempt executives even when those managers spend most of the day stocking, ringing up sales, and doing the same work as hourly staff. Under Heyen v. Safeway, the exemption applies only when the manager spends more than half the ti

Manager in Title, Worker in Practice: California's Executive Exemption

California retail, restaurant, grocery, and service businesses routinely classify store and shift managers as exempt executives and pay them a flat salary with no overtime. Many of those managers spend most of their day doing the same work as the hourly staff they supervise: stocking shelves, ringing up customers, cooking, cleaning, unloading trucks, and bagging. California law looks hard at that gap between title and reality, and when the manager is really doing rank-and-file work most of the time, the exemption collapses and overtime is owed for every week it did not fit.

The controlling case is Heyen v. Safeway Inc. (2013) 216 Cal.App.4th 795, where a grocery store assistant manager proved she spent the majority of her time on non-exempt tasks and recovered substantial unpaid overtime. Heyen is the decision every California employer and employee should understand before trusting a manager's exempt classification, because it sets out both the quantitative time test and California's refusal to borrow a forgiving federal rule.

The Statutory and Wage Order Framework

The executive exemption is authorized by Labor Code § 515 and spelled out in the IWC Wage Orders, typically at § 1(A)(1). To qualify, an employer must prove that the employee is primarily engaged in the management of the enterprise in which the employee is employed, or of a customarily recognized department or subdivision of it; that the employee customarily and regularly directs the work of two or more other employees; that the employee has the authority to hire or fire other employees, or whose suggestions and recommendations as to hiring, firing, advancement, promotion, or other change of status are given particular weight; that the employee customarily and regularly exercises discretion and independent judgment; and that the employee earns a monthly salary of at least two times the state minimum wage for full-time employment. As with the other white-collar exemptions, the employer bears the burden on every single element, and the exemption is read narrowly against the employer.

Primarily Engaged Means More Than Half the Time

The phrase that decided Heyen, and that decides most executive-exemption cases, is primarily engaged in. California does not use the looser federal formulation that asks only about an employee's primary duty in a qualitative sense. Instead, the Wage Order defines primarily to mean more than one-half of the employee's work time. The inquiry is quantitative and concrete: did the manager actually spend more than 50 percent of working hours on genuinely managerial tasks, measured against the whole workweek?

In Heyen, the evidence showed the assistant manager devoted most of her hours to non-exempt tasks like checking out groceries, stocking shelves, and bagging and serving customers, in large part because the store was not staffed well enough to let her manage full time. Because she failed the more-than-half test, she was non-exempt and entitled to overtime, no matter how much responsibility her title implied or how trusted she was. The court did not ask whether her managerial duties were her most important ones; it asked how her minutes were actually spent.

California Rejects the Federal Concurrent-Duties Rule

The most important doctrinal point in Heyen concerns what happens when a manager performs exempt and non-exempt work at the same time, for example supervising employees on the floor while also ringing up customers at a register. Federal law, under its concurrent-duties regulation, allows an employer to count that simultaneous work as exempt management time so long as the manager remains in charge of the operation. California expressly rejects that approach and refuses to import it.

Under Heyen, each task must be categorized according to its own primary purpose. When a manager rings a register because the store is short-staffed and a line of customers is waiting, that time is non-exempt sales work even if the manager is nominally in charge at the same moment. The manager cannot have the same minutes counted as both managing and selling. The court asks, for each task, what was the primary purpose of that activity, and classifies the time accordingly. This refusal to allow double-counting is why so many California managers who look busy supervising are, on an honest minute-by-minute accounting, doing non-exempt work for the majority of their shifts, and why employers cannot rescue a classification by arguing the manager was always keeping an eye on things.

What Counts as Exempt Management

Genuinely exempt managerial work includes interviewing, selecting, and training employees; setting and adjusting their rates of pay and hours of work; directing their work; appraising their productivity and efficiency; handling their complaints and grievances and disciplining them; planning the work; determining the techniques to be used; apportioning the work among the employees; deciding on the type of merchandise, materials, supplies, or tools to be bought, stocked, or sold; controlling the flow and distribution of goods; providing for the safety and security of the workplace; planning and controlling the budget; and monitoring or implementing legal compliance measures. The common thread is that the work involves running the operation rather than performing it.

