DISABILITY ACCOMMODATION | 2026-11-09
Medical Inquiries and Exams Under FEHA in California: 12940(e)-(f) (2026)
When a California employer may lawfully ask about your health or require a medical examination, by employment stage.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California strictly limits when an employer may ask about your health or require a medical exam. Under Gov. Code 12940(e) and (f), the rules change by stage: almost nothing is allowed before a conditional offer, post-offer exams must apply to all entrants in the job category, and exams of current em
When a California Employer May Ask About Your Health
California tightly regulates when an employer may probe an employee's or applicant's medical condition. The Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits disability-related inquiries and medical examinations except in defined circumstances tied to the stage of employment. The governing provisions are Gov. Code § 12940(e) and § 12940(f), implemented by the regulations at Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11071. These rules exist to keep hiring decisions focused on ability to do the job rather than on a worker's medical history, and to prevent employers from screening out applicants based on hidden health information.
For workers, understanding these limits is a shield against intrusive and unlawful questioning. For employers, following them is essential, because an improper medical inquiry or examination can itself be a FEHA violation even if no adverse action follows. The timing of the inquiry — before an offer, after an offer, or during employment — is what determines what is permitted.
Before a Conditional Offer: Almost Nothing Is Permitted
At the pre-offer stage, the rule is strict. Under Gov. Code § 12940(e), an employer may not make a disability-related inquiry or require a medical or psychological examination of an applicant before extending a conditional offer of employment. The employer cannot ask whether an applicant has a disability, cannot ask about the nature or severity of a condition, and cannot require a medical exam as part of the initial screening.
An employer may ask whether an applicant can perform the essential functions of the job, with or without reasonable accommodation, and may ask the applicant to describe or demonstrate how they would perform those functions. The line is between questions about ability to do the work, which are allowed, and questions designed to reveal a disability, which are not. This structure protects applicants from being weeded out on the basis of medical information before their qualifications are even evaluated.
After a Conditional Offer: The All-Entrants Rule
Once a conditional offer of employment has been made, the employer gains more latitude, but only within strict boundaries. Under Gov. Code § 12940(e) and the implementing regulations, a post-offer medical examination or disability-related inquiry is permitted only if it is required of all entering employees in the same job classification, regardless of disability. An employer cannot single out one applicant for a medical exam; the requirement must be uniform across the job category.
If a post-offer examination reveals a condition and the employer withdraws the offer, the employer must be able to show that the reason is job-related and consistent with business necessity, and that no reasonable accommodation would allow the person to perform the essential functions safely. The all-entrants rule prevents employers from using the post-offer stage as a backdoor to screen out individuals they suspect have disabilities.
Current Employees: Job-Related and Consistent With Business Necessity
For employees already on the job, the standard is different again. Under Gov. Code § 12940(f), an employer may require a medical or psychological examination or make a disability-related inquiry of a current employee only when the examination or inquiry is job-related and consistent with business necessity. This is a demanding standard. The employer must have a legitimate, objective basis to believe that the employee's ability to perform essential job functions is impaired, or that the employee poses a genuine safety risk.
A generalized curiosity, a stereotype, or a vague concern does not meet the standard. The business-necessity requirement protects employees from being forced into examinations designed to build a pretextual record or to pressure them out. When an employer does order an examination, it must be no broader than necessary to address the legitimate concern.
Fitness-for-Duty Examinations
A common application of the current-employee rule is the fitness-for-duty examination. An employer may require such an examination when it has a reasonable, objective basis to question whether an employee can safely and effectively perform essential job duties — for example, after a serious workplace incident, or when documented performance or conduct raises a genuine concern tied to a possible medical condition. The examination must still satisfy the job-related and business-necessity standard, and it must be limited in scope to the specific concern.
Fitness-for-duty examinations frequently intersect with accommodation duties. If an examination reveals a condition, the employer's obligation to engage in the interactive process under Gov. Code § 12940(n) and to provide reasonable accommodation under § 12940(m) is triggered. An employer cannot use a fitness-for-duty examination to justify removing an employee without first considering accommodation.
Confidentiality of Medical Information
Information obtained through any permitted examination or inquiry must be kept confidential. Under the FEHA regulations at Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 § 11071, medical information must be collected and maintained on separate forms and in separate files, treated as a confidential medical record, and disclosed only in narrow circumstances — such as informing supervisors of necessary work restrictions and accommodations, or first-aid personnel of conditions requiring emergency treatment.
California layers additional protection through the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA), Civ. Code § 56 and following. The CMIA restricts how employers and others may use and disclose individually identifiable medical information, and it provides remedies for improper disclosure. Together, the FEHA regulations and the CMIA mean that an employer who lawfully obtains medical information still bears a continuing duty to guard it.
