WORKER CLASSIFICATION | 2026-10-28
Joint Employer Liability After Martinez v Combs in California 2026
How staffing agencies and client businesses share liability for unpaid wages.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
When a staffing agency, labor contractor, or subcontractor fails to pay workers correctly, the business that benefited from the labor often says it was not the employer. California law does not let companies hide behind that arrangement. Through Labor Code 2810.3 and Martinez v. Combs, the state rec
Who Is Really Your Employer: Joint Liability Under California Law
When a staffing agency, labor contractor, or subcontractor fails to pay workers correctly, the business that benefited from the labor often tries to point the finger elsewhere and say it was not the employer. California law does not let companies hide behind that arrangement so easily. Through Labor Code § 2810.3 and the California Supreme Court decision in Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35, the state recognizes that more than one entity can be responsible for the wages of a single worker. This guide explains how joint and client-employer liability works, so that workers know whom they can hold accountable when their wages go unpaid.
Joint-employment questions arise across many industries, including warehousing, agriculture, janitorial services, hospitality, manufacturing, and construction, wherever one company supplies workers to another. Because the entity that signs the paychecks may be undercapitalized or may vanish, the ability to reach the client business that actually directed and benefited from the work can be the difference between recovering wages and recovering nothing. Our California employment law news page follows these developments closely.
Martinez v. Combs and the Three Definitions of Employ
The analytical heart of California joint-employment law is Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35. In that case the California Supreme Court examined what it means to employ someone for purposes of the state minimum wage law, drawing on the definitions embedded in the Industrial Welfare Commission wage orders. The Court held that to employ has three alternative meanings. First, to employ means to exercise control over the wages, hours, or working conditions of the worker. Second, it means to suffer or permit the worker to work. Third, it means to engage the worker, thereby creating a common law employment relationship.
The power of Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35 lies in the word alternative. A business can be an employer if it satisfies any one of these three tests, not only if it satisfies all of them. This means a company that does not sign the paychecks can still be an employer if it controls working conditions, or if it suffers or permits the work to occur, or if a common law employment relationship exists. The decision expanded the practical reach of wage liability well beyond the entity listed on the pay stub.
The Suffer or Permit to Work Standard
Among the three definitions, the suffer or permit to work standard is especially broad and is often decisive in joint-employment cases. The phrase has deep roots in the law and was historically aimed at reaching businesses that benefited from labor while trying to disclaim responsibility for it, including by using intermediaries. A business suffers or permits work when it has the power to prevent the work from occurring and yet allows it to proceed for the business's benefit. Under this standard, a company that knowingly accepts the fruits of a worker's labor cannot simply say that a separate contractor was the only employer.
The suffer or permit language captures situations where control in the narrow, direct-supervision sense may be hard to prove, but where the business plainly knew the work was being done for it and had the ability to stop it. This is why the standard matters so much to workers supplied through staffing agencies. Even if day-to-day supervision is shared or ambiguous, the client business that permitted the labor to proceed for its own benefit can fall within the definition of employer.
Labor Code § 2810.3: Client-Employer Shared Liability
California supplemented the case law with a powerful statute. Labor Code § 2810.3 provides that a client employer that obtains workers to perform labor within its usual course of business from a labor contractor shares with that labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for the payment of wages and for the failure to secure valid workers compensation coverage. In plain terms, when a business uses a staffing agency or labor contractor to supply workers for its regular operations, that business is on the hook alongside the contractor if the workers are not paid properly.
Section 2810.3 is significant because it does not require the worker to prove the fine details of control that a common law analysis might demand. If the client employer obtained the workers through a labor contractor to perform labor within the client's usual course of business, the statute imposes shared responsibility for wage payment by its own terms. The statute also prohibits a client employer from shifting to the labor contractor any legal duties or liabilities the client has under workplace safety laws, and it protects workers from retaliation for providing notice of violations or filing a claim.
