WORKER CLASSIFICATION | 2026-11-15

Owner-Operator Truckers, AB5, and Misclassification After Cal Cartage in California (2026)

California applies the ABC test to port and owner-operator truck drivers, and the Cal Cartage enforcement wave shows how costly misclassification has become in the trucking industry.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

For years, port and drayage trucking in California ran on an owner-operator model in which drivers leased or owned their trucks and were paid as independent contractors. AB5 and its ABC test changed the legal landscape, and after the Ninth Circuit confirmed that federal transportation law does not p

The Owner-Operator Model and Why It Came Under Fire

California's ports and distribution networks long relied on owner-operator truck drivers: individuals who drove a truck they owned or leased and were paid by the load or the trip as independent contractors. The model let motor carriers avoid payroll taxes, workers' compensation, minimum-wage and overtime obligations, and expense reimbursement, while often exercising tight control over the drivers. Regulators and courts increasingly viewed the arrangement as misclassification, especially at the ports, where lease-to-own truck programs could leave drivers deeply in debt to the very carriers that controlled their work.

California's response was to extend its strict employee-classification rules to trucking. The result is that an owner-operator who is controlled like an employee is treated as one, with all the wage-and-hour consequences that follow.

AB5 and the ABC Test Applied to Drivers

The governing statute is Labor Code § 2775, which codifies the ABC test for determining employee status. Under that test, a worker is presumed an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three prongs: that the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in the performance of the work, both under the contract and in fact; that the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business; and that the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.

For a drayage carrier, the second prong is often fatal. If the carrier's business is hauling freight, and the driver hauls freight, the driver performs work squarely within the usual course of the carrier's business, and the carrier cannot satisfy prong B. That single feature is why so many owner-operator arrangements fail the ABC test in trucking. The classification question is not academic: it determines who owes the driver minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest premiums, expense reimbursement, and accurate wage statements.

The FAAAA Preemption Fight

Motor carriers fought AB5 on the theory that federal law preempts its application to trucking. The Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act preempts state laws related to a motor carrier's prices, routes, or services, a provision codified at 49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1). Carriers argued that forcing them to treat drivers as employees would effectively dictate how they structure their services and should be preempted.

The Ninth Circuit rejected that argument. In California Trucking Association v. Bonta (9th Cir. 2021), the court held that the ABC test is a generally applicable labor law that does not bind carriers to particular prices, routes, or services and therefore is not preempted by 49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1). The Supreme Court declined to review the decision, leaving AB5 fully applicable to California trucking. After Bonta, the preemption shield that carriers had relied on is gone, and the ABC test governs owner-operator classification in the state.

The Cal Cartage Enforcement Wave

Enforcement in the port-trucking sector gave the law teeth. The People v. Cal Cartage litigation and the broader wave of port-trucking misclassification actions brought by public prosecutors targeted carriers that treated drayage drivers as independent contractors while controlling nearly every aspect of their work. These actions sought unpaid wages, reimbursement of unlawful deductions, and civil penalties, and they signaled that the state would pursue misclassification aggressively in the trucking industry. The practical lesson for carriers is that labeling a driver an owner-operator does not insulate the carrier when the state applies the ABC test and finds control.

The Classification Cases Behind the Doctrine

The modern framework rests on Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018), which adopted the ABC test for wage-order claims and reflected California's strong policy against misclassification; Labor Code § 2775 later codified and broadened it. Before Dynamex, classification turned on S.G. Borello and Sons v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) and its multifactor control test, which still governs claims outside the ABC test's reach. In the trucking context specifically, Garcia v. Border Transportation Group (2018) addressed how the ABC test and the Borello factors apply to different categories of claims, illustrating that some non-wage-order claims may still be analyzed under Borello even as wage-order claims use the ABC test. The upshot is that drivers often have multiple theories, and carriers must satisfy the most demanding one that applies.

The Penalties: Labor Code 226.8 and 2753

California does not merely reclassify misclassified drivers; it penalizes willful misclassification. Labor Code § 226.8 prohibits the willful misclassification of an individual as an independent contractor and authorizes substantial civil penalties for each violation, with enhanced penalties where there is a pattern or practice of misclassification. The statute also penalizes charging a misclassified worker for items that would be unlawful to deduct from an employee's pay, such as equipment or space fees, which strikes directly at port-trucking lease programs.

Liability can extend beyond the carrier. Labor Code § 2753 imposes joint and several liability on a person who, for money or other valuable consideration, knowingly advises an employer to treat an individual as an independent contractor to avoid employee status, subject to exceptions for the employer's own employees and licensed attorneys giving legal advice. Together these provisions mean that the consultants and intermediaries who design misclassification schemes can share the liability.

What a Misclassified Driver Can Recover

A driver reclassified as an employee is owed the full suite of wage-and-hour protections. That includes minimum wage and overtime under Labor Code § 510 and the applicable Wage Order, reimbursement of necessary business expenses under Labor Code § 2802, which in trucking can include fuel, truck payments, insurance, maintenance, and permit costs, meal and rest premiums, and accurate itemized wage statements. Unlawful deductions taken from the driver's pay, a hallmark of lease-to-own programs, must be repaid. The carrier may also owe unpaid payroll taxes and workers' compensation coverage. The penalties under Labor Code § 226.8 add to the exposure. For the parallel high-risk analysis in construction, see our guide to the construction contractor employee presumption, and our employment law news page follows classification enforcement statewide.

