CUSTOMS LITIGATION | 2026-10-30

IEEPA Refunds for Finally Liquidated Entries: What the Court of International Trade Orders and CBP Actually Say

A customs litigator reads the reliquidation orders, the CAPE 80-day cutoff, the 180-day protest window, and the two-year clock on a 28 U.S.C. § 1581(i) complaint, quoting the court and CBP directly.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

Many importers who paid IEEPA duties have already seen money come back through CBP's CAPE system. Many of the importers still waiting share one problem: some or all of their entries were finally liquidated before anyone asked for a refund. For those entries, CBP has told the Court of International...

The short answer

An IEEPA entry falls outside ordinary CAPE once it has been liquidated for more than 80 days (CBP’s cutoff, set inside its 90-day voluntary reliquidation period under 19 U.S.C. § 1501), and the liquidation becomes final and conclusive if no protest is filed within 180 days (19 U.S.C. § 1514). CBP’s position is that it cannot reliquidate finally liquidated entries without a court order, and the Court of International Trade’s July 2026 reliquidation orders, carried out through CAPE Phase 3 since October 6, 2026, run to importers that have their own case on file. For those entries the route is a civil action under 28 U.S.C. § 1581(i), which must be commenced within two years after the claim first accrues (28 U.S.C. § 2636(i)); our Court of International Trade filings page lists the docket numbers of the firm’s own actions.

Every week we talk to importers who were told, by a broker or by CAPE itself, that some of their IEEPA entries "can't be refunded." Usually that is not quite right. Those entries can't be refunded through an ordinary CAPE declaration, because they are finally liquidated. Whether they can be refunded at all depends on court orders that CBP is now carrying out, and on deadlines that keep running whether or not you are paying attention. Below we set out what the Supreme Court, the Court of International Trade and CBP have actually said, with the source for each quotation listed at the end.

Where IEEPA Refunds Stand on October 30, 2026

On February 20, 2026, the Supreme Court decided Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, No. 24-1287. The syllabus states the holding in one sentence: "IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs." That ruling made the reciprocal and other IEEPA duties unlawful, but it did not by itself put money back in anyone's bank account. Refunds depend on what happens to each entry inside CBP's systems.

CBP built a new tool for that work, the Consolidated Administration and Processing of Entries (CAPE), and deployed it in phases starting April 20, 2026. According to the October 6, 2026 declaration of CBP official Brandon Lord, filed in Freestyle World, Inc. v. United States, No. 26-01088, ECF No. 58, and described by the Court of International Trade in its October 8, 2026 opinion, CBP has liquidated or reliquidated more than 21.19 million entries without the IEEPA duties and has "certified and sent to the Treasury for disbursement, $126 billion in refunds for thousands of individual importers."

The same opinion names the gap. In the court's words: "As of now, the CAPE system has not accepted for processing all finally liquidated entries, nor all entries that have been liquidated for more than 80 days, if an importer has not separately filed a lawsuit." That sentence is the reason this article exists.

What "Finally Liquidated" Means in Customs Law

Liquidation is CBP's final computation of the duties owed on an entry. Until an entry liquidates, the duties you deposited at entry are estimates. Once it liquidates, three clocks matter.

The 90-day voluntary reliquidation window (19 U.S.C. § 1501)

Under 19 U.S.C. § 1501, CBP may reliquidate an entry on its own initiative within 90 days from the date of the original liquidation. After day 90, CBP loses that power. This is why CAPE works for some liquidated entries and not others: CAPE refunds liquidated entries by reliquidating them, and CBP can only do that voluntarily inside the 90-day period.

The 80-day CAPE cutoff

CBP set its CAPE cutoff ten days short of the statutory limit. Its IEEPA Duty Refunds page explains: "ACE accepts CAPE Declarations containing entries liquidated within the preceding 80 days. This allows sufficient time for CBP to process and reliquidate entries by the 90th day." In its April 2026 refund webinar, CBP confirmed the count: "It's 80 calendar days." An entry past day 80 is rejected with the error "Entry Summary is in Final Liquidation Status," which CBP's error guide defines as an entry summary liquidated or reliquidated more than 80 days ago.