What the Statute Covers and Its Limits
Section 2810.3 reaches the payment of wages, including the obligations to pay all wages due and to secure workers compensation coverage. It is aimed squarely at the economic core of the employment relationship. The statute contains defined terms and some exclusions, and it applies to client employers that meet certain size thresholds, so not every small business that uses occasional contract help falls within it. It also preserves a client employer's ability to seek indemnity from the labor contractor through their contractual arrangement, which means the shared liability between client and contractor does not leave the client without recourse against the party that actually ran the payroll.
Crucially, the statute operates alongside, not instead of, the common law and wage order definitions from Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35. A worker may pursue a client business under § 2810.3 and may independently argue that the business is an employer under the control test or the suffer or permit standard. These are complementary routes to the same destination, which is holding the business that benefited from the labor responsible for the wages.
The IWC Wage Order Definitions in Context
The three definitions the Court applied in Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35 come from the Industrial Welfare Commission wage orders, the body of regulations that govern wages, hours, and working conditions across California industries. Each wage order defines employ to mean engage, suffer, or permit to work, and defines employer to mean any person who directly or indirectly, or through an agent or any other person, employs or exercises control over the wages, hours, or working conditions of any person. The phrase directly or indirectly is what allows these definitions to reach beyond the immediate payroll entity to businesses that control or benefit from the work through an intermediary.
Because the wage order definitions govern most California wage claims, the joint-employment analysis they support applies to minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest period, and related claims. A worker who was denied overtime by a staffing agency, for example, may be able to reach the client business under the same definitions, provided the client controlled conditions, suffered or permitted the work, or qualifies as a client employer under § 2810.3. For a deeper look at how California defines and protects wage floors, see our guide on the California Equal Pay Act.
Why Joint Liability Matters for Recovery
The practical value of joint-employer doctrine is collectability. Staffing agencies and labor contractors are sometimes thinly capitalized, structured to dissolve, or quick to disappear when a wage claim lands. If the only responsible party were the contractor, many workers would win on paper and recover nothing in reality. By allowing a worker to reach the client business that directed and benefited from the labor, California ensures there is a solvent, accountable party standing behind the wages. The client business has every incentive to choose reputable contractors and to monitor their pay practices precisely because the law makes the client share the risk.
For workers, this means a wage claim should identify every entity that may qualify as an employer, including the staffing agency, the labor contractor, and the client business that used the workers in its usual course of business. Casting the claim broadly at the outset preserves the ability to recover from whichever party remains solvent and responsible.
How to Build a Joint-Employer Wage Claim
Identify every company whose name appeared on your paperwork, your badge, your schedule, your worksite, or your paychecks. Keep records that show who directed your work, who set your hours, who controlled the conditions on site, and whose business ultimately used your labor. Save any contract, assignment letter, or staffing agreement that connects you to the client business. Note whether the work you performed was part of the client's usual course of business, because that is the trigger for § 2810.3 shared liability. Preserve pay stubs and time records so the underlying wage violation can be proved against both the contractor and the client. The more clearly you can connect your labor to the business that benefited from it, the stronger your path to recovery.
Industries Where Joint Employment Commonly Arises
Joint-employment disputes are concentrated in sectors that rely heavily on contingent and supplied labor. Warehousing and logistics operations frequently staff their facilities through temporary agencies, and the workers who load, pick, and pack goods may be paid by an agency while taking direction from the facility operator. Agriculture uses farm labor contractors to supply crews to growers. Janitorial and building services are often subcontracted, sometimes through multiple layers. Hospitality venues bring in banquet and housekeeping staff through agencies, and manufacturing plants supplement their workforce with temporary line workers. In each of these settings, the business that controls the worksite and benefits from the labor is a candidate for joint-employer responsibility.
The reason these industries generate so many claims is structural. Supplied labor lets a business obtain workers without placing them directly on its payroll, which can create the impression that the business bears no wage responsibility. Labor Code § 2810.3 and the definitions applied in Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35 exist precisely to counter that impression, ensuring that a business cannot capture the benefit of labor in its usual course of business while disclaiming the duty to see that the workers are paid. Workers in these sectors should assume that more than one entity may be responsible and should preserve evidence connecting their labor to the operator of the worksite.
