CUSTOMS COMPLIANCE | 2026-11-15
The Harbor Maintenance Tax: What California Importers Owe, Why Exports Are Exempt, and How Refunds Work After U.S. Shoe
How the Harbor Maintenance Tax applies to imported and domestic cargo, why the Supreme Court struck it down as applied to exports, and how the refund and protest process works
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
Every California company that brings ocean cargo through the Ports of Los Angeles, Long Beach, Oakland, or any other U.S. port pays a fee most importers barely notice on their entry paperwork: the Harbor Maintenance Tax. Assessed as a small percentage of cargo value, the Harbor Maintenance Tax...
What the Harbor Maintenance Tax Is
The Harbor Maintenance Tax (HMT) is a federal charge imposed under 26 U.S.C. § 4461 on the use of certain ports for the commercial movement of cargo. It was enacted as part of the Water Resources Development Act of 1986 to fund the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund, which pays for the dredging and upkeep of the nation navigable harbors. The tax is assessed at a rate of 0.125 percent of the value of the commercial cargo — that is, $1.25 per $1,000 of cargo value — and it applies to port use in connection with imports, certain domestic movements, and cargo loaded or unloaded at a port subject to the tax. U.S. Customs and Border Protection collects the HMT on imported cargo at the time of entry, which is why it appears as a line item alongside duties and the Merchandise Processing Fee on an importer's entry summary.
Congress labeled the HMT a tax on port use and placed it in the Internal Revenue Code, but the government defended it as a user fee keyed to the value of cargo using the harbors. That characterization matters, because the constitutional treatment of a tax differs from that of a true user fee, and the distinction became central to the most important case in the HMT story.
Why Exports Are Exempt: United States v. U.S. Shoe
The single most consequential development in the law of the Harbor Maintenance Tax was the Supreme Court decision in United States v. United States Shoe Corp., 523 U.S. 360 (1998). The Court held that the Harbor Maintenance Tax, as applied to exports, is unconstitutional because it violates the Export Clause of the Constitution, Article I, Section 9, Clause 5, which provides that "No Tax or Duty shall be laid on Articles exported from any State." The government had argued that the HMT was a permissible user fee rather than a tax on exports, but the Court concluded that the charge did not qualify as a user fee: it was assessed on cargo value rather than tied to the services or benefits the exporter actually received from the harbor, so it operated as a tax on exports that the Export Clause forbids. After U.S. Shoe, the Harbor Maintenance Tax is not collected on exported cargo.
The decision did not invalidate the HMT as applied to imports. The Export Clause by its terms restrains only taxes on exports; it does not limit charges on imported goods, which are instead governed by Congress broad power to tax imports. So the practical result of U.S. Shoe is a split regime: exports are exempt from the HMT on constitutional grounds, while imports remain subject to it. For a California company that both imports and exports, this means the HMT is a cost of importing but not of exporting.
How the HMT Applies to Imports and Domestic Cargo
For imported cargo, the Harbor Maintenance Tax is assessed at 0.125 percent of the cargo value and collected by CBP at entry. The value used is generally the value of the cargo as entered, and the fee is paid by the importer of record along with duties and other charges. For domestic cargo — movements of cargo between U.S. ports — the HMT also applies in defined circumstances, with the fee paid by the shipper to CBP on a quarterly basis using CBP Form 349, as provided by the governing regulations. The regulations implementing the HMT appear in 19 C.F.R. § 24.24, which sets out the ports subject to the tax, the method of computing it, the exemptions, and the collection mechanics. Because the HMT turns on the use of a taxed port, the geography of a shipment matters: cargo moving through a port listed in the regulations is subject to the fee, while certain movements and certain ports are outside its scope.
Exemptions and Excluded Movements
Not all cargo that touches a U.S. port pays the Harbor Maintenance Tax. The statute and regulations exempt a number of movements. Exports are exempt as a constitutional matter after U.S. Shoe. Cargo moving to or from certain locations, bonded cargo in transit, and specified categories of goods may be exempt or outside the tax under the governing rules. The regulations in 19 C.F.R. § 24.24 enumerate the exemptions and the ports to which the tax applies, and CBP guidance addresses particular situations. Because the exemptions are specific and technical, a California importer that handles mixed cargo — some dutiable, some in transit, some destined for further export — should confirm the HMT treatment of each movement rather than assume the fee applies uniformly. Overpayment of the HMT on an exempt movement is recoverable, but only if the error is identified and a timely claim is made.
