EMPLOYMENT ARBITRATION | 2026-10-28

Employment Arbitration in California 2026: Armendariz and AB 51

When mandatory arbitration agreements are enforceable, what fairness the law requires, and how FAA preemption affects AB 51.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

Mandatory arbitration agreements are common in California workplaces, but state law tolerates them only within strict limits. The Armendariz decision set minimum fairness requirements, the unconscionability doctrine polices one-sided terms, and AB 51 tried to ban forced arbitration before the Federa

The Rise of Mandatory Employment Arbitration in California

Mandatory arbitration agreements have become a standard feature of California employment. Many employers require workers, as a condition of being hired or continuing employment, to sign agreements waiving their right to sue in court and instead resolving disputes before a private arbitrator. California law tolerates these agreements, but only within strict limits designed to protect employees from being forced into an unfair private forum. The governing framework comes from the California Supreme Court's landmark decision in Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare Services, Inc. (2000) 24 Cal.4th 83, together with the Federal Arbitration Act and California statutes addressing forced arbitration.

Because arbitration strips employees of a public jury trial, broad discovery, and in many cases an appeal, California courts scrutinize these agreements carefully. An agreement that imposes arbitration unfairly, or that lacks the basic procedural protections of a court, may be found unenforceable. Understanding when an arbitration agreement will hold up, and when it will not, is essential for any California worker presented with one.

The Armendariz Minimum Requirements

In Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare Services, Inc. (2000) 24 Cal.4th 83, the California Supreme Court held that when an employer compels arbitration of unwaivable statutory rights, such as claims under the Fair Employment and Housing Act, the arbitration agreement must satisfy certain minimum requirements to be enforceable. These requirements ensure that arbitration serves as a legitimate substitute for court rather than a mechanism to suppress claims.

The Armendariz minimum requirements are: a neutral arbitrator; adequate discovery sufficient to vindicate the employee's statutory rights; a written award that permits limited judicial review; the availability of all types of relief that would be available in court, including all statutory remedies; and a requirement that the employer bear any costs unique to arbitration, so the employee is not forced to pay forum fees they would never incur in court. An agreement that fails any of these elements, with respect to statutory claims, falls short of the Armendariz standard.

Neutral Arbitrator and Adequate Discovery

The requirement of a neutral arbitrator means the selection process cannot be rigged in the employer's favor. Agreements that let the employer unilaterally choose the arbitrator or the arbitration provider, or that draw from a pool skewed toward repeat-player employers, raise serious neutrality concerns. A fair, mutual selection process is required.

Adequate discovery is equally central. Statutory employment claims, particularly discrimination and retaliation claims, often turn on information in the employer's exclusive control, such as comparator data, personnel files, and internal communications. Under Armendariz, the employee must be afforded discovery sufficient to prove their claims. An agreement that sharply limits depositions, document requests, or interrogatories may be struck down because it prevents the employee from vindicating their rights.

Written Award, Full Remedies, and Cost Allocation

Armendariz also requires a written arbitration award that reveals the arbitrator's essential findings, so that limited judicial review remains meaningful. An arbitration that produces only a bare result, with no explanation, undermines the ability of a court to confirm that statutory rights were honored.

The agreement must also preserve all remedies available in court. An employee pursuing a statutory claim cannot be forced to give up punitive damages, statutory penalties, injunctive relief, or attorney fees that the statute provides. Finally, the employer must pay all costs unique to arbitration, including the arbitrator's fees and administrative costs that an employee would never face in court. Shifting those forum costs to the employee is a classic ground for unenforceability. Workers can read related coverage in our California employment law news section.

Opt-Out Provisions and Truly Voluntary Agreements

Not every arbitration agreement is mandatory. Some employers offer arbitration on a genuinely voluntary basis, giving employees a meaningful opportunity to opt out within a defined window without any adverse consequence to their employment. A truly voluntary agreement, where the employee understood the right to decline and faced no penalty for doing so, stands on firmer footing than a take-it-or-leave-it mandate, because it reduces the procedural unconscionability that flows from unequal bargaining power and coercion.

The reality, however, is that many purported opt-out provisions are illusory. If the opt-out window is buried, impossibly short, or practically difficult to exercise, or if declining carries subtle professional consequences, a court may find that the agreement was mandatory in substance despite its voluntary label. The existence of a meaningful opt-out is therefore a fact-intensive question. Employees who were told they could opt out should preserve any communications describing the process, because whether the opt-out was real bears directly on both the enforceability analysis under Labor Code § 432.6 and the degree of procedural unconscionability under the Armendariz framework.