The 180-day protest window (19 U.S.C. § 1514)

The importer's own tool against a liquidation is the protest. Section 1514(c)(3) requires that a protest "shall be filed with the Customs Service within 180 days after but not before—(A) date of liquidation or reliquidation, or (B) in circumstances where subparagraph (A) is inapplicable, the date of the decision as to which protest is made." If no protest is filed in time, 19 U.S.C. § 1514(a) makes the liquidation final and conclusive on all persons, including the United States.

Putting the three together

Customs lawyers use "finally liquidated" loosely, and so do the court and CBP, so it helps to be precise. In Freestyle World, the Court of International Trade uses the term for entries liquidated more than 90 days earlier and therefore past CBP's § 1501 voluntary reliquidation period. CBP's operational line is 80 days. For an importer, the practical categories are:

  • Unliquidated: eligible for an ordinary CAPE declaration.
  • Liquidated 80 days ago or less: eligible for an ordinary CAPE declaration, if filed before day 80 passes.
  • Liquidated more than 80 days ago but within 180 days: outside ordinary CAPE, but still protestable under § 1514.
  • Liquidated more than 180 days ago with no protest: final and conclusive under § 1514(a). Only a court order reaches these entries.

The last category is where most of the confusion arises.

The March 2026 Orders: From "Not Final" to Finally Liquidated

The refund machinery traces back to an order Judge Richard K. Eaton entered in Atmus Filtration, Inc. v. United States, No. 26-01259, on March 4, 2026. CBP's own CSMS # 68340863, announcing the April 20, 2026 CAPE deployment, describes that order as directing CBP to liquidate unliquidated entries without regard to the IEEPA duties and to reliquidate liquidated entries whose liquidation was not final.

The court's October 8, 2026 opinion in Freestyle World (Slip Op. 26-123) describes the same order as "covering unliquidated entries and entries for which liquidation was not final," and then states what came next: "Thereafter, the order was amended, to include finally liquidated entries in its scope, and then docketed in other cases."

The Atmus docket on CourtListener shows that the amendment came on March 27, 2026, and that it added language providing that "liquidated entries for which liquidation is final shall be reliquidated without regard to the IEEPA duties." The same docket shows the court suspending its amended order to the extent it required immediate compliance while CBP built the system to carry it out. That is the reason the March orders did not immediately produce refunds on old entries.

The government did not accept the finally liquidated piece. The Freestyle World opinion records: "On June 3, 2026, the Government appealed to the CAFC that portion of the order providing for liquidation or reliquidation of all affected entries." A later Court of International Trade filing cites the appeal as V.O.S. Selections, Inc. v. Trump, No. 26-1895 (Fed. Cir.). We have not found a Federal Circuit decision on that appeal as of the date of this article.

The July 2026 Orders: Reliquidation for Plaintiffs Only

In July 2026 the court began entering, in individual cases, orders that reach entries liquidated for more than 80 days. The July 15, 2026 order in Princess Awesome, LLC v. United States Customs and Border Protection, No. 25-00078, is the model. It directs CBP to "reliquidate, without regard to IEEPA duties, any and all of Plaintiffs' entries that have been liquidated for more than 80 days." It then attaches three conditions, quoted here in full:

  • "Reliquidation of entries that have been liquidated for more than 80 days is subject to Plaintiffs' counsel's submission to U.S. Customs and Border Protection of Plaintiffs' importer of record identification number(s), in accordance with instructions to be provided by U.S. Customs and Border Protection."
  • "Reliquidation shall occur only following U.S. Customs and Border Protection's acceptance of Plaintiffs' CAPE declarations."
  • "Nothing in this order addresses issues concerning duty free de minimis treatment under 19 U.S.C. § 1321 that are otherwise before this Court."

The AGS Company Automotive Solutions docket, No. 25-00255, shows an order of the same kind entered July 17, 2026. According to the Freestyle World opinion, the order has now been entered in more than 4,000 cases.

