WAGE & HOUR | 2026-10-31
Suitable Seating Rights in California 2026: The Kilby v. CVS Standard
California requires employers to provide seats when the nature of the work at a location reasonably permits sitting.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California requires employers to provide suitable seats to workers when the nature of the work reasonably permits sitting, yet cashiers, tellers, and clerks are routinely forced to stand all day. The California Supreme Court in Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy defined the standard task-by-task and placed the b
The Right to a Seat at Work in California
California is one of the few states that requires employers to provide suitable seating to employees when the nature of the work reasonably permits it. Cashiers, bank tellers, pharmacists, receptionists, and many other workers are frequently required to stand all day even when much of their work could be performed seated. The suitable-seating requirement is not a courtesy; it is a mandatory term of the IWC Wage Orders, enforceable through the Labor Code and the Private Attorneys General Act. For decades the requirement was largely ignored because its meaning was unclear. The California Supreme Court resolved that uncertainty, giving the provision real teeth.
The Wage Order Text: IWC Wage Order § 14
The seating requirement appears in section 14 of the applicable IWC Wage Orders. It provides, in substance, that all working employees shall be provided with suitable seats when the nature of the work reasonably permits the use of seats, and that when employees are not engaged in the active duties of their employment and the nature of the work requires standing, an adequate number of suitable seats shall be placed in reasonable proximity to the work area and employees shall be permitted to use such seats when it does not interfere with the performance of their duties. The provision thus has two distinct clauses: a seating requirement for work that reasonably permits sitting, and a proximity requirement for standing work during lulls.
Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy: Defining “Nature of the Work”
The California Supreme Court interpreted the seating requirement in Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc. (2016) 63 Cal.4th 1, answering questions certified by the Ninth Circuit. The Court made several holdings that reshaped seating litigation. First, the phrase “nature of the work” refers to an employee’s tasks performed at a given location for which a right to a suitable seat is claimed, not to a holistic consideration of the entire range of an employee’s duties anywhere on the jobsite. In other words, the analysis is location-by-location and task-by-task, not an all-or-nothing judgment about the job as a whole.
Second, the Court held that whether the nature of the work reasonably permits seating is an objective inquiry that considers the totality of the circumstances, including the feasibility of providing a seat, the physical layout of the workplace, and the physical demands of the tasks, but not the employer’s mere preference for a standing image or policy. Third, and importantly, the Court held that the employer bears the burden of proving that compliance is infeasible — that no suitable seat is available — rather than the employee bearing the burden of proving entitlement. This burden allocation is a significant practical advantage for workers.
How the Task-by-Task Analysis Works in Practice
Under Kilby, a court or jury examines the specific tasks an employee performs at a particular station. A cashier at a register performs scanning, payment processing, and bagging — tasks that may reasonably be performed while seated. The fact that the same cashier occasionally retrieves stock or faces a display elsewhere does not defeat the seating right at the register, because the inquiry focuses on the tasks at that location. An employer cannot avoid the requirement by pointing to incidental standing tasks performed elsewhere, nor by asserting that standing projects a more attentive or energetic image. The feasibility of a seat — counter height, space, and the mechanics of the tasks — drives the outcome.
The Statutory Hook: Labor Code § 1198
The Wage Order provision is made enforceable by Labor Code § 1198, which declares that the maximum hours of work and the standard conditions of labor fixed by the IWC are the maximum hours and standard conditions, and that the employment of any employee under conditions prohibited by the Wage Orders is unlawful. Because suitable seating is a standard condition of labor fixed by Wage Order § 14, an employer that fails to provide seating when the nature of the work reasonably permits it violates § 1198. This statutory hook is what transforms the seating clause from aspiration into an enforceable legal duty.
PAGA as the Enforcement Vehicle: Labor Code § 2699
Seating claims are overwhelmingly litigated under the Private Attorneys General Act, codified at Labor Code § 2699. Because the Wage Orders do not provide an individualized statutory penalty for seating violations and the harm is often non-monetary (the absence of a seat rather than lost wages), PAGA supplies the remedy: it authorizes an aggrieved employee, acting as a proxy for the state, to recover civil penalties for Labor Code violations, including violations of Wage Order provisions enforced through § 1198. A seating plaintiff must first exhaust PAGA’s administrative notice requirement by giving written notice to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and the employer, then may pursue penalties on a representative basis for the violations suffered by the aggrieved employees. The penalties are shared with the state, with the employees receiving a statutory percentage.