By contrast, performing the same production or service tasks as the hourly crew, even while keeping a watchful eye on the floor and remaining the person in charge, is non-exempt. The test is not whether the work is important, or whether only a trusted employee would be allowed to do it, or whether it must be done well for the store to succeed. It is whether the task itself is management or labor. Mopping a floor is labor even when the store manager does it because no one else is available.

Directing Two or More Employees and Hiring Authority

Beyond the time test, the executive exemption requires that the manager customarily and regularly direct the work of at least two full-time employees or their equivalent, such as four half-time employees. A shift lead who supervises no one on many shifts, or who oversees only one worker, does not satisfy this element. The exemption also requires that the manager either have genuine authority to hire and fire or have recommendations on hiring, firing, and advancement given particular weight by higher management. A supervisor whose personnel input is routinely ignored, or who merely relays decisions made entirely by others, does not meet this element. These requirements are independent of the time test, so an employer must prove all of them, and a failure on any one defeats the exemption on its own.

Proving a Heyen Claim

Because exempt managers rarely clock in and out, proving how time was actually spent is the central challenge of the case. Evidence commonly includes the employee's own detailed reconstruction of a typical week, testimony from coworkers who saw the manager working the floor, staffing and scheduling records showing chronic understaffing that forced the manager onto non-exempt tasks, corporate task lists and labor-budget targets, and point-of-sale records tying the manager to individual register transactions throughout the day. California's burden-shifting rules help the worker here as well: when the employer kept no records of the exempt employee's hours or activities, the employee may establish the amount and extent of non-exempt work as a matter of just and reasonable inference, and the employer must then come forward with evidence to negate that inference.

California Does Not Follow the Federal Executive Standard

As with the administrative exemption, California's executive exemption is stricter than its federal counterpart, and borrowing the federal analysis is a common and expensive mistake. The federal standard asks whether management is the employee's primary duty in a qualitative sense and expressly allows concurrent exempt and non-exempt work to be counted as exempt through its concurrent-duties rule. California does neither. It requires that the employee be primarily engaged in managerial work, meaning more than one-half of actual work time, and it rejects the concurrent-duties rule so that time on non-exempt tasks is non-exempt even during simultaneous supervision.

California also ties the exempt salary floor to two times the state minimum wage for full-time work, a figure that rises with the minimum wage and generally sits above the federal salary threshold. An employer that classified a manager as exempt based on federal criteria, or on an out-of-date salary level, may satisfy federal law and still violate California law for work performed in the state. Because California law controls here, the safe course is to run the full California analysis rather than rely on a federal classification, and a manager who was told the classification is proper under national policy should not assume that answer holds in California.

Remedies for a Misclassified Manager

A manager who proves misclassification recovers unpaid overtime under Labor Code § 510, enforced through Labor Code § 1194 with interest, reasonable attorney fees, and costs. The misclassification usually also means missed meal and rest periods, giving rise to premium pay under Labor Code § 226.7, and it exposes the employer to wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226 for statements that never recorded the hours, and, at separation, waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203. Because the stakes compound across every pay period and across every similarly situated manager in the chain, these cases frequently proceed as class or representative actions, and the aggregate exposure to an employer can be very large.

How the Standard Applies to Assistant Managers and Shift Leads

The Heyen standard is most often tested against assistant managers, shift supervisors, and department leads, because those are the roles employers most commonly classify as exempt while expecting them to pitch in on the floor. An assistant manager who opens the store, counts the drawer, and sets the day's assignments is doing exempt work during those tasks, but if the rest of the shift is spent cashiering, stocking, and serving customers because the hourly crew is too thin, the exempt portion is unlikely to exceed half the time. A shift lead who is called a supervisor but who spends the shift doing the same production work as the team, with only incidental direction of others, is especially vulnerable to reclassification, because that worker may fail both the time test and the requirement of regularly directing two or more employees.

The analysis is individual and fact-specific, so two people with the same title can come out differently depending on how each actually spends the week. A department manager at a large, well-staffed location who truly spends most of the time planning, directing, disciplining, and buying may be properly exempt, while a counterpart at an understaffed store doing the same nominal job is not. That is precisely why courts following Heyen insist on looking at the real allocation of time rather than the title on the schedule, and why workers should document their own week rather than assume the label is correct.

Why Understaffing Drives the Exemption to Fail

The practical engine behind most successful Heyen-type claims is understaffing. Corporate labor budgets routinely allocate fewer hourly payroll hours than a store actually needs to run, and the salaried manager becomes the safety valve. Because the manager draws a fixed salary regardless of hours, it costs the company nothing extra on paper to push the manager onto the register, onto the sales floor, or into the stockroom whenever the hourly staffing runs short. The result is that the manager spends the bulk of the week doing the very production and service work the exemption was never meant to cover, all while the employer continues to treat the position as exempt.

