OVERTIME PAY | 2026-11-13
Makeup Time Under Labor Code Section 513 in California (2026)
How California workers can make up lost hours without triggering daily overtime, and the strict written-request rules employers must follow.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California generally pays daily overtime after eight hours, but Labor Code 513 lets an employee make up time lost for a personal obligation without the makeup hours counting as overtime. The rule is narrow: the employee must ask in writing for each occasion, the time must be made up in the same work
What makeup time is and why it exists
California is a daily-overtime state. Under Labor Code § 510, a nonexempt employee earns time-and-a-half after eight hours in a workday and double time after twelve, independent of the forty-hour weekly threshold borrowed from federal law. That protection is valuable, but it can be inconvenient when a worker needs to leave early for a doctor appointment, a parent-teacher conference, or a plumber at home. Labor Code § 513 exists to give employees a limited, employee-controlled way to recover those lost hours later in the same week without the recovered hours being treated as daily overtime.
The trade is simple on paper: an employee who loses time for a personal obligation may work extra hours on another day that week to replace the lost time, and the employer need not pay a daily-overtime premium on the makeup hours even if the makeup day runs past eight hours. The statute, however, hedges this flexibility with conditions designed to stop employers from quietly converting overtime into straight time. Those conditions are where nearly every dispute arises.
The text of Labor Code Section 513
Labor Code § 513 provides that an employer may permit an employee to make up work time that is or would be lost as a result of a personal obligation of the employee. Makeup work time that does not exceed eleven hours in a day and forty hours in a workweek is not counted toward the computation of daily overtime under Labor Code § 510. The employee must request the makeup time in a written, signed request for each occasion the employee wants to make up time. Critically, the statute bars the employer from encouraging or otherwise soliciting an employee to request makeup time.
Read carefully, the section packs four separate conditions into one sentence: a qualifying reason (a personal obligation), a timing rule (same workweek), two hour ceilings (eleven per day, forty per week), and a procedural rule (a signed written request per occasion). A fifth rule the employer-conduct ban is stated separately. Each one is independent; failing any single one defeats the exemption and the makeup hours revert to ordinary overtime.
The written request rule each occasion in writing
The written-request requirement is the condition employers violate most often. The employee not the employer must initiate makeup time, and must do so in a signed writing for each separate occasion. A standing blanket authorization at hire, or a verbal nod from a supervisor, does not satisfy § 513. If an employee loses two hours on Monday and wants to work them Wednesday, there must be a written, signed request tied to that specific lost time.
There is one practical accommodation in the law. An employee who knows in advance that a series of personal obligations will recur may provide a single written request covering several planned occasions, so long as each occasion is identified. But an open-ended request to make up time whenever needed is not valid, because it untethers the makeup from a specific lost-time event and invites the employer pressure the statute forbids.
The eleven-hour daily and forty-hour weekly ceilings
Even a properly requested makeup day is capped. Makeup hours are shielded from daily overtime only up to eleven hours in a single day and forty hours across the workweek. If a makeup day pushes total hours past eleven, every hour above eleven is daily overtime at time-and-a-half under Labor Code § 510, and hours past twelve are double time. Likewise, once the workweek total exceeds forty hours of actual work, weekly overtime obligations attach regardless of the makeup label. Makeup time is a daily-overtime shield only; it never erases weekly overtime, double time past twelve, or the seventh-consecutive-day premiums that Labor Code § 510 also governs.
What counts as a personal obligation
The statute does not define personal obligation, and no California appellate decision has drawn a precise boundary, so employers and employees should read the term by its ordinary meaning: a personal, non-work errand or responsibility that forces the employee to lose scheduled work time a medical visit, a family matter, a home repair, a court appearance for a personal matter. The reason belongs to the employee; makeup time is not a tool for the employer to flex staffing. Because the request must be the employee own and in writing, the paper trail usually settles whether a given absence qualifies.
The ban on employer solicitation or encouragement
Labor Code § 513 expressly forbids an employer from encouraging or soliciting makeup requests. This is the heart of the protection. An employer may inform employees that makeup time exists as an option for example in a neutral handbook description but it may not suggest to a particular employee that she make up time, may not condition approval of an early departure on a makeup request, and may not build a schedule that depends on employees routinely making up hours. The moment the employer drives the request, the arrangement looks like an unlawful scheme to avoid paying daily overtime, and the hours become compensable overtime.
How makeup time differs from an alternative workweek schedule
Employees often confuse makeup time with an alternative workweek schedule under Labor Code § 511. They are different animals. An alternative workweek lets a work unit adopt a regular schedule of up to ten hours a day without daily overtime, but only through a formal secret-ballot election of at least two-thirds of affected employees, an employer-proposed written agreement, reporting to the Division of Labor Statistics and Research, and the procedures in the applicable IWC Wage Order. It is a standing schedule for a group.
