PERSONAL INJURY | 2026-11-15
The Per Diem Argument for Pain and Suffering in California: How Lawyers Put a Number on Noneconomic Damages
How Beagle v. Vasold permits per diem argument in California, the limits on how a lawyer may suggest a figure to the jury, and how courts review verdicts for pain and suffering
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
One of the hardest questions in any injury trial is also one of the most important: how much is pain and suffering worth? Unlike medical bills and lost wages, which can be added up, pain and suffering has no price tag and no formula. The law asks a jury to translate a human experience of pain,...
The Problem: Valuing the Unmeasurable
California law divides a personal injury plaintiff's damages into economic and noneconomic categories. Economic damages — medical expenses, lost earnings, and the like — can be documented and calculated. Noneconomic damages — pain and suffering, physical impairment, disfigurement, inconvenience, anxiety, and loss of enjoyment of life — cannot. There is no market price for a day of chronic pain or a lifetime of limited mobility. California Civil Code § 3333 allows recovery of all detriment proximately caused by a tort, and the standard jury instruction, CACI 3905A, directs the jury to award a reasonable amount for noneconomic loss without providing a formula, telling jurors that no fixed standard exists and that they must use their judgment. This open-ended standard creates a practical difficulty: how is a lawyer to help a jury arrive at a number when the law provides none?
Beagle v. Vasold and the Per Diem Argument
The California Supreme Court answered part of that question in Beagle v. Vasold, 65 Cal.2d 166 (1966). The Court held that a lawyer may argue to the jury that it should value pain and suffering by reference to a per diem or per-unit-of-time rate — for example, suggesting that a certain amount per day, multiplied over the plaintiff expected period of suffering, yields an appropriate total. The Court reasoned that while pain and suffering cannot be measured precisely, the law already asks juries to fix a sum for it, and counsel should be permitted to offer the jury a rational way to approach the task. A per diem argument does not change the legal standard — the jury still must award a reasonable amount in its own judgment — but it gives the jury a framework for thinking about a large, abstract figure by breaking it into smaller, more comprehensible units of time.
Beagle thus placed California among the jurisdictions that permit per diem argument, rejecting the view (held in some other states) that suggesting a mathematical formula for an inherently unmeasurable loss misleads the jury. The California approach trusts the jury, properly instructed, to treat counsel suggestion as argument rather than evidence and to exercise its own judgment.
What a Per Diem Argument Looks Like
In practice, a per diem argument breaks the plaintiff's suffering into time units and assigns a value to each. Counsel might suggest that a day of living with chronic pain is worth a stated amount, then multiply that figure by the number of days in the plaintiff remaining life expectancy to produce a lifetime total; or counsel might use smaller units — hours, for instance — to make the point that the suffering is continuous. The argument is rhetorical as much as arithmetical: its force comes from reframing an overwhelming lifetime total as the accumulation of many individually comprehensible units, and from inviting the jury to consider what a day of the plaintiff's experience is worth. Because it is argument and not evidence, the suggested figure is not binding on the jury, and the jury remains free to award more, less, or a figure reached by entirely different reasoning.
The Limits: The Suggested Figure Is Argument, Not Evidence
The permission granted by Beagle comes with an important qualification: a per diem suggestion is argument, not evidence, and must be understood as such. Counsel may suggest a figure and a method, but counsel may not present the suggested per diem rate as though it were a proven fact or an established value, and the jury must understand that the ultimate award rests on its own judgment under the instructions. Courts guard against the risk that a confidently presented mathematical formula will be mistaken for something more objective than it is. The line is between offering the jury a reasoned way to approach the valuation — permitted — and implying that the law or the evidence dictates a particular number — not permitted. A trial court retains discretion to regulate argument so that it stays within these bounds.
The Golden Rule Prohibition
A related limit is the prohibition on the "golden rule" argument. Counsel may not ask the jurors to put themselves in the plaintiff's position and award the amount they would want for themselves, because such an argument invites the jury to decide the case on personal interest and sympathy rather than on an impartial assessment of the evidence. The golden rule prohibition and the per diem rule interact: a lawyer may suggest a per diem value as a reasoned framework, but may not convert it into an improper appeal by asking each juror what they personally would charge to endure the plaintiff's pain. The distinction can be subtle, and courts police it, because the valuation of pain and suffering is already an emotionally charged exercise and the rules are designed to keep it tethered to reasoned judgment rather than raw sympathy.
