EMPLOYMENT ARBITRATION | 2026-11-13
McGill Rule: Public Injunctive Relief and Arbitration in California (2026)
California bars employers from using arbitration clauses to waive your right to seek public injunctive relief.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
Many California workers assume that signing an arbitration agreement locks every possible claim into private arbitration, including claims that would stop an employer from harming the public. The McGill rule says otherwise, voiding any waiver of the right to seek public injunctive relief in any foru
What the McGill Rule Protects, and Why It Matters
If you signed an arbitration agreement when you were hired in California, you may assume that every claim you could ever bring against your employer is now locked inside private arbitration, including claims that would stop the company from harming other workers or the public. California law says otherwise. Under the rule announced in McGill v. Citibank, N.A. (2017) 2 Cal.5th 945, a contract provision that purports to waive your right to seek public injunctive relief in any forum, court or arbitration, is contrary to California public policy and unenforceable.
Public injunctive relief is a court order whose primary purpose and effect is to prohibit unlawful conduct that threatens future injury to the general public, not merely to the individual plaintiff. In the employment context it can reach deceptive or unlawful practices that affect current and future workers and the public at large. The McGill rule means an employer cannot use the fine print of an arbitration clause to immunize that kind of ongoing public harm from any judicial remedy.
The Statutory Foundation: Civil Code § 3513 and § 1668
The McGill rule is not a special arbitration exception invented out of nothing. It rests on two long-standing provisions of the California Civil Code. Civil Code § 3513 provides that anyone may waive the advantage of a law intended solely for that individual's benefit, but a law established for a public reason cannot be contravened by a private agreement. The right to seek public injunctive relief exists for a public reason, so a private waiver of it runs headlong into § 3513.
Civil Code § 1668 reinforces the point: contracts that have as their object, directly or indirectly, to exempt anyone from responsibility for their own fraud, willful injury, or violation of law, whether willful or negligent, are against the policy of the law. A clause that tells an employee they may never ask any tribunal to stop the employer from breaking the law as to the public is exactly the kind of exculpatory bargain these statutes forbid.
Why the Federal Arbitration Act Does Not Preempt the Rule
Employers routinely argue that the Federal Arbitration Act, 9 U.S.C. § 2, sweeps away any state rule that interferes with arbitration. The FAA's saving clause, however, preserves generally applicable contract defenses such as fraud, duress, and unconscionability. The California Supreme Court held that the McGill rule is precisely such a generally applicable defense: it does not single out arbitration agreements, and it applies equally to a waiver of public injunctive relief contained in any contract. Because the rule governs the enforceability of a waiver rather than the choice of arbitration as a forum, it is not preempted.
The federal courts agreed. In Blair v. Rent-A-Center (9th Cir. 2019), the Ninth Circuit held that the FAA does not preempt the McGill rule, rejecting the argument that it stands as an obstacle to the FAA's objectives. That alignment between the California Supreme Court and the Ninth Circuit gives the rule durable force in both state and federal court.
Public Versus Private Injunctive Relief
The dividing line that decides a McGill case is the difference between public and private injunctive relief. Private injunctive relief resolves a dispute between the parties and rectifies individual wrongs; it benefits the plaintiff, or a group of similarly situated private parties, by giving them the benefit of their bargain. Public injunctive relief, by contrast, is aimed at the public and seeks to remedy a threat to the public at large.
In employment disputes the distinction can be subtle. An order reinstating one worker or requiring back pay is private. An order requiring an employer to stop making unlawful misrepresentations in its hiring materials, or to cease an across-the-board practice that violates a statute protecting the public, can be public. Pleading the claim so that the requested relief genuinely runs to the public, not just to the named plaintiff, is the drafting task that decides whether the McGill rule applies.
How McGill Interacts With Unconscionability Under Armendariz
The McGill rule is one of several tools a California worker can use to resist an overbroad arbitration clause. The other main tool is unconscionability. In Armendariz v. Foundation Health Psychcare Services (2000) 24 Cal.4th 83, the California Supreme Court held that a mandatory employment arbitration agreement covering unwaivable statutory rights must provide a neutral arbitrator, adequate discovery, a written award, all remedies available in court, and must not require the employee to bear forum costs they would not face in court. An agreement that fails these minimums is substantively unconscionable.
