WAGE & HOUR | 2026-11-12

The Berman Hearing Wage Claim Process Under Labor Code 98 in California 2026

How California workers recover unpaid wages through the Labor Commissioner and what happens when an employer appeals.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

A Berman hearing under Labor Code 98 gives California workers a low-cost, informal way to recover unpaid wages through the Labor Commissioner instead of filing a lawsuit. This guide walks through how to file, what the Order, Decision, or Award means, the fifteen-day appeal window, the employer bond

What a Berman Hearing Is and Why It Exists

Most California workers who are owed wages cannot afford to file a lawsuit in superior court, wait two years for trial, and pay a lawyer along the way. The Legislature recognized that gap and created an administrative shortcut. Labor Code § 98 authorizes the Labor Commissioner, acting through the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, to hold an informal hearing to adjudicate an employee's wage claim. Practitioners call it a Berman hearing, after the legislator who sponsored the enabling statute.

The Berman hearing is designed to be fast, inexpensive, and accessible. There are no court filing fees, the rules of evidence are relaxed, and a worker can appear without a lawyer. A deputy Labor Commissioner acts as the hearing officer, takes testimony under oath, reviews documents, and issues a written decision. The whole proceeding is built to resolve ordinary wage disputes, unpaid overtime, missed final pay, bounced paychecks, unreimbursed losses, without the cost and delay of civil litigation.

What Claims Belong in a Berman Hearing

The Berman process handles claims for wages and related amounts an employee is owed. Typical claims include unpaid regular and overtime wages, minimum-wage shortfalls, unpaid final wages, waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203, meal and rest premiums, and penalties for noncompliant wage statements under Labor Code § 226. The common thread is that the claim arises from the employment relationship and seeks a sum of money the employer failed to pay.

Some disputes are a poor fit for the Berman process. Large class claims, complex misclassification questions involving many workers, and claims intertwined with discrimination or wrongful-termination theories often belong in court. But for an individual worker owed a discrete sum, the Berman hearing is frequently the most efficient path to a decision.

How the Claim Is Filed and Processed

A worker starts the process by filing an Initial Report or Claim with the Labor Commissioner, describing the wages owed and the period involved. The agency may first set a settlement conference, an informal meeting where a deputy tries to resolve the dispute by agreement. If the conference does not resolve the matter, the claim proceeds to a Berman hearing.

At the hearing, both sides present evidence. The employee testifies about hours worked and pay received; the employer responds with payroll records, time records, and its own witnesses. Because employers are required to keep accurate records, gaps in the employer's documentation often help the worker. The hearing officer weighs the evidence and issues an Order, Decision, or Award, commonly abbreviated ODA, stating who owes what.

The Order, Decision, or Award and the Right to Appeal

The ODA is the hearing officer's ruling. It is not the end of the road, because Labor Code § 98.2 gives either party the right to appeal. Under § 98.2(a), a party dissatisfied with the ODA may seek review by filing an appeal in the superior court within fifteen days after service of the decision. This appeal is not a traditional appellate review of the administrative record. Instead, it is a trial de novo, meaning the superior court hears the dispute fresh, as if the Berman hearing had never happened.

The short fifteen-day deadline is jurisdictional in practice, and a party that lets it pass loses the right to challenge the ODA. Once the appeal period expires without an appeal, the ODA can be entered as a judgment and enforced like any other judgment.

The Employer's Bond Requirement Under § 98.2(b)

The Legislature anticipated that employers might appeal simply to delay payment and wear down a worker. To prevent that, Labor Code § 98.2(b) requires an employer that appeals an ODA to post an undertaking, a bond or cash deposit, in the amount of the award. This security guarantees that if the worker ultimately prevails, the money is there to satisfy the judgment. An employer that fails to post the required undertaking can have its appeal dismissed. This requirement is a powerful equalizer, because it forces an appealing employer to put its money where its appeal is.

The Fee-Shifting Trap in § 98.2(c)

The most consequential feature of the Berman appeal is the one-way fee exposure in Labor Code § 98.2(c). When a party appeals the ODA to superior court and is unsuccessful in the appeal, that party must pay the other side's costs and reasonable attorney's fees. The statute defines unsuccessful in a way that strongly protects the worker: an appealing employer is unsuccessful unless it obtains a result more favorable than the ODA.

This asymmetry is deliberate. It discourages employers from appealing a modest award just to impose litigation costs on a worker. An employee who merely holds the line and defends the award can recover fees, while the employer that rolled the dice and failed to improve its position pays. The leading decisions on what counts as an unsuccessful appeal, including Smith v. Rae-Venter Law Group and Post v. Palo Alto, examine exactly when an appealing party has or has not bettered the award, and they shape how both sides evaluate the risk of a trial de novo.

DLSE Representation on Appeal Under § 98.4

A worker who wins at the Berman hearing and then faces an employer's appeal is not necessarily left to fend for themselves. Labor Code § 98.4 allows the Labor Commissioner to represent an employee who is financially unable to obtain counsel in the de novo appeal. This free representation is another feature that levels the playing field, because it means an employer cannot always count on outspending the worker in the second round.

