WORKER CLASSIFICATION | 2026-11-11

Prop 22 App-Based Driver Classification After Castellanos in California (2026)

Proposition 22 classifies qualifying app-based drivers as independent contractors, and the California Supreme Court upheld it in Castellanos.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

Proposition 22, approved by California voters in 2020, carved app-based rideshare and delivery drivers out of the state employee-classification rules and defined them as independent contractors when certain conditions are met, while guaranteeing a limited set of benefits. In 2024 the California Supr

A ballot measure that rewrote driver classification

Few recent changes in California employment law have been as consequential, or as contested, as Proposition 22. Passed by voters in November 2020 and codified at Business and Professions Code § 7448 and the sections that follow, Prop 22 responded directly to the wave of classification reform that had swept rideshare and delivery work into the employee column. It created a special legal category for app-based drivers who work for network companies, defining them as independent contractors rather than employees when specified conditions are satisfied, and attaching a package of limited benefits in exchange.

For drivers, the practical stakes are large. Employee status would bring minimum wage for all hours, overtime, meal and rest breaks, reimbursement of expenses, workers' compensation, and more. Independent-contractor status under Prop 22 instead provides a narrower, specially designed set of protections. Understanding exactly what Prop 22 does is essential for any driver or company operating in this space.

The classification problem Prop 22 answered

To understand Prop 22, start with the law it displaced. In Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court (2018), the California Supreme Court adopted the ABC test for determining employee status under the Wage Orders. Under the ABC test, a worker is presumed to be an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three prongs: that the worker is free from control and direction, that the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business, and that the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade. The Legislature codified and extended that framework in AB 5, now found principally at Labor Code § 2775.

The ABC test is demanding, and its second prong is especially hard for rideshare and delivery companies to satisfy, because driving is arguably within the usual course of a company whose business is arranging rides and deliveries. Prop 22 was written to take app-based drivers out of that analysis entirely for the defined category.

What Prop 22 actually provides

Business and Professions Code § 7448 and following classify an app-based driver for a network company as an independent contractor, and not an employee or agent, with respect to the driver's relationship with the network company, if certain conditions are met. The central conditions concern control: the network company must not set specific dates, times of day, or a minimum number of hours during which the driver must work; must not require the driver to accept any specific rideshare or delivery service request as a condition of maintaining access to the platform; must not restrict the driver from performing services through other network companies except while engaged on a request; and must not restrict the driver from working in any other lawful occupation or business.

If the company imposes those kinds of control, the Prop 22 classification does not apply. The measure's independent-contractor status is thus conditional: it depends on the company genuinely leaving the driver free to choose when to work, which requests to accept, and whether to work for competitors.

The limited benefits Prop 22 guarantees

In exchange for independent-contractor status, Prop 22 requires network companies to provide a defined package of alternative benefits. These include a minimum earnings guarantee calculated by reference to the driver's engaged time (generally the time from accepting a request to completing it), a per-mile compensation component for expenses, a health-care subsidy or stipend for drivers who log sufficient engaged hours, occupational-accident insurance to cover on-the-job injuries, and protection against discrimination and sexual harassment.

These benefits are deliberately narrower than the full suite of employee protections, and they are calibrated to engaged time rather than to all hours a driver spends logged in and available. That engaged-time calibration is one of the most criticized features of the measure, because time spent waiting for requests may not count toward the earnings floor. Drivers evaluating their pay should understand which portions of their time count under the Prop 22 formulas and which do not. The specific dollar amounts and thresholds are set by the measure and adjusted over time, so drivers should verify current figures rather than assume a fixed number.

Castellanos v. State of California upholds Prop 22

Prop 22's validity was challenged almost immediately. Opponents argued that the measure unconstitutionally restricted the Legislature's authority over workers' compensation and violated other provisions of the California Constitution. In Castellanos v. State of California (2024), the California Supreme Court upheld Proposition 22 against that state-constitutional challenge. The Court rejected the argument that Prop 22 impermissibly intruded on the Legislature's workers'-compensation power, concluding that the measure could stand.

The upshot of Castellanos is that Prop 22 remains in force. App-based drivers in the defined category are, as a matter of California law, independent contractors with respect to their network companies when the measure's conditions are met, and they receive the Prop 22 benefit package rather than full employee status. Drivers and companies can now operate with greater certainty about the governing rule, though the broader policy debate continues.

How Prop 22 fits with AB 5 and the ABC test

Prop 22 is best understood as a carve-out, a specific exception to the general classification regime of AB 5 and Labor Code § 2775. For workers who fall outside the app-based-driver definition, the ordinary analysis still governs: the ABC test under Dynamex and § 2775 presumptively applies, subject to the statutory exemptions that route certain occupations to the older multifactor test from S.G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341. Prop 22 does not disturb that framework for anyone other than the app-based drivers it defines.

This layered structure means classification in California now depends heavily on the precise nature of the work and the engaging entity. A delivery driver working through a network company covered by Prop 22 is analyzed one way; a courier working through a traditional dispatch service may be analyzed under the ABC test or a statutory Borello exemption. For a detailed look at one of those statutory exemptions, see our discussion of the AB 5 referral-agency exemption under Labor Code section 2777, which shifts qualifying workers to the Borello test rather than the ABC test.