The HMT Compared to the Merchandise Processing Fee
Importers frequently confuse the Harbor Maintenance Tax with the Merchandise Processing Fee (MPF), because both are federal charges collected by CBP at entry and both are calculated as a percentage of value. They are distinct. The MPF is an ad valorem processing fee with a statutory minimum and maximum per entry, applies to formal entries regardless of mode of transport, and is waived for goods qualifying under certain free trade agreements. The HMT, by contrast, is tied specifically to the use of ports for waterborne cargo, has no per-entry cap, applies only to cargo moving by water through taxed ports, and — unlike the MPF — does not have the same free trade agreement exemptions. A California importer evaluating landed cost must account for both charges separately, and a refund analysis must distinguish which fee was assessed and on what basis, because the rules for recovering an overpaid HMT differ from those for the MPF.
Refunds and Protests When the HMT Is Wrongly Assessed
When the Harbor Maintenance Tax has been paid on cargo that was exempt — most clearly, on an export after U.S. Shoe, but also on other exempt movements — the payer may seek a refund. The path to recovery depends on the nature of the claim. For HMT collected on imports as part of the entry, the ordinary customs remedies apply: the importer may be able to challenge the assessment through the protest process under 19 U.S.C. § 1514 and, if the protest is denied, bring an action at the Court of International Trade, ideally with guidance from a Los Angeles customs and international trade attorney. Where Customs merely collects the tax without making a protestable decision, the Supreme Court in U.S. Shoe recognized that the challenge belongs under the Court of International Trade residual jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C. § 1581(i). For the export refunds that followed U.S. Shoe, the government established procedures for exporters to claim back HMT paid on exports, and the Court of International Trade handled extensive litigation over the scope and mechanics of those refunds. The key practical point is that refund rights are subject to time limits and procedural requirements; an importer or exporter that identifies an erroneous HMT assessment should act promptly, because a stale claim can be lost regardless of its merits.
The Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund and Policy Debates
The Harbor Maintenance Tax feeds the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund, which Congress intended to pay for harbor dredging and maintenance. Over the years, the relationship between the revenue collected and the amounts actually spent on harbor maintenance has been the subject of policy debate, and legislative proposals have periodically sought to change how the fund is used or how the tax is structured. For a California importer, these policy debates matter less than the current rules, but they are worth watching because changes to the HMT regime — rates, exemptions, or the treatment of particular movements — can affect landed cost. The constitutional baseline from U.S. Shoe is stable: exports cannot be taxed. Within that baseline, the statutory and regulatory details can and do change, which is another reason to treat HMT compliance as an ongoing matter rather than a settled one.
Practical Compliance for California Importers
For a California business moving cargo by water, sound HMT practice has several components. First, verify that the HMT is being correctly assessed on imports and that it is not being charged on exempt movements, including exports. Second, reconcile the HMT and MPF line items on entry summaries against the governing rules, because an error in either can recur across many entries and compound. Third, preserve the records needed to support a refund claim — entry documents, proof of export, and evidence of the cargo value and movement — so that an overpayment can be recovered within the applicable time limits. Fourth, treat any change in sourcing, routing, or port of entry as an occasion to reconfirm HMT treatment, because the tax turns on the use of taxed ports and the nature of the movement. Importers who want help can consult attorneys experienced in customs and trade compliance.
How the HMT Fits the Broader Customs Picture
The Harbor Maintenance Tax is one of several charges that together make up the true cost of importing: the ordinary duty determined by tariff classification and valuation, the Merchandise Processing Fee, the HMT on waterborne cargo, and, for goods subject to trade remedies, antidumping or countervailing duties and Section 301 or Section 232 tariffs. A California importer that manages only the headline duty rate, without accounting for the HMT and the other fees, will understate its landed cost and may miss refund opportunities. The HMT also illustrates a recurring theme in customs law: a charge can be challenged on constitutional or statutory grounds, as U.S. Shoe showed, and importers who understand the legal basis for a fee are better positioned to recognize when it has been wrongly assessed. For broader coverage, see our international trade and customs news.
