EMPLOYMENT ARBITRATION | 2026-11-20
EFAA Sexual Harassment Arbitration Ban in California 2026
A federal law lets California workers void a predispute arbitration clause and take a sexual-harassment claim to court.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
If you signed an arbitration agreement when you were hired, you may believe your only option for a sexual-harassment claim is private arbitration with no jury and no public record. A 2022 federal law changed that. At your election, a predispute arbitration clause is unenforceable for a sexual-harass
The End of Forced Arbitration for Harassment Claims
For decades, California employers routinely required workers to sign predispute arbitration agreements that funneled every claim, including sexual harassment, into private arbitration where there is no jury, limited appeal, and often no public record. In 2022 that changed for one category of claim. The Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act, a federal statute, gives a worker the power to void a predispute arbitration clause and take a sexual-harassment or sexual-assault claim to court. The law is a rare federal expansion of worker choice, and it overrides the strong pro-arbitration policy that governs most employment disputes.
The Act is codified in the Federal Arbitration Act at 9 U.S.C. § 401 and § 402. At the election of the person alleging the conduct, a predispute arbitration agreement is unenforceable with respect to a case relating to a sexual-harassment dispute or a sexual-assault dispute. The election belongs to the claimant, not the employer, and it can be made even if the worker signed a seemingly airtight arbitration agreement years earlier.
The significance is hard to overstate. Before the Act, a worker who experienced harassment typically had no choice but to pursue the claim in a confidential forum chosen and paid for in part by the employer, before an arbitrator the employer may have appeared before repeatedly. The Act restores the worker's access to the public court system, a jury of peers, and the deterrent effect of a public record, for the category of misconduct where secrecy has done the most harm.
What the Federal Statute Actually Says
Under 9 U.S.C. § 402, no predispute arbitration agreement and no predispute joint-action waiver is valid or enforceable with respect to a case that is filed under federal, state, or tribal law and relates to a sexual-assault or sexual-harassment dispute, at the election of the person alleging the conduct. The statute reaches both the forced-arbitration clause and any waiver of the right to pursue a class or collective action for the covered dispute.
A critical procedural rule appears in the same provision: whether the Act applies, and whether an agreement is enforceable, is decided by a court under federal law, not by an arbitrator, even if the contract delegates arbitrability questions to the arbitrator. This removes the usual gateway advantage employers enjoy, where an arbitrator decides whether arbitration is required. For harassment claims, the courthouse door stays under judicial control.
That delegation override is a substantial departure from ordinary arbitration law. Normally a clear delegation clause sends even the question of arbitrability to the arbitrator. The Act flips that rule for covered disputes, ensuring that a neutral judge, not a private arbitrator with an interest in the outcome, decides the threshold question of whether the worker can stay in court.
Who Elects, and When the Election Happens
The power to invalidate the arbitration clause rests solely with the person alleging sexual harassment or sexual assault. An employer cannot force the issue, and a co-defendant cannot override the claimant's choice. The election is made after a dispute arises, which is why the statute speaks of predispute agreements: the worker could not have knowingly surrendered a right that did not yet exist. A worker who prefers arbitration may still choose it, but the default has flipped in favor of the claimant's forum selection.
Timing matters because the Act applies to disputes or claims that arise or accrue on or after its enactment date in March 2022. The relevant question is when the harassment claim accrued, not when the arbitration agreement was signed, so a pre-2022 agreement does not shield post-enactment conduct.
Because the trigger is accrual rather than signing, employers cannot rely on the age of an arbitration agreement to force older claims into arbitration. A worker harassed in 2026 who signed an arbitration agreement in 2018 still holds the election. The practical effect is that every covered claim arising after the enactment date is subject to the worker's choice of forum, regardless of how the employer drafted its onboarding paperwork.
What Counts as a Sexual-Harassment Dispute
The Act defines a sexual-harassment dispute broadly as a dispute relating to conduct that is alleged to constitute sexual harassment under applicable federal, tribal, or state law. In California, that pulls in claims under the Fair Employment and Housing Act and related provisions, so a hostile-work-environment or quid-pro-quo claim grounded in California law relates to a sexual-harassment dispute for purposes of the federal election.
Because the statutory phrase is relating to, courts have read it to reach an entire case that includes a covered claim, not merely the harassment count in isolation. A worker whose complaint pairs harassment with retaliation and wage claims may be able to keep the whole case in court, though the precise scope is litigated case by case.
The breadth of the phrase case relating to a sexual-harassment dispute has become the central battleground. Some employers argue the Act reaches only the harassment count, while workers argue it reaches the whole case filed, so long as the case relates to the harassment dispute. The better-reasoned decisions focus on the statute's use of the word case rather than claim, which supports keeping the entire action in court where a genuine harassment claim is present.
How This Interacts With California Arbitration Law
California tried to limit forced employment arbitration through Labor Code § 432.6 and Gov. Code § 12953, which together made it unlawful to require an applicant or employee to waive, as a condition of employment, the right to pursue a Fair Employment and Housing Act or Labor Code claim in a judicial forum. Those provisions, enacted as AB 51, were largely preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act as applied to the formation of arbitration agreements, leaving many California workers bound to arbitrate.