Makeup time, by contrast, is individual, episodic, and employee-initiated. There is no election and no reporting. It addresses a one-off lost-time event, not a recurring schedule. An employer cannot use makeup time to achieve, piecemeal, the four-ten schedule that only a lawful alternative workweek election can create. Employers that want predictable longer days must run the § 511 election; those that want to accommodate occasional personal errands use § 513.
Recordkeeping and wage statements
Makeup time must still be recorded accurately. The employer has to keep time records showing the hours actually worked each day, and the wage statement furnished under Labor Code § 226 must reflect total hours and the correct gross wages. Makeup hours are paid at the employee regular rate for straight time; they are simply exempt from the daily-overtime premium. If the employer later cannot produce a signed written request for the occasion, it has no defense to an overtime claim for those hours. Good practice is to retain each signed makeup request with the corresponding timecard.
Remedies when an employer gets it wrong
If an employer treats hours as unpaid makeup time without meeting every § 513 condition no signed request, makeup outside the same workweek, hours over eleven in the day, or employer pressure the hours are overtime, and the employee can recover the unpaid premium. The primary recovery vehicle is Labor Code § 1194, which lets an employee sue for unpaid minimum wage and overtime plus interest and attorney fees, and § 1194.2 adds liquidated damages for minimum-wage violations. The Labor Commissioner may also assess civil penalties under Labor Code § 558 of fifty dollars for an initial pay-period violation and one hundred dollars for subsequent violations, plus the underpaid wages. A plaintiff may additionally pursue penalties on behalf of the state under the Private Attorneys General Act, Labor Code § 2699. Where improper makeup-time accounting produces inaccurate wage statements, § 226 penalties can stack on top.
For a deeper look at how non-piece and premium time must be tracked and separately paid, see our discussion of piece-rate rest and recovery pay, which turns on the same principle that California counts and pays for all hours actually worked.
Practical steps for employees
If you want to make up lost time, put the request in writing, sign and date it, identify the specific lost-time occasion, and keep a copy. Make up the time within the same workweek, and watch the daily total do not let a makeup day exceed eleven hours if you expect the hours to stay straight time. If a supervisor suggested or pressured you to make up time, or if you were made up time outside the same week and then shorted on overtime, document who said what and when. That record is usually decisive.
Practical steps for employers
Employers that want to offer makeup time should adopt a neutral written policy, use a standardized signed request form, approve requests only when they are genuinely employee-initiated, and train supervisors never to suggest makeup time to a specific worker. Keep the signed requests with the timecards, confirm the makeup falls in the same workweek, and stop the shield at eleven daily or forty weekly hours. When in doubt, pay the overtime the premium is far cheaper than a § 1194 and § 2699 action built on a missing signature.
A worked example of lawful makeup time
Consider a nonexempt employee scheduled Monday through Friday, eight hours a day. On Tuesday she must leave three hours early to take a parent to a medical appointment a genuine personal obligation. On Monday she signs and dates a written request stating she will make up three hours on Thursday of the same week. On Thursday she works eleven hours. Because the makeup is employee-initiated, in writing, within the same workweek, and the makeup day does not exceed eleven hours, the three extra Thursday hours are straight time, not daily overtime, even though Thursday ran past eight hours. Her weekly total remains forty, so no weekly overtime attaches either. Change one fact she works twelve hours Thursday and the twelfth hour is daily overtime under Labor Code § 510 regardless of the makeup label, because the eleven-hour ceiling in Labor Code § 513 is exceeded. Change another the employer suggested she make up the time and the whole arrangement collapses into overtime, because the solicitation ban was violated.
Meal and rest periods still apply on makeup days
Makeup time does not suspend California break law. On any workday of more than five hours, the employee is still entitled to a thirty-minute duty-free meal period, and to a second meal period after ten hours, under Labor Code § 512 and the applicable IWC Wage Order. Paid ten-minute rest periods are also required for every four hours worked or major fraction. A makeup day that runs eleven hours therefore requires two meal periods and at least three rest periods. If the employer denies a compliant break on a long makeup day, it owes a premium of one additional hour of pay under Labor Code § 226.7, entirely separate from the makeup-time question. Employers sometimes forget that stretching a day to eleven hours multiplies their break obligations.
Who can use makeup time, and who cannot
Makeup time under Labor Code § 513 is a device for nonexempt employees, because only nonexempt employees earn the daily overtime that makeup time shields. A properly classified exempt executive, administrative, or professional employee is paid on a salary basis and does not earn daily overtime, so makeup time is irrelevant to that worker. Part-time nonexempt employees may use makeup time on the same terms as full-time workers, subject to the same eleven-hour daily and forty-hour weekly ceilings. Employees covered by a collective bargaining agreement may have overtime and scheduling terms governed by the agreement, which can displace some default rules, but the agreement cannot authorize the employer to coerce makeup requests in violation of the statute core protection.
