WORKER CLASSIFICATION | 2026-11-10
Dynamex Retroactivity Under Vazquez v. Jan-Pro: California 2026
California applies the Dynamex ABC worker-classification test retroactively to cases pending when Dynamex was decided.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
When California adopted the strict ABC worker-classification test in Dynamex (2018), a key question was whether it applied to earlier conduct. In Vazquez v. Jan-Pro (2021), the California Supreme Court held the ABC test applies retroactively to cases pending when Dynamex was decided, creating substa
The ABC Test Applies Retroactively in California
When the California Supreme Court adopted the strict ABC test for worker classification in Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) 4 Cal.5th 903, it upended decades of settled expectations about who counts as an independent contractor. A critical follow-up question was whether the new test applied only going forward or also to conduct that predated the decision. In Vazquez v. Jan-Pro Franchising International, Inc. (2021) 10 Cal.5th 944, the Court answered that the Dynamex ABC test applies retroactively to all cases that were not yet final when Dynamex was decided. For employers that used contractor labor before 2018, that holding created substantial back-wage exposure, and for misclassified workers it reopened the door to years of unpaid obligations.
This guide explains the ABC test, the Vazquez retroactivity holding and its reasoning, how AB 5 and its exemptions codified and modified the standard, how the Borello multifactor test still survives, and what the retroactivity rule means in practice for wage claims, penalties, and employer defenses.
What the ABC Test Requires
Under the ABC test, a worker is presumed to be an employee for purposes of the wage orders, and the hiring entity bears the burden of proving all three of the following to establish independent-contractor status. Part A: the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract and in fact. Part B: the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business. Part C: the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed. If the hiring entity fails to prove any one prong, the worker is an employee.
Prong B is often decisive. A cleaning company that classifies its cleaners as contractors, or a bakery that treats its cake decorators as contractors, will usually fail prong B because the workers perform the very service the business sells. That is precisely the kind of arrangement Vazquez addressed in the janitorial-franchise context.
The Vazquez Retroactivity Holding
In Vazquez, janitorial workers alleged they had been misclassified as independent contractors through a multi-tier franchise structure. The litigation was pending when Dynamex was decided, and the question reached the California Supreme Court on whether the ABC test governed the pre-2018 conduct. The Court held that Dynamex applies retroactively. It reasoned that judicial decisions interpreting statutes ordinarily apply both prospectively and retroactively, that Dynamex addressed the meaning of the suffer-or-permit-to-work standard already embedded in the wage orders rather than announcing a brand-new rule from whole cloth, and that the parties had no sufficiently settled, reasonable reliance interest in the old approach to justify a departure from the usual rule of retroactivity.
The practical consequence is significant. Employers cannot defend pre-2018 misclassification by arguing that they relied on the more flexible multifactor approach that preceded Dynamex. Claims that were live in 2018 and later are measured against the ABC test even for the earlier work.
How AB 5 Codified and Limited the Test
The Legislature responded to Dynamex with Assembly Bill 5, which codified the ABC test at Labor Code § 2775 and created a long list of exemptions. For exempt occupations and relationships, the older multifactor test from S.G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341 applies instead of the ABC test. The exemptions, expanded by AB 2257, cover many professional, creative, and business-to-business relationships, each with its own conditions set out across Labor Code § 2776 through § 2784. An employer invoking an exemption must satisfy every element of the specific exemption; falling just short returns the relationship to the ABC test.
Because AB 5 operates prospectively as a statute while Vazquez addressed the judicial test, the two interact in time-sensitive ways. For periods governed by the ABC test, whether through Dynamex retroactivity or AB 5 codification, the three-prong analysis controls unless a valid exemption applies.
Borello Still Matters
The ABC test did not erase the Borello standard. Borello uses a multifactor analysis centered on the hiring entity's right to control the manner and means of the work, along with secondary factors such as whether the work is part of the hirer's regular business, the skill required, who supplies the tools and workplace, the method of payment, and the parties' belief about the relationship. Borello continues to govern claims that fall within an AB 5 exemption and certain claims outside the wage orders. Distinguishing when Borello applies and when the ABC test applies is one of the most important threshold questions in a California classification dispute, because the two tests can produce different results on the same facts.
What Retroactivity Means for Back-Wage Exposure
Because Vazquez reaches back to work performed before 2018 in cases that were still pending, a misclassified worker can pursue unpaid minimum wage, unpaid overtime, meal- and rest-period premiums, unreimbursed business expenses under Labor Code § 2802, and wage-statement and waiting-time penalties for periods that an employer assumed were closed. Misclassification is the gateway violation: once a worker is reclassified as an employee, every wage-and-hour protection in the Labor Code and the applicable wage order attaches to the prior work. For employers with large contractor workforces, aggregated across many workers and multiple years, the retroactive exposure can be substantial.
Civil Penalties for Willful Misclassification
Beyond unpaid wages, California imposes penalties for willful misclassification. Labor Code § 226.8 prohibits willfully misclassifying an individual as an independent contractor and authorizes civil penalties, which increase where there is a pattern or practice of violations. Separately, misclassification claims are frequently pursued through the Private Attorneys General Act, which lets an aggrieved employee recover civil penalties on behalf of the state. The combination of back wages, § 226.8 penalties, and PAGA exposure is what makes classification one of the highest-stakes areas of California employment law.
Employer Defenses and Their Limits
An employer defending a classification claim for a period governed by the ABC test must prove all three prongs, and good-faith reliance on the pre-Dynamex landscape is not a defense to the retroactive application of the test under Vazquez. The strongest genuine defenses are that a valid AB 5 exemption applies so that Borello governs, that under Borello the hiring entity lacked the right to control the manner and means of the work, or that the worker in fact operated an independent business serving multiple clients. Contractual labels calling the worker an independent contractor carry little weight; California looks to the economic and practical reality of the relationship, not the paperwork.