What Prop 22 does not cover

It is important to recognize the boundaries of Prop 22. The measure governs the relationship between a qualifying app-based driver and the network company. It does not transform every gig worker into an exempt contractor, and it does not override protections that apply regardless of classification. A driver who believes a company has misclassified them by imposing the kind of control Prop 22 forbids, or who is not an app-based driver at all, may still have a classification claim under the ABC test and § 2775.

Moreover, Prop 22's independent-contractor status does not strip drivers of the anti-discrimination and anti-harassment protections the measure itself guarantees, nor of generally applicable protections that do not depend on employee status. Drivers who face discrimination, harassment, or denial of the Prop 22 benefits they are owed may have claims to enforce those specific rights.

Practical guidance for drivers

Drivers who want to understand their rights under Prop 22 should start by examining how the network company treats them in practice. Does the company dictate specific hours, penalize declining requests, or bar working for competitors? If so, the conditions for Prop 22 classification may not be met, which could matter to a classification analysis. Drivers should also track their engaged time, earnings, and mileage to confirm the company is honoring the minimum earnings guarantee and expense components, and should keep records of their logged hours to assess eligibility for the health-care stipend.

If a driver believes the company has failed to pay the guaranteed benefits, has misclassified them by imposing forbidden control, or has discriminated against them, documentation is key. Save earnings summaries, trip records, and communications from the platform. Our employment-law news page follows classification and gig-economy developments as the law continues to evolve.

Engaged time versus logged-in time

One of the most important and least understood features of Prop 22 is the distinction between engaged time and logged-in time. Engaged time generally refers to the period from when a driver accepts a request to when the ride or delivery is completed. Logged-in time is the broader period during which a driver has the app open and is available to accept requests, including the gaps spent waiting between trips. Prop 22's minimum earnings guarantee is calibrated to engaged time, which means the waiting periods between requests may not count toward the earnings floor the same way an employee's on-call or waiting time might under employee wage law.

This distinction has real financial consequences, because in slower periods a driver may spend significant logged-in time without a corresponding pay guarantee. Drivers should track both their engaged time and their total logged-in time to understand what the earnings guarantee is actually delivering, and to assess whether the company is correctly calculating the guaranteed amount. Misunderstanding this distinction leads many drivers to assume the guarantee covers all their available time when it does not.

The amendment lock and the durability of Prop 22

Prop 22 is unusually difficult to change. As a voter initiative, it contains provisions making legislative amendment extraordinarily hard, requiring any amendment to be consistent with the measure's purpose and to pass by an extraordinary legislative supermajority, and barring certain changes outright, such as authorizing collective bargaining for the covered drivers except through a narrowly defined path. The practical effect is that the rules Prop 22 established are entrenched and cannot be casually altered by ordinary legislation.

After Castellanos v. State of California (2024) upheld the measure, that durability became more significant. Drivers and companies can rely on the Prop 22 framework as the operative law for the defined category for the foreseeable future, absent a new ballot measure or a successful future legal challenge on different grounds. For drivers, this stability cuts both ways: the guaranteed benefits are locked in, but so is the independent-contractor classification and the limits that come with it.

Deactivation and the loss of platform access

Because app-based drivers depend on continued access to the platform, deactivation, the loss of the ability to accept requests, functions much like a termination in its effect on livelihood. Prop 22 and related provisions address deactivation by requiring network companies to maintain certain procedures, including advance notice in some circumstances and an opportunity to be reconsidered, rather than permitting arbitrary, unexplained removals. A driver who is deactivated should request the company's stated reason and any available appeal or reconsideration process, and should preserve the communications surrounding the deactivation.

Deactivation that is actually a pretext for discrimination or for retaliation against a driver who asserted rights, such as complaining about unpaid guaranteed earnings, may implicate the anti-discrimination protections Prop 22 itself guarantees and other generally applicable laws. The key is to document the sequence of events, because the timing and the company's shifting explanations are often the most revealing evidence.

When a misclassification claim may still exist

Prop 22's independent-contractor status is conditional. It applies only when the network company refrains from the specific forms of control the measure prohibits: dictating particular hours, requiring acceptance of specific requests as a condition of access, restricting work for competitors except while engaged, and barring other lawful work. If a company crosses those lines, the foundation for Prop 22 classification may be undermined, and a worker could argue that the ordinary classification analysis under the ABC test and Labor Code § 2775 should apply. In that event, the demanding ABC test, which presumes employee status unless the hiring entity proves all three prongs, would govern.

Similarly, a worker who does not actually fit the app-based-driver definition, for example because the work or the engaging entity falls outside Prop 22's scope, is not covered by the carve-out at all and is analyzed under the general rules. Classification therefore remains a fact-intensive inquiry even in the gig economy, and a driver should not assume that Prop 22 forecloses every classification argument.

