WAGE & HOUR | 2026-10-28
California Off-the-Clock Work and Hours Worked After Frlekin 2026
Time spent under your employers control, including mandatory exit bag and security checks, counts as hours worked and must be paid in California.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California defines hours worked around the degree of control the employer exercises, not merely around active labor. That means mandatory security screenings, bag checks, boot-up time, and waiting for a supervisor can all be compensable even when they happen after you punch out. Frlekin v. Apple con
Off-the-Clock Work and the Meaning of Hours Worked
Off-the-clock work is any work an employee performs that the employer does not count and does not pay. It can be obvious, like finishing tasks after punching out, or subtle, like waiting in line for a mandatory security check at the end of a shift. California law treats these situations seriously because the state defines compensable time more broadly than federal law. The controlling concept is hours worked, and in California that concept turns on the degree of control the employer exercises over the employee.
Two Labor Code provisions anchor the obligation. Labor Code § 1194 gives employees a private right of action to recover unpaid wages, including minimum wages, plus interest, attorney fees, and costs. Labor Code § 1198 makes it unlawful to employ a worker under conditions that violate the applicable wage order, including the order's requirements for hours and wages. Together these sections mean that time worked off the clock, in violation of the wage order, is both unlawful and recoverable. For related coverage of small increments of unpaid time, see our article on the rejection of the de minimis rule in Troester v. Starbucks, and follow developments at California employment law news.
How California Defines Hours Worked Through Control
The Industrial Welfare Commission wage orders define hours worked as the time during which an employee is subject to the control of the employer, and includes all the time the employee is suffered or permitted to work, whether or not required to do so. This definition has two independent prongs. The first prong asks whether the employer controls the employee. The second asks whether the employer suffers or permits the work. An employee can be owed wages under either prong.
The control prong is especially important for off-the-clock disputes. If an employer requires an employee to remain on the premises, follow specific rules, submit to a procedure, or stay available for the employers benefit, the employee is under the employers control and the time is compensable, even if the employee is not performing active, productive labor. Waiting can be working when the waiting is controlled by and benefits the employer.
Frlekin v. Apple and Mandatory Exit Searches
The California Supreme Court applied the control standard to a common retail practice in Frlekin v. Apple Inc. (2020) 8 Cal.5th 1038. Apple required its retail employees to submit to searches of their bags and personal Apple devices whenever they left the store, including at the end of a shift and during meal breaks. Employees had to locate a manager or security guard, wait their turn, open their bags, and have their belongings inspected before they could leave. This process could take several minutes, and sometimes longer during busy periods, and it all occurred after employees had clocked out.
Apple argued that the searches were not compensable because employees could avoid them entirely by choosing not to bring a bag or personal device to work. In Apple's view, the time was not controlled because it was, in a sense, voluntary. The California Supreme Court rejected that argument. It held that the time employees spent waiting for and undergoing mandatory exit searches was compensable as hours worked under the applicable wage order.
The Court emphasized the practical reality of the arrangement. Employees were required to find a manager, wait, and submit to the search before leaving; they could not simply walk out. During the search, they were confined to the premises and subject to detailed rules about how to present their belongings. That level of control, the Court concluded, made the time compensable regardless of whether bringing a bag was technically optional. The Court observed that the choice to bring a bag was not a true escape from employer control, because many workers reasonably bring personal items to work.
Why the Voluntariness Argument Failed
The significance of Frlekin lies in its rejection of the voluntariness defense. Employers often argue that off-the-clock time is not compensable because the employee could have avoided it. The Court made clear that the proper inquiry is not whether an employee could theoretically sidestep the activity, but whether the employer controlled the employee during the time in question. Once an employee is on the premises and subject to the employers rules and direction, the control prong is satisfied and the time counts.
This reasoning reaches well beyond bag checks. It applies to any mandatory, employer-controlled activity that occurs outside recorded time, including security screenings, temperature checks, equipment inspections, and waiting for a supervisor to release the employee. The lesson is that the label an employer places on an activity does not control; the degree of control does.
Common Forms of Off-the-Clock Work in California
Off-the-clock work takes many forms. Employees may be required to boot up computers and load software before they can clock in, or to shut systems down after clocking out. Retail and warehouse workers may undergo security or bag checks. Remote and hybrid workers may be expected to answer calls, emails, and messages after hours. Employees may perform mandatory cleaning, restocking, or cash-handling duties after the register closes. Each of these activities can be compensable if it occurs under the employers control, whether or not it was captured by the time clock.
