WAGE & HOUR | 2026-11-16
California Commission Agreements in Writing Under Labor Code 2751 in 2026
Any California employer paying commissions must put the compensation plan in a signed writing, spell out how commissions are computed and paid, and give the employee a copy.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California sales employees are frequently paid in whole or part by commission, yet many work for months without ever seeing a written plan that explains how their commissions are earned and paid. That gap is not just bad practice. Labor Code § 2751 makes a signed written commission agreement mandato
Why Written Commission Plans Became Mandatory
Commission pay was a recurring source of wage disputes in California because the terms often lived only in a manager's head or a verbal promise. Workers could not tell when a commission was earned, how it was calculated, or whether a chargeback was legitimate. To close that gap, the Legislature enacted Labor Code § 2751, which took effect in 2013 and requires a written commission agreement for employees who perform services in California and are paid commissions. The statute shifts commission plans out of the realm of oral understandings and into enforceable, signed documents.
The requirement is not a formality. A clear written plan protects the employee by fixing the rules in advance, and it protects the employer by documenting the agreed method. When the writing is missing, the ambiguity almost always cuts against the employer, because California wage law resolves doubt in favor of the worker and against the party that controlled the recordkeeping. An employer that wants to enforce a precise forfeiture or chargeback rule must have written that rule down and secured the employee's signature.
What Labor Code 2751 Requires
Labor Code § 2751 requires three things when an employer enters into a contract of employment that involves commissions as a method of payment for services rendered in California. First, the contract must be in writing. Second, the writing must set forth the method by which the commissions are to be computed and paid. Third, the employer must give a signed copy of the contract to every employee covered by it and obtain a signed receipt for the contract from each employee.
The statute also addresses what happens when a commission contract expires but the parties keep working: the terms of the expired contract are presumed to remain in force until a new contract is signed or the employment ends. That continuation rule is a trap for employers who let an old plan lapse while changing how they actually pay, because the written but expired plan still governs. The duty to define the method of computing and paying commissions is the heart of the statute. A one-line promise to pay a percentage is not enough if it does not explain the triggering event, the treatment of returns and chargebacks, and the timing of payment.
What Counts as a Commission
Not every incentive payment is a commission. Under California law, a commission is compensation paid to a person for services rendered in the sale of the employer's property or services and based proportionately on the amount or value of that sale. Short-term productivity bonuses, profit-sharing plans, and flat per-task payments generally are not commissions within the meaning of § 2751. Characterizing a payment correctly matters, because the written-agreement requirement and the earning rules attach only to true commissions.
An employer cannot escape the statute by mislabeling a commission as a bonus, and an employee cannot force a discretionary bonus into the commission framework. Courts look at the substance of the arrangement, not the label. If the payment rises and falls proportionately with the value of sales the employee makes, it is likely a commission regardless of what the employer calls it, and the full weight of § 2751 applies.
Commissions Are Wages
Once earned, a commission is a wage. Labor Code § 200 defines wages to include all amounts for labor performed, whether fixed or ascertained by the standard of time, task, piece, commission basis, or other method of calculation. Because a commission is a wage, it is subject to the timing rules of Labor Code § 204, which require wages to be paid at least twice during each calendar month on designated paydays.
The consequence is significant: an earned commission cannot be held indefinitely at the employer's convenience. Once the conditions for earning the commission are satisfied, the amount must be paid on the regular payday for the period in which it becomes calculable. California recognizes that some commissions cannot be computed until a later event, such as the customer's payment, occurs. In that situation the commission becomes due when it can reasonably be calculated, but the employer cannot use that flexibility as a pretext for stalling payment on commissions that are already fully earned.
When a Commission Is Earned
The written plan controls when a commission is earned, as long as its conditions are lawful. An employer may condition the earning of a commission on events such as the customer's payment or the expiration of a return period, provided the plan says so clearly and the conditions are not a pretext for forfeiting work already done. Courts scrutinize conditions that purport to strip an employee of a commission for sales already closed, especially after the employee leaves.
The clearer the plan, the more likely a court will enforce it as written; the vaguer the plan, the more likely a court will read it in the employee's favor. A frequent battleground is the departing salesperson whose deals close after separation. Whether that worker is owed the commission turns on what the written plan says the earning event is. If the plan is silent or ambiguous, the worker who did the substantial work of the sale often prevails, because forfeiture of earned wages is disfavored.
The Peabody Rule on Pay Periods
A central question in commission cases is how to attribute a commission across time, especially when an employee argues that a large commission should be spread across earlier low-earning weeks to satisfy minimum pay rules. In Peabody v. Time Warner Cable (2014), the California Supreme Court held that an employer may not attribute commission wages paid in one pay period to other pay periods to satisfy compensation requirements.
