WAGE & HOUR | 2026-10-28

California Equal Pay Act Under Labor Code 1197.5 in 2026

Equal pay for substantially similar work across sex, race, and ethnicity.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

California has one of the strongest equal pay laws in the country. Labor Code 1197.5, the California Fair Pay Act, prohibits paying an employee less than employees of the opposite sex, or of another race or ethnicity, for substantially similar work. The law reaches beyond identical titles, focuses o

Equal Pay for Substantially Similar Work: California Labor Code § 1197.5

California has one of the strongest equal pay laws in the country. Labor Code § 1197.5, commonly called the California Fair Pay Act, prohibits an employer from paying any employee at a wage rate less than the rate paid to employees of the opposite sex, or of another race, or of another ethnicity, for substantially similar work when viewed as a composite of skill, effort, and responsibility and performed under similar working conditions. The law reaches beyond identical job titles, focuses on the real substance of the work, and places the burden on the employer to justify any pay disparity. If you suspect you are paid less than coworkers who do substantially the same work, this statute is your central tool.

The Fair Pay Act was strengthened over the years to close loopholes that had made earlier equal pay promises hollow. It expanded the comparison from equal work at the same establishment to substantially similar work regardless of location, and it added race and ethnicity alongside sex as protected bases. This guide explains what substantially similar work means, the narrow defenses an employer may raise, why prior salary is not a defense, and the pay-transparency rules that help workers detect disparities in the first place. See our California employment law news page for ongoing coverage.

Substantially Similar Work, Not Identical Jobs

A defining feature of § 1197.5 is that it compares substantially similar work rather than identical jobs or matching titles. The statute directs that the work be assessed as a composite of skill, effort, and responsibility, performed under similar working conditions. Skill refers to the experience, ability, education, and training needed to do the job. Effort refers to the physical or mental exertion the job demands. Responsibility refers to the degree of accountability or duty involved. Working conditions encompass the physical surroundings and hazards of the job. Two positions with different titles can be substantially similar if, taken as a whole across these factors, they require comparable skill, effort, and responsibility under comparable conditions.

This composite approach prevents employers from defeating an equal pay claim through cosmetic title changes. A business cannot pay a woman less than a man for essentially the same job by calling her an assistant and him a specialist if the underlying duties, demands, and accountability are substantially the same. The focus on substance over label is what gives the statute real teeth.

The Employer Must Justify Every Disparity

Once an employee shows that she is paid less than an employee of the opposite sex, or of another race or ethnicity, for substantially similar work, the burden shifts to the employer. Under § 1197.5 the employer must affirmatively demonstrate that the entire wage differential is based upon one or more specified bona fide factors. Those factors are a seniority system, a merit system, a system that measures earnings by quantity or quality of production, or a bona fide factor other than sex, race, or ethnicity, such as education, training, or experience. This is a demanding standard because the employer must justify the whole gap, not merely offer a plausible partial explanation.

The bona fide factor other category is itself tightly constrained. The employer must prove that the factor is not based on or derived from a sex, race, or ethnicity based differential in compensation, that it is job related with respect to the position in question, and that it is consistent with a business necessity. Even then, the defense fails if the employee demonstrates that an alternative business practice exists that would serve the same business purpose without producing the wage differential. These requirements make it difficult for an employer to rationalize a pay gap after the fact with a vague appeal to market forces or budget.

Prior Salary Is Not a Defense

One of the most important reforms in the California Fair Pay Act addresses the way pay inequity perpetuates itself. Under § 1197.5(a)(3), prior salary cannot, by itself, justify any disparity in compensation. If employers were allowed to set pay based on what a worker earned at a previous job, historical discrimination would follow workers from employer to employer, because a woman underpaid early in her career would carry that suppressed wage forward indefinitely. The statute breaks that cycle by removing prior salary as a standalone justification for unequal pay.

This rule works hand in hand with the salary-history ban in Labor Code § 432.3, which prohibits an employer from relying on the salary history information of an applicant as a factor in deciding whether to offer employment or what salary to offer, and from asking an applicant about salary history. Together these provisions mean an employer can neither solicit prior pay to set a new salary nor later invoke prior pay to defend an existing gap. The combined effect is to require employers to justify pay by the demands of the job and the worker's qualifications, not by the accident of what the worker was paid before.