Read the Princess Awesome conditions slowly, because they tell you how the process actually runs:

  1. The order runs to plaintiffs. An importer that has not sued is not covered by it.
  2. Plaintiffs' counsel has to get the importer of record number to CBP, following CBP's instructions. Missing or mismatched IOR numbers stall the case.
  3. The refund still moves through CAPE. The court order does not send a check; it authorizes CBP to accept a CAPE declaration for entries it would otherwise reject.
  4. De minimis issues under 19 U.S.C. § 1321 are carved out and are not resolved by these orders.

What CBP Has Said About Finally Liquidated Entries and CAPE Phase 3

CBP's position on its own authority is stated plainly in the Freestyle World opinion, which reports that "the Government asserts that, without a court order directing it to do so, Customs does not have the authority to reliquidate finally liquidated entries." That position is consistent with the statute. After the 90-day § 1501 window and the 180-day § 1514 window, the liquidation is final, and an agency cannot simply reopen it.

CBP's answer for plaintiffs is CAPE Phase 3. The court's October 8, 2026 opinion states: "On October 6, 2026, Customs deployed CAPE Phase 3, which permits the plaintiffs in the more than 4,000 cases where the court's order has been entered to file a CAPE declaration." A footnote in the opinion reports that, as of October 7, 2026, declarations covering about 1.1 million entries and $500 million in claimed refunds had been accepted for processing in Phase 3.

Two practical points follow. First, Phase 3 is a CAPE function, so the filing rules for every CAPE declaration still apply: CBP accepts declarations only from the importer of record or the licensed customs broker that filed the entries, and CBP pays refunds by ACH to a party with refund bank information in the ACE Portal. Second, admission to Phase 3 depends on the court order being entered in your case and on CBP having your importer of record number under the instructions the order references. If either is missing, a Phase 3 declaration will not get through.

You may have seen references to an earlier CBP declaration in Freestyle World that first set the October 6 date. We have not quoted it here because we could not confirm its text from an official source at the time of writing. The October 6 deployment itself is confirmed by the court's opinion quoted above.

The October 8, 2026 Class Certification: What It Does and Does Not Do

In Freestyle World, Slip Op. 26-123, the court ruled on a motion to certify a class of importers. The holding: "the court grants Freestyle's motion and certifies the proposed class pursuant to USCIT Rule 23(b)(2)." The relief the class seeks, according to the opinion, is "an injunction directing liquidation or reliquidation of entries without regard to unlawfully imposed IEEPA duties." The court also observed that "it appears that the Government does not object to the requested relief itself; it only opposes granting this relief on a class-wide basis."

Class certification is a procedural ruling about who is in the case. It is not the same thing as an order directing CBP to reliquidate a particular class member's finally liquidated entries, and Phase 3, as described in the opinion, is open to plaintiffs in the cases where the individual order has been entered. If you are relying on class membership instead of your own case, understand three things: you do not control the timing, you do not control the litigation, and the government's appeal of the finally liquidated portion of the March orders remains pending. Some importers will reasonably decide to wait. Importers with significant finally liquidated deposits, or with entries approaching the two-year limit discussed below, often decide not to.

Sorting Your Entries: Which Route Fits Which Entry

Every refund decision starts with an entry-level list. Have your broker pull, for every entry on which IEEPA duties were deposited: the entry number, importer of record number, entry type, liquidation status, liquidation date, any protest number, any AD/CVD or drawback flag, and the IEEPA deposit amount. Then sort by liquidation date as of today.

Unliquidated, or liquidated 80 days ago or less

File a CAPE declaration through the importer's or broker's ACE Portal account, and do it before day 80 passes on the liquidated ones. Every day counts here, because an entry that crosses day 80 while you are assembling the file moves into a harder category.

Liquidated 81 to 180 days ago

These entries are outside ordinary CAPE but still inside the protest window. A protest under § 1514 must be filed within 180 days of the liquidation date. A timely protest keeps the liquidation from becoming final and preserves the path to a denied-protest action under 28 U.S.C. § 1581(a) if CBP denies it. Note that CBP's CAPE validation rejects entries that are on an open or suspended protest, so the protest and CAPE routes have to be coordinated, not run in parallel by different people who are not talking to each other.