Statutes of Limitations on the Underlying Claims

The Berman process does not suspend the time limits that govern the underlying wage claims. The limitations periods come from the Code of Civil Procedure. Claims founded on a statutory penalty generally fall under Code Civ. Proc. § 338, which provides a three-year period, while claims on an oral contract fall under Code Civ. Proc. § 339, and certain penalty claims fall under the one-year period in Code Civ. Proc. § 340. A worker should file promptly, because wages that fall outside the applicable limitations window may be unrecoverable even in an otherwise strong claim.

Berman Hearing Versus a Direct Lawsuit

A worker is not required to use the Berman process. An employee can instead file a civil action and pursue wages directly under Labor Code § 1194 for minimum wage and overtime, with its one-way fee shift favoring employees. The choice depends on the size and complexity of the claim. A discrete individual claim often fits the administrative process; a large or representative claim often belongs in court. Workers weighing the state-citation alternative can also review our guide on unpaid wage citations and penalties under Labor Code section 1197.1, which explains how the Labor Commissioner can cite an employer directly for subminimum pay.

Common Mistakes on Both Sides

Workers lose otherwise valid claims by failing to document hours, by missing the filing deadline, or by not appearing at the hearing. Employers damage their own position by failing to keep the time and payroll records the law requires, by missing the fifteen-day appeal window, or by appealing without a realistic chance of bettering the award and thereby triggering the fee shift in § 98.2(c). Both sides benefit from treating the Berman hearing seriously, because the ODA has real consequences and the appeal rules are unforgiving.

Practical Steps to Prepare for a Berman Hearing

A worker should assemble a clear timeline of employment, copies of wage statements, personal records of hours worked, text messages or schedules showing work time, and a simple calculation of the amount claimed. An employer should gather complete payroll and time records, the written wage-rate notice required at hiring, and any documentation of payments made. Organized evidence wins Berman hearings, because the hearing officer must decide quickly and relies heavily on the documents in front of them.

The Settlement Conference Before the Hearing

Before the formal Berman hearing, the Labor Commissioner often schedules a settlement conference. This is an informal, off-the-record meeting at which a deputy explores whether the parties can resolve the claim by agreement. The conference serves two purposes: it gives the worker and employer a low-pressure chance to compromise, and it lets the deputy gauge the strength of each side's documentation. Workers should not treat the conference as a formality. Coming prepared with a clear calculation and the key documents signals seriousness and often produces a fair settlement without the need for a full hearing. Employers, for their part, can use the conference to correct a genuine error quickly and cap their exposure before penalties and fees mount.

Evidence and the Burden of Proof at the Hearing

At the Berman hearing itself, the worker generally carries the initial burden of showing that work was performed for which wages were not paid. But California law eases that burden in a crucial way. Because employers are required to keep accurate time and payroll records, a worker who lacks records can meet the burden by producing a reasonable estimate of hours worked, and the burden then shifts to the employer to produce records that negate the estimate. An employer that failed to keep the required records cannot benefit from the gap its own noncompliance created. This evidentiary rule, rooted in longstanding wage-and-hour doctrine, is why organized personal records, and the employer's recordkeeping failures, so often determine the outcome.

What the Order, Decision, or Award Can Grant

The ODA can award more than base wages. Depending on the claim, it can include unpaid overtime, minimum-wage shortfalls, waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203 when final wages were late, premiums for missed meal and rest periods, penalties tied to noncompliant wage statements under Labor Code § 226, and interest. The hearing officer calculates each component and states the total in the award. Because the ODA bundles these items, a worker who pleads the full scope of the claim at the outset recovers far more than one who lists only the headline unpaid wages.

Collecting on an Award After You Win

Winning the ODA is not the same as getting paid. If the employer does not appeal and does not pay, the Labor Commissioner can have the ODA entered as a court judgment, which then opens the standard judgment-enforcement toolkit, including liens, levies, and other collection measures. The Labor Commissioner operates a judgment-enforcement unit that assists workers in collecting final awards, which is a meaningful advantage of the administrative route for workers facing employers who try to hide assets or dissolve. Persistence at the collection stage is often what converts a paper award into actual recovery.

Retaliation for Filing a Wage Claim

An employer may not punish a worker for using the Berman process. Labor Code § 98.6 prohibits discharging or otherwise retaliating against an employee for filing a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner, and it provides its own remedies, including reinstatement and lost wages. A worker who is fired, demoted, or harassed shortly after filing should document the sequence of events, because a retaliation claim is separate from, and additional to, the underlying wage claim and can substantially increase the employer's exposure.

Who Can File and Which Workers Are Covered

The Berman process is open to employees owed wages, and it reaches a broad range of workers. Current and former employees can file, and the process is not limited by the size of the employer. A frequent threshold fight is whether the claimant is an employee at all or was misclassified as an independent contractor. Because the wage protections hinge on employee status, the hearing officer may first have to decide classification using the governing legal standards before reaching the wage calculation. Workers who were labeled contractors but functioned as employees should not assume the Berman door is closed; the label does not control the right.