A commission is counted in the pay period in which it is actually paid or earned, not averaged backward across prior weeks. Peabody prevents employers from using a single later commission to paper over earlier shortfalls, and it reinforces that each pay period stands on its own. For inside sales employees whose exemption or minimum-pay compliance depends on the pay-period math, Peabody can be decisive, because it forecloses the averaging maneuver employers once used to claim compliance across a quarter.
Vehicle Dealer Commissions
California provides a specialized timing rule for certain commissions in the vehicle sales context. Labor Code § 204.1 provides that commission wages paid to any person employed by an employer licensed as a vehicle dealer are due and payable once each calendar month on a day designated in advance as the regular payday. This carve-out reflects the particular rhythm of vehicle sales compensation.
It does not relax the written-agreement requirement of § 2751; a dealer must still provide a signed written plan that defines how commissions are computed and paid. It simply adjusts the payment-timing default for that industry. A dealership that assumes the monthly-payment rule excuses it from the written-plan requirement misreads the statute, because the two provisions operate independently and both apply to a commissioned vehicle salesperson.
What Happens When There Is No Writing
If an employer pays commissions without the signed written agreement § 2751 requires, the employer has violated the statute. The practical effect in litigation is that the employer loses the benefit of any favorable but undocumented terms it might have wanted to enforce, such as forfeiture conditions or chargeback rules, because those terms were never reduced to a signed writing.
The employee's reasonable understanding of how commissions are earned tends to prevail where the employer failed to document a different rule. The missing writing becomes the employer's problem, not the worker's. An employer cannot, after a dispute arises, produce an after-the-fact memo describing the plan it wishes it had signed; the statute requires the writing and the signed receipt up front, and courts will not rescue an employer that skipped those steps.
Remedies for Unpaid Commissions
An employee who earned commissions that were not paid can pursue them as unpaid wages. Because commissions are wages under § 200 and must be paid on time under § 204, nonpayment can support a wage claim with interest. If the commissions were still owed when employment ended, waiting-time penalties under Labor Code § 203 may apply, running up to thirty days of the employee's daily wage.
Inaccurate wage statements that omit or misstate commissions can support penalties under Labor Code § 226, and attorney fees may be available in a successful wage action. Our broader coverage of pay-practice enforcement at our California employment law news page explains how these penalties stack, and workers paid on alternative formulas may also want our guide to piece-rate rest period pay, which addresses a related non-hourly pay model that raises similar earning and timing questions.
Practical Steps for Employees and Employers
An employee paid by commission should ask for the written plan immediately, keep every version, and track sales, payments, and chargebacks independently. If no plan exists, that fact itself supports a claim, and the worker's contemporaneous records of closed deals become the measure of what is owed. Saving emails confirming deals and payments strengthens the record considerably.
Employers should draft a plan that defines the commission, states the precise earning event, addresses returns and chargebacks, specifies payment timing consistent with § 204, provides a signed copy, and obtains a signed receipt. Reviewing the plan whenever the compensation structure changes prevents the slow drift into noncompliance that produces litigation. Re-signing a fresh plan each time the formula changes is far cheaper than defending a claim built on an expired or missing agreement.
Why Commission Compliance Keeps Mattering
Sales-driven businesses change their incentive structures often, and each change is a chance to fall out of compliance with § 2751. A plan that was signed years ago may no longer match how commissions are actually paid, and an expired plan carried forward by practice still binds the parties until a new one is signed. Keeping the written agreement current and matched to real practice is the single most effective way to avoid a commission dispute.
For workers, the lesson is to demand the writing and keep it. For employers, the lesson is that the statute is specific and unforgiving: the writing, the content, the copy, and the signed receipt are all required, and shortcuts on any of them hand the employee the advantage in any later fight over what the worker is owed.
Draws Against Commission
Many commission plans pay a recoverable draw, an advance against future commissions that the employer later recovers from commissions actually earned. California permits recoverable draws, but the written plan must explain how the draw works, and the arrangement cannot be used to drive a worker's pay below the minimum wage for hours worked. A draw that the employer claws back so aggressively that the employee effectively earns less than minimum wage for the pay period violates California wage law, because minimum-wage obligations under the Wage Orders and Labor Code § 1197 apply regardless of the commission structure.
The plan should state clearly whether the draw is recoverable or nonrecoverable and how any deficit is treated at separation. An employer generally cannot recover an outstanding draw deficit from a departing employee as if it were a debt, because that would convert an advance on wages into an unlawful deduction. The precise treatment belongs in the signed writing § 2751 requires, and an ambiguous draw provision tends to be read against the employer who drafted it.
Chargebacks and Clawbacks
Chargebacks reverse a previously credited commission when a sale is later canceled, returned, or unpaid. California allows chargebacks only when the written plan defines them clearly and the commission was conditional on the event that triggered the chargeback. If the plan ties earning to a customer's final payment and the customer never pays, a chargeback of an advanced commission may be proper. But an employer cannot retroactively charge back commissions that were already fully earned under the plan's terms, because an earned commission is a wage under § 200 that cannot be taken back through an unlawful deduction.