Liquidated more than 180 days ago, no protest filed

These are finally liquidated in the strictest sense. Neither CAPE nor a protest reaches them. The route is a civil action in the Court of International Trade under 28 U.S.C. § 1581(i), the court's residual jurisdiction, which covers claims arising out of laws providing for tariffs and their administration and enforcement when no other subsection of § 1581 applies. The orders described above have been entered in cases brought that way.

Entries already under protest

A pending protest is not a refund. If the protest was filed on time, the entry is not finally liquidated, and you have options: wait for the protest decision, or, as CBP told the trade in its April 2026 webinar, "You do have the option to withdraw the protest and then file for the IEEPA refund on a CAPE declaration." Withdrawal only helps if CAPE will accept the entry afterward, which means the 80-day rule still applies. Talk to counsel before withdrawing a protest on an entry that liquidated more than 80 days ago.

The § 1581(i) Complaint and Its Two-Year Limit

Residual jurisdiction comes with its own statute of limitations. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2636(i): "A civil action of which the Court of International Trade has jurisdiction under section 1581 of this title, other than an action specified in subsections (a)–(h) of this section, is barred unless commenced in accordance with the rules of the court within two years after the cause of action first accrues." The Court of International Trade has treated § 2636(i), as the more specific provision, as controlling over the six-year general limit in 28 U.S.C. § 2401(a), and it has dismissed § 1581(i) claims filed more than two years after they accrued.

When an IEEPA refund claim "first accrues" is a question the government can be expected to argue. The careful approach is to measure two years from the earliest plausible date for each entry, which for many importers means the date the IEEPA deposit was paid, and to file before the earliest of those dates passes. IEEPA duties were first collected in 2025, so for the oldest entries that two-year mark is not far away. Waiting to see how the Federal Circuit rules does not stop the clock.

What the complaint involves

A § 1581(i) action is commenced by filing a summons and complaint together with the court's required forms. The court's filing fee is $400. The complaint identifies the plaintiff importer, the IEEPA duties paid, the entries at issue, and the relief requested, which in these cases is reliquidation without regard to the IEEPA duties and refund with interest as provided by law. Once the case is on the docket, counsel follows the court's procedure for having the standard reliquidation order entered, submits the importer of record number to CBP under CBP's instructions, and coordinates with the broker who will file the Phase 3 CAPE declaration.

You can see what these filings look like in practice on our Court of International Trade filings page, which lists the docket numbers of the firm's own actions so that anyone can check them on the court's public docket. For a plain-English overview of the finally liquidated problem and the steps involved, see our page on IEEPA refunds for finally liquidated entries; for entries still inside the protest window, see how to file a CBP protest for an IEEPA refund.

A Practical Checklist for Importers and Brokers

  1. Build the entry list. Every IEEPA entry, with liquidation date and status as of today. Do not rely on memory or on a list from three months ago; entries move between categories every day.
  2. Flag the 80-day entries first. Anything liquidated in the last 80 days goes on a CAPE declaration now.
  3. Calendar the 180-day protest dates. For each entry liquidated 81 to 180 days ago, calendar the protest deadline and decide, entry by entry, whether to protest.
  4. Separate the finally liquidated entries. Total the IEEPA deposits on entries liquidated more than 180 days ago without a protest. That number, and the age of the oldest deposit, drive the decision on a § 1581(i) complaint.
  5. Confirm the importer of record data. The Princess Awesome order conditions reliquidation on submission of the IOR number. Make sure the number you give counsel is the number on the entry summaries.
  6. Confirm ACH refund enrollment. CBP pays IEEPA refunds electronically to a party with refund bank information in the ACE Portal. Without it, an accepted declaration does not produce a deposit.
  7. Assign one owner. Protests, CAPE declarations and litigation touch the same entries. One person should hold the master list.

Fees and How to Reach Us

Our fees are stated the same way everywhere we publish them: 2% of the refund where a CAPE declaration suffices; 7% where a Court of International Trade complaint is required, or a flat $2,000 where the refund is under $29,000. No attorney fee unless we recover. The client is responsible for case costs, including the $400 court filing fee and approximately $40 for service by mail.