Unconscionability and the McGill rule attack different defects. Unconscionability looks at one-sided, oppressive, or surprising terms under Civil Code § 1670.5, which lets a court refuse to enforce, or sever, an unconscionable clause. The McGill rule invalidates a public-injunctive-relief waiver no matter how procedurally fair the rest of the agreement is. A worker may raise both: the agreement is unconscionable under Armendariz and, independently, its public-injunctive-relief waiver is void under McGill.
Severance and the Poison-Pill Problem
When a court finds a public-injunctive-relief waiver unenforceable, what happens to the rest of the arbitration agreement depends on the contract's severance language and on Civil Code § 1670.5. Many agreements contain a clause stating that if the class, representative, or public-injunctive waiver is found unenforceable, the entire arbitration provision falls, sometimes called a poison pill. Under such language, the whole claim, including the request for public injunctive relief, proceeds in court. Other agreements let the court sever only the offending waiver and send the remaining claims to arbitration while the public-injunctive claim stays in court. Reading the severance and non-severability clauses carefully is essential before predicting where the case will be heard.
McGill in the Shadow of PAGA After Viking River and Adolph
The McGill rule is often confused with the rules governing the Private Attorneys General Act. They are different doctrines. PAGA, Labor Code § 2698 and following, lets an aggrieved employee recover civil penalties on behalf of the state for Labor Code violations. In Adolph v. Uber Technologies (2023), the California Supreme Court held that an employee compelled to arbitrate the individual component of a PAGA action still retains standing to pursue the representative PAGA claims. That holding concerns statutory standing to enforce penalties, not the public-injunctive-relief waiver that McGill addresses.
The practical lesson is that a California worker facing an arbitration clause may have several non-overlapping avenues: a McGill argument to preserve public injunctive relief, an unconscionability challenge under Armendariz and § 1670.5, and PAGA representative standing under § 2699 as construed in Adolph. For a fuller treatment of the penalty and cure mechanics that drive PAGA exposure, see our guide on the 2024 PAGA reforms.
Procedure: Resisting a Motion to Compel Arbitration
When an employer moves to compel arbitration under Code of Civil Procedure § 1281.2, the worker who wants to preserve a public-injunctive claim must raise the McGill rule in the opposition. Section 1281.2 directs the court to order arbitration if it finds an enforceable agreement, subject to defenses such as waiver and grounds for revocation of any contract. The McGill rule supplies a revocation ground as to the public-injunctive waiver. The worker should (1) plead a genuine request for public injunctive relief under an applicable statute, (2) identify the waiver language, and (3) argue that § 3513 and § 1668 make that waiver void and that the FAA does not preempt the rule under Blair.
What a Worker Must Show, and What an Employer Will Argue
To invoke McGill, a worker should establish that the relief sought is genuinely public in nature, that the operative agreement waives the right to seek such relief in all fora, and that the underlying statute authorizes public injunctive relief. Employers commonly respond that the requested relief is really private, benefiting only the plaintiff and coworkers, that no public-injunctive remedy is available under the pleaded statute, or that the FAA preempts the rule. The first argument is where most McGill disputes are won or lost, because the characterization of the relief is often contestable and fact-bound.
Remedies and Strategic Value
A successful McGill argument keeps the public-injunctive component of the case in court, where a judge can issue a forward-looking order stopping the unlawful practice. Even when the individual damages are arbitrated, the public injunction can produce systemic change that a private award cannot. That leverage often reshapes settlement, because an employer that must litigate an injunction affecting its entire workforce faces very different exposure than one facing a single arbitration.
Practical Steps for California Employees and Employers
Workers should keep the arbitration agreement they signed, note any clause that waives class, representative, or public-injunctive relief, and consult counsel before assuming a claim is barred. Employers should review their arbitration templates: a blanket public-injunctive waiver is not just unenforceable, it can trigger a poison-pill clause that forces the entire dispute into court. Drafting the agreement to comply with Armendariz and to carve public injunctive relief out of the waiver is the compliant path. Both sides benefit from understanding that the enforceability of these clauses is decided under ordinary contract law, Civil Code § 3513, § 1668, and § 1670.5, not under any arbitration-specific shortcut.
