PERSONAL INJURY | 2026-11-17
When an Insurer Can Recover Defense Costs: The Buss Rule, Mixed Actions, and the Duty to Defend in California
How California requires a liability insurer to defend an entire mixed action but allows it to seek reimbursement of the costs of defending claims that were never even potentially covered, and the limits the Buss rule places on that right
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California law imposes one of the broadest duties to defend in the country: a liability insurer must defend its insured against an entire lawsuit if even one claim in it is potentially covered, even though other claims are plainly outside the policy. But that breadth raises a hard question — if the insurer must defend claims that were never covered at all, can it later recover the money it spent defending those uncovered claims? The California Supreme Court answered that question in a decision t
California's Broad Duty to Defend
California imposes an expansive duty to defend on liability insurers. Under the rule the California Supreme Court established in Gray v. Zurich Insurance Co., 65 Cal.2d 263 (1966), and reaffirmed many times, an insurer must defend its insured whenever the underlying lawsuit presents the potential for coverage — that is, whenever the facts alleged or known raise even the possibility that the claim falls within the policy. The duty to defend is broader than the duty to indemnify: an insurer may have to defend a suit even if it ultimately turns out there is no coverage and no obligation to pay, because the duty to defend is measured by the potential for coverage, not by the eventual outcome. This broad duty protects insureds, ensuring they are not left to fund their own defense while a coverage dispute is resolved. But it also creates a structural tension when a lawsuit contains a mix of covered and uncovered claims.
The Mixed Action Problem
A mixed action is a lawsuit that contains both claims that are at least potentially covered by the policy and claims that are not covered at all — not even potentially. California's broad duty-to-defend rule means that if even one claim in the action is potentially covered, the insurer must defend the entire action, including the claims that are plainly outside the policy, because the defense cannot practically be split claim by claim while the litigation proceeds. This creates the problem the Buss rule addresses: the insurer is compelled to pay for defending claims it never agreed to cover and that were never even potentially within the policy. The question is whether, having fulfilled its duty to defend the whole action, the insurer can later recover the portion of its defense costs attributable solely to the claims that were never covered.
The Buss Rule: Reimbursement for Never-Covered Claims
The California Supreme Court resolved this in Buss v. Superior Court, 16 Cal.4th 35 (1997). The Court held two things. First, consistent with the broad duty to defend, the insurer must defend the entire mixed action — it cannot refuse to defend the uncovered claims while the covered claim remains in the case, because a meaningful defense must be immediate, an immediate defense must be complete, and the insurer cannot parse the claims while the case proceeds. Second, and crucially, the Court held that the insurer may seek reimbursement from the insured for the defense costs attributable solely to the claims that were never even potentially covered. The Court explained that the duty to defend the entire action is imposed by law prophylactically, in support of the policy: to defend meaningfully the insurer must defend immediately, and to defend immediately it must defend entirely. The reimbursement right, by contrast, is not found in the policy; the Court held it is implied in law as quasi-contractual, grounded in restitution. As to the potentially covered claims, the insurer defends because it agreed to; but as to the claims that were never potentially covered, the insurer has no contractual obligation, and allowing the insured to keep the benefit of a defense it never paid for would unjustly enrich the insured at the insurer's expense. Buss thus struck a balance: the insured gets the complete, immediate defense the broad duty requires, but the insurer can recoup the cost of defending claims that were entirely outside the policy.
The Key Limit: Only Claims Never Even Potentially Covered
The most important limit in Buss is what the insurer may recover. Reimbursement is available only for the costs of defending claims that were never even potentially covered — claims entirely outside the policy from the outset. The insurer may not recover the cost of defending claims that were potentially covered, even if the potential for coverage is later eliminated, because the duty to defend potentially covered claims is exactly what the insurer agreed to provide. This distinction is decisive. If a claim was genuinely potentially covered when the duty to defend arose, later developments that defeat coverage end the duty only prospectively, and the insurer cannot recoup what it spent while the potential existed. The California Supreme Court refined this in Scottsdale Ins. Co. v. MV Transportation, 36 Cal.4th 643 (2005): an insurer that properly reserved its rights may recoup the defense costs it advanced if it is determined, as a matter of law, that no duty to defend ever arose because the action never presented a potential for coverage. The line is therefore between a potential for coverage that actually existed and later disappeared (no reimbursement) and one that never existed at all (reimbursement may be available). The practical effect is that the insurer's right to reimbursement is narrow, confined to the defense costs that can be attributed solely to claims that had no possibility of coverage. Many defense costs in a mixed action are common to both the covered and uncovered claims — the same discovery, the same witnesses, the same motions — and those common costs are not recoverable, because they would have been incurred in defending the potentially covered claims regardless.