Remedies, Deadlines, and What a Claim Requires
Because seating is enforced through PAGA, the central remedy is civil penalties rather than back wages, though a seating claim often travels alongside wage claims that do seek back pay. To bring a PAGA seating claim, the employee must be an aggrieved employee who suffered the violation, must satisfy PAGA’s notice and exhaustion procedures, and must act within the applicable limitations period, generally one year for the PAGA penalty claim measured from the violation, subject to tolling during the administrative notice period. The claimant must then prove, location by location, that the nature of the work reasonably permitted seating and that suitable seats were not provided; under Kilby, the employer must then shoulder the burden of proving infeasibility.
Practical Steps for Workers and Employers
Employees who stand all shift should document the specific tasks performed at each station and whether those tasks could be done seated, along with any request for a seat and the employer’s response. Employers should conduct a station-by-station seating assessment, provide seats wherever the tasks reasonably permit, and document genuine infeasibility where it exists, because under Kilby the burden to prove infeasibility falls on the employer. For related wage-and-hour duties that often arise in the same workplaces, see our discussion of on-call and standby pay and our ongoing employment law news coverage.
The Two Clauses of Section 14: Active Work and Standing Lulls
Section 14 of the Wage Orders contains two separate obligations that are easy to conflate. The first clause requires suitable seats for employees whose work reasonably permits sitting while performing active duties — the cashier who could scan and bag seated, the teller who could process transactions seated. The second clause addresses employees whose active work genuinely requires standing: for them, the employer must place an adequate number of suitable seats in reasonable proximity to the work area and permit their use during lulls when the employee is not engaged in active duties. A greeter or a line worker whose tasks demand standing is still entitled to a nearby seat for downtime under the second clause. Kilby confirmed that these are distinct inquiries, so an employer cannot defeat a second-clause claim by proving that active work requires standing; the question then becomes whether seats are available in proximity for the inevitable periods of inactivity.
What Makes a Seat “Suitable”
The requirement is for a suitable seat, not merely any seat, and suitability is assessed against the specific tasks and workstation. A suitable seat accommodates the physical dimensions of the work surface and the reach and movement the tasks require; a stool at the wrong height, a seat that cannot be positioned at the counter, or a chair that obstructs the task is not suitable. The totality-of-the-circumstances inquiry under Kilby includes the feasibility of providing a seat given the workspace layout and whether a seat would genuinely allow the employee to perform the tasks. Importantly, the employer’s business judgment that standing projects a better image or keeps employees more alert is not a legitimate consideration; Kilby expressly rejected employer preference for a particular image as a basis for denying seats. The analysis is objective and task-focused, not a deference to managerial style.
PAGA Procedure: Notice, Exhaustion, and Penalties
Because seating is enforced through PAGA, the procedural steps are as important as the merits. Before filing suit, the aggrieved employee must give written notice to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and to the employer, describing the specific Labor Code provisions alleged to have been violated and the facts and theories supporting the claim — here, Labor Code § 1198 and Wage Order § 14. The agency has a period to decide whether to investigate; if it does not act or declines, the employee may proceed in court. The limitations period for a PAGA penalty claim is generally one year from the violation, with the notice-and-exhaustion period tolling the deadline. Penalties under Labor Code § 2699 are assessed per aggrieved employee per pay period for the violations, and recovered penalties are allocated largely to the state with a statutory share distributed to the aggrieved employees; the statute also awards attorney’s fees and costs to a prevailing employee, which is central to the economics of representative seating litigation.
Common Workplaces and Recurring Fact Patterns
Suitable-seating claims arise most often in a recognizable set of workplaces. Retail and grocery cashiers stationed at registers performing repetitive scanning and payment tasks are the paradigmatic plaintiffs, as the Kilby litigation itself reflected. Bank tellers, pharmacy clerks, call-center and customer-service representatives, toll-booth and parking attendants, and assembly or inspection workers at fixed stations present similar facts: discrete, repetitive tasks performed at a single location that could reasonably be done seated. Employers in these industries that maintain blanket standing policies — often justified by a desire for an alert, customer-ready appearance — are the most exposed, because Kilby forecloses image-based justifications and places on them the burden of proving, station by station, that seating is infeasible. A worker in any of these roles who is denied a seat should assess the claim location by location, consistent with how a court will evaluate it.
