WAGE & HOUR | 2026-10-31

On-Call and Standby Pay in California 2026: The Mendiola Control Test

When an employer controls your on-call time, those hours are compensable work under California law.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

California workers are frequently kept on call or on standby without being paid for those hours, but state law takes a different view. When an employer exercises sufficient control over your time, those on-call hours become compensable work, even if you are resting or sleeping. This guide explains t

What On-Call and Standby Pay Means Under California Law

Many California workers spend hours each week tethered to a pager, a phone, or a worksite without performing active tasks, yet never see those hours on a paycheck. The question of whether on-call or standby time must be paid is one of the most litigated issues in California wage and hour law, and the answer turns on a single word: control. When an employer exercises enough control over an employee during on-call periods, that time becomes compensable “hours worked,” even if the worker is reading, resting, or sleeping. Understanding where the line falls can mean the difference between being paid for every controlled hour and surrendering thousands of dollars in unpaid wages.

The governing framework is the Industrial Welfare Commission (IWC) Wage Orders. For most industries, IWC Wage Order No. 4 defines “hours worked” as the time during which an employee is subject to the control of an employer, and includes all the time the employee is suffered or permitted to work, whether or not required to do so. That two-pronged definition — control, plus suffered-or-permitted — is the engine that drives nearly every on-call dispute in the state.

The Control Test After Mendiola v. CPS Security Solutions

The California Supreme Court settled the standby question in Mendiola v. CPS Security Solutions, Inc. (2015) 60 Cal.4th 833. The case involved security guards who were required to remain on-site in trailers overnight at construction sites, ready to respond to disturbances. The guards were on call during these hours but could read, watch television, or sleep in the meantime. The employer argued the inactive time was not compensable. The Supreme Court disagreed and held that on-call hours constituted “hours worked” because the guards were subject to the employer’s control: they had to remain on the premises, respond to situations, and obtain permission before leaving.

Critically, Mendiola also rejected the employer’s attempt to exclude sleep time from compensable hours for these 24-hour-plus shifts, holding that California law does not permit the exclusion of sleep time from on-site standby shifts under Wage Order No. 4. The Court refused to import a federal sleep-time exclusion into the California Wage Orders. The practical lesson is sweeping: if an employer requires you to stay at or near the worksite and respond when needed, your sleeping, eating, and idle hours are generally all on the clock.

The Factors Courts Weigh to Decide If On-Call Time Is Paid

California courts assess the degree of employer control by weighing several practical factors drawn from Mendiola and earlier federal and state authority. No single factor is dispositive; the analysis is holistic. The most influential considerations include:

Whether there are excessive geographic restrictions on the employee’s movements; whether the frequency of calls is unduly restrictive; whether a fixed and short time limit for response is imposed; whether the on-call employee can easily trade on-call responsibilities; whether and to what extent the employee can engage in personal activities during the period; and whether the employee is required to remain on the employer’s premises. An employee confined to a trailer with a two-minute response window is plainly controlled; an employee who may roam freely across a county and need only answer a phone within an hour may not be.

Compulsory Travel Time: Morillion v. Royal Packing Co.

A closely related doctrine governs mandatory travel. In Morillion v. Royal Packing Co. (2000) 22 Cal.4th 575, the California Supreme Court held that the time agricultural employees spent riding employer-mandated buses from a central departure point to the fields, and back, was compensable “hours worked” because the workers were subject to the employer’s control during the ride. They could not use the time for their own purposes, could not take a different route, and were prohibited from using their own transportation. Morillion confirmed that control, not physical labor, is the touchstone of compensability, and its reasoning dovetails with the on-call analysis: whenever an employer dictates where you must be and forbids you from using time as your own, the clock runs.

Statutes That Make Unpaid On-Call Time Recoverable

The Wage Orders define the duty, but the Labor Code supplies the remedy. Labor Code § 1194 gives any employee who receives less than the legal minimum wage or legal overtime compensation a private right of action to recover the unpaid balance, together with interest, reasonable attorney’s fees, and costs. This fee-shifting provision is one-directional in the employee’s favor, which is why wage counsel will take meritorious on-call cases. Labor Code § 1197 makes payment of less than the applicable minimum wage unlawful, and Labor Code § 1198 makes it unlawful to employ anyone under conditions that violate the Wage Orders, including the hours-worked requirements. Together these sections convert the control test into enforceable money.

Proving the Claim: CACI 2702 and the Elements

When an unpaid on-call case goes to a California jury, the court instructs on the failure to pay minimum wage using CACI 2702. The plaintiff must prove that he or she performed work for the employer, the amount of time worked, and that the employer did not pay at least the minimum wage for all hours worked. In an on-call case, the contested element is almost always the amount of time worked, which collapses into the legal question of whether the controlled standby hours count. Because the control test is a question of law applied to facts, well-documented records of restrictions — response-time rules, geographic limits, on-premises requirements — are the backbone of a winning case.

