INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR | 2026-10-28
Independent Contractor Exemptions and Borello Test California 2026
When AB 5 exemptions remove a worker from the ABC test and return classification to the Borello multifactor control standard in California.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
The ABC test is the default rule for classifying California workers, but a long list of exemptions in Labor Code sections 2776 through 2784 removes certain relationships from that test entirely. When an exemption applies, classification returns to the older Borello multifactor control standard, whic
Why Some California Contractors Are Judged Under Borello, Not the ABC Test
The ABC test is the starting point for classifying workers in California, but the Legislature recognized that a rigid three-prong rule could not fairly capture every working relationship. When it codified and refined AB 5, it wrote a substantial list of exemptions into Labor Code §§ 2776-2784. For a relationship that fits one of those exemptions, the ABC test does not apply at all. Instead, classification returns to the older multifactor control standard from S.G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341.
This distinction matters enormously. The ABC test, adopted in Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court (2018) 4 Cal.5th 903, is difficult for businesses to satisfy because prong B disqualifies anyone performing work within the hiring entity's usual course of business. The Borello standard asks a more flexible question, so whether an exemption applies is frequently the single most important issue in a classification dispute.
The Professional Services Exemption
Labor Code § 2778 exempts specified professional services from the ABC test, including categories such as marketing, human-resources administration, travel agents, graphic design, grant writing, fine artists, certain licensed professionals, and freelance writers and photographers subject to conditions the statute sets out. To qualify, the worker must generally maintain a business location separate from the hiring entity, hold any required business license, negotiate rates, set hours outside project deadlines, and be free to work for others.
These conditions are not optional. A business claiming the professional-services exemption must be able to show that each statutory condition is met, because failing the conditions puts the relationship back under the ABC test where prong B is likely to be fatal.
The Business-to-Business Exemption
One of the most important exemptions is the business-to-business contracting relationship in Labor Code § 2776. It applies when a bona fide business entity contracts to provide services to another business, rather than to an individual, and the service provider meets a detailed list of conditions. Among them, the contracting business must:
- Be free from the control and direction of the contracting business in performing the work;
- Provide services directly to the contracting business rather than to its customers;
- Have a written contract;
- Maintain any required business license or tax registration;
- Maintain a business location separate from the contracting business;
- Actually be customarily engaged in an independently established business of the same nature;
- Advertise and hold itself out to other potential customers;
- Provide its own tools and set its own rates.
Every one of these twelve statutory conditions must be satisfied. The B2B exemption is not a general permission to avoid the ABC test; it is a narrow safe harbor for genuine company-to-company relationships, and it does not apply to an individual worker providing services to the public through a business.
Referral Agencies and Other Specified Occupations
Labor Code § 2777 provides a referral-agency exemption for relationships between a referral agency and a service provider that offers services to clients through that agency, such as certain graphic design, tutoring, event planning, or home-cleaning services, again subject to a list of conditions. Additional provisions in §§ 2779-2784 address motor-club services, construction subcontracting, data aggregators, and other specified relationships. Each carries its own conditions, and each must be analyzed on its own terms.
No Single Exemption Covers Everyone in an Occupation
A frequent error is to assume that because an occupation appears somewhere in the AB 5 exemptions, every worker in that occupation is automatically exempt. The exemptions do not work that way. Each one attaches conditions to the particular relationship, and the same type of worker may be exempt in one engagement and covered by the ABC test in another depending on how the relationship is structured. A photographer who markets to many clients, sets rates, and controls the work may fall within the professional-services exemption, while a photographer engaged to shoot a company's products on a fixed schedule under the company's direction may not. The analysis is always relationship-specific, never occupation-wide.
How the Borello Test Actually Works
When an exemption applies and Borello governs, 48 Cal.3d 341 directs courts to treat the right to control the manner and means of accomplishing the work as the principal factor. But the control factor is not the only consideration. The court also weighs a set of secondary factors:
- Whether the worker is engaged in a distinct occupation or business;
- Whether the work is usually done under the principal's direction or by a specialist without supervision;
- The skill required in the occupation;
- Whether the worker or the principal supplies the tools and the place of work;
- The length of time the services are performed;
- The method of payment, by time or by the job;
- Whether the work is part of the principal's regular business;
- Whether the parties believe they are creating an employer-employee relationship.