The Employer’s Infeasibility Burden in Practice
One of the most consequential aspects of Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc. (2016) 63 Cal.4th 1 is where it placed the burden of proof. Once an employee identifies the tasks performed at a particular location and shows that those tasks could reasonably be performed seated, the employer must prove that no suitable seat is feasible there. This burden allocation reverses the intuition that a worker demanding a seat must justify the request; instead, the employer that denied the seat must justify the denial. To carry its burden, an employer typically must present concrete evidence about the workstation: its physical dimensions, the reach and movement the tasks demand, interactions with customers or equipment that a seat would genuinely obstruct, and why no suitable seat — of any height or design — could allow the work to be done. Generalized assertions that cashiers “need to be mobile” or that standing looks more professional will not satisfy the burden, because Kilby rejected image preferences and demanded a task-specific, objective showing.
Combining Seating Claims With Other Wage Violations
Suitable-seating claims rarely travel alone. The same employers that deny seats often maintain other practices that violate the Labor Code and Wage Orders — missed or late meal and rest breaks, off-the-clock work, or inaccurate wage statements — and a representative action under Labor Code § 2699 can aggregate these violations into a single proceeding. Because PAGA penalties accrue per aggrieved employee per pay period for each distinct violation, bundling a seating claim with meal-and-rest and recordkeeping claims can substantially increase the civil penalties at stake, and the attorney-fee provision supports the representative action as a whole. For a worker, this means a seating problem may be the entry point to a broader review of the employer’s wage practices; for an employer, it means a seating audit should be part of a comprehensive compliance review rather than an isolated fix, because the practices that generate seating exposure frequently signal other liabilities.
History and Purpose of the Seating Requirement
The suitable-seating provision is not a recent innovation; versions of it have appeared in California’s Wage Orders for over a century, originating in protective labor legislation aimed at the physical toll of prolonged standing, particularly on women workers in early retail and manufacturing settings. Over time the provision became gender-neutral and industry-wide, embedded in section 14 of the modern Wage Orders, but its underlying purpose endured: to prevent the unnecessary physical burden of standing all day when the work can be done seated. For decades the requirement was underenforced because its key phrase — “nature of the work reasonably permits” — lacked an authoritative interpretation, and employers defaulted to standing policies without challenge. Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc. (2016) 63 Cal.4th 1 supplied that interpretation and, by adopting a task-and-location focus and assigning the infeasibility burden to employers, revived a long-dormant protection. Understanding this history helps explain both why so many employers still maintain non-compliant standing policies and why the right, once clarified, has become a frequent subject of representative litigation under the Private Attorneys General Act.
How Trembach Law Firm Evaluates a Suitable-Seating Claim
A seating evaluation applies the Kilby framework station by station. Counsel catalogs the specific tasks the employee performs at each location, assesses whether those tasks could reasonably be performed seated given the workstation’s layout and dimensions, and documents the employer’s standing policy and any request for and denial of a seat. Because the claim is enforced through Labor Code § 1198 and the Wage Order and pursued under PAGA, Labor Code § 2699, the evaluation also confirms the employee’s status as an aggrieved employee, prepares the required written notice to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and the employer, and tracks the one-year limitations period with its tolling. Counsel then assesses the scope of the aggrieved group, the per-pay-period penalties, and whether related meal-and-rest or recordkeeping violations should be joined. The objective is to convert a widely ignored Wage Order right into enforceable penalties and, where appropriate, systemic workplace change, with attorney’s fees recoverable for the prevailing employee.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does my California employer have to give me a seat?
Yes, when the nature of the work reasonably permits the use of a seat. IWC Wage Order § 14 requires suitable seating, and Kilby v. CVS Pharmacy, Inc. (2016) 63 Cal.4th 1 interprets the standard task-by-task at each work location.
What does “nature of the work” mean?
Under Kilby, it refers to the tasks performed at the specific location where a seat is claimed, not the job as a whole. If the tasks at your register or counter can reasonably be done seated, you are entitled to a seat there even if you occasionally stand for other tasks elsewhere.
Who has to prove that a seat is or is not feasible?
The employer. Kilby held that once an employee shows the nature of the work at a location, the employer bears the burden of proving that compliance — providing a suitable seat — is infeasible.
How are seating violations enforced?
Primarily through the Private Attorneys General Act, Labor Code § 2699, because the violation is enforced through Labor Code § 1198 and the Wage Order rather than through individualized wage penalties. The employee must satisfy PAGA notice and exhaustion requirements first.
What can I recover for a seating violation?
Civil penalties under PAGA, shared with the state, with employees receiving the statutory percentage, plus attorney’s fees. Seating claims are often combined with wage claims that seek additional back-pay remedies.
Contact Trembach Law Firm. If your employer forces you to stand all shift for work that could be done seated, Anatolii Trembach and the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate your stations under the Kilby standard and pursue a suitable-seating claim. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301