Review of Excessive (or Inadequate) Verdicts
Because noneconomic damages rest on the jury's judgment, appellate and trial courts give verdicts substantial deference, but not unlimited deference. A verdict for pain and suffering may be challenged as excessive (or, less commonly, inadequate), and the trial court may address an excessive verdict through a motion for new trial or a remittitur under Code of Civil Procedure § 662.5, conditioning the denial of a new trial on the plaintiff's acceptance of a reduced amount. The classic California statement of the standard appears in Seffert v. Los Angeles Transit Lines, 56 Cal.2d 498 (1961), where the Court addressed when a pain-and-suffering award is so large as to shock the conscience and reflect passion or prejudice. The reviewing court does not substitute its own judgment for the jury simply because it would have awarded a different figure; it intervenes only when the award is so disproportionate to the injury that it cannot be explained as the product of reasoned decision. This deferential-but-real review is the backstop that keeps per diem argument, and noneconomic awards generally, within bounds.
How the Per Diem Argument Interacts With MICRA
In cases subject to the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA) — professional negligence claims against health care providers — the value of noneconomic damages is capped by statute. California Civil Code § 3333.2 limits noneconomic damages in such cases, with the cap amount adjusted upward over time under the 2022 legislation that revised MICRA. A per diem argument in a MICRA case operates against that ceiling: however the jury reasons about pain and suffering, the recoverable noneconomic award cannot exceed the statutory cap. Outside the MICRA context — in ordinary personal injury cases — there is generally no comparable statutory cap on noneconomic damages, so the per diem argument and the jury's judgment, subject to review for excessiveness, set the figure. Understanding whether a case is subject to MICRA is therefore essential to understanding how far a per diem argument can carry.
Why the Per Diem Argument Matters to Injured People
For an injured person, the per diem argument matters because it addresses a real risk: that a jury, faced with an unmeasurable loss and no formula, will undervalue pain and suffering simply because it does not know how to think about the number. A reasoned per diem framework gives the jury a disciplined way to account for the duration and continuity of the plaintiff's suffering, which can be the difference between an award that reflects the true impact of an injury and one that reflects the jury's discomfort with large figures. At the same time, the limits on the argument — that it is argument not evidence, that it cannot become a golden rule appeal, and that the resulting verdict is reviewable — protect the fairness of the process. The per diem argument is thus a tool that, used properly, helps juries do a genuinely difficult job. Injured people can learn more about the firm's work in California personal injury cases, including our work as a Los Angeles personal injury lawyer.
Practical Points for California Injury Cases
Several practical points follow. First, the availability of a per diem argument means that how a plaintiff presents the duration and daily reality of pain and suffering — through testimony, medical evidence, and day-in-the-life proof — directly supports the valuation framework counsel will offer. Second, the argument must be framed as a reasoned suggestion, not a mandatory calculation, to stay within Beagle limits. Third, because noneconomic verdicts are reviewable for excessiveness, a plaintiff benefits from a record that connects the award to the evidence rather than to sympathy. And fourth, in MICRA cases, counsel and client must understand that the statutory cap will limit the recoverable noneconomic award regardless of the jury's reasoning. Taken together, these points show that valuing pain and suffering, far from being arbitrary, is governed by a structured body of law that balances the plaintiff's right to full compensation against the need for reasoned, reviewable judgment.
Day-in-the-Life Evidence and Supporting the Figure
A per diem argument is only as persuasive as the evidence of suffering behind it. Because the argument asks the jury to value each unit of time the plaintiff spends in pain or disability, the plaintiff benefits from evidence that makes the daily reality of the injury concrete. Day-in-the-life evidence — testimony and, where appropriate, visual proof showing how the plaintiff manages ordinary activities, the accommodations the injury forces, the tasks that have become impossible, and the continuous presence of pain — gives the jury a factual basis for assigning value to a day. Medical testimony about the permanence of a condition, the expected duration of symptoms, and the plaintiff's life expectancy supplies the time horizon over which a per diem figure is multiplied. Testimony from family members and the plaintiff themselves about sleep, mood, relationships, and the loss of activities once enjoyed fills in the human detail. Without this foundation, a per diem figure can seem arbitrary; with it, the figure becomes a reasoned way of accounting for a documented, continuing loss.
