MEDICAL MALPRACTICE | 2026-11-13

Periodic Payment of Future Damages in California Medical Malpractice Cases: How Code of Civil Procedure § 667.7 Changes What a Verdict Actually Pays

How MICRA’s periodic payment statute works, why future damages of $250,000 or more can be paid over time rather than in a lump sum, what happens if the injured person dies, and how it interacts with the noneconomic cap and attorney fees

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

A California medical malpractice jury may award millions of dollars for a lifetime of future medical care and lost earnings. But a catastrophically injured patient and their family are often surprised to learn that the money may not arrive as one check. Under the Medical Injury Compensation Reform...

Why Medical Malpractice Verdicts Are Paid Differently

Medical malpractice damages in California are governed by the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA), a set of statutes enacted in 1975 that apply specifically to actions for professional negligence against health care providers. MICRA changed several ordinary tort rules for this one category of case: it caps noneconomic damages, modifies the collateral-source rule, limits attorney fees, and — of central importance here — allows the future-damages portion of a judgment to be paid periodically rather than all at once. These rules do not apply to ordinary negligence cases; they are unique to claims against health care providers for professional negligence, which is why identifying whether a claim is a MICRA claim is the first analytical step. Our overview of California medical malpractice claims explains how these cases are evaluated from the outset.

The Periodic Payment Statute: Code of Civil Procedure § 667.7

The periodic payment rule lives in Code of Civil Procedure § 667.7. It provides that, in an action for professional negligence against a health care provider, at the request of either party the court shall enter a judgment ordering that future damages be paid in whole or in part by periodic payments rather than by a lump sum if the award equals or exceeds $250,000 in future damages. That threshold was $50,000 from 1975 until Assembly Bill 35 (2022) raised it to $250,000, effective January 1, 2023. "Future damages" includes damages for future medical treatment, care or custody, loss of future earnings, loss of bodily function, or future pain and suffering — the losses that will accrue after the judgment. Past damages are not subject to periodic payment, and if the future-damages award falls below the threshold, the statute does not apply. The statute makes the election available to either side; once it is requested and the threshold is met, the court must order periodic payment of the future damages in whole or in part.

What the Judgment Must Specify

When periodic payments are ordered, the judgment cannot simply state a number. Section 667.7 requires the court to make a specific finding as to the dollar amount of periodic payments that will compensate the plaintiff for the future damages, and the judgment must specify the recipient or recipients of the payments, the dollar amount of each payment, the interval between payments, and the number of payments or the period over which they will be made. The purpose is to match the stream of payments to the period during which the plaintiff’s future losses are expected to accrue — for example, aligning payments for future attendant care with the plaintiff’s life expectancy. This is why the way future damages are presented and itemized at trial matters: the jury’s findings on future losses become the raw material the court uses to structure the payment schedule. Once entered, the payment schedule may be modified only in the event of the plaintiff’s death.

The Constitutionality of Periodic Payments: American Bank & Trust

The periodic payment rule was challenged as a violation of equal protection and due process in the years after MICRA’s enactment, on the theory that it treated medical malpractice plaintiffs worse than other tort plaintiffs. The California Supreme Court rejected that challenge in American Bank & Trust Co. v. Community Hospital (1984) 36 Cal.3d 359, holding that Section 667.7 does not deny due process or equal protection and is rationally related to the Legislature’s goal of reducing medical malpractice insurance costs. The Court reasoned that periodic payments serve legitimate purposes: helping ensure that money paid to an injured plaintiff is actually available when the anticipated expenses or losses arise, and eliminating the so-called windfall to a plaintiff’s heirs when the plaintiff dies before the losses are incurred. To avoid a conflict with the right to jury trial, the Court also construed the statute to require the jury to designate the portion of its award attributable to future damages. American Bank & Trust remains the foundation of the rule’s validity.