How FEHA Compares to Federal Law
These California rules parallel, and in places exceed, protections under the federal ADA, which also restricts pre-offer inquiries and examinations and requires that examinations of current employees be job-related and consistent with business necessity. Because FEHA defines disability more broadly than the ADA and is construed in favor of coverage, California employees frequently have stronger protection against intrusive medical inquiries than federal law alone would provide. For a closer look at that broader state standard, see our article on how the FEHA disability definition is broader than the ADA.
Remedies and Deadlines When the Rules Are Broken
An unlawful medical inquiry or examination can be an independent FEHA violation. A worker pursuing such a claim must exhaust administrative remedies by filing a complaint with the Civil Rights Department under Gov. Code § 12960, which for conduct on or after January 1, 2020 allows three years from the unlawful act. After a right-to-sue notice issues, Gov. Code § 12965 generally permits one year to file the lawsuit. Remedies can include damages for emotional distress, economic losses where an adverse action followed, injunctive relief, and reasonable attorney fees and costs. Improper disclosure of medical information may additionally support a claim under the CMIA. Stay current on workplace-rights developments through our employment law news page.
Practical Steps for Workers and Employers
Workers who are asked intrusive medical questions during hiring, or who are ordered into an examination without a clear job-related reason, should document the request, note who asked and when, and avoid volunteering more than the law requires. If an examination is ordered, ask what business necessity supports it and keep a record of the answer. Employees who suspect their medical information was improperly shared should preserve evidence of the disclosure.
Employers should audit their application forms and interview scripts to remove pre-offer medical questions, ensure that any post-offer examinations are uniform across job classifications, and require managers to articulate a specific, job-related basis before ordering any examination of a current employee. Storing medical information separately and training supervisors on confidentiality are low-cost measures that prevent costly violations.
Separating Lawful Questions From Disability-Related Inquiries
Not every health-related question is a prohibited medical inquiry. Under the framework FEHA shares in structure with federal law, a disability-related inquiry is one likely to elicit information about whether a person has a disability, and it is those inquiries that are tightly restricted. An employer may generally ask whether an applicant can perform the essential functions of the job, with or without accommodation, and may ask an employee to describe or demonstrate how she would perform a task. What it may not do, outside the permitted windows, is probe for the existence, nature, or severity of a disability.
The line can be subtle. Asking whether an employee can lift the weight a job requires is permissible; asking whether she has a back condition that affects lifting is a disability-related inquiry that must fit within the statutory allowances. Employers that blur this distinction, especially in interviews, create liability even when they believe they are simply assessing fitness for the role.
Testing for Drugs and Alcohol
Medical examination rules interact with substance testing in specific ways. Testing for current illegal drug use is generally not treated as a prohibited medical examination, and current use of illegal drugs is not itself a protected disability under FEHA. Alcohol testing, however, can constitute a medical examination because it measures a physiological condition, so it is subject to the job-related and business-necessity constraints that govern examinations of current employees. Employers must structure testing programs with these differences in mind, particularly where a positive result could reveal a protected condition such as a disability in recovery.
These distinctions carry real consequences. An employer that imposes broad alcohol or medical testing on incumbent employees without a job-related, business-necessity justification risks violating the examination rules, even where a narrow, safety-driven program would have been defensible.
Return-to-Work Certifications and Over-Broad Requests
Return-to-work situations are a common source of unlawful inquiries. An employer may seek a fitness-for-duty certification confirming an employee can safely perform essential functions, but it may not use the occasion to demand an employee’s complete medical history or details unrelated to the job. A certification request must be limited to the functions at issue; a sweeping demand for diagnoses, treatment records, or unrelated conditions exceeds what the job-related and business-necessity standard permits.
Workers returning from medical leave should be alert to this. A request to confirm you can perform your duties is proper, but a demand to disclose your full chart, your medications, or conditions that have nothing to do with the job is the kind of over-broad inquiry FEHA restricts.
Wellness Programs and Voluntary Disclosures
Employer wellness programs that invite health screenings or questionnaires raise medical-inquiry concerns because they solicit exactly the information the statute guards. Such programs are tolerated only where participation is genuinely voluntary and the resulting medical information is kept confidential and segregated from personnel decisions. A program that pressures employees to disclose health information, or that feeds results into employment decisions, loses the voluntariness that makes it lawful.
