SEVERANCE & RELEASES | 2026-11-01

Silenced No More Act in California: Non-Disparagement and SB 331 Explained (2026)

California bars severance and settlement terms that stop you from speaking out about unlawful workplace conduct, and employers must include specific carve-out language.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

For years, employers used non-disparagement and confidentiality clauses in severance and settlement agreements to buy the silence of departing workers, including workers who had experienced harassment or discrimination. California moved decisively against that practice. Today, if a severance or sett

Why California Restricted Silence Clauses

In the wake of widespread reporting on how confidential settlements concealed patterns of workplace harassment, California lawmakers concluded that silence provisions were enabling repeat misconduct. A worker who settled a harassment claim and signed a broad confidentiality or non-disparagement clause could be barred from warning coworkers or the public about the perpetrator. The Legislature decided that the public interest in exposing unlawful workplace conduct outweighs an employer's interest in buying silence. A series of statutes followed, culminating in the expansion known as the Silenced No More Act.

The result is a framework that sharply limits what an employer can require a departing or settling employee to keep secret. The rules apply to both negotiated severance agreements and to settlement agreements resolving employment disputes, and they reach non-disparagement clauses, confidentiality clauses, and related provisions that would restrain protected disclosures.

The Silenced No More Act and Government Code Section 12964.5

The Silenced No More Act, enacted through Senate Bill 331, amended Government Code § 12964.5, which sits within the Fair Employment and Housing Act. The statute makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer to require an employee, in exchange for a raise, bonus, or as a condition of employment or continued employment, to sign a non-disparagement or other agreement that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose information about unlawful acts in the workplace.

Critically, the earlier version of the law focused on sex-based harassment and discrimination. The Silenced No More Act broadened the scope to cover disclosures about all forms of unlawful workplace conduct, including harassment and discrimination based on any protected characteristic, not just sex. This expansion is the heart of the reform. A worker can now speak about unlawful conduct regardless of the protected class involved.

The Required Carve-Out Language

Government Code § 12964.5 does more than prohibit overbroad silence clauses. When an agreement that restrains the disclosure of information related to conditions in the workplace contains a non-disparagement or similar provision, the agreement must include specific language making clear that the employee retains the right to disclose unlawful conduct. The statute requires substantially the following statement: nothing in the agreement prevents the employee from discussing or disclosing information about unlawful acts in the workplace, such as harassment or discrimination or any other conduct the employee has reason to believe is unlawful.

If that carve-out is missing, the non-disparagement or confidentiality provision is unenforceable to the extent it purports to restrain protected disclosures, and the omission can expose the employer to liability. For employees, this means you should look for the carve-out in any severance or settlement document and understand that even without it, you retain the right to speak about unlawful conduct. Employers, in turn, must build the carve-out into their template agreements to keep them enforceable.

What You Can Still Be Required to Keep Confidential

The statutes do not abolish confidentiality entirely. An employer may still protect legitimate trade secrets, proprietary information, and confidential business information through properly drafted provisions. The settlement amount itself may generally remain confidential in many circumstances. And a separate provision commonly permits the parties to keep the claimant's identity and the facts that could reveal it confidential at the claimant's request. The line the law draws is between protecting genuine confidential business information and the claimant's chosen privacy, on the one hand, and silencing disclosure of unlawful conduct, on the other.

This distinction matters in drafting. A clause that broadly prohibits disparaging the employer or disclosing the facts of the dispute will likely run afoul of the law if it sweeps in unlawful conduct. A narrower clause that protects trade secrets and the settlement sum, paired with the required carve-out, is far more defensible.

Code of Civil Procedure Section 1001 and Settlement Confidentiality

A companion statute, Code Civ. Proc. § 1001, addresses confidentiality in settlement agreements for certain claims filed in a civil action or administrative action. It prohibits provisions that prevent the disclosure of factual information related to claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, failure to prevent such harassment or discrimination, and retaliation for reporting it. Under § 1001, a provision in a settlement agreement that attempts to bar disclosure of that factual information is void as a matter of law and against public policy.

Section 1001 preserves the claimant's ability to keep the claimant's own identity confidential, and in many cases allows the settlement amount to remain private. The statute reflects the same policy judgment as the Silenced No More Act: the facts underlying unlawful conduct should not be buried by a settlement. Together, Government Code § 12964.5 and Code Civ. Proc. § 1001 form a two-part shield, one aimed at severance and employment agreements, the other at settlements of filed claims. For a related look at how California protects workers who come forward, see our discussion of the California False Claims Act and whistleblower protections.

How These Rules Affect Severance Negotiations

When you are presented with a severance agreement, the non-disparagement and confidentiality terms deserve close scrutiny. A departing employee should confirm that the agreement contains the required disclosure carve-out and that no clause purports to prevent reporting unlawful conduct to a government agency or participating in an investigation. Many agreements also need to preserve the employee's right to communicate with the Civil Rights Department, the Labor Commissioner, and federal agencies. A provision that chills those communications is problematic.