What Happens If the Injured Person Dies

One of the most consequential features of Section 667.7 concerns death. If the judgment creditor — the injured plaintiff — dies before all periodic payments have been made, the statute permits the judgment to be modified, and the California Supreme Court has read it to mean that the defendant’s continuing liability for future damages other than loss of future earnings is subject to termination. In other words, the stream of payments compensating for future medical care and future pain and suffering can be cut off, because the need those payments were meant to serve has ended. Under Section 667.7(c), however, damages for the plaintiff’s loss of future earnings are not reduced or terminated by the death; they are paid to the persons to whom the plaintiff owed a duty of support immediately before death, so that surviving dependents are not deprived of the support the earnings would have provided. This allocation reflects the statute’s logic: care money follows the need for care, while lost-income money follows the dependents who relied on that income. For families, understanding this rule before trial is essential, because it directly affects the value of a periodic payment judgment compared to a lump sum.

Securing the Payment Stream

A judgment payable over decades is only as good as the assurance that the payments will actually be made. Section 667.7 addresses this by requiring, as a condition of authorizing periodic payments, that a judgment debtor who is not adequately insured post security adequate to assure full payment of the damages awarded; when all payment obligations end, any remaining security reverts to the judgment debtor. If the court finds that the judgment debtor has exhibited a continuing pattern of failing to make the scheduled payments, the statute directs the court to find the debtor in contempt and, in addition to the required periodic payments, to order the debtor to pay all damages caused by the failure, including court costs and attorney’s fees. For plaintiff’s counsel, obtaining adequate security is a critical step: a periodic payment judgment without an adequately insured or secured, enforceable payment stream exposes the client to the risk of a defendant’s future insolvency.

Interaction With the Noneconomic Damages Cap

Periodic payments operate alongside MICRA’s other features. The noneconomic damages cap in Civil Code § 3333.2 limits the total recoverable for pain, suffering, and other noneconomic harm; under the 2022 amendments to MICRA (Assembly Bill 35), that cap was raised from its longstanding $250,000 level. For cases filed or arbitrations demanded on or after January 1, 2023, the cap began at $350,000 in injury cases and $500,000 in wrongful death cases, and it increases each January 1 — by $40,000 a year toward $750,000 for injury and by $50,000 a year toward $1,000,000 for wrongful death — with 2 percent annual inflation adjustments beginning January 1, 2034. The amount in effect at the time of judgment, arbitration award, or settlement applies, and separate caps can apply to health care providers, health care institutions, and certain unaffiliated defendants. Future noneconomic damages that survive the cap can themselves be subject to periodic payment. The two rules work in sequence: the cap limits the amount of noneconomic damages, and the periodic payment statute governs how the future portion of what remains is paid out over time. Counsel must track both to understand a client’s true recovery.

Collateral Source and Attorney Fees

Two further MICRA rules shape the economics of a periodic payment judgment. The collateral-source rule is modified by Civil Code § 3333.1, which allows the defendant to introduce evidence of certain benefits the plaintiff received from other sources, such as health insurance or disability benefits; the plaintiff may then introduce evidence of amounts paid to secure those benefits, and the source of those benefits cannot recover against the plaintiff or be subrogated to the plaintiff’s rights. And attorney fees in MICRA cases are limited by Business and Professions Code § 6146. As amended by Assembly Bill 35, the contingency fee may not exceed 25 percent of the amount recovered if the case settles before a civil complaint or demand for arbitration is filed, or 33 percent if the recovery comes after filing, with the possibility of a higher fee in a tried or arbitrated case only on a motion showing good cause. When periodic payments are awarded under Section 667.7, the court places a total value on the payments based on the plaintiff’s projected life expectancy and includes that amount in the total award from which the fee is calculated. These provisions mean that the headline verdict number and the amount a plaintiff ultimately receives can diverge significantly, and clients deserve a clear explanation of the difference. A family that understands, before trial, how the cap, the collateral-source rule, the fee limits, and the periodic payment structure interact is far better positioned to make informed decisions about settlement and trial than one that learns of these rules only when the judgment is entered.

