WAGE & HOUR | 2026-10-28
California Minimum Wage and the De Minimis Rule After Troester 2026
California rejects the federal de minimis doctrine for regularly worked off-the-clock minutes, meaning small increments of time must still be paid.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
Many California employers assume that a few minutes of work before or after a shift are too small to matter. State law says otherwise. California has rejected the federal de minimis doctrine for regularly recurring off-the-clock time, meaning even short increments of compensable work must be paid at
Why a Few Minutes of Off-the-Clock Work Matters in California
Employers often assume that small, irregular bits of work performed before clocking in or after clocking out are legally trivial. Under federal law, a doctrine known as de minimis sometimes excuses these small increments. California, however, takes a far more protective view of an employees time. The state minimum wage is not a suggestion or an aspiration. It is a floor that applies to every hour and, in many situations, every minute that an employee is under the employers control. When a worker spends four, five, or ten minutes each shift closing a store, transmitting data, locking doors, or setting an alarm, those minutes add up to real money across weeks and years.
California law makes payment of at least the minimum wage mandatory. Labor Code § 1197 states plainly that the minimum wage fixed by the Industrial Welfare Commission is the minimum wage to be paid to employees, and the payment of a lower wage is unlawful. There is no carve-out in that statute for tiny amounts of time. The statewide wage schedule set by Labor Code § 1182.12 raises the floor on a fixed timetable, and local ordinances in cities such as Los Angeles and San Francisco push the required rate even higher. For a deeper overview of these developments, see our ongoing coverage of California employment law news.
What the De Minimis Doctrine Is and Where It Came From
The de minimis doctrine traces to the federal Fair Labor Standards Act and the United States Supreme Court decision in Anderson v. Mt. Clemens Pottery Co. Under that federal rule, employers may sometimes disregard small amounts of otherwise compensable time when the time is administratively difficult to record and the aggregate claim is modest. Federal regulators have treated periods of roughly ten minutes or less per day as potentially excludable under this theory.
The key question in California was whether that federal shortcut applies to claims brought under the state Labor Code and the wage orders. California wage protections are independent of federal law and are, as a rule, more generous to employees. The wage orders define the obligation to pay for all hours worked, and nothing in the text of Labor Code § 1197 or the relevant wage order authorizes an employer to ignore worked minutes simply because recording them is inconvenient.
Troester v. Starbucks and the Rejection of De Minimis for Regular Tasks
The California Supreme Court confronted this issue directly in Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829. The plaintiff was a shift supervisor who, after clocking out, routinely performed closing tasks: he transmitted daily sales data to corporate headquarters, activated the store alarm, locked the front door, and sometimes walked coworkers to their cars or let employees back inside to retrieve belongings. These tasks took roughly four to ten additional minutes each closing shift and were not captured by the time clock.
Starbucks argued that the small, hard-to-measure increments should be excused under the federal de minimis doctrine. The California Supreme Court disagreed. It held that neither the governing statute nor the applicable wage order had adopted the federal de minimis rule, and that the doctrine did not apply to the regularly occurring, off-the-clock work at issue. The Court reasoned that an employer that requires employees to work minutes off the clock on a regular basis or as a regular feature of the job may not evade the obligation to pay by invoking a federal convenience rule. Importantly, the Court recognized that modern timekeeping technology makes capturing short increments far more feasible than it was when the federal doctrine arose.
The Troester Court stopped short of holding that every conceivable split-second of activity must always be recorded. It left open the possibility that some truly minute or irregular bits of time might be impractical to capture. But the thrust of the opinion is unmistakable: in California, routine off-the-clock minutes are compensable, and employers bear the burden of designing systems that capture that time.
Hours Worked and the Scope of Employer Control
California wage orders define hours worked to include all time during which an employee is subject to the control of the employer, as well as all time the employee is suffered or permitted to work, whether or not required to do so. This control-based standard is broader than the federal test. The practical consequence is that when a worker is required to remain on premises, perform closing duties, wait for a manager, or complete a mandatory task, that time is almost always compensable even if it occurs outside the scheduled shift and outside the recorded punches.
Because of this breadth, the de minimis defense found little room to operate in Troester. If the time is worked under employer control and recurs as a feature of the job, it is hours worked, and hours worked must be paid at no less than the minimum wage required by Labor Code § 1197 and the schedule in Labor Code § 1182.12.