What Workers Can Recover
When off-the-clock work goes unpaid, the consequences for the employer can be substantial. Under Labor Code § 1194, an employee can recover unpaid wages, interest, and attorney fees and costs. A violation of the wage order's hours-worked requirements is itself unlawful under Labor Code § 1198. Depending on the facts, employees may also recover premium pay for missed meal and rest periods when off-the-clock duties intrude on those breaks, waiting-time penalties at separation, and wage-statement penalties when the hours are misreported. Representative penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act may also be available.
Because off-the-clock policies are usually uniform, these claims are well suited to class and representative treatment. In Frlekin itself, the security-check policy applied across a large retail workforce, which is why the dispute proceeded on a classwide basis.
Protecting Yourself Against Off-the-Clock Violations
If you suspect you are working off the clock, start documenting now. Record the tasks you perform before clocking in and after clocking out, how long each takes, and whether they are required. Keep copies of policies, schedules, and any manager instructions. If you undergo security or bag checks, note the typical wait time and whether it occurs after you punch out. Detailed, contemporaneous records are far more persuasive than later recollection, and they allow counsel to quantify your claim precisely under the hours-worked standard.
How Frlekin Changed the Compliance Landscape
Before Frlekin, many California employers operated security and loss-prevention programs on the assumption that post-shift screenings were unpaid because they came after the final punch. Frlekin ended that assumption. By grounding compensability in employer control rather than in the character of the activity, the decision forced a wholesale review of end-of-shift procedures across retail, warehousing, logistics, and manufacturing. Employers that continue to require screenings must now either pay for the time or redesign the process so that employees remain on the clock until released.
The decision also reframed how courts analyze a whole category of employer-mandated activities. The same control-based reasoning that made bag checks compensable applies to COVID-era health screenings, equipment sign-outs, mandatory shuttle rides on employer-controlled transport, and post-shift debriefs. Whenever an employer requires an employee to remain on site and follow its rules after the scheduled shift, Frlekin supplies the framework for concluding that the time is hours worked.
The Difference Between California and Federal Security-Check Law
Frlekin is especially striking when compared with federal law. The United States Supreme Court reached the opposite result for a similar practice under federal law in Integrity Staffing Solutions v. Busk, holding that time spent in post-shift security screenings was not compensable under the federal Portal-to-Portal Act because the screenings were not the principal activity the employees were hired to perform. California, however, does not use the federal principal-activity test. It uses the control standard in its wage orders. The Frlekin Court was aware of the federal decision and declined to follow it, underscoring once more that California wage law stands on its own and often reaches a more employee-protective result than federal law on identical facts.
Meal and Rest Periods Intertwined With Off-the-Clock Work
Off-the-clock work frequently corrupts meal and rest periods, creating additional liability. If an employee must undergo a security check before leaving for a meal break, as the employees in Frlekin did during meal periods, the break may be shortened or delayed, which can trigger premium pay for a noncompliant meal period. The same is true when employees are expected to monitor devices or remain on call during unpaid breaks. A single off-the-clock policy can therefore generate layered claims: unpaid minimum wages for the controlled time, premium pay for the interrupted break, and wage-statement penalties when the hours are not accurately recorded. These derivative claims often increase the total exposure well beyond the value of the raw unpaid minutes.
Burden of Proof and the Employer's Recordkeeping Duty
California places the duty to keep accurate time records squarely on the employer. When an employer fails to record compensable off-the-clock time, employees are not left without a remedy simply because the employer's own records are silent. Courts allow employees to prove the amount of uncompensated work by reasonable inference and estimation when the employer has failed to maintain required records, shifting the practical burden to the employer to rebut that estimate. This rule matters in off-the-clock cases precisely because the disputed time was, by definition, never captured by the time clock. An employer cannot benefit from the gap in records that its own unlawful practice created.
Remote and Hybrid Work Expands Off-the-Clock Risk
The growth of remote and hybrid work has multiplied the ways off-the-clock time can arise. A nonexempt employee working from home may log into systems before the recorded start time, continue answering messages after logging out, or remain tethered to a phone during an unpaid meal period. Each of these can be compensable under the control and suffer-or-permit prongs of the hours-worked definition, just as surely as a bag check in a store. Because remote work is harder to supervise and record, employers that permit or expect after-hours responsiveness without capturing the time create exactly the kind of uncompensated-work exposure that Labor Code § 1194 and Labor Code § 1198 are designed to remedy.