The connection between evidence and argument also matters on appeal. Because a noneconomic verdict is reviewed for excessiveness, an award that is well supported by evidence of serious, permanent, daily suffering is far more defensible than one that appears to rest on sympathy. A plaintiff who builds a thorough evidentiary record of the injury impact gives the trial court and any reviewing court a basis to sustain the verdict as the product of reasoned decision rather than passion or prejudice.
The Per Diem Debate Across Jurisdictions
California permission for per diem argument reflects one side of a long-running national debate. Some jurisdictions bar per diem arguments entirely, reasoning that assigning a mathematical rate to an inherently unmeasurable loss creates a false appearance of precision and may mislead the jury into treating a lawyer suggestion as evidence. Other jurisdictions, like California after Beagle v. Vasold, permit the argument, trusting the jury — properly instructed that the figure is argument, not evidence — to use it as a framework while exercising independent judgment. A third group leaves the matter to the trial court's discretion. California approach places it among the jurisdictions that allow the argument, subject to the limits already described: the figure is argument, it cannot become a golden rule appeal, and the verdict remains reviewable. For a California injured person, the significance of this debate is simply that the tool is available here, where in some other states it would not be. That availability, used responsibly, helps juries approach the genuinely difficult task of valuing human suffering in a disciplined way rather than guessing at a number with no framework at all.
Related Guides
For related reading, see our personal injury news, and learn more about the firm's work representing injured people in California personal injury matters.
- California Personal Injury Lawyers
- The Ensuing Loss Doctrine and the Faulty Workmanship Exclusion in California Property Insurance
- The Judgment-Creditor Direct Action Against an Insurer Under Insurance Code Section 11580 in California
- Superseding and Intervening Causes in California Personal Injury Law: When a Later Event Breaks the Chain of Liability
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a per diem argument?
It is a closing-argument technique in which a lawyer suggests valuing pain and suffering by a rate per unit of time — for example, an amount per day multiplied over the period of suffering — to give the jury a framework for arriving at a figure for an otherwise unmeasurable loss.
Is the per diem argument allowed in California?
Yes. In Beagle v. Vasold, 65 Cal.2d 166 (1966), the California Supreme Court held that counsel may argue a per diem or per-unit-of-time valuation for pain and suffering, treating it as a permissible way to help the jury approach the task.
Does a per diem figure bind the jury?
No. A per diem suggestion is argument, not evidence. The jury must award a reasonable amount in its own judgment under CACI 3905A and may award more, less, or a figure reached by different reasoning. Counsel may not present the suggested rate as an established value.
What is the golden rule prohibition?
It bars counsel from asking jurors to award what they personally would want if they were the plaintiff, because that invites a decision based on self-interest and sympathy rather than impartial judgment. A per diem argument must not cross into a golden rule appeal.
How do courts handle an excessive pain-and-suffering verdict?
A trial court may grant a new trial or order a remittitur under Code of Civil Procedure § 662.5, conditioning denial of a new trial on acceptance of a reduced amount. Under Seffert v. Los Angeles Transit Lines, 56 Cal.2d 498 (1961), appellate courts intervene only when an award is so disproportionate that it reflects passion or prejudice.
Is there a cap on pain-and-suffering damages?
In ordinary personal injury cases, no comparable statutory cap generally applies. In MICRA cases — professional negligence against health care providers — Civil Code § 3333.2 caps noneconomic damages, with the cap amount increasing over time under the 2022 revisions. A per diem argument in a MICRA case operates against that ceiling.
Why is pain and suffering so hard to value?
Because it has no market price and no formula. Unlike medical bills and lost wages, pain, disability, and loss of enjoyment of life cannot be added up. The law asks the jury to use its judgment, and the per diem argument exists to help the jury approach that judgment in a structured way.
Does strong evidence of daily suffering help?
Yes. Because a per diem argument values suffering by its duration and daily reality, testimony, medical evidence, and day-in-the-life proof that show how the injury affects the plaintiff every day directly support the valuation framework and help connect the award to the evidence.
Speak With a California Personal Injury Attorney
If you have suffered a serious injury, the value of your pain and suffering may be the largest part of your claim — and the hardest to prove. Trembach Law Firm presents the daily reality of our clients' suffering and uses the tools California law allows, including the per diem argument approved in Beagle v. Vasold, to help juries arrive at a figure that reflects the true impact of an injury. For a free consultation, call (213) 645-2246. Because noneconomic damages turn on how well the duration and depth of suffering are presented and argued, skilled advocacy on this point can be decisive to a fair recovery.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301