PAGA ENFORCEMENT | 2026-11-03
Are PAGA Waivers Enforceable in California in 2026? Iskanian, Viking River, and Your Rights
Under Iskanian, a pre-dispute waiver of a representative PAGA action is unenforceable, even though Viking River lets employers arbitrate the individual PAGA component.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
In Iskanian v. CLS Transportation, the California Supreme Court held that a pre-dispute agreement waiving the right to bring a representative PAGA action is unenforceable as against public policy, because the state is the real party in interest and the FAA does not preempt that rule. The later U.S.
Why a Pre-Dispute PAGA Waiver Is Unenforceable in California
The California Private Attorneys General Act, Labor Code § 2698 et seq., lets an “aggrieved employee” sue to recover civil penalties for Labor Code violations — not just those the employee suffered, but those suffered by other employees as well — acting as a proxy for the state. Because PAGA is so powerful, employers have long tried to shut it down in advance through arbitration agreements that force employees to waive the right to bring a representative PAGA action. In Iskanian v. CLS Transportation Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal.4th 348, the California Supreme Court held that such a pre-dispute waiver of the right to bring a representative PAGA claim is unenforceable as against public policy.
The reasoning is foundational: a PAGA action is a dispute between the employer and the state, with the employee acting on the state's behalf. A private agreement between employer and employee cannot bargain away rights that belong to the government. That is why an employee cannot, before any dispute arises, agree to give up the representative PAGA remedy.
What PAGA Actually Does
Under Labor Code § 2699, an aggrieved employee may recover civil penalties that previously only the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) could collect. Historically, the default civil penalty structure provided a set amount per aggrieved employee per pay period for an initial violation and a higher amount for each subsequent violation, with the recovered penalties split between the state (the larger share, paid to the LWDA) and the aggrieved employees (the remainder). The employee who brings the action also may recover attorney's fees and costs.
Critically, PAGA is a law enforcement device, not a class action. The employee is a private attorney general deputized to enforce the Labor Code. That characterization is what made the Iskanian waiver analysis come out the way it did — you cannot privately waive the state's enforcement interest.
The FAA Preemption Question
Employers argued that the Federal Arbitration Act (9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq.) preempts California's anti-waiver rule, because the FAA requires courts to enforce arbitration agreements according to their terms, including clauses that waive collective or representative proceedings. The Iskanian Court disagreed as to representative PAGA claims. It reasoned that the FAA governs private disputes, whereas a PAGA claim is a public enforcement action in which the state is the real party in interest. Because the rule against PAGA waivers does not single out arbitration and concerns a claim that is fundamentally public, the Court held the FAA did not preempt it.
That holding set up years of tension between California's PAGA jurisprudence and the United States Supreme Court's broad FAA decisions — tension that eventually reached the high court.
Viking River Cruises: The Individual-Versus-Representative Split
In Viking River Cruises, Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639, the United States Supreme Court addressed whether the FAA requires enforcement of an agreement to arbitrate the individual component of a PAGA action. The Court drew a line that Iskanian had not: it distinguished the employee's individual PAGA claim (penalties for violations the plaintiff personally suffered) from the representative or non-individual PAGA claim (penalties for violations suffered by other employees).
The high court held that the FAA preempts the Iskanian rule to the extent that rule prevented parties from agreeing to arbitrate the individual PAGA claim. In other words, an employer can compel arbitration of the plaintiff's own individual PAGA component. But the Supreme Court left in place the core of Iskanian: a wholesale pre-dispute waiver of the representative PAGA action remains invalid. The practical fight then shifted to what happens to the non-individual claims once the individual claim is sent to arbitration.
What Happened to Standing After Viking River
The Viking River majority suggested that once the individual PAGA claim is compelled to arbitration, the plaintiff might lose standing to pursue the representative claims in court, which would require dismissal of the non-individual portion. But standing under PAGA is a question of California law, and the United States Supreme Court does not have the last word on it. California courts subsequently addressed whether an employee who is compelled to arbitrate the individual claim retains standing to litigate the representative claims. The California Supreme Court has since confirmed that a plaintiff does retain statutory standing as an aggrieved employee to pursue the non-individual PAGA claims even when the individual claim is sent to arbitration (cited here by name and year because the precise reporter page should be confirmed): the standing requirement in Labor Code § 2699 turns on having been employed by the alleged violator and having suffered at least one Labor Code violation, not on whether the individual claim proceeds in court.
The upshot: employers can split off and arbitrate the individual PAGA claim, but they generally cannot use that split to extinguish the representative action. For how courts handle the trial of large representative PAGA groups, see our analysis of PAGA manageability after Estrada v. Royalty Carpet Mills.