How Unpaid Minimum Wage Claims Are Enforced
California gives employees a direct private remedy. Labor Code § 1194 provides that any employee receiving less than the legal minimum wage is entitled to recover the unpaid balance, together with interest, reasonable attorney fees, and costs of suit, notwithstanding any agreement to work for less. This fee-shifting provision is central to enforcement. It allows workers with relatively small individual claims to obtain counsel, because the attorney can recover fees from the employer if the claim succeeds.
In addition, the applicable wage order, IWC Wage Order § 4, governs minimum wages, hours, and working conditions for many professional, technical, clerical, mechanical, and similar occupations, and reinforces the obligation to pay for all hours worked. Workers may also pursue liquidated damages for minimum wage violations and, where appropriate, penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act. Off-the-clock minimum wage theories frequently proceed as class or representative actions precisely because the unpaid minutes are uniform across a workforce.
Practical Steps for Workers Who Perform Off-the-Clock Tasks
If you regularly perform tasks before clocking in or after clocking out, documentation is your most valuable tool. Keep a personal log of the tasks you perform and roughly how long they take. Note whether you close the store, transmit data, wait for security checks, boot up or shut down systems, or respond to calls and messages outside your scheduled hours. Save schedules, messages from supervisors, and any policies that require these tasks.
Patterns matter. A single stray minute on one shift is unlikely to drive a claim, but four to ten minutes every closing shift, five days a week, across a year of employment, is a substantial and recoverable sum once multiplied across a workforce. For related timekeeping issues involving mandatory security screenings, see our discussion of off-the-clock work and mandatory exit searches under Frlekin v. Apple.
What Employers Should Do to Comply
Employers cannot rely on the federal de minimis doctrine to justify systematic off-the-clock work in California. Compliant employers audit their opening and closing procedures to identify every task that occurs outside recorded time. They adjust timekeeping so that employees punch in before the first compensable task and punch out only after the last one. Where a time clock cannot capture a short post-shift task, employers can restructure the workflow, use mobile or app-based punching, or pay a reasonable fixed increment that fully covers the time. The lesson of Troester is that the burden of capturing worked minutes falls on the employer, not the worker.
Why California Diverges From Federal Wage Law
California has long charted its own course on wage and hour protection, and Troester is best understood against that backdrop. The Industrial Welfare Commission wage orders predate many federal protections and reflect a deliberate policy choice to guard the time and earnings of California workers more aggressively than the Fair Labor Standards Act requires. When a California statute or wage order is silent on a federal doctrine, courts do not assume the federal rule was imported by default. Instead, they ask whether California law actually adopted it. In Troester, the California Supreme Court found no adoption of the de minimis doctrine in either the text of Labor Code § 1197 or the controlling wage order, and it declined to graft a federal convenience rule onto a protective state scheme.
This is a recurring theme across California wage law. The state uses a broader control-based definition of hours worked, a quantitative duties test for exemptions, and daily overtime that federal law does not mandate. Troester fits squarely within that pattern. The practical takeaway for employees and employers alike is that federal wage decisions are persuasive at best and are never a safe substitute for California authority.
Distinguishing Regular From Truly Irregular Time
Troester did not abolish the possibility that some tiny, irregular increments of time might be impractical to record. The Court expressly reserved that question. What it decided was that routine, recurring off-the-clock work, performed as a regular feature of the job, must be paid. The line that matters, therefore, is between time that happens predictably and as part of the ordinary workflow and time that is genuinely sporadic and minuscule.
In practice, most off-the-clock disputes fall on the compensable side of that line. Closing a store, transmitting data, waiting for a security check, and booting up systems are not random events; they occur every shift because the job requires them. An employer that tries to characterize such recurring tasks as too trivial to track is likely to lose, because the recurrence itself demonstrates that the time is a predictable feature of the job rather than an unforeseeable blip.
Industries Where Off-the-Clock Minutes Are Common
Certain industries generate off-the-clock minimum wage exposure almost by design. Retail and food service employees frequently perform opening and closing tasks outside their recorded shifts, including counting registers, setting alarms, and locking up. Warehouse and distribution workers may undergo security screenings or equipment checks. Call-center and customer-service employees often must boot computers and load multiple applications before they can take the first call, and that setup time is routinely unrecorded. Healthcare workers may perform handoff and charting duties after clocking out. In each setting, the unpaid minutes are small per shift but uniform across a large workforce, which is precisely why Troester-style claims so often proceed as class actions.
