WAGE & HOUR | 2026-11-02
Unlimited PTO and Vested Vacation After McPherson: California 2026
An unlimited vacation policy that is not truly unlimited can still create vested vacation payable at termination under California law.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
Unlimited paid time off sounds like it ends vacation payouts, but in California it can do the opposite. In McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation the Court of Appeal held that an unlimited policy that is not truly unlimited can still create vested vacation that must be paid at termination, because
The Promise And Peril Of Unlimited Vacation
Unlimited paid time off is marketed as a modern benefit that frees employees from counting days and spares employers from tracking accruals. In California the arrangement carries a legal trap that many employers do not see coming. If an unlimited policy is not truly unlimited, a departing employee may be owed a payout for vacation the law treats as vested, even though the policy said nothing ever accrued. The Court of Appeal exposed this risk in McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation, Inc. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 243.
The reason unlimited policies are dangerous in California is that vacation here is not a gratuity the employer can give and take away. Vacation is a form of deferred wages, earned as the employee works, and California law forbids forfeiture of wages already earned. An unlimited policy that functions like a capped policy in disguise does not escape that rule; it simply obscures how much vacation the employee actually earned.
Vacation Is Vested Wages: Suastez v. Plastic Dress-Up
The foundational case is Suastez v. Plastic Dress-Up Co. (1982) 31 Cal.3d 774. The California Supreme Court held that paid vacation is a form of deferred compensation that vests as the employee renders service, in the same way wages are earned. Once vested, vacation pay cannot be forfeited. The Court reasoned that vacation is not a gift but part of the compensation the employee labors to earn, so denying it at separation would be no different from withholding earned wages.
That principle is why California employers cannot impose use-it-or-lose-it vacation policies. Because the vacation is already earned, a rule that wipes it out at year-end or at termination strips the employee of a vested wage. Employers may cap total accrual at a reasonable ceiling so that no more vacation accrues until some is used, but they cannot eliminate vacation that has already vested.
Labor Code § 227.3: No Forfeiture At Separation
The statute that codifies the no-forfeiture rule is Labor Code § 227.3. It provides that when an employment contract or employer policy provides for paid vacation, and an employee is terminated without having taken off vested vacation time, all vested vacation must be paid as wages at the employee's final rate of pay. The statute makes clear that forfeiture of vested vacation is contrary to public policy, which is why use-it-or-lose-it provisions are void in California.
Section 227.3 is the mechanism that converts vested vacation into a final-pay obligation. If a departing worker has vested vacation on the books, it must be paid out at separation, and if it is not, the failure can trigger the waiting-time penalty structure. For how unpaid final-wage items generate penalties, see our discussion of waiting-time penalties and the good-faith dispute defense under Labor Code § 203.
What McPherson Held About Unlimited Policies
In McPherson the employer told a group of employees they had no fixed number of vacation days and were simply expected to take time as needed. In practice, however, the employees worked long hours, the expectation was that they would take only a few weeks, and the policy was never clearly communicated as genuinely unlimited. The Court of Appeal held that this so-called unlimited policy was not truly unlimited and functioned as an implied accrual of a fixed amount of vacation. Because vacation had effectively vested, the employer owed a payout at separation under § 227.3.
Critically, the court did not hold that every unlimited policy triggers a payout. It held that this policy, which was undefined, uncommunicated, and administered with an implied cap and an expectation of limited use, functioned as a traditional accrual policy and therefore produced vested vacation. The decision turned on the gap between what the policy claimed and how it actually operated.
The Factors That Make An Unlimited Policy Fail
Reading McPherson together with Suastez, several factors push an unlimited policy toward being treated as a disguised accrual plan. First, the policy is not clearly spelled out in writing as genuinely unlimited. Second, in practice there is an undisclosed ceiling, an expectation that employees take only a certain amount. Third, employees who take too much are discouraged or penalized, so the policy is not truly unlimited after all. Fourth, the workload makes it impractical for employees to take meaningful time, so the unlimited label is illusory. When these factors combine, a court can find that the policy produced an implied vested benefit.
How To Draft A Genuinely Unlimited Policy
The McPherson court suggested, and later guidance has reinforced, that a genuinely unlimited policy can avoid a payout obligation if it is designed carefully. The policy should state in writing and in clear terms that time off is not earned or accrued, that there is no bank of hours, and that employees are free to take reasonable time off subject to business needs. The employer should communicate the policy consistently, apply it uniformly, allow employees to actually take substantial time without penalty, and spell out that unused time has no cash value because nothing was ever accrued. Where the policy truly operates that way, there is no vested vacation to pay out at separation.