Which Statutes Authorize Public Injunctive Relief
The McGill rule only matters if the underlying law actually authorizes public injunctive relief. The paradigm example is California's Unfair Competition Law, Business and Professions Code § 17200, which defines unfair competition to include any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice. Its remedial provision, Business and Professions Code § 17203, authorizes a court to enjoin unlawful practices, and California courts recognize that a UCL injunction can run to the benefit of the general public. An employee who challenges an employer practice that also harms the public, for example systematic misrepresentations affecting the broader workforce or consumers, may seek a public injunction under the UCL even where the arbitration agreement tries to foreclose it.
Other statutes can supply public injunctive relief as well, including the Consumers Legal Remedies Act and, in appropriate employment settings, the injunctive remedies that accompany the Fair Employment and Housing Act under Government Code § 12965. The threshold question in every McGill case is whether the pleaded statute authorizes relief whose primary purpose is to benefit the public rather than to compensate the plaintiff. If it does, the waiver of that relief is what the McGill rule invalidates.
Delegation Clauses and Who Decides
Modern arbitration agreements often contain a delegation clause purporting to send all questions of arbitrability, including the validity of the agreement, to the arbitrator. Employers invoke delegation to argue that even the McGill challenge must be decided in arbitration. California and federal courts have grappled with this, but the enforceability of a public-injunctive waiver is generally treated as a question the court can reach, because it concerns whether a particular remedy may be waived at all under Civil Code § 3513 and § 1668, not merely whether a dispute is arbitrable. A worker opposing a motion to compel under Code of Civil Procedure § 1281.2 should address the delegation clause head-on and explain why the court, not the arbitrator, decides the public-policy question.
Drafting the Complaint to Survive a Motion to Compel
Because the characterization of the relief decides the case, pleading matters enormously. A complaint seeking a public injunction should allege the ongoing, forward-looking nature of the harm, identify the statute authorizing public injunctive relief, describe the threat to the general public or the broader workforce rather than only to the named plaintiff, and request an order prohibiting the unlawful practice prospectively. A complaint that frames the relief as purely compensatory, or as benefiting only the plaintiff and a defined group of coworkers, invites the court to classify it as private and to compel the entire claim to arbitration.
Severability Analysis Under Civil Code § 1670.5
When a court strikes a public-injunctive waiver, Civil Code § 1670.5 gives it discretion to enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable or unlawful clause, to limit the clause's application, or to refuse enforcement of the contract as a whole. The outcome turns on the agreement's own severability language and on whether the offending provision is so central that severance would rewrite the parties' bargain. Where the agreement contains a non-severability or poison-pill provision tied to the public-injunctive waiver, the court typically keeps the entire dispute, including any damages claims, in court. Where severance is permitted, the public-injunctive claim stays in court while arbitrable claims proceed in arbitration, producing parallel tracks that counsel must manage carefully.
A Practical Hypothetical
Consider a worker whose employer requires signing an arbitration agreement that waives the right to seek any injunctive relief on behalf of others. The worker later learns the employer is systematically misclassifying its workforce and advertising unlawful terms that mislead prospective employees and the public. The worker sues under Business and Professions Code § 17200, seeking a § 17203 injunction stopping the practice going forward, plus individual damages. The employer moves to compel arbitration. Under McGill, the waiver of public injunctive relief is void under § 3513 and § 1668; under Blair, the FAA does not preempt that conclusion. Depending on the severance clause, the § 17203 public-injunction claim remains in court while the damages claims may be arbitrated, or, if a poison-pill applies, the whole case stays in court.