Employees should also pay attention to the consideration being offered. Severance is a negotiation, and understanding that unlawful silence clauses are unenforceable can shift leverage. You do not have to trade away your right to speak about unlawful conduct, because the law does not permit the employer to demand it in the first place. Negotiating from that baseline is very different from negotiating as if silence were the price of severance.

Remedies and Consequences for Violations

Because § 12964.5 is part of the Fair Employment and Housing Act, requiring or maintaining a prohibited provision can constitute an unlawful employment practice, exposing the employer to the remedies available under that Act. Under Code Civ. Proc. § 1001, a prohibited settlement provision is void and unenforceable, so an employer cannot use it to silence the claimant or to claw back consideration. These consequences give the statutes real teeth and change the calculus for employers who might otherwise paper over misconduct with aggressive confidentiality terms.

Practical Checklist Before You Sign

First, read every non-disparagement and confidentiality provision slowly and ask whether it would stop you from describing conduct you believe was unlawful. Second, confirm the required carve-out language is present. Third, make sure nothing bars you from reporting to or cooperating with a government agency. Fourth, separate legitimate confidentiality, such as trade secrets and your own privacy, from unlawful silence. Fifth, get the agreement reviewed before you sign, because once signed, unwinding a bad deal is far harder than fixing the language up front. For ongoing coverage of California workplace law, visit our employment law news page.

The Broader Family of California Silence Statutes

The Silenced No More Act did not appear in isolation. It is the culmination of a series of California reforms aimed at preventing confidentiality from concealing unlawful workplace conduct. Earlier legislation limited confidentiality in settlements of sex-based harassment and discrimination claims, and Code Civ. Proc. § 1001 codified those limits for filed claims. Government Code § 12964.5 then extended the principle from settlements of filed claims to the broader universe of severance and employment agreements, and the Silenced No More Act expanded the covered subject matter from sex-based conduct to all forms of unlawful workplace conduct. Understanding this progression helps workers and employers see that the carve-out requirement is part of a consistent and deepening policy, not a one-off rule.

Because these statutes overlap, a single separation can implicate more than one of them. A negotiated severance agreement is governed by § 12964.5, while a settlement of a harassment or discrimination claim that has been filed in court or with an agency is governed by Code Civ. Proc. § 1001. Many separations involve both a severance payment and the release of potential claims, so both statutes can apply to the same document. Analyzing which rules govern which provisions is a key part of reviewing any separation package.

Separation Agreements and the Review Period

Beyond the silence rules, California and federal law give departing employees time to consider a release before signing. When a severance agreement asks an older worker to release age-discrimination claims, federal law requires that the worker receive a written agreement in understandable language, be advised in writing to consult an attorney, and be given a defined period to consider the agreement and a period after signing to revoke it. These review and revocation protections operate alongside the California silence rules, so a worker should never feel pressured to sign a severance agreement on the spot. Use the review period to have the document examined for unlawful silence clauses and missing carve-outs.

A worker who is rushed, who is told the offer expires immediately, or who is discouraged from consulting a lawyer should treat those pressure tactics as red flags. A properly drafted California severance agreement will include the required disclosure carve-out, will preserve the right to communicate with government agencies, and will give the worker a genuine opportunity to review the terms with counsel. The absence of any of these features is a reason to slow down, not to speed up.

Drafting Compliant Agreements: An Employer's Perspective

Employers are not left guessing about how to comply. A compliant severance or settlement agreement separates legitimate confidentiality from unlawful silence. It protects genuine trade secrets, proprietary information, and the employer's confidential business information through narrowly tailored clauses. It permits the parties to keep the settlement amount confidential where the law allows and to protect the claimant's identity at the claimant's request. And it includes the disclosure carve-out required by Government Code § 12964.5, making clear that nothing in the agreement prevents the employee from discussing or disclosing unlawful acts in the workplace.

Employers should audit their template agreements, because a form that predates the Silenced No More Act almost certainly lacks the required language and the expanded scope. Maintaining or presenting a non-compliant agreement is itself an unlawful employment practice under the Fair Employment and Housing Act, so the cost of outdated templates is not merely unenforceability but potential liability. Updating templates, training human-resources staff, and routing separation documents through counsel are the practical steps that keep an employer on the right side of the line.

Interaction With the Right to Report to Government Agencies

No severance or settlement agreement can lawfully prevent a worker from reporting possible violations to, or cooperating with, a government agency. A California worker retains the right to file a charge with the Civil Rights Department, to file a claim with the Labor Commissioner, and to communicate with federal agencies. A confidentiality or non-disparagement clause that purports to bar those communications is unenforceable to that extent, and such a clause can independently support a claim that the employer engaged in an unlawful practice. When reviewing an agreement, confirm that it expressly preserves these rights or at least does not purport to restrict them.