No single secondary factor is decisive. A court weighs them together with the control inquiry to reach a conclusion about economic reality. Because the test is holistic, it offers businesses more room to establish genuine contractor status than the all-or-nothing ABC prongs do.
Structuring a Lawful Contractor Relationship
A business that wants to engage a true independent contractor should start by confirming which test applies. If no exemption fits, the ABC test governs and the analysis is driven by prongs B and C, which no contract language can cure. If an exemption does fit, the business should document compliance with every statutory condition and then structure the relationship to satisfy the Borello control factor.
In practice, that means refraining from dictating the manner and means of the work, allowing the contractor genuine independence over scheduling and methods, ensuring the contractor serves other clients, and avoiding integrating the contractor into the day-to-day supervisory structure as if the person were an employee. Our companion guide to the ABC test and AB 5 worker classification explains the default framework that applies when no exemption is available.
What Happens If the Exemption Fails
Claiming an exemption that does not actually apply is a common and costly mistake. If a business treats a worker as an exempt contractor but cannot prove every condition of the claimed exemption, the relationship falls back to the ABC test. At that point the business must satisfy all three prongs, and if the worker performs services within the usual course of the business, prong B defeats the classification. The result is the same liability a misclassified employee can recover: unpaid wages, overtime, meal and rest premiums, expense reimbursement, and penalties.
Burden of Proof and Documentation
Whether the dispute is resolved under the ABC test or under Borello, the hiring entity bears the burden of justifying contractor status. That is why documentation is not a formality. Written contracts, evidence of the contractor's separate business, licenses, insurance, marketing to other clients, and records showing the contractor controlled the work are the proof that decides close cases. Workers challenging a classification should gather the opposite evidence: records of the control the company exercised, the absence of other clients, and the integration of their role into the company's operations.
The Construction Subcontractor Exemption
Labor Code § 2781 addresses the relationship between a contractor and an individual performing work pursuant to a subcontract in the construction industry. When the detailed conditions of that section are met, the relationship is governed by Borello rather than the ABC test. The conditions include that the subcontract be in writing, that the subcontractor be licensed by the Contractors State License Board where required, that the subcontractor maintain a business location separate from the contractor, and that the subcontractor have the authority to hire and fire other persons to perform the work. The construction context carries its own layered statutory requirements, so businesses in this sector should confirm compliance with each condition before relying on the exemption.
The Single-Engagement and Professional Conditions in Detail
Several exemptions turn on whether the worker genuinely operates as an independent business rather than a disguised employee. The professional-services exemption in Labor Code § 2778, for example, generally requires that the individual maintain a business location separate from the hiring entity, which may be the individual's residence; hold any required business license or professional license; have the ability to set or negotiate rates; outside of project completion dates, have the ability to set hours; be customarily engaged in the same type of work with other clients or hold themselves out to other potential customers; and customarily and regularly exercise discretion and independent judgment in the performance of the services. These are conjunctive conditions, and a hiring entity that cannot establish each one loses the exemption.
The recurring theme across every exemption is independence proven by conduct, not recited by contract. A worker who serves only one client, works from the client's premises, uses the client's tools, and cannot negotiate rates will not satisfy the exemption conditions no matter how the agreement is captioned.
Why the Choice of Test Decides Most Disputes
The difference between the ABC test and Borello is often outcome-determinative. Under the ABC test, prong B asks whether the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business. For a worker performing the company's core service, the answer is no, and the classification fails regardless of how much independence the worker enjoys. Under Borello, by contrast, a worker performing the company's regular work can still be an independent contractor if the control factor and secondary factors point that way. That is why establishing an exemption is frequently the whole ballgame: it moves the case from a test the business usually loses to one it can win.
For a full explanation of how the ABC prongs operate when no exemption applies, and the consequences of getting classification wrong, see our companion guide on California employment law news and the related classification coverage.
Audit Checklist for Businesses Relying on an Exemption
A business that intends to treat a worker as an exempt contractor should build and preserve a file documenting each element of the exemption it is claiming. That file should typically include:
- A written contract that accurately describes an arm's-length business relationship;
- Evidence of the contractor's separate business location, licenses, and tax registrations;
- Proof that the contractor markets to and serves other clients;
- Records showing the contractor supplies its own tools and sets its own rates;
- Documentation that the contractor controls the manner and means of the work.
Because the burden of justifying contractor status rests on the business, the absence of this documentation is itself a serious risk. A contemporaneous record created while the relationship is healthy is far more persuasive than explanations constructed after a dispute arises.