The danger lies in the gap between words and practice. An employer that labels a policy unlimited but runs it like a three-week plan will be treated as having a three-week accrual plan, and the vested vacation must be paid. Employers tracking developments in this area can follow our California employment law news page.
Calculating The Payout And Final Rate Of Pay
When vested vacation must be paid, Labor Code § 227.3 requires payment at the employee's final rate of pay, not the rate in effect when the vacation was earned. For a worker whose pay rose over time, that means the oldest vacation is cashed out at the highest, most recent rate. The payout is part of final wages and is due on the same § 201 or § 202 timeline as the rest of the final paycheck, which is why a delayed vacation payout can itself start the waiting-time penalty clock.
Remedies When A Payout Is Denied
An employee denied a vacation payout can recover the unpaid vacation as wages, interest, and, if the failure was willful and without a good-faith dispute, the Labor Code § 203 waiting-time penalty of up to thirty days of pay. Because unpaid vacation is a wage, it can also support an unfair-competition claim under Business and Professions Code § 17200 reaching back four years, and representative penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act. The breadth of these remedies is why misclassified unlimited policies create such large exposure across a workforce.
Practical Guidance For Employees
Workers under an unlimited policy should save the written policy, any emails describing how much time they were expected to take, and records of time actually taken or denied. If the practice reveals an implied cap or discouraged real time off, the policy may not be genuinely unlimited, and vested vacation may be owed at separation under McPherson. Because vacation is a wage, the same deadlines and penalties that apply to other final wages apply here, and workers should act before the limitations period runs.
Accrual Caps Versus Forfeiture: The Line California Draws
It is important to separate two concepts that sound similar but are treated very differently. A reasonable accrual cap is lawful. An employer may provide that once a worker banks a certain amount of vacation, no further vacation accrues until the worker uses some, which simply pauses earning without destroying anything already earned. Forfeiture is different and unlawful. A rule that erases vacation the worker already earned, whether at year-end or at separation, takes a vested wage and is void under Labor Code § 227.3 and the reasoning of Suastez v. Plastic Dress-Up Co. (1982) 31 Cal.3d 774. The distinction explains why employers may slow accrual but can never claw it back.
In the unlimited-policy context, the danger is that an implied cap operates like an accrual plan with a hidden ceiling. If employees in practice bank the equivalent of three weeks and are discouraged from taking more, a court may treat the arrangement as a three-week accrual plan, and the three weeks become vested and nonforfeitable. The McPherson decision is essentially an application of this principle to a policy dressed up as unlimited.
How Courts Decide If A Policy Is Truly Unlimited
Courts look past the label to the operation of the policy. They examine whether the policy was clearly communicated in writing as providing no accrual, whether employees were in fact free to take substantial time without adverse consequences, whether the employer tracked or limited time in a way that implied a ceiling, and whether the workload left any realistic opportunity to take unlimited time. A policy that passes all of these tests may genuinely avoid a payout obligation, because there is no accrued, vested benefit to pay. A policy that fails them, as in McPherson, will be treated as a disguised accrual plan with a vested payout due under Labor Code § 227.3.
Because the analysis is fact-specific, two employers with identical written policies can reach different outcomes based on how they actually administer the benefit. This is why documentation of real usage patterns matters so much, both for employers seeking to defend a policy and for employees seeking to prove an implied cap.
Sick Leave And PTO Combined Policies
Many employers combine vacation and sick leave into a single paid-time-off bank. This creates a wrinkle, because California paid sick leave under the Healthy Workplaces, Healthy Families Act is generally not payable at termination, while vacation is. When an employer lumps the two together into one PTO bank with no allocation, California treats the entire bank as vacation for payout purposes, meaning the whole balance becomes vested wages payable at separation. Employers who want to preserve the non-payout nature of sick leave must keep it in a separate, clearly designated bank rather than folding it into general PTO, or they risk converting their sick-leave liability into a vacation payout obligation.
Exposure Across A Workforce
The reason misclassified unlimited policies alarm employers is the scale of the exposure. If a policy that was supposed to eliminate payouts is instead found to create vested vacation, every employee who separated within the limitations period may be owed a payout at their final rate, plus interest, plus potential Labor Code § 203 waiting-time penalties and Business and Professions Code § 17200 restitution reaching back four years, plus representative penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act. A policy adopted to simplify administration can become a classwide liability. The safest course for an employer uncertain about its policy is to audit how the policy actually operates and, if it functions like an accrual plan, to account for the vested benefit rather than discover it in litigation.