The LWDA Notice Prerequisite
Before filing any PAGA action, an aggrieved employee must give written notice to the employer and to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, specifying the Labor Code provisions allegedly violated and the facts and theories supporting the claim, and must pay the required filing fee, under the exhaustion procedures of Labor Code § 2699.3. The LWDA then has a window to decide whether to investigate; if it declines or does not respond within the statutory period, the employee may proceed. This notice-and-exhaustion step is jurisdictional in effect — skipping it is fatal to the claim — and it is unaffected by any arbitration agreement.
The notice requirement reinforces why PAGA waivers fail: the statute builds the state into the process from the very first step. The employee is not pursuing a purely private grievance; the employee is initiating a state enforcement process.
Drafting Realities for Employers
After Iskanian and Viking River, an arbitration agreement that tries to waive the entire representative PAGA action remains unenforceable. What an employer can do is include a clause compelling arbitration of the individual PAGA claim, often paired with a severability provision so that an overbroad waiver does not sink the whole agreement. But employers should not assume that arbitrating the individual claim kills the representative claim — California standing law generally keeps the representative action alive in court.
Employers that rely on boilerplate “representative action waivers” copied from other states risk having the clause struck and facing the full representative action anyway. The safer course is a carefully drafted, California-specific clause that acknowledges the individual-versus-representative distinction.
What This Means for Workers
If you signed an arbitration agreement when you were hired, you likely did not waive your right to bring a representative PAGA action, even if the agreement says you did — that waiver is unenforceable under Iskanian. You may be required to arbitrate your individual PAGA claim, but your ability to pursue penalties on behalf of other aggrieved employees generally survives. Because PAGA penalties are substantial and the recovery is shared with the state, these actions are a major tool for enforcing the Labor Code where individual damages would be too small to litigate alone.
You still must satisfy the Labor Code § 2699.3 notice requirement and the one-year limitations period that generally governs PAGA penalties, so prompt action matters.
Deadlines and Remedies
PAGA penalty claims are generally subject to a one-year statute of limitations, which can be tied to the underlying Labor Code violation. The LWDA notice process can affect timing, so the limitations clock and the exhaustion steps must be managed together. Remedies are civil penalties under Labor Code § 2699, the larger share of which goes to the state, plus attorney's fees and costs to a prevailing employee. Because penalties accrue per employee per pay period, the aggregate exposure in a representative action can be very large even when each individual's harm is modest. Follow current PAGA developments on our employment law news page.
Why PAGA Exists at All
To understand why PAGA waivers fail, it helps to understand why the Legislature created PAGA. California concluded that state labor agencies lacked the resources to investigate and penalize the full universe of Labor Code violations. The Private Attorneys General Act, codified at Labor Code § 2698 et seq., responded by deputizing private employees to step into the state's shoes and recover civil penalties the agency itself could have pursued. The recovered penalties are then shared, with the larger portion going to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and the remainder to the aggrieved employees.
This structure makes PAGA fundamentally different from a private damages lawsuit. The employee is not primarily seeking personal compensation; the employee is enforcing public law on behalf of the state. That public character is the throughline connecting Iskanian's anti-waiver holding, the FAA-preemption analysis, and the later standing disputes.
The Arbitration Battlefield After Viking River
Following Viking River Cruises, Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639, the practical litigation sequence in many PAGA cases became predictable. The employer moves to compel arbitration of the plaintiff's individual PAGA claim under the parties' arbitration agreement and the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq. The court, if the agreement is valid, sends the individual claim to arbitration and stays the representative claim. The parties then litigate whether the representative claim survives.
The Viking River majority predicted that the plaintiff would lose standing to pursue the representative claim once the individual claim left for arbitration. But because PAGA standing is a matter of California statutory interpretation, the California courts — not the federal high court — have the final say. California has concluded that a plaintiff remains an aggrieved employee with standing to pursue the non-individual claims notwithstanding arbitration of the individual claim. The representative action therefore generally proceeds in court while the individual claim is arbitrated.
What Counts as an Aggrieved Employee
Standing under Labor Code § 2699 turns on being an “aggrieved employee” — a person employed by the alleged violator against whom one or more of the alleged Labor Code violations was committed. The plaintiff need not have personally suffered every violation asserted in the representative action; suffering at least one Labor Code violation by the employer is enough to confer standing to seek penalties for violations suffered by other employees. This broad standing concept is central to PAGA's enforcement reach and is why a single affected worker can anchor a workforce-wide penalty action.
It is also why employers cannot easily pick off a PAGA plaintiff by settling or mooting the individual claim. The representative claim belongs, in substance, to the state, and the plaintiff prosecutes it as the state's proxy.
Severability and Drafting After Iskanian
Many arbitration agreements contain a “representative action waiver” stating the employee gives up any right to bring a representative PAGA claim. Under Iskanian v. CLS Transportation Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal.4th 348, that waiver is unenforceable. Whether the rest of the agreement survives depends on the agreement's severability clause and whether the waiver was a non-severable, essential term. A well-drafted agreement typically includes a severability provision so that striking the unlawful representative waiver does not void the entire arbitration clause, allowing the individual PAGA claim to be compelled to arbitration while the representative claim proceeds in court.