Franchises, Subcontractors, and the Limits of Control
Not every business relationship creates joint employment, and the doctrine has real limits. A company that merely contracts for a finished product or a defined service, without controlling the conditions under which the work is performed and without suffering or permitting the specific workers to labor for its benefit, may fall outside the definitions. In the franchise context, the mere existence of a franchise relationship does not by itself make the franchisor the employer of the franchisee's workers; the analysis turns on whether the franchisor exercised the kind of control over wages, hours, or working conditions, or suffered or permitted the work, that the wage order definitions require.
The decisive inquiry remains functional. Courts look at who actually set the pay and schedules, who directed the work, who had the power to prevent it, and whose usual course of business the labor served. A business that genuinely stands at arm's length from the workforce of an independent contractor is in a different position from one that directs the daily work and benefits from it. Because these lines can be fact-intensive, workers who are unsure whether a particular business qualifies as a joint employer should preserve the evidence of control and benefit and let the full analysis be applied to the specific facts.
Retaliation and Enforcement Under § 2810.3
California protects workers who raise wage problems in a joint-employment setting, recognizing that supplied and contingent workers are especially vulnerable to pressure. Labor Code § 2810.3 includes protections that prevent a client employer from retaliating against a worker for providing notice of a violation or for filing a claim to recover wages. This matters because a temporary or agency worker who complains risks being removed from an assignment, and the law aims to keep that fear from silencing legitimate claims. Retaliation in this context can itself give rise to liability separate from the underlying wage claim.
Enforcement typically proceeds by naming every potentially responsible entity in a single claim, which preserves the worker's ability to recover from whichever party remains solvent and accountable. Because § 2810.3 makes the client employer share civil liability for the payment of wages and for workers compensation coverage, and because the definitions from Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35 allow the client to be reached as an employer in its own right, a worker is not confined to pursuing only the entity that issued the paychecks. The statute also preserves the client employer's right to seek indemnity from the labor contractor, which means holding the client responsible does not let the contractor off the hook but instead ensures the wages get paid first and the businesses sort out their shares afterward. For workers, the message is to document thoroughly and to pursue every accountable party from the outset.
The economic logic behind this structure is worth emphasizing. By making the client business share responsibility, § 2810.3 gives the business a direct financial stake in choosing reputable labor contractors and in monitoring how those contractors pay the workers they supply. A client that looks the other way while a cut-rate contractor underpays its crews can no longer treat that as someone else's problem. This alignment of incentives protects workers prospectively, not just after a violation, because businesses that know they share the liability have every reason to insist on lawful pay practices throughout the chain of contractors that staff their operations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the company I actually worked for be liable even if a staffing agency paid me?
Yes. Under Labor Code § 2810.3, a client employer that obtains workers through a labor contractor to perform labor in its usual course of business shares civil liability for wage payment. Under Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35, the client can also be an employer if it controls conditions or suffers or permits the work.
What are the three definitions of employ in California?
Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35 adopted three alternative definitions from the IWC wage orders: to exercise control over wages, hours, or working conditions; to suffer or permit to work; and to engage, creating a common law employment relationship. Meeting any one makes a business an employer.
What does suffer or permit to work mean?
It means a business that had the power to prevent the work and allowed it to proceed for its benefit can be an employer, even without direct day-to-day supervision. The standard was designed to reach businesses that use intermediaries to disclaim responsibility.
Does § 2810.3 cover more than unpaid wages?
It covers the payment of wages and the failure to secure valid workers compensation coverage, and it bars shifting workplace safety duties to the labor contractor. It also protects workers from retaliation for raising violations.
Why does joint-employer liability matter to me?
Because staffing agencies are sometimes undercapitalized or may dissolve, the ability to reach the solvent client business that benefited from your labor can be the difference between a paper victory and actually recovering your wages.
Talk to a California Wage Attorney About Joint Liability
If a staffing agency or labor contractor failed to pay you properly, the business that used your labor may share responsibility for your wages. Trembach Law Firm can help you identify every accountable party and pursue what you are owed. Attorney Anatolii Trembach represents California workers in joint-employer and wage disputes. Call (213) 645-2246 for a free, confidential consultation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301