The Insurer's Burden to Prove Allocation
Because reimbursement is limited to costs attributable solely to never-covered claims, the allocation of defense costs is central, and Buss places the burden on the insurer. The insurer seeking reimbursement must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the specific defense costs it seeks to recover were incurred solely in defense of the claims that were never even potentially covered — and were not costs that would have been incurred anyway in defending the potentially covered claims. This is a demanding showing. Litigation defense is rarely neatly divisible; much of the work serves the defense of all claims at once. The insurer cannot recover for that shared work, and it bears the burden of isolating the costs that are genuinely attributable to the uncovered claims alone. The difficulty of making this allocation is, in practice, a significant constraint on the insurer's reimbursement right, because the insurer often cannot carry its burden of separating the solely-uncovered costs from the common costs.
Reservation of Rights and Notice
An insurer that wishes to preserve a reimbursement right typically does so by defending under a reservation of rights and giving the insured notice that it intends to seek reimbursement of the costs of defending non-covered claims. Buss itself observed that, because the reimbursement right belongs to the insurer, the insurer may reserve it unilaterally, and that the reservation gives the insured notice of how the insurer may proceed; Scottsdale likewise conditioned recoupment on a proper reservation of rights. By defending under a reservation and notifying the insured of its reimbursement position, the insurer avoids the argument that it waived the right or that the insured was misled into believing the defense was being provided without any possibility of a reimbursement claim. The reservation-of-rights and notice practice is thus an important procedural feature of the Buss framework: it informs the insured that, while the insurer is honoring its broad duty to defend the whole action, it may later seek to recover the portion attributable solely to claims that were never covered. An insured that receives such a reservation should understand that a reimbursement demand may follow and should be alert to the allocation question — specifically, whether the costs the insurer seeks to recover are truly attributable solely to never-covered claims or are common costs that are not recoverable.
Interaction with Independent Cumis Counsel
The Buss framework interacts with the rules governing independent counsel. When an insurer defends under a reservation of rights that creates a conflict of interest between the insurer and the insured, California law — under Civil Code section 2860 and the Cumis line of authority — may entitle the insured to independent counsel paid by the insurer (San Diego Navy Federal Credit Union v. Cumis Ins. Society, Inc., 162 Cal.App.3d 358 (1984)). Section 2860(b) sets the line: no conflict exists as to allegations or facts for which the insurer simply denies coverage, but when the insurer reserves its rights on a coverage issue whose outcome can be controlled by the defense counsel the insurer retained, a conflict may exist. A claim for punitive damages, or a suit seeking more than the policy limits, does not by itself create a conflict. The insured may waive independent counsel in writing, and section 2860 also limits the rates the insurer must pay that counsel. The interplay matters because the same mixed-action situation that gives rise to the insurer's potential reimbursement right under Buss may also give rise to the insured's right to independent counsel under section 2860. The two doctrines address different aspects of the same problem: Cumis addresses who controls the defense when a conflict exists, while Buss addresses who ultimately pays for defending the never-covered claims. An insured navigating a reservation of rights should understand both, which is where guidance from counsel experienced with insurer coverage disputes is valuable.
Defense of the Whole Action Comes First
A point that is easy to lose in the reimbursement analysis is that the insurer must still defend — fully and immediately. Buss does not permit an insurer to decline or limit the defense of a mixed action on the theory that some claims are uncovered; the insurer's obligation to provide a complete defense of the entire action is unqualified while the potentially covered claim remains. The reimbursement right is a back-end remedy, asserted after the fact, not a basis for stinting on the defense. An insurer that fails to provide a complete defense breaches the duty to defend and exposes itself to the serious consequences that follow a defense breach in California, including potential liability for a resulting judgment and bad-faith exposure. The insured, therefore, is entitled to insist on a full defense of the whole action, with the reimbursement question reserved for later resolution — and the insured can contest that reimbursement claim on the ground that the costs sought were not solely attributable to never-covered claims.
Why the Buss Rule Matters for Policyholders
For a California policyholder, the Buss rule is a double-edged feature of the state's broad duty to defend. On the one hand, it preserves the policyholder's right to a complete and immediate defense of the entire action whenever any claim is potentially covered — a powerful protection. On the other hand, it exposes the policyholder to a potential reimbursement claim for the cost of defending claims that were never covered at all. The practical significance for policyholders lies in the limits on that reimbursement right: it reaches only costs attributable solely to never-covered claims, not potentially covered claims that fail, and not common costs; and the insurer bears the burden of proving the allocation. A policyholder facing a reimbursement demand should scrutinize whether the claims at issue were truly never even potentially covered and whether the costs sought are genuinely severable from the common defense. Understanding these limits is often the difference between a large reimbursement liability and a small one or none. In practice, the insurer's difficulty in disentangling the solely-uncovered costs from the shared defense means that many reimbursement demands, when tested against the Buss allocation standard, recover far less than the insurer initially claims — and sometimes nothing at all. For broader coverage, see our personal injury news.