Pay-Scale Transparency and § 432.3

Information is the precondition of enforcement, because a worker cannot challenge a pay gap she cannot see. California addressed this through pay-scale disclosure requirements added to Labor Code § 432.3 by Senate Bill 1162. Under those provisions, an employer must, upon reasonable request, provide the pay scale for a position to an applicant applying for employment, and must provide to a current employee the pay scale for the position in which the employee is currently employed. Larger employers must also include the pay scale in job postings, so that the compensation range is visible from the outset rather than hidden until an offer is negotiated.

These transparency rules make the Fair Pay Act enforceable in practice. When pay ranges are disclosed, an employee can compare the posted or provided range against her own compensation and against the compensation of coworkers doing substantially similar work, which surfaces disparities that would otherwise remain concealed. The law also imposes pay data recordkeeping obligations on employers, reinforcing the ability of workers and regulators to detect patterns of inequity.

Protection Against Retaliation

The Fair Pay Act protects workers who exercise its rights. Section 1197.5 makes it unlawful for an employer to discharge, discriminate, or retaliate against an employee because the employee invoked or assisted in the enforcement of the equal pay law. Just as important, the statute protects the free flow of pay information among employees. An employer may not prohibit an employee from disclosing the employee's own wages, discussing the wages of others, inquiring about another employee's wages, or encouraging other employees to exercise their rights under the section. These protections dismantle the pay-secrecy policies that historically allowed disparities to persist unseen.

Because the ability to discuss pay is protected, an employer cannot lawfully discipline a worker for comparing salaries with a colleague or for asking a coworker what he earns. Workers who learn of a disparity through such conversations are acting within their rights, and any adverse action taken against them for doing so is itself a violation that carries its own remedies.

Remedies Under the Fair Pay Act

An employee who prevails under § 1197.5 may recover the wages she was unlawfully denied, meaning the difference between what she was paid and what she should have been paid for substantially similar work. The statute also provides for an additional equal amount as liquidated damages, which doubles the recovery of unpaid wages, along with interest and the costs and reasonable attorney fees of bringing the action. The availability of liquidated damages and fee shifting reflects the Legislature's intent to make enforcement meaningful and to remove the financial barriers that would otherwise deter workers from pursuing valid claims.

The statute also sets a lookback window for recovery and a limitations period for filing, and it allows the employee to pursue the claim either through the Labor Commissioner or in court. Because pay disparities often persist over long periods and compound through raises calculated as percentages, the recoverable amounts can be significant once the full differential is traced across the relevant period.

How to Evaluate a Possible Equal Pay Claim

Begin by identifying coworkers of a different sex, race, or ethnicity who perform work that is substantially similar to yours when measured by skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions. Gather what you can about their compensation through lawful means, including the pay-scale disclosures you are entitled to request under § 432.3 and conversations protected by the Fair Pay Act. Document your own duties in detail so the substantial-similarity comparison can be made on substance rather than title. Preserve your offer letters, performance reviews, and pay records, and note whether your pay was ever anchored to a prior salary, because prior salary alone cannot justify a gap under § 1197.5(a)(3). If a disparity appears and the employer cannot point to a genuine seniority, merit, or production system or a legitimate, job related, business necessity factor that accounts for the entire difference, you may have a strong claim.

How the California Fair Pay Act Compares to Federal Law

California's equal pay protections are broader than their federal counterparts in several important respects, which is why a worker in California often has a stronger claim under state law. Where federal equal pay law historically compared equal work at the same establishment and focused on sex, § 1197.5 compares substantially similar work, reaches across establishments, and covers disparities based on race and ethnicity in addition to sex. The composite assessment of skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions gives the California standard a wider sweep than a narrow equal-work comparison tied to a single location.

The allocation of proof is also more favorable to employees. Under § 1197.5 the employer bears the burden of affirmatively proving that the entire differential rests on a permitted factor, and the bona fide factor other than sex, race, or ethnicity must be job related and consistent with business necessity, a defense the employee can still defeat by showing an alternative practice. The prohibition in § 1197.5(a)(3) on using prior salary alone to justify a disparity, reinforced by the salary-history ban in § 432.3, removes a justification that once allowed historical pay gaps to persist. Together these features make the state statute a formidable tool. Workers weighing their options should also understand related wage protections, such as those described in our guide on written commission agreements under Labor Code § 2751.