If you were asked an unlawful question or subjected to an improper examination, document what was asked, when, and by whom, and note any adverse action that followed. A worker harmed by an unlawful inquiry may pursue the same FEHA remedies available for disability discrimination, including damages and injunctive relief, after satisfying the administrative-exhaustion requirements that govern FEHA claims.
Genetic Information and CalGINA
California bars employers from seeking or using genetic information in employment decisions. The state’s genetic-information protections, incorporated into Government Code § 12940 and § 12926, prohibit requesting, requiring, or using an individual’s genetic information, including family medical history and the results of genetic tests. This closes a door that ordinary medical inquiries might otherwise leave open, because family history questions in a health screening can reveal exactly the kind of predictive genetic information the law protects. Employers that gather health data through wellness programs or exams must be careful not to sweep in genetic information.
The prohibition is broad and does not depend on whether the employer acted on the information. Simply soliciting genetic information outside narrow exceptions can violate the statute, which is one more reason employer health inquiries must be tightly tailored to current ability to perform the job.
Confidential Storage and Separate Files
Any medical information an employer lawfully obtains must be kept confidential. FEHA requires that medical records gathered through post-offer exams, fitness-for-duty certifications, or accommodation requests be maintained separately from ordinary personnel files and disclosed only on a need-to-know basis, such as to supervisors who must implement a restriction or to first-aid personnel in an emergency. Treating medical information like routine personnel data, or circulating a diagnosis among managers who have no need for it, is itself a violation independent of any hiring or firing decision.
Employees harmed by improper disclosure of their medical information have a claim even if they suffered no adverse job action, because the confidentiality obligation protects privacy in its own right. The secure, segregated handling of medical records is a legal duty, not merely good practice.
Who Conducts and Pays for a Required Exam
When an employer lawfully requires a medical examination, whether post-offer or job-related for a current employee, the employer bears the cost and arranges the exam; it cannot shift that expense onto the worker. The examination must be limited in scope to what the permitted purpose allows, and the examiner’s inquiry should match the job-related, business-necessity justification rather than ranging across unrelated aspects of the employee’s health. An exam that exceeds its lawful purpose becomes an unlawful inquiry regardless of who performs it.
Workers asked to undergo an examination should understand both that a properly limited, job-related exam can be lawful and that they are not required to foot the bill or submit to an open-ended probe of their medical history. The scope and the cost allocation are both constrained by the statute.
The Governing Statutory Text
The rules on medical questions and examinations are grounded in the text of FEHA itself. Government Code § 12940(e) restricts medical and psychological inquiries and examinations of applicants, permitting job-related questions about the ability to perform essential functions but barring inquiries designed to identify a disability before a conditional offer. Government Code § 12940(f) governs examinations and inquiries directed at current employees, allowing them only when job-related and consistent with business necessity. The broad definitions in Government Code § 12926 determine what counts as a disability or medical condition for these purposes, and because those definitions are expansive, the inquiries that could reveal them are correspondingly limited.
Reading these provisions together shows why the timing of a question matters so much. The same inquiry that is forbidden before a conditional offer under § 12940(e) may be permissible after the offer under the all-entrants rule, and an inquiry aimed at a current employee must independently satisfy the job-related, business-necessity test of § 12940(f).
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If an employer asked improper questions about your health or required an unjustified medical examination, that can be an independent FEHA violation. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can review what you were asked and whether your rights were violated. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation. For related guidance, browse our California employment-law news page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a California employer ask about my medical history during a job interview?
Generally no. Under Gov. Code 12940(e), an employer may not make disability-related inquiries or require a medical exam before a conditional offer. It may only ask whether you can perform the essential job functions, with or without reasonable accommodation.
Can my employer require a medical exam after offering me the job?
Yes, but only if the exam is required of all entering employees in the same job classification, not just you. If the employer withdraws the offer based on the results, it must show the reason is job-related and consistent with business necessity and that no accommodation would work.
When can my current employer order me to take a medical examination?
Only when the examination or inquiry is job-related and consistent with business necessity under Gov. Code 12940(f) — meaning the employer has an objective basis to believe your ability to perform essential functions is impaired or that you pose a genuine safety risk. The exam must be no broader than necessary.
Is my medical information confidential if the employer lawfully obtains it?
Yes. Under Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 section 11071, medical information must be kept on separate confidential forms and files and disclosed only in narrow circumstances. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, Civ. Code 56, adds further protection and remedies for improper disclosure.
Is an unlawful medical inquiry a violation even if I am not fired?
Yes. An improper disability-related inquiry or examination can be an independent FEHA violation regardless of whether an adverse action follows. You generally have three years under Gov. Code 12960 to file an administrative complaint with the Civil Rights Department.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301