Strategic Implications for Both Sides

The periodic payment rule changes trial strategy. Because the death rule can sharply reduce the total paid on a periodic payment judgment, defendants may elect periodic payments in cases involving plaintiffs with shortened life expectancies, while plaintiffs may prefer a lump sum. The itemization of future damages by category — care, earnings, pain and suffering — becomes critical, because the categories are treated differently on death and in structuring the payment schedule. Both sides must present evidence of future losses with the periodic payment framework in mind, and both must be prepared to litigate the structure of the judgment after the verdict. The outcome of that post-verdict structuring can be as important to the client as the verdict itself.

Present Value, Discounting, and the Real Value of a Periodic Judgment

A lump-sum award of future damages is ordinarily reduced to present value — discounted to reflect that a dollar received today is worth more than a dollar received years from now. Periodic payments change this calculus. Because the payments are made over time as the losses accrue, the periodic payment structure handles the timing of the money differently than a discounted lump sum would. For the plaintiff, this means the headline future-damages figure and the economic value of what is actually received can diverge, and the divergence depends on the payment schedule, the duration, and the treatment of each category of future loss. A plaintiff deciding how to present future damages, and whether to resist a defense election of periodic payments, needs a clear-eyed analysis of these economics rather than a focus on the gross verdict number alone.

The interaction with life expectancy is especially important. Because payments for future care and future pain and suffering generally end on the plaintiff’s death, the expected duration of the payment stream — tied to the plaintiff’s projected life span — drives the real value of a periodic judgment. In a case involving a shortened life expectancy, a periodic payment structure can substantially reduce the total paid compared to a lump sum, which is one reason a defendant may seek it in such cases and why plaintiff’s counsel must weigh the structure carefully at the judgment stage.

Periodic Payments by Judgment Versus Structured Settlements

It is important to distinguish the periodic payments imposed by Section 667.7 at judgment from structured settlements that parties negotiate voluntarily. A structured settlement is a consensual arrangement, typically funded by an annuity, in which the parties agree that settlement proceeds will be paid over time — often for tax-planning or long-term-security reasons, and sometimes with terms the plaintiff finds advantageous, such as payments for a fixed period that continue to a beneficiary regardless of the plaintiff’s death. Section 667.7 periodic payments, by contrast, are imposed by the court at the election of a party after a verdict, and they carry the statutory death rule that can terminate future-care payments.

The practical significance is that a plaintiff has far more control over the terms of a negotiated structured settlement than over a court-ordered periodic payment judgment. In settlement, the plaintiff can bargain for fixed payment periods, beneficiaries, and payment schedules that fit the family’s needs. At judgment under Section 667.7, the structure is governed by the statute and the court’s order. This difference is one reason a catastrophic medical malpractice case may resolve by settlement with a negotiated structure rather than proceeding to a verdict and a statutory periodic payment judgment — the parties can craft terms that serve the injured person and the family more precisely than the statute allows.

Weighing Lump Sum Against Periodic Payment at Judgment

When a verdict comes in and a party elects periodic payments under Section 667.7, the plaintiff faces a set of trade-offs that should be understood before trial, not discovered afterward. A lump sum gives the plaintiff immediate control of the money, the ability to invest it, and certainty that the full future-care award belongs to the plaintiff and the estate regardless of how long the plaintiff lives. Periodic payments, by contrast, spread the money over time, tie it to the periods when losses accrue, and carry the statutory rule that future-care payments end at death. For a plaintiff with a normal life expectancy, a properly secured periodic payment stream may deliver the full value; for a plaintiff whose life is expected to be short, it may deliver substantially less than the gross award.