Converting A Traditional Policy To Unlimited
Employers that already have a traditional accrual plan and wish to switch to a genuinely unlimited policy face a special problem: the vacation employees already accrued under the old plan is vested and cannot be erased by the change. Under Suastez and Labor Code § 227.3, the accrued balance at the moment of conversion is a vested wage. An employer that announces a new unlimited policy and simultaneously zeroes out existing balances commits an unlawful forfeiture. The correct approach is to freeze and pay out, or carry as a protected balance, the vacation accrued under the old plan, and apply the new unlimited approach only going forward. Employees who find their accrued balances wiped out at the moment of a policy change should recognize that the vested portion remains owed despite the new label.
Evidence That Decides These Cases
Because the outcome depends on how a policy operates in practice, the evidence that decides unlimited-vacation cases is usually documentary and behavioral. Written policy language, onboarding materials, and handbook provisions establish what the employer said. Email and messaging records about how much time employees could take, and any approvals or denials of requests, establish how the policy actually worked. Payroll and scheduling data show whether employees were realistically able to take substantial time. Comparisons among employees can reveal an unspoken norm of a few weeks a year, which is the hallmark of an implied cap. Both employers defending a policy and employees challenging one should preserve these records early, because they are the proof on which a court decides whether the policy was truly unlimited or an accrual plan in disguise under McPherson.
Deadlines For Bringing A Vacation Claim
A claim for unpaid vested vacation is a wage claim, so the limitations periods that govern wage claims apply. A worker generally has three years to sue for the unpaid vacation itself, and up to four years when the claim is brought as an unfair-competition action under Business and Professions Code § 17200. If the failure to pay out vested vacation was willful and not supported by a genuine good-faith dispute, the Labor Code § 203 waiting-time penalty may add up to thirty days of pay. Because the payout is due on the final-pay timeline under Labor Code § 201 or Labor Code § 202, the clock on the penalty starts at separation, not when the worker later discovers the law. Workers who suspect their unlimited policy was really a capped plan should seek advice promptly, both to preserve the oldest portions of the claim and to assemble the usage evidence that decides these cases before it is lost.
Employers conducting a self-audit should remember that fixing a policy going forward does not extinguish liability for employees who already separated. If the policy operated as a disguised accrual plan, those former employees may still be owed payouts within the limitations period, and the cleanest resolution is often to calculate and pay what is owed rather than wait for a representative claim to surface the issue across the workforce.
Why California Is Different From Other States
Employers that operate in multiple states are often caught off guard by California vacation law, because many states permit use-it-or-lose-it policies and allow employers to decline any payout at separation. California does not. The combination of Suastez v. Plastic Dress-Up Co. (1982) 31 Cal.3d 774 and Labor Code § 227.3 makes vested vacation a nonforfeitable wage, and no handbook provision, out-of-state headquarters policy, or multistate uniform rule can override that for employees who work in California. A national employer that rolls out a single unlimited-PTO policy designed for jurisdictions that allow forfeiture may unwittingly create vested-vacation liability for its California workforce. The lesson is that vacation and PTO policies must be evaluated against California law specifically, not against a national template, and that the McPherson analysis of whether an unlimited policy is genuinely unlimited is a distinctly California inquiry that other states do not share.
For a worker, this means that a policy lawful where the company is headquartered may still owe a California payout. For an employer, it means a single policy applied nationwide is a trap unless it is tested against the California rules on vesting and forfeiture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does an unlimited vacation policy mean I get no payout when I leave?
Not necessarily. Under McPherson v. EF Intercultural Foundation, Inc. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 243, if the policy is not truly unlimited and operates like a capped accrual plan, you may be owed a payout for vested vacation under Labor Code § 227.3.
Why is vacation treated as wages in California?
Because Suastez v. Plastic Dress-Up Co. (1982) 31 Cal.3d 774 held that paid vacation is deferred compensation that vests as you work, so it cannot be forfeited.
Are use-it-or-lose-it vacation policies legal in California?
No. Labor Code § 227.3 bars forfeiture of vested vacation, so use-it-or-lose-it provisions are void. Employers may cap further accrual but cannot wipe out vacation already earned.
At what rate is my unused vacation paid out?
At your final rate of pay under Labor Code § 227.3, even for vacation earned when your pay was lower.
How can an employer design a truly unlimited policy?
By stating clearly in writing that no time is accrued or banked, communicating and applying the policy consistently, allowing employees to take substantial time without penalty, and confirming that unused time has no cash value because nothing vested.
Trembach Law Firm advises California employees and employers on vacation payouts, unlimited PTO policies, and vested-wage disputes under McPherson and Labor Code § 227.3. For a confidential consultation, call (213) 645-2246.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301