Who Pays the HMT and Who Can Claim a Refund
Identifying the correct party is important both for compliance and for refunds. For imported cargo, the importer of record pays the Harbor Maintenance Tax to CBP as part of the entry, and it is the importer that would ordinarily pursue a refund of an HMT overpayment on an import through the protest process. For exports, before U.S. Shoe ended the practice, the exporter paid the HMT, and it was exporters who claimed refunds under the procedures established after the decision. For domestic movements, the party responsible depends on the nature of the shipment and the governing rules. Because the HMT can be paid by different parties depending on the movement, a company that both imports and exports must understand which of its transactions carried the fee, who paid it, and on what basis, before it can assess whether a refund is available.
A refund claim also depends on documentation. To recover an HMT overpayment, the claimant must be able to show that the fee was paid, that the cargo fell within an exemption or that the assessment was otherwise erroneous, and that the claim is timely. For an export refund, that meant proving the export; for an erroneous import assessment, it means establishing the basis for the exemption and following the protest procedure under 19 U.S.C. § 1514 within the statutory period. Because the records needed to support a refund — entry summaries, bills of lading, proof of export, and valuation documents — are generated at the time of the transaction, a company that maintains good records is far better positioned to recover an overpayment than one that must reconstruct the transaction years later. The practical discipline is to treat HMT line items as items to verify, not merely to pay, so that an erroneous assessment is caught while the records to challenge it are still at hand.
Related Guides
For related reading, see our international trade and customs news, and learn more about the firm's work in customs and trade defense and antidumping and countervailing duty defense.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Harbor Maintenance Tax?
It is a federal charge under 26 U.S.C. § 4461, assessed at 0.125 percent of cargo value, on the use of certain ports for the commercial movement of cargo. It funds the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund for harbor dredging and maintenance, and CBP collects it on imports at entry.
Do I pay the HMT on exports?
No. In United States v. U.S. Shoe Corp., 523 U.S. 360 (1998), the Supreme Court held the HMT unconstitutional as applied to exports under the Export Clause. The HMT is not collected on exported cargo; it still applies to imports and certain domestic movements.
Why are exports exempt but imports not?
The Export Clause (Article I, Section 9, Clause 5) forbids any tax on articles exported from a state, and the Court found the HMT operated as such a tax rather than a true user fee. The Export Clause does not restrain charges on imports, which Congress has broad power to tax, so the HMT remains valid as applied to imported cargo.
How much is the HMT?
It is 0.125 percent of the cargo value — $1.25 per $1,000 — with no per-entry cap. For high-value or high-volume cargo, it can be a meaningful cost, which is why verifying correct assessment matters.
How is the HMT different from the Merchandise Processing Fee?
The MPF is a processing fee on formal entries with a statutory minimum and maximum per entry, applies regardless of transport mode, and is waived for certain free trade agreement goods. The HMT applies only to waterborne cargo through taxed ports, has no cap, and does not share the MPF free trade agreement exemptions.
Can I get a refund if the HMT was charged in error?
Yes, subject to procedure and time limits. For HMT on imports, the customs protest process under 19 U.S.C. § 1514 and, if denied, an action at the Court of International Trade are the usual routes. For HMT paid on exports before the practice stopped, CBP established refund procedures, and the Court of International Trade handled extensive litigation over those refunds.
Where are the HMT rules found?
The statute is 26 U.S.C. §§ 4461–4462, and the implementing regulations are in 19 C.F.R. § 24.24, which lists the taxed ports, the computation method, the exemptions, and the collection mechanics.
Does the HMT apply to cargo moving by truck or air?
No. The HMT is tied to the use of ports for waterborne cargo. Cargo moving by truck or air is not subject to the HMT, though it may be subject to the Merchandise Processing Fee and ordinary duties. The mode and routing of a shipment determine HMT exposure.
Speak With a California Customs and Trade Attorney
If your company moves cargo through California ports and you want to confirm that the Harbor Maintenance Tax is being correctly assessed — or recover an overpayment on exempt cargo — Trembach Law Firm can help. We advise on HMT compliance, the interaction of the HMT with the Merchandise Processing Fee and duties, and refund and protest claims at the Court of International Trade. For a consultation, call (213) 645-2246. Because the HMT is a recurring cost that can be wrongly assessed and is recoverable only within time limits, careful attention to it is a practical step every California importer and exporter should take.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301