Timing, Fees, and Strategic Considerations
Preserving public injunctive relief changes the economics of a dispute. A court-ordered injunction can reshape an employer's practices firm-wide, and fee-shifting statutes such as the UCL's companion provisions and § 12965 can make the public-injunctive claim worth pursuing even where individual damages are modest. Workers should raise the McGill argument at the first motion to compel rather than waiting, because failing to assert a contract defense promptly risks a waiver argument of a different kind. Employers, for their part, should recognize that an overbroad waiver is not merely unenforceable but can forfeit the entire benefit of the arbitration program through a poison-pill clause.
Mass Arbitration and the Modern Battlefield
The enforceability of arbitration clauses has grown more contested as employers face mass arbitration, where thousands of individual demands are filed at once. In that environment, the McGill rule retains independent significance because it operates on the remedy rather than on the forum. Even an employer that prevails in channeling individual damages claims into arbitration cannot use that victory to extinguish a properly pleaded claim for public injunctive relief. Courts continue to apply Code of Civil Procedure § 1281.2 to decide motions to compel, and the public-policy limits of Civil Code § 3513 and § 1668 continue to govern which remedies may be bargained away. For California workers, the rule is a stable anchor in a shifting area of law.
Interplay With Unwaivable Statutory Rights
The McGill rule is part of a broader California principle that certain statutory rights cannot be waived by private contract. The same logic that invalidates a public-injunctive-relief waiver also underlies the Armendariz requirement that arbitration preserve all statutory remedies. A worker should view these as a toolkit: if an arbitration agreement strips a nonwaivable remedy, whether by waiving public injunctive relief outright or by limiting the damages or remedies available in arbitration, the agreement collides with California public policy. Civil Code § 1670.5 then supplies the court's power to refuse enforcement or to sever, and the combined effect is to keep the most important public-facing relief available in court.
Key Takeaways for California Workers and Employers
The McGill rule is a narrow but powerful protection. A contractual waiver of the right to seek public injunctive relief is void in California under Civil Code § 3513 and § 1668, the Federal Arbitration Act does not preempt that conclusion under Blair v. Rent-A-Center and 9 U.S.C. § 2, and the rule operates independently of unconscionability under Armendariz and Civil Code § 1670.5 and of PAGA standing under Labor Code § 2699. For workers, the practical move is to plead a genuine public injunction under a statute that authorizes it, such as Business and Professions Code § 17203, and to raise the rule at the first motion to compel under Code of Civil Procedure § 1281.2. For employers, the practical move is to remove public-injunctive waivers from arbitration templates, because such a waiver is not merely unenforceable but can forfeit the entire arbitration program through a poison-pill clause. Where the stakes are high, early legal advice on both sides prevents costly missteps.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If you signed an arbitration agreement and believe your employer is engaged in conduct that harms the public, or if you are an employer trying to keep your arbitration program enforceable, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate your rights under the McGill rule and California arbitration law. For more California workplace developments, visit our employment law news page. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the McGill rule allow a worker to avoid arbitration entirely?
Not by itself. The rule only voids a waiver of the right to seek public injunctive relief. Depending on the agreement's severance language, the public-injunctive claim may proceed in court while your individual damages claims are still arbitrated. A poison-pill clause can send the whole case to court, but that depends on the specific contract.
What counts as public injunctive relief in an employment case?
It is relief whose primary purpose is to stop unlawful conduct that threatens the public or the workforce at large, not just to compensate you. An order halting an across-the-board unlawful practice can qualify; an order for your individual back pay or reinstatement generally does not.
Can my employer rewrite the agreement to get around McGill?
No. Because the rule rests on Civil Code § 3513 and § 1668, a drafted-around waiver of public injunctive relief remains void. An employer can comply only by not waiving that right, not by relabeling it.
Does the Federal Arbitration Act override the McGill rule?
No. Both the California Supreme Court in McGill and the Ninth Circuit in Blair v. Rent-A-Center held the FAA does not preempt the rule, because it is a generally applicable contract defense preserved by 9 U.S.C. § 2.
How is McGill different from a PAGA claim?
PAGA recovers civil penalties for Labor Code violations on the state's behalf under Labor Code § 2699, and its arbitration treatment is governed by cases like Adolph v. Uber. McGill is narrower: it only preserves the right to seek public injunctive relief against a contractual waiver. They can both apply to the same case but address different rights.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301