Unconscionability: The Two-Pronged Test

Even an agreement that nominally addresses the Armendariz factors may be unenforceable if it is unconscionable. California applies a two-pronged unconscionability analysis requiring both procedural and substantive unconscionability, though the two are evaluated on a sliding scale. The more procedurally oppressive an agreement, the less substantive unfairness is needed to render it unenforceable, and vice versa.

Procedural unconscionability concerns the circumstances of contract formation, focusing on oppression and surprise. An arbitration agreement presented on a take-it-or-leave-it basis as a condition of employment, with no opportunity to negotiate and often buried in onboarding paperwork, carries a significant degree of procedural unconscionability. The inherent inequality of bargaining power between employer and employee heightens this concern.

Substantive Unconscionability and Severance

Substantive unconscionability focuses on whether the terms themselves are overly harsh or one-sided. Terms that lack mutuality, such as requiring only the employee to arbitrate while allowing the employer to go to court for the claims it cares about, are a hallmark of substantive unconscionability. So are shortened limitations periods, fee-splitting provisions that burden the employee, confidentiality clauses that handicap the employee's ability to build a case, and limitations on remedies.

When an agreement contains unconscionable terms, a court may sever them and enforce the remainder, or it may refuse to enforce the agreement at all. Under Armendariz, where an agreement is permeated by unconscionability, meaning it contains multiple unlawful provisions reflecting a systematic effort to impose an inferior forum, a court may decline to sever and instead void the entire agreement. A single, isolated offending term is more likely to be severed.

Class and PAGA Waivers Within Arbitration Agreements

Employment arbitration agreements almost always contain a class action waiver, requiring the employee to arbitrate only on an individual basis and to forgo class or collective proceedings. Under the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 2, and controlling United States Supreme Court authority, class waivers in arbitration agreements are generally enforceable, and California may not refuse to enforce them on the ground that it disfavors individual arbitration of what might otherwise be a class claim. This is a significant limitation on the collective remedies available to workers who have signed arbitration agreements.

Representative claims under the Private Attorneys General Act occupy a special position, however. As explained in Viking River Cruises, Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639, an employer may compel the individual component of a PAGA claim into arbitration, but a wholesale waiver of the right to bring any representative PAGA action is treated differently because PAGA claims belong to the state. The interaction between arbitration agreements and PAGA remains one of the most actively litigated areas of California employment law, and an employee who has signed an arbitration agreement should not assume it forecloses every form of collective or representative relief.

AB 51 and Labor Code Section 432.6

In an effort to curb forced arbitration, the California Legislature enacted Assembly Bill 51, codified primarily at Labor Code § 432.6. That statute prohibits an employer from requiring, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit, that an applicant or employee waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of the Fair Employment and Housing Act or the Labor Code, including the right to file and pursue a civil action. In substance, § 432.6 attempts to ban mandatory arbitration of these claims.

Labor Code § 432.6 also prohibits retaliation against workers who refuse to sign such agreements and reaches opt-out schemes that effectively compel arbitration. The statute was designed to make truly voluntary, not coerced, any waiver of the right to a judicial forum for core employment claims.

FAA Preemption and the Fate of AB 51

The enforceability of Labor Code § 432.6 has been shaped by the Federal Arbitration Act, codified at 9 U.S.C. § 2, which makes written arbitration agreements valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, and which preempts state laws that single out or disfavor arbitration. The United States Supreme Court in Viking River Cruises, Inc. v. Moriana (2022) 596 U.S. 639 reaffirmed the broad preemptive force of the FAA over state rules that obstruct arbitration.

Applying these principles, the Ninth Circuit ultimately held that the FAA preempts Labor Code § 432.6 to the extent it penalizes or bars the formation of arbitration agreements governed by the FAA. The practical consequence is that, for agreements within the FAA's reach, a California employer may generally still require arbitration despite AB 51, and once an arbitration agreement is actually formed it may be enforced. AB 51 continues to have force in narrow situations outside the FAA's scope, but employees should assume that an otherwise valid, FAA-governed arbitration agreement will be enforceable even though AB 51 purported to prohibit it. This interplay is complex and fast-moving, so workers should get current advice; see also our discussion of representative actions in PAGA claims after Viking River and Adolph.

Delegation Clauses and Who Decides Enforceability

Modern arbitration agreements frequently contain a delegation clause, a provision stating that the arbitrator, rather than a court, will decide threshold questions of arbitrability, including whether the agreement itself is enforceable. Under the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 2, and the case law interpreting it, a clear and unmistakable delegation clause can require that even challenges to the agreement's validity be decided by the arbitrator. This can be a significant hurdle for an employee seeking to have a court rule the agreement unconscionable.