Buss and the Broader Reimbursement Debate
The reasoning of Buss v. Superior Court, 16 Cal.4th 35 (1997), placed California in the middle of a national debate about whether insurers may recover defense costs at all. Some jurisdictions bar reimbursement entirely, reasoning that the insurer's duty to defend is part of what the premium bought and that allowing recoupment undermines the certainty of the defense. California, by contrast, permitted a limited reimbursement right grounded in restitution — but confined it carefully to costs attributable solely to claims never even potentially covered. The limit is what makes the California rule workable: it preserves the insured's right to a complete defense while preventing a windfall to the insured as to claims entirely outside the policy. It is important to distinguish Buss, which concerns defense costs in a mixed action, from the separate question of whether an insurer that pays a settlement or indemnity can seek reimbursement of amounts paid on non-covered claims, which raises different considerations. In Blue Ridge Ins. Co. v. Jacobsen, 25 Cal.4th 489 (2001), the California Supreme Court held that an insurer defending under a reservation of rights may, in some circumstances, seek reimbursement of a reasonable settlement paid over the insured's objection when the claims are later determined not to be covered; courts applying Blue Ridge look to whether the insurer made a timely and express reservation of rights, notified the insured of its intent to accept the settlement, and offered the insured the opportunity to assume its own defense. It is also distinct from the equitable contribution rules that govern how multiple insurers of the same risk share defense and indemnity costs among themselves. For the policyholder, the practical questions under Buss remain focused: were the claims at issue never even potentially covered, and can the insurer carry its burden of proving that the costs it seeks were incurred solely in their defense rather than shared with the covered claim. Where the answer to either is no, the reimbursement claim fails, which is why the allocation analysis is so often the decisive battleground.
Related Guides
For related reading, see our personal injury news, and learn more about the firm's work in California personal injury representation and handling claims against insurance companies.
- California Personal Injury Lawyers
- The Genuine Dispute Doctrine: When an Insurer's Denial Is Not Bad Faith in California
- When an Excess Insurer Sues the Primary: Equitable Subrogation for Breach of the Duty to Settle in California
- California Multi-Vehicle Accident Liability: Complete Guide 2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Buss rule?
In Buss v. Superior Court, 16 Cal.4th 35 (1997), the California Supreme Court held that an insurer must defend an entire mixed action if any claim is potentially covered, but may seek reimbursement from the insured for the cost of defending claims that were never even potentially covered.
What is a mixed action?
A mixed action is a lawsuit containing both claims that are at least potentially covered by the policy and claims that are not covered at all. Because California requires the insurer to defend the whole action if any claim is potentially covered, the insurer must defend the uncovered claims too.
Why does the insurer have to defend uncovered claims?
California's duty to defend is broad: if even one claim is potentially covered, the insurer must defend the entire action, because Buss holds that a meaningful defense must be immediate and an immediate defense must be complete; the insurer cannot parse the claims while the case proceeds. The duty to defend is broader than the duty to indemnify.
What costs can the insurer recover?
Only the costs that can be allocated solely to claims that were never even potentially covered — claims entirely outside the policy from the outset. The insurer cannot recover the cost of defending claims while they were genuinely potentially covered, even if coverage is later defeated, nor joint costs that served the defense of covered and uncovered claims alike. Under Scottsdale Ins. Co. v. MV Transportation (2005), if it is determined as a matter of law that no potential for coverage ever existed, an insurer that properly reserved its rights may recoup the defense costs it advanced.
Who proves the allocation of costs?
The insurer. It must prove by a preponderance that the costs it seeks were incurred solely in defense of the never-covered claims and were not costs that would have been incurred anyway in defending the potentially covered claims. This is a demanding showing because much defense work is shared.
How does the insurer preserve its reimbursement right?
Typically by defending under a reservation of rights and notifying the insured that it intends to seek reimbursement for the cost of defending non-covered claims. This avoids a waiver argument and informs the insured that a reimbursement demand may follow.
How does Buss relate to Cumis counsel?
A reservation of rights may create a conflict of interest entitling the insured to independent counsel under Civil Code section 2860 and the Cumis line of cases — generally when the insurer reserves rights on a coverage issue whose outcome the insurer-retained defense counsel could control. The same mixed-action situation can trigger both the insured's right to independent counsel (who controls the defense) and the insurer's potential reimbursement right under Buss (who ultimately pays for never-covered claims).
Can the insurer limit the defense because some claims are uncovered?
No. The insurer must provide a complete, immediate defense of the entire action while a potentially covered claim remains. Reimbursement is a back-end remedy asserted later, not a basis for stinting on the defense. Failing to provide a full defense breaches the duty to defend.
Speak With a California Insurance Coverage Attorney
If your insurer is defending you under a reservation of rights and has signaled that it may seek reimbursement of defense costs, or you face a reimbursement demand after a mixed action, Trembach Law Firm can help. We analyze whether the claims were potentially covered or never covered, contest the allocation of defense costs, and advise on the interaction of the duty to defend with independent counsel. For a consultation, call (213) 645-2246. Because the insurer's reimbursement right is narrow and the insurer bears the burden of proving the allocation, careful analysis can greatly limit a policyholder's exposure.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301