If you have entries that CAPE rejected as finally liquidated, or you are not sure which category your entries fall into, call our customs line at (213) 645-2246 for a consultation. Bring your broker's entry list if you have it. No outcome can be promised in any case, and the right route depends on the dates and facts of your entries.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does "finally liquidated" mean for an IEEPA refund?

It means the liquidation can no longer be changed by CBP on its own or by a protest. CBP's voluntary reliquidation power ends 90 days after liquidation under 19 U.S.C. § 1501, and the protest period ends 180 days after liquidation under 19 U.S.C. § 1514(c)(3). CBP stops accepting liquidated entries in ordinary CAPE after 80 days so it can finish reliquidation before day 90.

Can CBP refund a finally liquidated entry without a court order?

According to the Court of International Trade's October 8, 2026 opinion in Freestyle World, the government's position is that "without a court order directing it to do so, Customs does not have the authority to reliquidate finally liquidated entries." CAPE Phase 3, deployed October 6, 2026, is open to plaintiffs in cases where the court's reliquidation order has been entered.

What is CAPE Phase 3?

It is the CAPE function that lets plaintiffs with a reliquidation order file a CAPE declaration for entries liquidated more than 80 days ago. The court's opinion states that Customs deployed it on October 6, 2026, for "the plaintiffs in the more than 4,000 cases where the court's order has been entered."

My entry liquidated 120 days ago. Is it too late?

Not necessarily. It is outside ordinary CAPE, but still within the 180-day protest window under § 1514. File a protest before day 180, or discuss with counsel whether a Court of International Trade action is the better route for that entry.

How long do I have to file a § 1581(i) complaint?

Under 28 U.S.C. § 2636(i), the action is barred unless commenced within two years after the cause of action first accrues. Because the government may argue for an early accrual date, measure from the earliest plausible date for each entry, such as the date the IEEPA deposit was paid.

Does the October 8, 2026 class certification protect me?

The court certified a class under USCIT Rule 23(b)(2). Certification decides who is in the case; it is not itself an order reliquidating any class member's entries, and the government's appeal of the finally liquidated portion of the March orders remains pending. If your finally liquidated deposits are significant or your oldest entries are close to the two-year mark, consider whether to file your own action.

Does the court order pay me directly?

No. The Princess Awesome order states that "Reliquidation shall occur only following U.S. Customs and Border Protection's acceptance of Plaintiffs' CAPE declarations." The refund still runs through CAPE and is paid by ACH to a party enrolled for refunds in the ACE Portal.

Sources Quoted in This Article

  • Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, No. 24-1287 (U.S. Feb. 20, 2026), slip opinion: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/24-1287_4gcj.pdf
  • Freestyle World, Inc. v. United States, No. 26-01088, Slip Op. 26-123 (Ct. Int'l Trade Oct. 8, 2026): https://www.cit.uscourts.gov/sites/cit/files/26-123.pdf (also at https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/11018148/freestyle-world-inc-v-united-states/)
  • Atmus Filtration, Inc. v. United States, No. 26-01259, docket: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/72339861/atmus-filtration-inc-v-united-states/
  • Princess Awesome, LLC v. United States Customs and Border Protection, No. 25-00078, order of July 15, 2026, docket: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69940555/princess-awesome-llc-v-united-states-customs-and-border-protection/
  • AGS Company Automotive Solutions v. United States Customs and Border Protection, No. 25-00255, docket: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/71898481/ags-company-automotive-solutions-v-united-states-customs-and-border/
  • CBP, International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) Duty Refunds: https://www.cbp.gov/trade/programs-administration/trade-remedies/ieepa-duty-refunds
  • CBP, IEEPA Duty Refunds and CAPE webinar, April 2026: https://www.cbp.gov/sites/default/files/2026-04/webinar_ieepa_refunds_overview_4.17.pdf
  • CBP, CSMS # 68340863: https://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/USDHSCBP/bulletins/412cc7f
  • 19 U.S.C. § 1514: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/19/1514
  • 28 U.S.C. § 2636: https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-2015-title28-section2636&num=0&edition=2015

Attorney advertising. This article is general information about customs law as of October 30, 2026, not legal advice for any particular entry. Court orders and CBP procedures in the IEEPA refund litigation are changing; confirm the current state of the docket and CBP guidance before acting.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301