Proving a Pay Disparity in Practice

Winning an equal pay claim depends on building a clear comparison and then holding the employer to its burden. The first task is to identify one or more valid comparators, meaning coworkers of a different sex, race, or ethnicity whose work is substantially similar to yours across skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions. The comparison is made on the real content of the jobs, so detailed documentation of duties matters more than the titles on an organizational chart. Pay-scale disclosures obtained under § 432.3 and protected conversations about compensation help establish what comparators actually earn.

Once a disparity is shown, the focus shifts to the employer's proffered explanation. The employer must account for the entire gap with a seniority system, a merit system, a production-based system, or a legitimate bona fide factor, and each of those systems must be genuine rather than a label applied after the fact. If the employer cannot document a consistent, job related basis for the full differential, or if the explanation turns out to rest on prior salary that § 1197.5(a)(3) forbids as a standalone justification, the disparity stands unjustified. Careful records of your qualifications, your performance, and the timeline of your pay strengthen every stage of this analysis.

Pay Transparency, Recordkeeping, and SB 1162

The enforcement of equal pay depends on visibility, and California has steadily expanded the transparency obligations that make disparities detectable. Through amendments to § 432.3 enacted by Senate Bill 1162, employers must provide the pay scale for a position to applicants and to current employees upon reasonable request, and larger employers must include the pay scale in their job postings. A pay scale means the salary or hourly wage range the employer reasonably expects to pay for the position, so an applicant can see the range before accepting an offer and a current employee can compare the posted range against actual pay for substantially similar work.

Beyond disclosure, the law imposes recordkeeping duties. Employers must maintain records of job titles and wage rate histories for each employee for a defined period, and certain larger employers must submit pay data reports that break down compensation by job category and by sex, race, and ethnicity. These records and reports are powerful because they surface patterns that an individual employee could never see on her own, and they create a documentary trail that supports both private claims and regulatory enforcement. When an employer fails to disclose a pay scale on request, or fails to keep the required records, those failures can themselves carry consequences and can strengthen the inference that a pay disparity was not based on a legitimate factor. Taken together with the substantive protections of § 1197.5 and the prohibition in § 1197.5(a)(3) on relying on prior salary alone, the transparency and recordkeeping rules turn the Fair Pay Act from an aspiration into an enforceable guarantee.

For employees, the practical value of these rules is that they shift the information advantage. Historically, pay secrecy allowed disparities to persist because no one outside management could see them. Now an employee who suspects she is underpaid can request the pay scale for her position, discuss compensation with colleagues without fear of discipline, and point to the employer's own records if a dispute arises. That combination of disclosure, protected conversation, and mandatory recordkeeping is what makes § 1197.5 enforceable in the real world rather than only on paper, and it is why California workers are better positioned than ever to identify and challenge unequal pay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the work have to be identical to bring an equal pay claim?

No. Labor Code § 1197.5 compares substantially similar work assessed as a composite of skill, effort, and responsibility under similar working conditions. Different job titles can still be substantially similar if the underlying demands are comparable.

Can my employer use my prior salary to justify paying me less?

No. Under § 1197.5(a)(3), prior salary alone cannot justify a pay disparity, and § 432.3 bars an employer from asking about or relying on your salary history when setting pay.

What defenses can an employer raise to a pay gap?

The employer must prove the entire differential rests on a seniority system, a merit system, a production-based system, or a bona fide factor other than sex, race, or ethnicity that is job related and consistent with business necessity. A partial or vague explanation is not enough.

Am I allowed to ask coworkers what they earn?

Yes. The Fair Pay Act protects your right to disclose your own wages and to discuss or inquire about the wages of others, and § 432.3 entitles you to request the pay scale for your position. An employer cannot retaliate against you for doing so.

What can I recover if I win?

You can recover the unpaid wage differential, an equal additional amount as liquidated damages, interest, and your costs and reasonable attorney fees under § 1197.5. The doubling of wages and fee shifting are designed to make enforcement meaningful.

Speak With a California Equal Pay Attorney

If you believe you are paid less than coworkers who do substantially similar work because of your sex, race, or ethnicity, Trembach Law Firm can evaluate your claim under the California Fair Pay Act. Attorney Anatolii Trembach represents California employees in equal pay, wage, and retaliation matters. Call (213) 645-2246 for a free, confidential consultation.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301