WAGE & HOUR | 2026-10-31
Time Rounding in California 2026: The Camp v. Home Depot Rule
When your employer records your exact minutes, California law requires payment for all of them, not a rounded figure.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California employers long rounded employees clock punches to the nearest quarter hour, but that practice is collapsing. After Camp v. Home Depot, where an employer records exact minutes it must pay for all of them. This guide explains the shift from neutral rounding to pay-to-the-minute, the meal-pe
The End of Time Rounding When Exact Time Is Known
For years, California employers rounded employees’ clock-in and clock-out times to the nearest increment — often the nearest quarter hour — on the theory that rounding was permissible if it was neutral over time. That practice is now in serious doubt. A line of California Supreme Court and Court of Appeal decisions has steadily narrowed, and in the meal-period context eliminated, the employer’s ability to round. The clearest signal came from the Court of Appeal’s decision in Camp v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (2022), which held that where an employer captures the exact amount of time an employee works, the employer must pay for all of that time and may not use rounding to pay for less. Because modern timekeeping systems record every minute, rounding is increasingly indefensible.
How Rounding Used to Work: See’s Candy Shops
The modern California rounding debate began with See’s Candy Shops, Inc. v. Superior Court (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 889. There, the Court of Appeal adopted a rounding standard borrowed from federal law, holding that an employer could round employee time to the nearest increment if the rounding policy was fair and neutral on its face and did not, over a period of time, result in a failure to compensate employees properly for all time actually worked. Under See’s Candy, a neutral rounding system that rounded up as often as it rounded down, and that did not systematically favor the employer, was lawful. For a decade, employers relied on See’s Candy to justify quarter-hour rounding.
Camp v. Home Depot Changes the Analysis
The Court of Appeal in Camp v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (2022) confronted a situation that See’s Candy had not: an employer whose electronic timekeeping system recorded employees’ exact minutes but whose payroll then rounded those times to the nearest quarter hour, resulting in some employees being paid for less time than they actually worked. The court held that when an employer can and does capture the exact time worked, it must pay for all the time worked; neutral rounding cannot be used to deprive an employee of compensation for minutes the employer knows were worked. The decision reframed rounding as a workaround for imprecise timekeeping — a justification that disappears once precise records exist.
The practical consequence is stark. Virtually every contemporary timekeeping system — biometric scanners, badge swipes, app-based punches — records exact minutes. Under Camp, an employer using such a system cannot lawfully round, because it already knows the true figure. Rounding survives, if at all, only where exact time genuinely cannot be captured, a shrinking category in the digital age.
No Rounding for Meal Periods: Donohue v. AMN Services
The California Supreme Court had already closed the door on rounding in the meal-period context in Donohue v. AMN Services, LLC (2021) 11 Cal.5th 58. The Court held that employers may not round time punches for meal periods, because the meal-period statutes and Wage Orders are concerned with precise compliance — a thirty-minute, timely, duty-free meal break — and rounding can mask violations that trigger premium pay. Donohue also held that time records showing non-compliant meal periods raise a rebuttable presumption of a meal-period violation, shifting the burden to the employer to show a lawful break was provided. Together with Camp, Donohue signals a judicial preference for exactitude over convenient rounding.
Small Amounts Still Count: Troester v. Starbucks
The companion principle is that California generally does not excuse small increments of unpaid work. In Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829, the California Supreme Court rejected the federal de minimis doctrine as a defense to claims for regularly occurring off-the-clock work of several minutes per shift. The employee had to perform closing tasks after clocking out, amounting to minutes each day that added up over time. The Court held that the Labor Code and Wage Orders do not permit employers to require work for minutes off the clock on a regular basis without compensation. Troester underscores the theme uniting these cases: in California, worked minutes must be paid, and employers may not round or wave away small but regular increments.
The Statutory Backbone: Labor Code § 204, § 226, and § 1174
These timekeeping rules rest on core Labor Code provisions. Labor Code § 204 requires the timely payment of all wages earned, establishing the pay-period cadence that rounding can disrupt. Labor Code § 226 requires employers to furnish accurate, itemized wage statements showing, among other things, total hours worked; rounding that understates hours produces inaccurate statements and independent liability. Labor Code § 1174 requires employers to keep accurate records of hours worked and wages paid, the very records that make rounding unnecessary and expose it when it understates time. A rounding practice that shortchanges employees therefore implicates all three statutes at once.