These trade-offs explain why the periodic payment election is contested after verdict and why the categories of future damages must be clearly established at trial. A plaintiff’s counsel — such as an experienced Los Angeles medical malpractice lawyer — who anticipates a defense election can shape the evidence — emphasizing the categories that survive death, such as loss of future earnings for dependents, and ensuring the record supports an adequate payment schedule and security. Counsel can also pursue settlement with a negotiated structure that avoids the statutory death rule. The periodic payment statute does not reduce the jury’s role in finding the damages, but it transforms what those findings are worth, and a family deserves to understand that transformation before the verdict is ever returned.

Related Guides

For related reading, see our California medical malpractice practice and the latest personal injury news.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a periodic payment judgment?

It is a medical malpractice judgment in which the future-damages portion is paid in installments over time rather than as a single lump sum. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 667.7, either party may request it, and when the future-damages award equals or exceeds $250,000 (the threshold since January 1, 2023; it was previously $50,000), the court must order that the future damages be paid in whole or in part by periodic payments.

Does this apply to all injury cases?

No. Section 667.7 is part of MICRA and applies only to actions for professional negligence against health care providers. Section 667.7 does not apply to ordinary negligence cases.

Which damages are paid periodically?

Only future damages — future medical treatment and care, future lost earnings, loss of bodily function, future pain and suffering, and similar losses that accrue after judgment — and only when the future-damages award equals or exceeds $250,000. Past damages are not paid periodically, and the court may order the future damages paid periodically in whole or in part.

What happens to the payments if the injured person dies?

The judgment may be modified on the plaintiff’s death, and the defendant’s continuing liability for future damages other than loss of future earnings is subject to termination, because the need for future care ends. Damages for loss of future earnings are not reduced or terminated; they are paid to the persons to whom the plaintiff owed a duty of support.

Is the periodic payment rule constitutional?

Yes. In American Bank & Trust Co. v. Community Hospital (1984) 36 Cal.3d 359, the California Supreme Court held that Section 667.7 does not violate due process or equal protection, reasoning that it rationally serves legitimate goals, including helping ensure future-care funds are available when needed and eliminating a windfall to heirs if the plaintiff dies early.

How is the plaintiff protected if the defendant stops paying?

A judgment debtor who is not adequately insured must post security adequate to assure full payment. If the debtor shows a continuing pattern of failing to pay, the court must find the debtor in contempt and order it to pay the damages caused by the failure, including court costs and attorney’s fees. Securing the payment stream is a key task for plaintiff’s counsel.

How does the noneconomic cap interact with periodic payments?

Civil Code § 3333.2 caps noneconomic damages; under the 2022 MICRA amendments the cap started at $350,000 for injury and $500,000 for wrongful death in cases filed on or after January 1, 2023, and rises each year. The cap limits the amount; the periodic payment statute then governs how the future portion of what remains is paid over time. Both rules apply in sequence.

Are attorney fees affected?

Yes. Business and Professions Code § 6146 limits MICRA contingency fees to 25 percent of a recovery obtained by settlement before a complaint or arbitration demand is filed and 33 percent after filing, and in a periodic payment judgment the court values the payments based on the plaintiff’s projected life expectancy for purposes of computing the fee. The headline verdict and the client’s net recovery can differ significantly.

Speak With a California Medical Malpractice Attorney

If you or a family member was seriously harmed by medical negligence, Trembach Law Firm can pursue the compensation the law allows and work to see that the future-damages portion of any judgment is properly structured and secured over the long term. We explain exactly how periodic payments, the noneconomic cap, and attorney-fee rules affect what you actually receive. For a free consultation, call (213) 645-2246. We handle California medical malpractice cases on a contingency basis. From the start we build the case with the periodic payment framework in mind — itemizing future care, future earnings, and future pain and suffering so that the record supports both an adequate payment schedule and the security that backs it — and we counsel families candidly on how a court-ordered periodic payment judgment compares to a negotiated structured settlement, so the choice that governs decades of a loved one’s care is made with full understanding.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301