Red flags that makeup time is being abused
Certain patterns signal that an employer is using makeup time to dodge overtime rather than to accommodate workers. A standing makeup policy applied to a whole department, makeup requests that always appear right when the employer is short-staffed, supervisors who propose makeup time to fix schedule gaps, makeup hours that routinely span multiple weeks, or a complete absence of signed per-occasion requests all suggest the arrangement is employer-driven and therefore unlawful. When makeup time is real, the paper trail shows the employee asking, in writing, for a specific personal reason, and the makeup landing in the same week. When it is a scheme, the signatures are missing and the pattern follows the employer needs, not the employee personal obligations.
Deadlines and how to bring a claim
An employee who was shorted overtime because an employer misused makeup time generally has up to three years to sue for the unpaid wages under the statute of limitations for statutory wage claims, and a claim bundled with an unfair-competition theory under Business and Professions Code § 17200 can reach back four years for restitution of unpaid wages. An employee may file a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner (the DLSE) or file a civil action. The Labor Commissioner can order payment of the unpaid overtime and assess penalties under Labor Code § 558, and a civil action can recover wages, interest, and attorney fees under Labor Code § 1194 plus PAGA penalties under Labor Code § 2699. Preserving timecards, schedules, and any makeup-request forms (or proving none exist) is critical, because the employer carries the burden to justify why premium pay was not owed.
Why federal law has no makeup-time equivalent
Makeup time is a distinctly California concept because it solves a distinctly California problem. Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 207, overtime is owed only for hours worked beyond forty in a workweek there is no federal daily-overtime requirement. A worker who leaves early one day and works longer another day in the same week never triggers federal overtime as long as the weekly total stays at or under forty, so federal law has no need for a makeup-time mechanism. California, by contrast, imposes daily overtime after eight hours under Labor Code § 510, which is exactly what makes intra-week shifting of hours potentially costly. Labor Code § 513 exists to relieve that daily-overtime consequence in narrow, employee-controlled circumstances. The upshot is that employers operating in multiple states cannot assume their federal-compliant scheduling practices satisfy California law, and employees should not assume that because a schedule change would be fine under federal rules it is automatically fine under California daily-overtime rules. The makeup-time conditions must still be met.
Reporting-time pay and makeup days
Makeup time intersects with California reporting-time pay rules, which require that an employee who reports for a scheduled shift but is given less than half the scheduled hours be paid for at least half the shift (and not less than two nor more than four hours) at the regular rate, under the applicable IWC Wage Order. A makeup day is still a reporting day. If an employer schedules an employee for an eleven-hour makeup shift and then sends her home after one hour because work dried up, reporting-time pay may be owed even though the hours were nominally makeup hours. The makeup label governs only the overtime characterization of hours actually worked; it does not displace the separate reporting-time guarantee or any other Wage Order protection that attaches to the day.
The employer burden to justify withholding overtime
In a wage dispute, once an employee shows she worked hours that would ordinarily be overtime under Labor Code § 510, the employer bears the burden to prove an exemption or exception applies including that hours were lawful makeup time rather than compensable overtime. That burden has concrete consequences. If the employer cannot produce the employee signed written request for the occasion, cannot show the makeup occurred in the same workweek, or cannot rebut evidence that it solicited the makeup, it fails to carry the burden and the hours are overtime. This allocation is why meticulous records matter and why a makeup-time defense so often collapses: the very condition that makes makeup time lawful a signed, employee-initiated, same-week request is also the thing employers most frequently fail to document. Courts do not presume compliance from the employer say-so; they look for the paper the statute requires.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If your employer labeled your extra hours as makeup time but never had your signed request, pushed you to make up time, or still owes you a daily-overtime premium, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can review your pay records and timecards and pursue the wages and penalties you are owed. For a confidential consultation about makeup time, daily overtime, or any California wage dispute, call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246. You can also follow developments in California wage-and-hour law through our employment law news page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my employer make me use makeup time instead of paying overtime?
No. Labor Code § 513 forbids an employer from encouraging or soliciting makeup time. Makeup time must be the employee own choice, requested in a signed writing for each occasion. If your employer required or pressured the arrangement, the extra hours are overtime and the premium is owed.
Does makeup time have to be used in the same week I lost the hours?
Yes. The makeup hours must be worked within the same workweek as the lost time. Time made up in a later week does not qualify for the § 513 shield, and those hours count toward daily overtime under Labor Code § 510.
How many makeup hours can I work in one day without overtime?
Up to eleven hours in a single workday and forty in the workweek. Hours beyond eleven in a day are daily overtime, hours past twelve are double time, and work over forty hours in the week triggers weekly overtime regardless of the makeup label.
Is a verbal request or a one-time form at hire enough?
No. The statute requires a signed, written request for each occasion you want to make up time. A verbal request or a single blanket authorization signed at hire does not satisfy § 513, and the employer cannot rely on it to avoid paying overtime.
What can I recover if my employer mishandled makeup time?
You can recover the unpaid overtime premium, interest, and attorney fees under Labor Code § 1194, civil penalties under Labor Code § 558, wage-statement penalties under § 226 where applicable, and PAGA penalties under § 2699. An attorney can evaluate which remedies fit your situation.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301