Remedies and Penalties for Unpaid Rounded Time
An employee shorted by rounding can recover the unpaid wages for the rounded-away minutes, aggregated across every shift within the limitations period. Because rounding understates hours, it typically produces inaccurate wage statements under § 226, which carry their own penalties, and unpaid amounts at separation can trigger waiting-time penalties. Where rounding is applied uniformly through a payroll system, the claims proceed naturally as class actions or as representative claims under the Private Attorneys General Act. The limitations period is generally three years for the wage claims, extendable to four years under the unfair-competition law. Even a few minutes per shift, multiplied across a workforce and years, can generate substantial exposure.
Practical Steps for Workers and Employers
Employees should compare their actual punch times against the hours reflected on their pay stubs; a consistent gap in the employer’s favor is the signature of unlawful rounding. Employers should disable rounding in any system that records exact minutes, pay to the minute, and audit meal-period records for compliance with Donohue. Because these issues interact with how pay is calculated once hours are fixed, see our related coverage of the regular rate and flat-sum bonuses and our ongoing employment law news updates.
The Meal-Period Presumption and Premium Pay
The Donohue decision did more than ban meal-period rounding; it reshaped how meal-period cases are litigated. The Court held that when an employer’s own time records show a missed, short, or late meal period, those records raise a rebuttable presumption that the employee was not provided a compliant break, shifting to the employer the burden of proving that a lawful, duty-free thirty-minute meal period beginning before the end of the fifth hour of work was in fact provided or validly waived. This matters because a non-compliant meal period entitles the employee to one additional hour of pay at the regular rate as a premium under the meal-and-rest-break statute, and a second premium is owed for a non-compliant second meal period. Rounding that papers over a few minutes of lateness can therefore conceal premium liability, which is precisely why the Court forbade it in this context. Employees reviewing their records for rounding should also scan for late or short meal punches that may each carry a one-hour premium.
Grace Periods, Auto-Deductions, and Other Timekeeping Traps
Beyond classic rounding, several timekeeping practices raise the same legal problems. Automatic meal deductions — where a payroll system subtracts thirty minutes whether or not the employee actually took the break — are dangerous because they deem a break taken without proof and can produce unpaid worked time contrary to Troester. “Grace period” policies that let employees punch in early or out late but pay only from the scheduled start are lawful only if the employee is genuinely not working during the grace period; if the employee performs any task, the time is compensable. Policies that require employees to complete security checks, boot up systems, or perform opening or closing duties off the clock run directly into Troester’s rejection of the de minimis defense. Each of these practices, like rounding, can understate compensable time and create inaccurate records in violation of Labor Code § 1174 and inaccurate wage statements in violation of Labor Code § 226.
Wage Statement and Final-Pay Consequences
Rounding violations rarely stand alone; they propagate into derivative claims that often dwarf the underlying wage shortfall. Labor Code § 226 requires an itemized wage statement accurately showing gross wages, total hours worked, and net wages, among other items. When rounding understates hours, the wage statement is inaccurate, and a knowing and intentional violation exposes the employer to statutory penalties per employee per pay period, subject to a cap, plus the employee’s actual damages or the statutory amount, whichever is greater, along with attorney’s fees. Separately, when an employee’s employment ends, all earned and unpaid wages — including rounded-away minutes — are due immediately on discharge or within seventy-two hours on resignation; failure to pay triggers waiting-time penalties equal to the employee’s daily wage for each day the wages remain unpaid, up to thirty days. These stacked penalties are why a modest per-shift rounding error can resolve into a large aggregate judgment.
Proving a Rounding Claim With the Employer’s Own Data
The distinguishing feature of a post-Camp rounding case is that the proof usually comes from the employer’s own systems. Because the timekeeping system records exact punches while payroll applies the rounded figures, a side-by-side comparison of raw punch data against paid hours exposes the shortfall with mathematical precision. Counsel typically obtains the raw time records in discovery and runs a comparison across the class period, quantifying the aggregate unpaid minutes without needing to reconstruct individual memories. This data-driven proof makes rounding claims attractive for class treatment, because liability and damages can be established from uniform electronic records rather than individualized testimony. Employees who suspect rounding should preserve their own punch confirmations and pay stubs, and employers should recognize that their records will be the central exhibit in any dispute.
Where Rounding May Still Survive
The decisions have narrowed rounding dramatically, but they have not, as a formal matter, declared all rounding unlawful in every circumstance. Camp v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (2022) held that an employer may not round when it captures the exact time worked; it did not purport to resolve whether neutral rounding remains permissible in the rare setting where exact time genuinely cannot be captured. In practice, that residual category is vanishingly small, because contemporary biometric, badge, and app-based systems record precise punches, and once exact time exists the employer must pay it. The prudent reading — and the one California’s highest court has signaled sympathy for — is that employers should abandon rounding and pay to the minute. An employer still relying on See’s Candy Shops, Inc. v. Superior Court (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 889 to justify quarter-hour rounding on a system that records exact minutes is exposed, because the factual premise of neutral rounding — imprecise timekeeping — no longer holds.