The federal Act fills part of that gap for the specific category of sexual harassment and assault, because it operates as an amendment to the Federal Arbitration Act itself, 9 U.S.C. § 1 et seq., rather than as a conflicting state rule. The result is a layered landscape: most claims remain arbitrable, but covered harassment and assault claims are not, at the worker's election.
This interaction is important for California workers because it means the protection does not depend on the fate of state legislation that federal preemption has hollowed out. The Act achieves through federal law what AB 51 could not achieve through state law, at least for the covered category. Workers therefore have a durable, federally grounded right that does not rise or fall with the shifting preemption analysis surrounding state arbitration statutes.
Unconscionability Still Matters for Everything Else
For claims the Act does not cover, California workers still have the defense of unconscionability under Civ. Code § 1670.5, which lets a court refuse to enforce a contract or clause it finds unconscionable at the time it was made. The California Supreme Court's decision in Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare (2000) set the baseline requirements for an enforceable employment arbitration agreement, including a neutral arbitrator, adequate discovery, a written award permitting limited judicial review, all remedies available in court, and no requirement that the employee pay unreasonable arbitration-specific costs.
An agreement that is both procedurally unconscionable, because it was imposed on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, and substantively unconscionable, because it is one-sided, may be unenforceable even outside the harassment context. Workers should not assume arbitration is inevitable merely because they signed.
Unconscionability operates on a sliding scale: the more procedural oppression, the less substantive unfairness is needed to render the agreement unenforceable, and vice versa. Many employment arbitration agreements carry significant procedural unconscionability simply because they are presented on a nonnegotiable basis at hire, which lowers the substantive showing a worker must make to defeat the clause for non-covered claims.
Severability and the Rest of the Agreement
When a court finds the Act applies, it does not necessarily void the entire arbitration agreement for all purposes; it renders the agreement unenforceable with respect to the covered case. Many agreements contain severability clauses, so a worker may litigate the harassment claim in court while unrelated future disputes remain subject to arbitration. The practical effect, however, is that an employer cannot compel arbitration of the case the worker has chosen to bring to court.
Employers sometimes argue that only the harassment count should proceed in court while related counts go to arbitration. Because splitting a single case between forums is inefficient and the statute speaks of the case, many courts keep the related claims together, but this remains a developing area that rewards careful pleading.
From a strategic standpoint, how a complaint is drafted can influence whether the whole case stays in court. A worker with a strong harassment claim bundled with related retaliation and wage theories should expect the employer to try to peel off the non-harassment counts, and should be prepared to argue that those counts relate to the same sexual-harassment dispute for purposes of the Act.
Strategic Consequences for Workers and Employers
For workers, the Act restores access to a jury, public proceedings, and broader appellate review for the most sensitive category of workplace misconduct. Public filing can also matter to survivors who want accountability rather than a confidential arbitration. For employers, the Act increases exposure and makes confidential resolution harder, which has prompted many to revisit nondisclosure and arbitration practices.
The Act also interacts with limits on secrecy agreements. California already restricts confidentiality provisions that prevent disclosure of information about harassment, and the combination of public litigation plus those disclosure rules reduces the leverage employers once gained from mandatory arbitration.
A jury trial also changes the economics of a case. Arbitrators are sometimes perceived to award more conservative damages, while a jury that hears credible testimony about harassment may return a substantially larger verdict, including punitive damages where the conduct is egregious. That shift in potential exposure gives workers meaningful settlement leverage they lacked when arbitration was mandatory.
Practical Steps Before and After a Dispute
A worker who has experienced sexual harassment should preserve evidence, document the conduct and any complaints made, and consult counsel before signing any new agreement or severance release. Signing a post-dispute arbitration agreement, or a release that waives the right to elect court, can forfeit the protection the Act provides. Because the election is the worker's to make, the decision whether to invoke it should be informed by the strength of the claim and the forum's advantages. Our broader California employment law news coverage tracks how courts apply the Act, and workers weighing privacy issues may also review our guide to Social Security number confidentiality under Civil Code § 1798.85.
Employers should audit arbitration templates, confirm that arbitrability of covered claims is left to courts, and avoid drafting that purports to compel arbitration of harassment claims, which can expose the employer to fee-shifting and sanctions when a worker successfully resists a motion to compel.
Timing is also critical because the underlying harassment claim carries its own administrative and limitations deadlines under California law, including the requirement to exhaust certain administrative remedies before filing suit. The right to choose a court forum is valuable only if the worker preserves the claim itself, so prompt consultation with counsel protects both the forum choice and the substantive case.
What Happens When an Employer Moves to Compel Arbitration
When a worker files a harassment case in court, the employer will often respond with a motion to compel arbitration, asking the judge to send the dispute to a private arbitrator under the signed agreement. The worker opposes the motion by invoking the Act, and under 9 U.S.C. § 402 the court decides the threshold question of whether the Act applies, even if the agreement purports to hand arbitrability to the arbitrator. The worker's opposition shows that the case relates to a sexual-harassment dispute and that the claim arose on or after the enactment date, which together render the predispute agreement unenforceable at the worker's election.