How Drivers Prove Control

Because prong B often decides the case, many disputes still turn on control evidence under prong A and the Borello analysis for claims outside the ABC test. Drivers should document who sets the routes, who dictates the schedule, who controls the rate and the loads, whether the driver can work for other carriers, who owns or controls the truck and the financing, and whether the carrier deducts expenses from pay. Dispatch records, settlement statements, lease agreements, and communications directing the driver's work are the core proof. The more the carrier controls, the weaker its independent-contractor defense.

Compliance Steps for Carriers

Carriers that want to use genuine owner-operators must confront the reality that prong B of Labor Code § 2775 is extremely hard to satisfy when the driver hauls the freight the carrier sells. Some carriers restructure as true brokerages or use business-to-business arrangements, but those require genuine independence that survives scrutiny, not relabeling. Carriers should stop deducting truck and equipment costs from driver pay, avoid lease-to-own arrangements that chain drivers to the carrier, and seek legal advice before assuming any owner-operator model is lawful after Bonta. Given Labor Code § 2753, the advisers who design these structures share the risk, which should concentrate the mind.

Drivers should know that signing an owner-operator agreement does not make them independent contractors. If the carrier controls the work and the driver hauls the carrier's freight, California law likely treats the driver as an employee entitled to wages, reimbursement, and penalties, and no contract can waive those rights.

Why Prong B Is Nearly Impossible for Drayage Carriers

The analytical heart of owner-operator misclassification is prong B of Labor Code § 2775, which asks whether the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business. A drayage or motor carrier exists to move freight. A driver who moves that freight is performing the carrier's core service, not something ancillary to it. Courts have consistently found that a worker who does the very thing the business sells falls inside the usual course of business, so the carrier cannot satisfy prong B no matter how independent the driver otherwise appears. This is why ownership of the truck, a lease agreement, or a clause reciting independence rarely rescues the arrangement. The only arrangements that survive are those where the driver genuinely operates a separate business serving many customers, and even then prong A control and prong C independent-business requirements must also be met.

The B-to-B and Brokerage Restructuring Problem

Some carriers have tried to escape Labor Code § 2775 by restructuring as freight brokers or by casting the relationship as a business-to-business contract. California law recognizes a business-to-business exemption in limited circumstances, but it requires that the service provider be a genuine, separately incorporated business that provides services directly to the contracting business rather than to its customers, maintains its own clientele, and satisfies a lengthy list of conditions. A paper reorganization that leaves the carrier controlling routes, rates, and loads does not qualify. A true brokerage that merely matches independent carriers with shippers is a different model, but a company cannot both direct the driver like an employee and claim to be a neutral broker. The substance of the relationship, not its label, controls, which is the lesson the ABC test drives home.

FAAAA Preemption After Bonta: The Settled Landscape

Because the preemption question shaped a decade of litigation, it is worth being precise about where the law now stands. The Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, 49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1), preempts state laws related to a motor carrier's prices, routes, or services. In California Trucking Association v. Bonta (9th Cir. 2021), the court reasoned that the ABC test is a generally applicable labor standard that does not compel a carrier to use any particular prices, routes, or services; it merely determines who is an employee, as countless background labor laws do. On that reasoning the test survives preemption. With the Supreme Court declining review, carriers can no longer rely on a preemption defense to avoid Labor Code § 2775. The practical consequence is that the classification question is now decided on the ABC test's merits, where prong B usually controls.

Lease-to-Own Programs and Unlawful Deductions

The port-trucking model that drew the most enforcement attention was the lease-to-own truck program, in which a carrier leased a truck to a driver, classified the driver as an independent contractor, and then deducted the lease payments, insurance, fuel, and maintenance from the driver's settlements. When those drivers are reclassified as employees, the deductions become unlawful, because an employer may not shift its operating costs onto employees. Labor Code § 226.8 specifically penalizes charging a misclassified worker fees for the employer's equipment or space, and Labor Code § 2802 requires reimbursement of the very costs the lease program extracted. The result is that a lease-to-own carrier can owe both the repayment of deductions and reimbursement of business expenses, a double exposure that made the Cal Cartage-era actions so consequential.

Which Test Applies to Which Claim

Not every claim a driver brings is analyzed under the ABC test. Garcia v. Border Transportation Group (2018) illustrates that wage-order claims use the ABC test adopted in Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) and codified in Labor Code § 2775, while certain non-wage-order claims may still be evaluated under the multifactor S.G. Borello and Sons v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) standard. For a driver this is usually favorable, because the core wage claims, minimum wage and overtime under Labor Code § 510, expense reimbursement under Labor Code § 2802, and meal and rest premiums, are wage-order claims governed by the harder-to-rebut ABC test. Carriers must therefore satisfy the most demanding standard that applies to the claims at issue, and a driver often has multiple overlapping theories.