Timely Payment of Wages Under Labor Code § 204
Rounding also implicates the timing rules of Labor Code § 204, which requires that wages earned be paid on regular, semimonthly paydays and that all wages earned in a pay period be paid within the statutory window. When rounding understates hours, a portion of earned wages is not paid when due, a § 204 timing violation that exists independently of the ultimate recovery of the unpaid amounts. The timely-payment principle reinforces why small, recurring underpayments matter: the Labor Code treats the prompt payment of all earned wages as a protected right, not a matter the employer may approximate through rounding. Combined with the recordkeeping duty of Labor Code § 1174 and the itemized-statement duty of Labor Code § 226, § 204 completes a statutory framework that assumes exact computation and timely payment of every earned minute, leaving rounding little room to operate.
From Neutral Rounding to Exact Pay: The Trajectory of the Law
Viewed together, the California decisions trace a clear trajectory away from approximation and toward exact payment. See’s Candy Shops, Inc. v. Superior Court (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 889 opened the door to neutral rounding borrowed from federal practice. Six years later, Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829 rejected the federal de minimis defense and insisted that regularly recurring minutes of work be paid. Three years after that, Donohue v. AMN Services, LLC (2021) 11 Cal.5th 58 barred rounding of meal-period punches and created a presumption of violation from non-compliant records. And the following year, Camp v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (2022) held that where exact time is captured the employer must pay all of it. The through-line is unmistakable: as timekeeping technology made exactitude possible, California law insisted on it, treating rounding not as a neutral convenience but as a mechanism that too often shifts the cost of imprecision onto workers. For employers, the compliance lesson is to retire rounding entirely in favor of paying every recorded minute; for workers, the lesson is that the law now strongly presumes they are owed pay for time their employer’s system recorded but did not pay.
How Trembach Law Firm Builds a Rounding and Off-the-Clock Case
A timekeeping case begins with a precise comparison of the employer’s raw punch data against the hours it actually paid. Counsel obtains the electronic time records, runs a punch-by-punch analysis across the limitations period, and quantifies the aggregate unpaid minutes attributable to rounding, automatic meal deductions, grace-period policies, and off-the-clock opening or closing tasks of the kind Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829 held compensable. The analysis also scans meal-period punches for the late or short breaks that trigger premium pay and the rebuttable presumption recognized in Donohue v. AMN Services, LLC (2021) 11 Cal.5th 58. Counsel then layers in the derivative wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226 and waiting-time penalties for former employees, and assesses class and PAGA treatment given that a single payroll rule applied uniformly to the workforce. Because the proof lives in the employer’s own data, these claims are both provable and efficient to litigate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is time rounding still legal in California?
Increasingly not. In Camp v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc. (2022), the Court of Appeal held that where an employer captures exact time worked, it must pay for all that time and cannot round. Because modern systems record exact minutes, lawful rounding is now rare.
Can my employer round my meal-period punches?
No. In Donohue v. AMN Services, LLC (2021) 11 Cal.5th 58, the California Supreme Court held that meal-period time punches may not be rounded, and that records showing non-compliant breaks create a rebuttable presumption of a violation.
My employer says a few minutes a day is too small to matter. Is that right?
No. In Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829, the California Supreme Court rejected the federal de minimis defense for regularly occurring off-the-clock work of several minutes per shift. Those minutes must be paid.
What was the old rule under See’s Candy?
See’s Candy Shops, Inc. v. Superior Court (2012) 210 Cal.App.4th 889 permitted neutral rounding that did not, over time, underpay employees. Camp has largely displaced that rule wherever exact time is captured.
What can I recover if I was underpaid by rounding?
You can recover the unpaid wages for the rounded-away minutes across every affected shift, plus interest, potential wage-statement penalties under Labor Code § 226, waiting-time penalties, and attorney’s fees.
Is an automatic meal-period deduction lawful?
Only if the employee actually took a full, duty-free thirty-minute break. A payroll system that automatically deducts thirty minutes whether or not the break was taken can produce unpaid worked time contrary to Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829 and create the inaccurate records and wage statements that Labor Code § 1174 and § 226 forbid. If you worked through an auto-deducted meal period, that time is compensable.
Contact Trembach Law Firm. If your employer rounds your time and pays you for fewer minutes than you worked, Anatolii Trembach and the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can compare your punch records to your pay and pursue the wages you are owed. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301