The enforceability of a chargeback turns on what the written plan says the earning event is. A plan that makes commissions contingent and says so plainly can support chargebacks; a plan that is silent or treats the commission as earned at the point of sale cannot support clawing it back later. Workers facing chargebacks should compare the deductions against the plan's actual earning language.
Commissions Owed at Termination
Separation sharpens every commission question. When employment ends, Labor Code § 201 requires immediate payment of final wages on discharge, and § 202 requires payment within seventy-two hours when an employee quits without notice. Commissions that are earned and calculable at separation are wages that must be paid on that schedule. Commissions that cannot yet be calculated, because a contingency has not resolved, become due when they can reasonably be computed, and the employer must then pay them promptly.
A frequent dispute involves deals the departing salesperson substantially completed but which close after the last day. Whether those commissions are owed depends on the written plan's earning terms, and courts disfavor forfeiture of commissions for work substantially performed. If the employer fails to pay commissions that were due at separation, waiting-time penalties under § 203 can add up to thirty days of the worker's daily wage, a significant multiplier on the unpaid amount.
How a Commission Dispute Typically Proceeds
A worker pursuing unpaid commissions can file a claim with the Labor Commissioner or bring a civil action. The first step is assembling the written plan, the sales records, and the pay history to show what was earned and what was paid. Because commissions are wages, the general three-year limitations period applies to the statutory claims, and a four-year reach is often available through the unfair competition law. The worker bears the initial burden of showing the commissions were earned, after which the employer must justify any nonpayment, chargeback, or draw recovery under the plan.
The absence of a compliant § 2751 writing strengthens the worker's position, because the employer cannot point to documented terms to justify withholding. Keeping independent records of closed deals and payments received is therefore the single most valuable thing a commissioned employee can do, since those records often become the measure of the award when the employer's documentation is incomplete.
Minimum Wage, Overtime, and Inside Sales
A commission structure never excuses an employer from the baseline wage protections. For most commissioned employees, the employer must still ensure that pay for each pay period meets at least the applicable minimum wage for all hours worked under § 1197, and non-exempt commissioned workers remain entitled to overtime under § 510 unless a recognized exemption applies. A narrow inside-sales exemption from overtime exists under certain Wage Orders, but it requires that the employee earn more than one and one-half times the minimum wage and that more than half of the employee's compensation come from commissions. Both prongs must be satisfied in each representative period, and an employer that fails either prong owes overtime.
Because that exemption is strict and easy to miscalculate, employers frequently assume it applies when it does not. A commissioned worker whose commissions dip below the required share, or whose total pay falls below the wage threshold, is non-exempt and entitled to overtime for that period. This is another area where the Peabody rule matters, because the pay-period analysis cannot be smoothed across time to manufacture compliance.
Keep Your Own Record of Every Sale
The most practical protection a commissioned employee has is an independent record. Employers control the sales database, the crediting decisions, and the chargeback entries, so a worker who relies solely on the employer's numbers is at a disadvantage if a dispute arises. Keeping a personal log of each closed deal, its value, the date, and any payment or cancellation creates a parallel record that can be compared against the employer's accounting.
When the figures diverge, that independent record often becomes the worker's best evidence of what was earned. Combined with the written plan required by § 2751 and the pay stubs the employer must provide under § 226, a careful personal log lets a worker reconstruct exactly what the employer owed and paid. In the frequent situation where the employer never produced a compliant written plan, the worker's own contemporaneous records can supply the measure of damages a court or the Labor Commissioner uses.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If you were paid commissions without a signed written plan, or an employer is withholding commissions you believe you earned, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can review your agreement against the requirements of § 2751 and the earning rules California law imposes. Call (213) 645-2246 to discuss whether your commissions were properly documented and paid.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does my California employer have to give me a written commission agreement?
Yes. Labor Code § 2751 requires a signed written agreement that sets out how commissions are computed and paid whenever an employer pays commissions for services rendered in California, and the employer must give you a copy and obtain your signed receipt.
Are commissions considered wages in California?
Yes. Labor Code § 200 defines wages to include compensation calculated on a commission basis, so earned commissions are wages that must be paid on time under the § 204 payday rules and cannot be withheld indefinitely once the earning conditions are met.
Can my employer average a big commission backward to cover earlier low-pay weeks?
No. Under Peabody v. Time Warner Cable (2014), an employer may not attribute a commission paid in one pay period to earlier periods to satisfy compensation requirements. Each pay period stands on its own.
What if my employer never put the commission plan in writing?
The employer has violated § 2751, and undocumented terms that favor the employer, such as forfeiture or chargeback conditions, are difficult to enforce. Your reasonable understanding of how commissions are earned tends to prevail, and your own records of closed deals measure what is owed.
What can I recover for unpaid commissions?
You can pursue the unpaid commissions as wages with interest, potential waiting-time penalties under § 203 if you have left the job, wage-statement penalties under § 226, and possible attorney fees in a successful action.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301