Berman Hearing Versus Small Claims Court

Workers sometimes weigh a Berman hearing against small claims court. Both are accessible and low-cost, but they differ in important ways. The Berman process is handled by specialists who understand wage law, it carries the appeal protections of Labor Code § 98.2, including the bond requirement and the one-way fee shift, and the Labor Commissioner can assist with collection and even represent a worker on appeal under Labor Code § 98.4. Small claims court has dollar limits and no wage-law specialists. For most wage disputes, the Berman process offers stronger procedural protections tailored to the claim.

The Bond Requirement as a Practical Equalizer

In day-to-day practice, the undertaking requirement in Labor Code § 98.2(b) changes employer behavior. An employer that might otherwise appeal reflexively must first tie up cash or secure a bond equal to the award, which forces a sober assessment of whether the appeal can actually improve the result. Combined with the fee-shift in § 98.2(c), the bond requirement discourages appeals brought only to delay or to pressure the worker into abandoning a valid award. For workers, this means a hard-won ODA is more likely to stick, and that the employer who does appeal has genuine confidence in its position rather than merely a desire to stall.

After the Trial De Novo: Finality and Payment

If an appeal proceeds to a trial de novo in superior court, the court hears the dispute fresh and enters its own judgment. That judgment supersedes the ODA and becomes the operative order. At that point the fee-shifting provision in Labor Code § 98.2(c) is applied: if the appealing party failed to obtain a more favorable result than the ODA, it must pay the other side's costs and reasonable attorney's fees. The bond posted under Labor Code § 98.2(b) stands as security for the worker if the employer loses. Once the judgment is final, the worker can enforce it like any civil judgment, and the Labor Commissioner may assist in collection. Understanding this endpoint helps both sides weigh whether a de novo appeal is worth the risk, because an unsuccessful appeal is costly for the party that brought it.

Common Berman Claims and How They Are Valued

Understanding how a hearing officer values a claim helps a worker present it well. Unpaid regular wages are valued by multiplying the unpaid hours by the applicable rate. Overtime is valued at the premium rate required by Labor Code § 510, generally one and one-half times the regular rate beyond eight hours in a day or forty in a week, and double time where the law requires. Waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203 continue the daily wage for each day final pay was late, up to thirty days. Wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226 compensate for injury from noncompliant pay stubs. A worker who itemizes each category with supporting numbers gives the hearing officer a roadmap to a full award, rather than leaving money unclaimed.

A Practical Timeline From Filing to Resolution

While every case differs, the Berman process tends to follow a recognizable arc. After the claim is filed, the agency reviews it and may set a settlement conference within a few weeks to a few months. If the conference does not resolve the matter, a hearing is scheduled, where both sides testify and submit documents. The hearing officer then issues the ODA, which starts the fifteen-day appeal clock under Labor Code § 98.2. If no one appeals, the ODA is entered as a judgment and collection begins. If an appeal is filed, the case moves to superior court for a trial de novo, where the bond requirement and fee-shift shape the parties' strategy. Knowing this sequence lets a worker plan, preserve evidence, and avoid being caught off guard by a deadline.

Talk to a California employment lawyer. The Berman hearing is accessible, but the appeal rules, the bond requirement, and the fee-shifting provision in Labor Code § 98.2 create real strategic stakes for both workers and employers. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm prepare and present Berman claims, defend and prosecute de novo appeals, and advise employers on avoiding the one-way fee trap. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation, and find more wage-claim guidance on our employment law news page.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to file a Berman wage claim?

Filing a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner under Labor Code § 98 does not require a court filing fee, and a worker can appear without a lawyer. The process was designed to be low-cost and accessible, which is a central reason many workers choose it over civil litigation.

What happens if the employer appeals my award?

Either party may appeal the Order, Decision, or Award to superior court within fifteen days under Labor Code § 98.2, and the appeal is a trial de novo. An appealing employer must post a bond equal to the award under § 98.2(b), and if the employer fails to obtain a better result, it must pay your costs and attorney's fees under § 98.2(c).

Can the state represent me if the employer appeals?

Yes. Labor Code § 98.4 allows the Labor Commissioner to represent an employee who cannot afford counsel in a de novo appeal of the ODA, which helps prevent an employer from simply outspending the worker in the second round.

Is there a deadline to bring my wage claim at all?

Yes. The underlying wage claims are subject to the limitations periods in the Code of Civil Procedure, including the three-year period in Code Civ. Proc. § 338 for many penalty and statutory claims. File promptly, because wages outside the limitations window may be lost.

Should I use a Berman hearing or file a lawsuit?

Discrete individual wage claims often fit the Berman process well, while large, complex, or representative claims may belong in court under remedies such as Labor Code § 1194. An employment lawyer can assess your claim and recommend the path that maximizes your recovery and minimizes your risk.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301