California courts, however, apply the ordinary principles of contract law, including unconscionability, to delegation clauses themselves. A delegation clause that is itself unconscionable, or that is not clearly and unmistakably delegated, will not strip the court of its authority to decide enforceability. An employee challenging an agreement should therefore consider whether to attack the delegation clause specifically, in addition to the agreement as a whole, because the two inquiries are analytically distinct. Skilled framing of the challenge can determine whether a court or an arbitrator decides the fairness of the agreement.

Arbitration Fees and the Risk of Default Under Section 1281.98

California has enacted procedural protections aimed at employers who compel arbitration and then fail to pay the required fees. Under the California Arbitration Act, when an employer that drafted a mandatory arbitration agreement fails to pay its share of the arbitration fees within the statutory window after they are due, the employer may be deemed to be in material breach of the arbitration agreement and in default. The consequence can be dramatic: the employee may elect to withdraw the claim from arbitration and proceed in court, and the employer may face monetary sanctions.

These fee-payment rules reinforce the Armendariz principle that an employer compelling arbitration of statutory claims must bear the unique costs of the forum it chose. An employer cannot force a worker into arbitration and then stall the proceeding by refusing to pay. For employees, this is a meaningful safeguard against being trapped in a private forum that the employer declines to fund. Workers should keep careful records of fee invoices and payment deadlines so that any default can be promptly asserted.

What California Workers Should Do When Asked to Sign

A worker presented with an arbitration agreement should not assume it is unenforceable, but should also not assume every term will hold up. The right approach is to read the agreement carefully, note whether it satisfies the Armendariz minimums, and preserve a copy. If a dispute later arises, an employment attorney can evaluate whether the agreement is unconscionable, whether individual provisions should be severed, and whether the agreement falls within or outside the FAA. Even a signed agreement may be vulnerable if it fails the Armendariz standard or is permeated with unconscionable terms, and the existence of an arbitration agreement does not eliminate substantive statutory rights under the Fair Employment and Housing Act or the Labor Code.

It is also worth understanding what arbitration does and does not change in practical terms. In arbitration you still present evidence, call witnesses, and argue the law, but you do so before a private decision-maker in a confidential proceeding rather than a public courtroom, and the right to appeal an adverse award is narrow. For some workers a faster, less formal process is an advantage; for others the loss of a jury and of robust appellate review is a serious cost. Because these trade-offs depend on the specific claim and the specific agreement, an individualized assessment is always preferable to a blanket assumption that arbitration is either good or bad.

Finally, an employee should never let the mere existence of an arbitration clause discourage them from asserting their rights. The clause determines the forum, not whether the employer violated the law. Statutes such as the Fair Employment and Housing Act and the Labor Code remain fully enforceable in arbitration, the Armendariz requirements guarantee a fair process for statutory claims, and California law supplies tools to invalidate unconscionable terms and to penalize employers who refuse to fund the arbitration they demanded. A worker who understands these protections can approach an arbitration agreement with confidence rather than resignation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my employer force me to sign an arbitration agreement to keep my job?

Labor Code § 432.6 purported to prohibit forced arbitration as a condition of employment, but the Ninth Circuit held that the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 2, preempts that prohibition for agreements within the FAA's reach. In practice, an FAA-governed arbitration agreement is generally enforceable even though AB 51 tried to ban it. You should still have the agreement reviewed, because unconscionable terms may be unenforceable.

What makes an arbitration agreement unenforceable in California?

Under Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare Services, Inc. (2000) 24 Cal.4th 83, an agreement covering statutory claims must provide a neutral arbitrator, adequate discovery, a written award, all statutory remedies, and employer payment of unique arbitration costs. An agreement that fails these requirements, or that is both procedurally and substantively unconscionable, may be struck down in whole or in part.

What is unconscionability?

Unconscionability has two prongs. Procedural unconscionability concerns oppression and surprise in how the agreement was formed, such as a take-it-or-leave-it presentation. Substantive unconscionability concerns overly harsh, one-sided terms, such as a lack of mutuality. California courts apply these on a sliding scale, and an agreement permeated with unlawful terms may be voided entirely.

Does arbitration mean I lose my discrimination claim?

No. Arbitration changes the forum, not the substance of your rights. Under Armendariz, the arbitrator must be able to award all remedies available in court, including statutory remedies under the Fair Employment and Housing Act. You can still prove discrimination and recover damages; the case is simply heard by an arbitrator rather than a jury.

Who pays for the arbitration?

Under Armendariz, when an employer compels arbitration of unwaivable statutory claims, the employer must bear the costs unique to arbitration, such as the arbitrator's fees. An agreement that forces the employee to split those forum costs is a common ground for finding the agreement unenforceable.

If you believe your employer has violated California labor or civil rights law, the Trembach Law Firm can help you understand your rights and options. Attorney Anatolii Trembach represents California workers in wage, discrimination, retaliation, and contract disputes. Call (213) 645-2246 today for a free, confidential consultation.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301