Reporting-Time Pay Is Different From On-Call Pay

Workers often confuse on-call pay with reporting-time pay, but they are distinct. Reporting-time pay compensates an employee who shows up for a scheduled shift and is sent home early or given less than half the usual day’s work; it is a minimum guarantee of two to four hours. On-call pay, by contrast, compensates controlled waiting time. An employee can be owed both: reporting-time pay for a canceled shift and on-call wages for controlled standby in between. Keeping the two theories separate is essential when calculating total exposure, and a worker who was both placed on standby and sent home may have overlapping claims arising from the same workweek.

Remedies, Penalties, and the Statute of Limitations

An employee who prevails on an on-call claim recovers the unpaid wages at the applicable rate for every controlled hour, plus prejudgment interest. Because unpaid standby hours frequently push a worker past the daily or weekly overtime thresholds, the recovery often includes overtime premiums as well. Separate derivative penalties may attach for inaccurate wage statements and for wages unpaid at separation (waiting-time penalties). The limitations period for statutory minimum-wage and overtime claims under the Labor Code is generally three years, extended to four years when pursued as an unfair-competition claim under the Business and Professions Code. Waiting too long can shrink a claim, so prompt action preserves the full window.

Practical Steps for Workers and Employers

If you are an employee, document every on-call shift: the hours you were required to be available, the response-time rule, any restriction on leaving home or the worksite, and whether you were actually called. Save text messages, schedules, and written policies. If you are an employer, audit your on-call policies against the Mendiola factors: loosen response windows, permit shift trades, lift on-premises requirements where feasible, and pay for genuinely controlled time rather than risk a class or representative action. For a broader view of related doctrines, see our coverage of split-shift premium pay and our running employment law news updates.

Overtime and Minimum-Wage Consequences of Unpaid Standby

Treating controlled on-call hours as compensable has a cascading effect on the rest of a worker’s paycheck. Because those hours are “hours worked,” they count toward the daily and weekly overtime thresholds. A guard who works a nominal twelve-hour active shift plus twelve hours of controlled overnight standby has worked twenty-four compensable hours in a single workday, which triggers both time-and-a-half beyond eight hours and double time beyond twelve under California’s daily-overtime structure. The same recharacterization can also expose a straight minimum-wage violation: if an employer pays a flat nightly stipend for a sixteen-hour on-site shift, dividing that stipend across sixteen compensable hours may yield an effective hourly rate below the legal minimum, independently violating Labor Code § 1197. In Mendiola the practical stakes were exactly this — once the standby hours were counted, the guards’ pay fell short on both overtime and minimum-wage grounds. Workers evaluating an on-call claim should therefore compute not just the unpaid straight-time hours but the overtime premiums and any minimum-wage shortfall those hours create.

Employer Agreements and Industry Carve-Outs

Employers sometimes point to written agreements purporting to exclude sleep or standby time, or to industry practice, to defeat on-call claims. California courts treat such provisions skeptically. The Mendiola Court made clear that the Wage Order’s definition of hours worked controls and that California had not adopted the federal framework permitting sleep-time exclusion agreements for on-site shifts under Wage Order No. 4. An employee generally cannot contractually waive the right to be paid for controlled time, because Labor Code § 1194 establishes a non-waivable statutory floor and public policy forbids private agreements that undercut minimum-wage and overtime protections. There are narrow, order-specific carve-outs for certain live-in employees and some ambulance-crew arrangements with specific written agreements, but these are exceptions defined by the applicable Wage Order, not a general license to go unpaid. Any employer relying on such a carve-out bears the burden of showing it squarely applies; the default rule is that controlled time is paid.

Building the Evidence: Records, Witnesses, and the Burden

Winning an on-call case is an exercise in documenting control. The strongest evidence includes written on-call policies stating response-time requirements, geographic limits, and on-premises rules; schedules and call logs showing how often the employee was actually summoned; GPS or badge records showing confinement to a worksite; and testimony about what the employee could and could not do during standby. Where an employer has failed to keep accurate records of hours worked — as Labor Code § 1198 and the Wage Orders require — California law eases the employee’s burden: once the employee produces sufficient evidence to show the amount and extent of uncompensated work as a matter of just and reasonable inference, the burden shifts to the employer to produce evidence of the precise hours or to negate the inference. This record-keeping failure doctrine frequently tips close cases in the employee’s favor, because the employer that ignored the control rule also often failed to track the controlled hours it should have paid.