Employees in remote roles should be especially attentive to boot-up and shutdown time, time spent loading or updating software, and the expectation of near-instant replies to messages outside scheduled hours. If the employer requires or knowingly permits that work, it is compensable, and the employers failure to provide a way to record it does not excuse payment.
What to Expect When You Pursue an Off-the-Clock Claim
An off-the-clock claim typically begins with a careful reconstruction of the uncompensated time using the employees records, the employers policies, and any electronic data such as building-access logs, computer login records, or scheduling-app histories. Counsel then applies the hours-worked standard to each category of activity and calculates the unpaid minimum wages, along with any derivative premiums and penalties. Many off-the-clock cases resolve through class or representative settlement because the underlying practice is uniform, but individual claims are also available. Throughout, the control-based framework confirmed in Frlekin v. Apple Inc. (2020) 8 Cal.5th 1038 governs whether the disputed time counts, giving employees a clear and favorable legal standard to build upon.
Retaliation Protections for Workers Who Speak Up
Employees sometimes hesitate to raise off-the-clock concerns because they fear losing their jobs. California law addresses that fear directly. It is unlawful for an employer to discharge, demote, or otherwise retaliate against an employee for complaining about unpaid wages, asserting rights under the Labor Code, or participating in a wage investigation or proceeding. An employee who is punished for questioning an off-the-clock practice may have a separate retaliation claim in addition to the underlying wage claim, with its own remedies including reinstatement and lost pay. These protections exist precisely so that the workers best positioned to identify unlawful off-the-clock practices can come forward without sacrificing their livelihoods.
In practice, raising a concern in writing, through an email or a message to human resources, both documents the complaint and marks the start of the protected activity. If adverse action follows soon after, the timing itself can support an inference of retaliation. Workers who are weighing whether to speak up should know that the law is designed to shield them when they do. Keeping a copy of the written complaint, along with any response, preserves proof of both the concern and the date it was raised, which can prove decisive if the employer later claims the worker never objected.
Why Legal Guidance Makes a Difference
Off-the-clock cases can appear simple but often involve layered legal questions: which activities are controlled, how to value derivative penalties, how far back the limitations period reaches, and whether the claim is best pursued individually or on a representative basis. Experienced wage-and-hour counsel can evaluate the employers written policies and actual practices, identify every category of uncompensated time, and quantify the full recovery available under Labor Code § 1194 and Labor Code § 1198. Because the law places the recordkeeping burden on the employer and gives employees a favorable control-based standard, a worker who seeks advice early is well positioned to recover the wages that the off-the-clock practice quietly took away. Counsel can also advise on whether the claim should be brought individually, as part of a class, or as a representative action, since the right vehicle depends on how widely the policy is applied and how the employer maintains its records.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is time spent in a mandatory security or bag check compensable in California?
Yes. In Frlekin v. Apple Inc. (2020) 8 Cal.5th 1038, the California Supreme Court held that time spent waiting for and undergoing mandatory exit searches is compensable hours worked, because employees are under the employers control during the search even if they punched out first.
What does hours worked mean under California law?
The wage orders define hours worked as time during which the employee is subject to the control of the employer, including all time the employee is suffered or permitted to work. Either employer control or permitted work can make time compensable, which is broader than the federal standard.
Can my employer avoid paying by saying the activity was optional?
Generally no. Frlekin rejected the argument that employees could avoid bag checks by not bringing a bag. The question is whether the employer controlled the employee during the time, not whether the employee could theoretically avoid the activity.
Does off-the-clock work include answering messages after hours?
It can. If your employer requires or permits you to respond to calls, emails, or messages outside your scheduled hours, that time may be compensable under the control and suffer-or-permit prongs of the hours-worked definition.
What can I recover for unpaid off-the-clock work?
Under Labor Code § 1194 you may recover unpaid wages, interest, attorney fees, and costs. A wage-order violation is also unlawful under Labor Code § 1198. Additional penalties for meal and rest periods, inaccurate wage statements, and late final wages may apply depending on the facts.
Consult a California Off-the-Clock Work Attorney
If you are required to work, wait, or submit to searches after clocking out, you may be owed significant unpaid wages under California law. Trembach Law Firm, led by attorney Anatolii Trembach, helps California employees recover pay for off-the-clock work, security checks, and other uncompensated time. Call (213) 645-2246 for a free, confidential consultation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301