This dynamic matters legally because it is both the cause of the violation and the evidence of it. Labor budgets, scheduling software data, and payroll records showing that hourly coverage was consistently below what the workload required tend to prove that managers were systematically doing non-exempt work. When those records exist across many locations and reflect a company-wide staffing model, they can support class certification, because the common question of whether the staffing model forced managers below the more-than-half threshold can be answered with common proof rather than one manager at a time.

The Burden of Proof and Narrow Construction

As with every California exemption, the employer bears the burden of proving the executive exemption, and courts construe it narrowly against the employer in favor of coverage. The employee does not have to prove non-exemption; the employer must affirmatively establish each element, including the quantitative more-than-half time test. Where the employer kept no record of how the manager actually spent each day, that evidentiary vacuum works against the employer, because California permits the employee to prove the extent of non-exempt work as a matter of just and reasonable inference, shifting to the employer the burden of coming forward with contrary evidence it often does not have.

This allocation of proof is why employers who want to rely on the executive exemption are well advised to track managerial activity, staff their locations adequately, and avoid labor models that predictably force salaried managers onto the floor. An employer that cannot show, with real evidence, that its managers spent more than half their time managing is in a poor position to defend the classification.

Deadlines, Penalties, and Class Treatment

The limitations landscape mirrors other wage claims. Unpaid overtime under Labor Code § 1194 generally reaches back three years, and up to four years as an unfair business practice under Business and Professions Code § 17200. Wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226 and waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203 have their own shorter periods, and a Private Attorneys General Act claim carries a one-year window with notice prerequisites. Because a misclassified manager typically worked long weeks for years, the unpaid overtime alone can be large, and when the employer's staffing model affected managers chain-wide, the claim is a natural candidate for class or representative treatment, multiplying the exposure across every store. Prompt action matters because the oldest and often largest pay periods fall off first.

Guidance for Employers and Managers

Employers should staff their locations well enough that managers are not routinely pulled onto the floor, should track what managers actually do rather than relying on an idealized job description, and should remember that California will not let simultaneous supervision rescue hours spent on production work. Managers who suspect misclassification should document, week by week, the share of time spent on non-exempt tasks and preserve schedules and staffing reports that show understaffing. Those weighing a claim may also want to compare the duties analysis used for office roles in our article on the administrative exemption, and can follow new developments on our employment law news page.

If you believe your employer has shortchanged your pay, misclassified your job, or ignored California wage law, you do not have to sort it out alone. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm represent California workers in wage-and-hour, overtime, and final-pay disputes, and we also advise employers who want to get classification and pay practices right before a claim lands. We will review your pay stubs, your actual job duties, your schedules, and your separation documents, explain where the law stands, and give you a candid assessment of what your claim is worth and how long you have to bring it. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation. Deadlines in wage cases are short and the earliest pay periods drop off first, so the sooner you call, the more we can protect.

Frequently Asked Questions

I am a salaried store manager but I spend most of my day stocking and at the register. Am I exempt?

Probably not. Under Heyen v. Safeway Inc., you are exempt only if you spend more than one-half of your work time on true managerial duties. If most of your time is hourly-type work, you are likely owed overtime despite your title and salary.

My boss says that because I supervise while I work the floor, it all counts as management. Is that right?

No. California rejects the federal concurrent-duties rule. Time spent on non-exempt tasks is non-exempt even if you are supervising at the same moment. Each task is classified by its own primary purpose.

Does a manager title automatically make me exempt?

No. Title is irrelevant. The employer must prove the time test, that you regularly direct two or more employees, that you have real hiring and firing authority or influence, that you exercise independent judgment, and that your salary meets the statutory floor.

How do I prove how I spent my time if I never clocked in?

You can reconstruct a typical week and support it with coworker testimony, schedules, staffing records, and point-of-sale data. If the employer kept no records, California lets you prove your hours as a matter of just and reasonable inference, shifting the burden to the employer to rebut it.

What can I recover?

Unpaid overtime with interest, attorney fees, and costs, plus likely meal and rest premium pay and wage-statement and waiting-time penalties. A lawyer can value the claim after reviewing your pay and schedule history.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301