Because the court resolves applicability, the worker is not forced to litigate the threshold issue in the very forum they are trying to avoid. A judge who finds the Act applies denies the motion to compel, and the case proceeds in court with the ordinary tools of civil litigation, including broad discovery and a jury. An employer that files a meritless motion to compel against a clearly covered harassment claim risks wasting the court's time and may face arguments for fees.
Workers should be prepared for the employer to argue that some claims in the complaint fall outside the Act and belong in arbitration. The response is that the statute speaks of the case relating to a sexual-harassment dispute, and splitting a unified case between two forums is both inefficient and contrary to the statutory text. Careful pleading that ties the related claims to the harassment narrative strengthens the argument to keep everything in court.
Weighing Court Versus Arbitration as a Survivor
The Act gives the survivor a choice, and choosing wisely requires weighing several factors. Court offers a public record, a jury, broad discovery, and full appellate review, which can increase both the pressure on the employer and the potential recovery, including punitive damages for egregious conduct. It also means the proceedings are generally public, which some survivors want for accountability and others find difficult. Arbitration offers privacy and speed but limited appeal and a decisionmaker the employer may appear before repeatedly.
There is no single right answer. A survivor with strong documentary evidence and a sympathetic narrative may prefer a jury, while a survivor prioritizing confidentiality might still elect arbitration. The key is that the choice belongs to the claimant, and it should be made with counsel after weighing the strength of the evidence, the desire for privacy, the likely damages, and the deterrent value of a public judgment. Because the election can be affected by the language of any release or new agreement, the decision should come before signing anything the employer proposes.
Confidentiality Limits and the Broader Legal Shift
The Act is part of a broader move away from silencing workers who experience harassment. California has separately narrowed the enforceability of confidentiality provisions that prevent a worker from disclosing information about unlawful harassment, and the combination of public litigation under the Act with those disclosure protections erodes the secrecy employers once relied on. An employer can no longer count on bundling a harassment claim into confidential arbitration and a sweeping nondisclosure clause to keep misconduct out of view.
For employers, this shift counsels prevention over suppression. Robust anti-harassment policies, prompt and genuine investigations, and accountability for wrongdoers reduce the risk that a public lawsuit will surface misconduct the company tolerated. For workers, the shift means the leverage that once flowed to employers through forced arbitration has moved toward survivors, who can now credibly threaten a public jury trial. The practical result is stronger settlement positions and greater incentive for employers to address complaints seriously when they are first raised.
The timing of the underlying claim should not be overlooked in the focus on arbitration. A California harassment claim generally must be pursued through the administrative process, with a right-to-sue notice obtained, within the limitations period the Fair Employment and Housing Act sets, and a federal claim carries its own administrative prerequisites. The right to elect a court forum under 9 U.S.C. § 402 is valuable only if the substantive claim remains alive, so a worker should calendar every deadline and begin the administrative steps promptly rather than waiting to resolve the arbitration question first. A claim that lapses on the merits cannot be rescued by a favorable forum ruling.
Finally, workers should understand that the Act governs the forum, not the substance of the harassment claim. Winning the right to a court does not by itself prove the harassment; the worker must still establish the elements of the underlying claim under California law, including that the conduct was severe or pervasive enough to alter the conditions of employment, or that a tangible job action was tied to a demand. The Act simply ensures that a jury, rather than a private arbitrator, hears that evidence. Pairing a strong substantive claim with a timely election of the court forum is what gives the law its full practical value for survivors.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If an employer is trying to force your sexual-harassment claim into arbitration, federal law may let you choose court instead. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm evaluate arbitration agreements, invoke the Act when it applies, and fight unconscionable clauses. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an employee avoid arbitration of a sexual-harassment claim in California?
Yes. Under 9 U.S.C. § 402, the person alleging sexual harassment may elect to make a predispute arbitration agreement unenforceable for that case, and a court rather than an arbitrator decides whether the Act applies, even if the contract delegates that question to the arbitrator.
Does the Act apply to an arbitration agreement signed years ago?
It can. The Act turns on when the harassment claim accrued, not when the agreement was signed, so conduct arising on or after March 2022 is covered even under an older predispute arbitration agreement.
Does the Act cover related retaliation or wage claims in the same lawsuit?
Because the statute refers to a case relating to a sexual-harassment dispute, many courts keep the whole case in court, though the scope of related claims is litigated and depends on how the complaint is framed.
What happens to the arbitration agreement for other disputes?
The Act renders the agreement unenforceable only for the covered harassment or assault case. Severability clauses often leave unrelated future disputes subject to arbitration while the harassment claim proceeds in court.
Are arbitration agreements that fall outside the Act always enforceable?
No. Workers may still challenge an agreement as unconscionable under Civ. Code § 1670.5 and the standards from Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare (2000), which require neutrality, adequate discovery, full remedies, and reasonable cost allocation.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301