The Referral Agency Exemption in Practice
Labor Code § 2777 exempts certain relationships between a referral agency and a service provider that uses the agency to connect with clients, covering listed services such as graphic design, photography, tutoring, consulting, youth sports coaching, caddying, wedding or event planning, minor home repair, moving, home cleaning, errands, furniture assembly, animal services, dog walking and grooming, picture hanging, pool cleaning, and yard cleanup. To qualify, the service provider must meet conditions including being free from the agency's control, maintaining any required licenses, delivering services under its own name rather than the agency's, providing its own tools, being free to maintain a clientele without restriction, setting its own rates, and being customarily engaged in an independently established business. The exemption is carefully bounded, and a relationship that departs from the listed services or fails a condition falls back to the ABC test.
The referral-agency exemption illustrates the Legislature's approach throughout AB 2257: it identifies specific, well-defined relationships where genuine independence is plausible and attaches detailed conditions designed to ensure the independence is real rather than nominal.
What Workers Should Do If They Suspect a False Exemption
A worker told that an exemption makes them an independent contractor should not assume the label is correct simply because the company cites a statute. The exemptions in Labor Code §§ 2776-2784 all require specific, provable conditions, and a company's say-so does not establish them. A worker who serves only one client, works under close direction, uses the company's equipment, and cannot negotiate rates is unlikely to fit any exemption, and the relationship almost certainly reverts to the ABC test. Workers in this position should preserve their contracts, pay records, schedules, and any communications showing how the work was directed, because this evidence determines both whether an exemption applies and, if it does not, how the ABC prongs resolve.
It is also worth remembering that the burden never shifts to the worker. In any forum, the hiring entity must prove both that an exemption applies and that the applicable test is satisfied. A worker who believes an exemption has been invoked incorrectly can challenge the classification through a wage claim, a civil action, or a representative PAGA action, and can recover the same wages, overtime, break premiums, expense reimbursement, and penalties available to any misclassified employee. The fact that a contract recites that an exemption applies, or that the worker signed an acknowledgment of contractor status, does not relieve the business of its burden or bar the worker from challenging the classification later.
Consequences of Relying on the Wrong Test
When a business applies Borello to a relationship that is actually governed by the ABC test, the error is costly. If an exemption does not apply, prong B typically controls, and a worker performing the company's core service is an employee regardless of how the Borello factors would come out. The business then faces the full suite of wage-and-hour liability: unpaid minimum wage and overtime, meal and rest premiums, reimbursement of business expenses under Labor Code § 2802, wage-statement and waiting-time penalties, and potential representative penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act. These remedies accrue per worker and per pay period, so an incorrect classification applied across a workforce can generate very large aggregate exposure. Confirming at the outset which test applies, and documenting the basis for any exemption, is the single most effective way to manage that risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
If my relationship is exempt from the ABC test, am I automatically a contractor?
No. An exemption only changes which test applies. If your relationship is exempt under Labor Code §§ 2776-2784, classification is then decided under S.G. Borello & Sons (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341. You can still be found to be an employee under that multifactor control test.
What is the difference between the professional-services and business-to-business exemptions?
The professional-services exemption in Labor Code § 2778 covers individuals in specified occupations who meet listed conditions. The business-to-business exemption in § 2776 covers contracting between two bona fide business entities and requires a separate, longer list of conditions, including that the provider serve the contracting business rather than its customers.
Does a written contract satisfy the B2B exemption by itself?
No. A written contract is only one of the required conditions in Labor Code § 2776. The provider must also maintain a separate business location, hold required licenses, serve other clients, provide its own tools, and meet every other listed condition. Missing any one condition defeats the exemption.
Is the Borello test easier to pass than the ABC test?
Generally yes for businesses, because Borello weighs the right to control plus secondary factors holistically rather than imposing the rigid prong B requirement that work fall outside the hiring entity's usual course of business.
Who decides whether an exemption applies?
If the classification is challenged, a court or the Labor Commissioner decides, and the hiring entity carries the burden of proving the exemption's conditions are met. A good-faith belief that an exemption applies does not excuse liability if the conditions are not actually satisfied.
If you are unsure whether your contractor relationship qualifies for an AB 5 exemption or should be analyzed under Borello, Trembach Law Firm can evaluate the facts and the statutory conditions that control your classification. Call attorney Anatolii Trembach at (213) 645-2246 for a free consultation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301