This protection matters because enforcement of the labor and anti-discrimination laws depends on workers being able to report what they experienced. If severance agreements could buy silence toward the agencies themselves, the entire enforcement system would be undermined. California law therefore treats the right to report and cooperate as something an employer cannot purchase through a release, no matter how much consideration is offered.

Real-World Examples of Unlawful and Lawful Clauses

Concrete examples help illustrate where the line falls. A clause stating that the employee agrees never to make any statement that disparages the company or its officers, with no carve-out, is unlawful under Government Code § 12964.5 to the extent it would prevent the employee from disclosing unlawful acts in the workplace. A clause stating that the employee will keep confidential all information about the dispute, again with no carve-out, is likewise problematic when the dispute involves harassment or discrimination. These broad, unqualified silence provisions are exactly what the Silenced No More Act and Code Civ. Proc. § 1001 were enacted to prohibit.

By contrast, a clause is far more defensible when it is narrowly drawn and paired with the required disclosure language. For example, a provision that protects the employer's trade secrets and proprietary business information, keeps the settlement sum confidential, and protects the claimant's identity at the claimant's request, while expressly stating that nothing in the agreement prevents the employee from discussing or disclosing unlawful acts in the workplace such as harassment or discrimination, respects both the employer's legitimate interests and the worker's protected rights. The difference between the unlawful and the lawful version is not subtle: it is the presence of the carve-out and the narrowing of confidentiality to genuinely protectable information.

For workers reviewing a proposed agreement, these examples provide a practical test. Ask whether any clause, read literally, would stop you from telling the truth about conduct you believe was unlawful. If so, that clause is likely unenforceable to that extent, and its presence without the required carve-out may itself violate the law. For employers, the examples point to a straightforward fix: narrow the confidentiality, add the carve-out, and preserve the right to report to government agencies. Doing so transforms a liability-creating agreement into a compliant one.

What to Do If You Suspect Your Agreement Is Unlawful

If you already signed a severance or settlement agreement and now suspect it contains an unlawful silence clause, do not assume you are bound to stay silent about unlawful conduct. A non-disparagement or confidentiality provision that purports to restrain protected disclosures is unenforceable to that extent under Government Code § 12964.5, and under Code Civ. Proc. § 1001 a prohibited provision in a settlement of a filed harassment or discrimination claim is void against public policy. That said, agreements vary, and some clauses may be valid in part, so you should have the specific document reviewed before you act.

If you are still negotiating, use the law as leverage. Insist that the agreement include the required disclosure carve-out, that confidentiality be narrowed to genuine trade secrets and your own privacy, and that nothing bar you from reporting to or cooperating with government agencies. Because the law already forbids the employer from demanding unlawful silence, you are not giving anything up by holding the agreement to the standard the Legislature set. A careful review before signing is far easier than unwinding a problematic agreement later.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my employer stop me from talking about harassment I experienced?

Generally no. Under the Silenced No More Act and Government Code § 12964.5, an employer cannot require you to sign a non-disparagement or confidentiality agreement that prevents you from disclosing information about unlawful acts in the workplace, including harassment and discrimination based on any protected characteristic.

What carve-out language must a severance agreement include?

When an agreement restrains disclosure of workplace conditions, it must include language stating that nothing in the agreement prevents you from discussing or disclosing information about unlawful acts in the workplace, such as harassment, discrimination, or other conduct you have reason to believe is unlawful. Without it, the silence provision is unenforceable as to protected disclosures.

Can the settlement amount still be kept confidential?

In many situations yes. The statutes target disclosure of the facts of unlawful conduct, not necessarily the dollar figure. Both Government Code § 12964.5 and Code Civ. Proc. § 1001 preserve the claimant's ability to keep the claimant's identity private, and the settlement sum may often remain confidential.

What does Code of Civil Procedure section 1001 add?

Section 1001 voids provisions in settlement agreements for filed claims that prevent disclosure of factual information about sexual assault, sexual harassment, and harassment or discrimination based on sex, and related retaliation. Such provisions are void as against public policy.

What if I already signed an agreement with an unlawful clause?

An unlawful non-disparagement or confidentiality clause is unenforceable to the extent it restrains protected disclosures, so it generally cannot be used to silence you about unlawful conduct even after signing. You should still get legal advice before acting, because the specifics of your agreement matter.

Review Your Severance Before You Sign

Silence should never be the price of severance in California. Trembach Law Firm reviews and negotiates severance and settlement agreements, strikes unlawful silence clauses, and protects your right to speak about unlawful conduct. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation before you sign anything.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301