Enforcing the benefits Prop 22 promises

The benefits Prop 22 guarantees are only meaningful if they are actually paid. A driver who believes the company has failed to meet the minimum earnings guarantee, has miscalculated engaged time or mileage, or has wrongly denied the health-care stipend despite sufficient engaged hours has a basis to challenge that failure. The measure also guarantees occupational-accident insurance for on-the-job injuries and protection against discrimination and harassment, and those guarantees can be enforced. Drivers should keep earnings statements, trip logs, and mileage records, because reconstructing what the company owed requires the underlying data.

Representative enforcement may also be available where a company systematically shortchanges a category of drivers, and generally applicable protections that do not depend on employee status continue to apply. The enforceability of the Prop 22 package is what gives the measure its character as a genuine, if limited, set of protections rather than a hollow promise.

What drivers gave up and what they kept

Understanding Prop 22 requires an honest accounting of the trade-off. By classifying covered drivers as independent contractors, the measure means those drivers do not receive the full suite of employee protections: minimum wage for all hours including waiting time, daily and weekly overtime, mandatory meal and rest breaks with premiums, full expense reimbursement under Labor Code § 2802, state-mandated workers' compensation, unemployment insurance, and paid sick leave on the terms employees receive. In their place, drivers receive the Prop 22 package tied to engaged time.

What drivers kept is the flexibility the measure protects, the freedom to choose when to work, which requests to accept, and whether to work for multiple platforms, along with the guaranteed benefits. Whether that trade is favorable depends heavily on an individual driver's circumstances and work patterns. What is not negotiable is the company's obligation to actually honor the conditions and benefits the measure requires, and a driver who is denied them should seek advice.

Occupational-accident insurance and on-the-job injuries

Because covered drivers are classified as independent contractors under Prop 22, they do not receive traditional state workers' compensation. In its place, the measure requires network companies to carry occupational-accident insurance to cover medical expenses and lost income resulting from injuries suffered while the driver is engaged on the platform. A driver injured during a ride or delivery should promptly report the injury to the company, seek medical attention, and document the circumstances, because the availability of coverage generally turns on whether the driver was engaged at the time of the injury. The distinction between engaged and merely logged-in time can therefore determine whether an injury is covered, which is one more reason drivers should understand and track their engaged time.

Disputes can arise over whether an injury occurred during engaged time, over the extent of medical and wage-replacement benefits, and over the insurer's handling of the claim. A driver who believes a legitimate injury claim has been wrongly denied or underpaid should preserve trip records showing engagement status at the time of the injury and seek advice about enforcing the coverage Prop 22 requires.

How Prop 22 compares to other classification exemptions

Prop 22 is one of several ways a worker can end up outside the default ABC-test analysis in California, but it is distinct from the statutory occupational exemptions. Some occupations are routed to the older multifactor test from S.G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341 by specific statutory exemptions within AB 5, while Prop 22 instead creates an outright classification rule for the defined app-based category, coupled with its benefit package. The difference matters: a Borello exemption still requires a fact-intensive assessment of the working relationship, whereas Prop 22 supplies a categorical answer for covered drivers who meet its conditions, in exchange for the guaranteed benefits.

Understanding which regime applies is the threshold question in any gig-economy classification dispute. A courier, delivery worker, or driver should first ask whether they fall within the Prop 22 app-based-driver definition at all, then whether the company satisfies the measure's conditions, and only then whether some other exemption or the default ABC test governs. These layers make California gig classification genuinely complex, and a careful analysis of the specific facts is essential before concluding how a given worker should be classified.

Talk to a California employment lawyer. If you drive for an app-based network company and believe you are owed guaranteed benefits, were misclassified despite the company controlling your work, or faced discrimination, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can assess your rights under Proposition 22 and California classification law. Call (213) 645-2246 for a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are app-based drivers employees or independent contractors in California?

Under Proposition 22, codified at Business and Professions Code § 7448 and following, qualifying app-based drivers for network companies are classified as independent contractors when the measure's conditions are met, rather than employees. The California Supreme Court upheld the measure in Castellanos v. State of California (2024).

What conditions must be met for Prop 22 to apply?

The network company must not set specific hours, must not require the driver to accept particular requests as a condition of platform access, must not bar the driver from working for other companies except while engaged on a request, and must not restrict other lawful work. If the company imposes that control, the classification may not apply.

What benefits does Prop 22 provide?

Prop 22 guarantees a limited package: a minimum earnings guarantee tied to engaged time, a per-mile expense component, a health-care stipend for drivers with sufficient engaged hours, occupational-accident insurance, and anti-discrimination and anti-harassment protection. These are narrower than full employee benefits.

Did Castellanos change whether Prop 22 is valid?

Castellanos v. State of California (2024) upheld Proposition 22 against a state-constitutional challenge, including the argument that it improperly restricted the Legislature's workers'-compensation authority. The measure remains in force.

How does Prop 22 relate to AB 5 and the ABC test?

Prop 22 is an exception to AB 5 and the ABC test of Labor Code § 2775 for the defined app-based-driver category only. Workers outside that category are still analyzed under the ABC test or an applicable statutory Borello exemption.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301