Agreements that make the representative waiver non-severable — providing that if the waiver is unenforceable the whole arbitration provision falls — can backfire on employers, leaving the entire case, individual and representative, in court. This drafting nuance is why California-specific review of arbitration agreements matters.
How PAGA Compares to a Class Action
A class action and a PAGA action are often confused but operate very differently. A class action aggregates the individual damages claims of many employees and requires class certification, notice to absent class members, and an opt-out mechanism. A PAGA action seeks civil penalties on behalf of the state under Labor Code § 2699, requires no class certification, and binds the state as the real party in interest. A single lawsuit can include both a class action for damages and a PAGA claim for penalties, but they are governed by distinct rules. For how courts handle the trial of a large representative PAGA group without a certification step, see our analysis of PAGA manageability after Estrada.
The absence of a certification stage is a double-edged sword: it streamlines the path to the merits, but it also removed the stage at which employers once hoped to raise manageability as a gatekeeping objection — an avenue the California Supreme Court has since foreclosed.
Practical Timeline of a PAGA Case
A PAGA matter typically unfolds in a predictable sequence, and understanding it helps workers preserve their rights. First comes the written notice to the employer and the Labor and Workforce Development Agency under Labor Code § 2699.3, identifying the specific Labor Code provisions allegedly violated and the facts supporting the claim, accompanied by the required filing fee. The agency then has a statutory window to decide whether to investigate; if it declines or stays silent past the period, the aggrieved employee may file suit. Because PAGA penalties are generally governed by a one-year limitations period, the notice must be sent while the claim is still timely, which is why early evaluation matters.
Once filed, the employer will often move to compel arbitration of the individual PAGA claim under the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq., relying on Viking River Cruises, Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639. The court decides the validity of the arbitration agreement and, if valid, sends the individual claim to arbitration while the representative claim — which survives under Iskanian v. CLS Transportation Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal.4th 348 — proceeds in court, typically on the same Labor Code § 2699 penalty theories. The representative action then moves toward a merits determination of whether violations occurred and how many penalties are due. Throughout, the state remains the real party in interest, which is the reason the pre-dispute waiver could not bargain the claim away in the first place.
Why PAGA Penalties Can Be Substantial
The financial power of a PAGA action comes from how penalties accrue. Under Labor Code § 2699, civil penalties attach on a per-employee, per-pay-period basis for many Labor Code violations, with a default structure providing one amount for an initial violation and a larger amount for each subsequent violation in a pay period. Because a mid-sized employer may issue many pay periods to many employees each year, a systemic violation — a defective wage statement, an unpaid overtime formula, a meal-period practice that denies breaks — can generate penalties that dwarf the individual wages at stake. That leverage is exactly why employers sought to waive representative PAGA actions in arbitration agreements, and exactly why Iskanian v. CLS Transportation Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal.4th 348 refused to let them.
The penalties are shared: the larger portion is paid to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and the remainder to the aggrieved employees, reflecting PAGA's public-enforcement character. A prevailing employee also recovers attorney's fees and costs, which makes it feasible to pursue claims that no individual worker could afford to litigate for personal damages alone. The combination of aggregate penalties, the state's stake, and fee-shifting is what gives the Act its deterrent force, and it is the reason a court evaluating a waiver treats the right as belonging, in substance, to the state rather than to the individual worker who may be bound by an arbitration clause.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did I give up my PAGA rights by signing an arbitration agreement?
Not your representative PAGA rights. Under Iskanian v. CLS Transportation Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal.4th 348, a pre-dispute waiver of the representative PAGA action is unenforceable. You may have to arbitrate your individual PAGA claim after Viking River, but the representative claim generally survives.
What is the difference between an individual and a representative PAGA claim?
The individual claim seeks penalties for violations you personally suffered; the representative (non-individual) claim seeks penalties for violations suffered by other aggrieved employees. Viking River Cruises, Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639 allows arbitration of the individual component while leaving the representative claim intact.
Do I have to notify the state before filing a PAGA case?
Yes. Under Labor Code § 2699.3, you must give written notice to the employer and the LWDA identifying the violated provisions and supporting facts, and pay the filing fee, before proceeding. This step cannot be waived by an arbitration agreement.
Can arbitrating my individual claim destroy the representative claim?
Generally no. Although Viking River suggested a loss of standing, California law determines PAGA standing, and an employee who was employed by the violator and suffered a Labor Code violation generally retains standing under Labor Code § 2699 to pursue the representative claim in court.
How long do I have to bring a PAGA claim?
PAGA penalty claims are generally subject to a one-year limitations period, coordinated with the mandatory LWDA notice process. Because timing and exhaustion interact, you should consult counsel quickly to preserve the claim.
Speak With a California PAGA Attorney
If your employer violated the Labor Code and you want to understand your rights under PAGA and your arbitration agreement, Trembach Law Firm can evaluate your claim and the notice steps required. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301