On-Call Scheduling, Reporting-Time, and Modern Predictive Laws

The control doctrine has grown more consequential as employers adopt just-in-time and on-call scheduling, in which workers must keep a shift block open, call in shortly before it starts, and learn only then whether they will work. California courts and local governments have responded. Some decisions have treated a mandatory call-in requirement as a form of reporting that can trigger reporting-time pay when the employee is effectively required to hold the time open and then is not used. Several California cities have also enacted predictive-scheduling or fair-workweek ordinances that require advance notice of schedules and premium pay for last-minute changes in covered industries such as retail and food service. While these ordinances are distinct from the Wage Order control test, they reflect the same policy judgment that animates Mendiola and Morillion: time an employer effectively reserves and controls has value and must be compensated. Workers subject to on-call scheduling should evaluate both the Wage Order control analysis and any applicable local scheduling ordinance, because the two can supply overlapping remedies for the same practice.

Exempt Status Does Not Always Defeat an On-Call Claim

Employers sometimes respond to on-call claims by asserting that the employee is exempt from overtime and therefore cannot complain about unpaid hours. That defense must be scrutinized. California’s exemptions — executive, administrative, and professional — require that the employee both earn a salary of at least twice the state minimum wage for full-time work and primarily perform exempt duties, and the employer bears the burden of proving every element of an exemption. Many on-call workers, such as security guards, technicians, and hourly support staff, are plainly non-exempt and entitled to pay for all controlled hours. Even where an exemption is claimed, adding substantial controlled on-call hours can undermine the salary-basis analysis or reveal that the employee’s actual duties are non-exempt. An employer cannot use a misapplied exemption label to avoid paying for controlled standby time; the classification itself is often the first issue a wage attorney challenges.

Interplay With Federal Law and the More-Protective Rule

Employers that operate in multiple states sometimes apply a single federal-compliant on-call policy nationwide, assuming the federal standard is enough. In California it is not. The federal Fair Labor Standards Act and its interpretive cases use a “waiting to be engaged” versus “engaged to wait” framework that can permit some on-call time to go unpaid, and federal regulations allow sleep-time exclusion agreements for certain long shifts. California’s Wage Orders are independently more protective, and where state law provides a greater benefit, state law governs the California employee’s claim. Mendiola made this explicit by refusing to import the federal sleep-time exclusion into Wage Order No. 4. The practical upshot is that a nationwide on-call policy drafted to the federal floor will systematically underpay California workers, and compliance in other states offers an employer no defense here. Workers whose employers invoke a national policy should understand that the California control test, not the federal engagement test, measures what they are owed, and that the difference frequently favors the employee by a substantial margin across controlled standby hours.

How Trembach Law Firm Evaluates an On-Call Case

Evaluating a potential on-call claim begins with mapping the employee’s schedule against the Mendiola control factors and then quantifying the dollars at stake. The analysis asks: how many standby hours occurred each week; what restrictions applied; were the hours tracked and paid at all; do the added hours cross daily or weekly overtime thresholds; and does the effective hourly rate fall below the minimum wage once standby hours are counted. Counsel then assesses the derivative claims — inaccurate wage statements under the Labor Code and waiting-time penalties for former employees — and whether the practice was applied to a group of workers in a way that supports class or representative treatment. Because Labor Code § 1194 shifts attorney’s fees to the prevailing employee, meritorious cases can be pursued without the worker paying fees out of pocket. The goal throughout is to recover full compensation for every hour the employer controlled, plus the penalties the law provides for the failure to pay and record those hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does my employer have to pay me for time I spend sleeping during an overnight on-call shift?

If you are required to remain at or near the worksite and respond when needed, yes. In Mendiola v. CPS Security Solutions, Inc. (2015) 60 Cal.4th 833, the California Supreme Court held that sleep time during on-site standby shifts cannot be excluded from compensable hours worked under Wage Order No. 4.

I carry a phone at home and only get called occasionally. Is that time paid?

It depends on the degree of control. If you can use the time largely for your own purposes, travel freely, and have a reasonable response window, the time is likely not compensable. If you face tight response deadlines, geographic restrictions, and frequent calls, a court may find the time controlled and payable.

What is the difference between on-call pay and reporting-time pay?

Reporting-time pay is a minimum guarantee when you report for a scheduled shift but are sent home early. On-call pay compensates controlled waiting time. They are separate theories, and you may be owed both in the same workweek.

How much can I recover for unpaid on-call hours?

You can recover the unpaid wages for every controlled hour under Labor Code § 1194, plus interest, overtime premiums where the hours exceed daily or weekly thresholds, attorney’s fees, and costs. Derivative wage-statement and waiting-time penalties may also apply.

How long do I have to file an unpaid on-call wage claim in California?

Generally three years for statutory Labor Code wage claims, and up to four years if pursued as an unfair-competition claim. Because delay can reduce your recovery, consult counsel promptly.

Contact Trembach Law Firm. If you believe you have been denied pay for controlled on-call or standby time, the employment attorneys at Trembach Law Firm, led by Anatolii Trembach, can evaluate your schedule, your employer’s policies, and your potential recovery. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301