Advising Liability and the Reach of Section 2753

One feature that distinguishes trucking misclassification from ordinary wage disputes is the exposure of advisers and intermediaries. Labor Code § 2753 provides that a person who, for money or other valuable consideration, knowingly advises an employer to treat an individual as an independent contractor to avoid employee status is jointly and severally liable with the employer if the individual is found not to be an independent contractor. The statute exempts a person giving advice to their own employer and licensed attorneys providing legal advice, but it squarely targets the consultants, payroll firms, and logistics intermediaries that design misclassification schemes. In the port-trucking sector, where layered contracting arrangements are common, § 2753 means the entity that structured the owner-operator model may share the liability with the carrier that used it. This provision changes the economics of misclassification advice, because the adviser can no longer profit from a scheme while leaving the carrier to absorb all the risk.

Statutory Penalties and How They Multiply

The financial exposure in a misclassification case compounds quickly. Beyond the unpaid wages themselves, Labor Code § 226.8 authorizes civil penalties for each willful misclassification, with enhanced penalties where the carrier engaged in a pattern or practice, and it separately penalizes charging a misclassified worker for equipment or space. Inaccurate wage statements trigger penalties under Labor Code § 226, and the failure to pay all wages due can trigger waiting-time penalties at the end of employment. California's representative-enforcement statute allows an aggrieved employee to pursue civil penalties on behalf of the state for Labor Code violations, which can aggregate across an entire driver workforce. Because each driver and each pay period can generate separate penalties, a carrier that misclassified a fleet of drivers faces liability measured in the millions, which is precisely what made the port-trucking enforcement wave so disruptive to the industry's traditional model.

Deadlines and How Drivers Preserve Their Claims

A driver who suspects misclassification should act before the limitations periods expire. Claims for unpaid minimum wage and overtime under Labor Code § 510 generally carry a three-year limitations period, extended to four years when pursued as an unfair business practice under Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200, while certain penalty claims run on shorter clocks. Reimbursement claims under Labor Code § 2802 and unlawful-deduction claims tied to lease programs follow their own timing rules, so a driver should not delay. The most valuable evidence, settlement statements showing deductions, dispatch and routing records, lease agreements, and communications directing the work, is often controlled by the carrier and can disappear, which makes an early records request and litigation-hold demand critical. Consulting an employment lawyer promptly ensures the strongest claims are filed in time and that the carrier's control over the work is documented while the evidence still exists.

When a Driver Really Is an Independent Business

It would be wrong to suggest that no truck driver can lawfully be an independent contractor in California. A driver who operates a genuinely independent business, serves multiple carriers or shippers, negotiates rates, controls which loads to accept and when to work, owns and controls the equipment without a carrier-financed lease, and holds the driver's own operating authority, can satisfy the ABC test or, for claims outside it, the Borello standard. The distinction is between an entrepreneur who happens to contract with a carrier and a worker who is economically dependent on and controlled by a single carrier. The more a driver functions as a one-truck operation tied to one company that dictates the terms, the more clearly Labor Code § 2775 points to employment. The more a driver functions as a true small business with a diversified customer base and genuine control over operations, the more defensible the independent classification becomes. Carriers that want to use real independent operators must build and respect that genuine independence rather than paper over an employment relationship, because under the ABC test the economic substance is what the court examines.

Drivers should know that signing an owner-operator agreement does not make them independent contractors. If the carrier controls the work and the driver hauls the carrier's freight, California law likely treats the driver as an employee entitled to wages, reimbursement, and penalties, and no contract can waive those rights.

Talk to a California employment lawyer. If you drive as an owner-operator and your carrier controls your routes, rates, and deductions, or if you operate a motor carrier and need to assess your classification after Bonta and the Cal Cartage actions, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate the relationship under Labor Code § 2775, § 226.8, and § 2753. Call (213) 645-2246 to discuss your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does AB5 apply to owner-operator truck drivers in California?

Yes. Labor Code § 2775 codifies the ABC test, and after California Trucking Association v. Bonta (9th Cir. 2021) confirmed that 49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1) does not preempt it, the test fully applies to port and owner-operator drivers in California.

Why do so many owner-operator arrangements fail the ABC test?

Because prong B requires that the driver perform work outside the usual course of the carrier's business. When the carrier's business is hauling freight and the driver hauls freight, the driver is within the usual course of business and the carrier cannot satisfy the test.

What penalties apply to willful misclassification of drivers?

Labor Code § 226.8 authorizes substantial civil penalties for willful misclassification, with enhanced penalties for a pattern or practice, and Labor Code § 2753 imposes joint and several liability on those who knowingly advise an employer to misclassify a worker.

Can a misclassified trucker recover truck and fuel costs?

Yes. Under Labor Code § 2802 an employer must reimburse necessary business expenses, which for a reclassified driver can include fuel, truck payments, insurance, maintenance, and permits, and unlawful deductions from pay must be repaid.

Does signing an owner-operator contract make me a contractor?

No. The contract label does not control. If the carrier directs your routes, rates, schedule, and deductions and you haul its freight, California law likely treats you as an employee under Labor Code § 2775 regardless of what the agreement says.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301