How the Damages Add Up Across a Workforce
The power of an off-the-clock minimum wage claim comes from multiplication. A single employee who works an unpaid eight minutes per shift, five shifts a week, loses roughly forty minutes of pay weekly. Over a year that approaches thirty-five hours of unpaid time for one person. Across a workforce of hundreds or thousands of employees and a multi-year limitations period, the aggregate exposure becomes substantial. When the fee-shifting provision of Labor Code § 1194 is added, along with potential liquidated damages and penalties, the total can dwarf the modest per-shift increment that the employer dismissed as trivial. This arithmetic is the engine behind the wave of off-the-clock litigation that followed Troester, and it is why compliance, not convenience, is the only safe path for employers.
Liquidated Damages and the Full Scope of Recovery
Unpaid minimum wages in California often come with more than the bare amount owed. In addition to the unpaid balance, interest, and attorney fees recoverable under Labor Code § 1194, an employee may be entitled to liquidated damages equal to the amount of the unpaid minimum wages, effectively doubling the minimum wage recovery in many cases. Liquidated damages exist because the Legislature recognized that the real loss from an unpaid wage is greater than the dollar figure alone; it includes the time value of money and the hardship of going without earned pay. An employer may avoid liquidated damages only by proving that it acted in good faith and had reasonable grounds to believe it was complying with the law, a defense that is difficult to sustain where the off-the-clock work was a known, routine feature of the job.
Beyond the minimum wage recovery, off-the-clock practices frequently generate derivative claims. When unpaid time is not reflected on pay records, wage statements become inaccurate, exposing the employer to penalties under the wage-statement statute. When the unpaid time is still owed at the end of employment and not paid, waiting-time penalties can accrue for each day the final wages are late, up to a statutory maximum. A single off-the-clock policy can therefore ripen into a layered claim combining unpaid wages, liquidated damages, wage-statement penalties, and waiting-time penalties, all amplified across the workforce.
The Statute of Limitations and Why Prompt Action Matters
Timing is important in any wage claim. California wage claims are generally subject to a three-year limitations period, which can be extended to four years when the claim is pursued as an unfair business practice. Representative penalty claims have their own, shorter windows. Because the recoverable period reaches back from the date a claim is filed, every month of delay can push the earliest recoverable pay out of reach. Employees who suspect they are working off the clock should preserve their records and seek advice promptly, both to protect the oldest portion of their claim and to stop the ongoing loss. Early action also preserves evidence, such as scheduling data and electronic logs, that employers may not retain indefinitely.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does California follow the federal de minimis rule for small amounts of work time?
No, not for regularly occurring off-the-clock work. In Troester v. Starbucks Corp. (2018) 5 Cal.5th 829, the California Supreme Court held that neither the Labor Code nor the applicable wage order had adopted the federal de minimis doctrine for routine, recurring off-the-clock minutes. That time must be paid at no less than the minimum wage set by Labor Code § 1197.
How many minutes must be unpaid before I have a claim?
There is no fixed threshold in California. Troester involved roughly four to ten minutes per closing shift and found that time compensable because it recurred as a regular feature of the job. What matters is whether the time is worked under the employers control and whether it happens regularly, not whether any single increment is large.
What can I recover for unpaid minimum wages?
Under Labor Code § 1194, an employee who was paid less than the legal minimum wage may recover the unpaid balance plus interest, reasonable attorney fees, and costs, regardless of any agreement to accept less. Liquidated damages and statutory penalties may also be available depending on the circumstances.
Does it matter that my employer says the time was too hard to track?
Generally no. The Troester Court observed that modern timekeeping technology makes capturing short increments feasible, and it placed the burden of designing a compliant system on the employer. Administrative inconvenience is not a defense to paying for regularly worked minutes.
What records should I keep to support an off-the-clock claim?
Keep a dated log of the tasks you perform off the clock and how long they take, along with schedules, written policies, and any supervisor communications requiring the tasks. Consistent documentation of a recurring pattern is far more persuasive than memory alone.
Speak With a California Wage and Hour Attorney
If you are required to work before clocking in or after clocking out, you may be owed unpaid minimum wages, interest, and attorney fees under California law. Trembach Law Firm, led by attorney Anatolii Trembach, represents California employees in unpaid wage and off-the-clock disputes. Call (213) 645-2246 for a free, confidential consultation to learn whether your off-the-clock minutes are compensable and what you may be able to recover.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301