Employers should also recognize that the single-entity and joint-employer doctrines can pull affiliated companies into liability. Our analysis of the integrated-enterprise single-employer test in California explains how separate but related entities can be treated as one employer, which often matters alongside a misclassification claim.
Deadlines and How to Pursue a Claim
Wage claims carry different limitations periods depending on the theory, commonly three years for statutory wage violations and up to four years when an unfair-competition theory under Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 is added, with PAGA claims subject to their own notice and timing rules. A worker who believes a current or former hiring arrangement was a misclassification should gather pay records, contracts, scheduling and control evidence, and communications showing how the work was actually directed. Because the interplay of Dynamex, Vazquez, AB 5 exemptions, and Borello is technical, early legal evaluation helps identify the correct test and the full scope of recoverable wages and penalties. For current developments, see our California employment law news.
The Suffer-or-Permit-to-Work Foundation
The ABC test did not appear out of nowhere. The California Supreme Court in Dynamex grounded it in the suffer-or-permit-to-work language that has long defined employment in the wage orders. That phrase is deliberately broad, reaching anyone the hiring entity knowingly allows to work. Vazquez leaned on this history to conclude that Dynamex interpreted an existing standard rather than invented a new obligation, which was central to its retroactivity holding. Because the wage orders already used the expansive suffer-or-permit standard before 2018, the Court reasoned that employers had no settled right to rely on a narrower test for wage-order coverage. This doctrinal lineage is why a worker can reach back to pre-2018 conduct: the governing wage-order language did not change, only the articulation of how to apply it.
Understanding this foundation helps workers and employers see why contractual labels and prior industry custom carry so little weight. The wage orders protect those the business suffers or permits to work, and the three prongs of the ABC test operationalize that protection.
Franchise and Multi-Tier Structures
Vazquez arose in a janitorial-franchise setting, where workers performed cleaning services through layered franchise agreements. Complex contractual structures, including franchises, multi-tier subcontracting, and labor intermediaries, do not automatically defeat employee status. Courts look through the paperwork to the economic reality: who benefits from the work, whose business the work is part of, and whether the worker genuinely runs an independent enterprise. Where the workers perform the core service the enterprise sells, prong B of the ABC test, codified at Labor Code § 2775, is difficult to satisfy regardless of how many contracting layers sit between the worker and the ultimate beneficiary. Employers should not assume that interposing a franchise or staffing structure converts employees into contractors.
Industries Where Prong B Commonly Fails
Prong B, requiring that the worker perform work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business, is the most common point of failure. A delivery company that classifies its drivers as contractors, a salon that classifies its stylists as contractors, a trucking firm that classifies its drivers as contractors, and a cleaning company that classifies its cleaners as contractors all tend to fail prong B because the workers perform the very service the business is in the business of providing. By contrast, a retail store that hires an outside plumber to fix a leak is engaging someone outside its usual course of business, so prong B is satisfied for that plumber. The distinction is practical: is the worker doing the company's core work, or a genuinely ancillary service.
Evaluating Your Own Classification
A worker trying to assess whether he or she was misclassified should look honestly at all three prongs. On control, did the company dictate schedules, methods, training, and supervision, or was the worker genuinely independent. On prong B, was the work the company's core product or service. On prong C, did the worker actually operate an independent business, with other clients, a business license, marketing, and the usual indicia of entrepreneurship, or did the worker depend entirely on the one company. Failing any single prong means the worker is an employee for wage-order purposes. Because the hiring entity bears the burden of proving all three under Labor Code § 2775, a worker does not have to disprove independent-contractor status; the company must affirmatively establish it.
Class and Representative Treatment
Misclassification claims frequently proceed as class actions or as PAGA representative actions because employers tend to classify entire categories of workers the same way. Common classification policies make the claims well suited to collective treatment, since the central question, whether the policy satisfies the ABC test, is usually common across the group. A single classification decision applied to hundreds of drivers or cleaners can generate aggregated back-wage and penalty exposure across the whole workforce and across multiple years, which is amplified by the Vazquez rule reaching pre-2018 periods. This aggregation is why classification cases settle for substantial sums and why employers should audit their contractor rosters proactively.
Reclassification and Going-Forward Compliance
An employer that concludes its workers are misclassified should move to reclassify them as employees and bring wage practices into compliance, including minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest periods, expense reimbursement under Labor Code § 2802, and accurate wage statements. Reclassification going forward does not erase past exposure, but it stops the accrual of new violations and demonstrates good faith. Employers relying on an AB 5 exemption to keep a worker as a contractor should paper the relationship to satisfy every element of the specific exemption in Labor Code § 2776 through § 2784 and apply the Borello factors conservatively, because a failed exemption drops the relationship back into the ABC test with full retroactive exposure.
Why Reliance on the Old Law Is No Defense
Employers often argue that it is unfair to apply the ABC test to conduct that predated Dynamex, because they structured their relationships in reliance on the more flexible multifactor approach that courts used for decades. Vazquez rejected that argument as a basis for prospective-only application. The California Supreme Court explained that the ordinary rule is retroactivity for judicial decisions interpreting statutes, that an exception requires a sufficiently settled and reasonable reliance interest plus inequity from retroactive application, and that neither was present because the suffer-or-permit standard already governed the wage orders. The Court also noted that the wage protections at stake are remedial and serve important public purposes, which weighs against carving out a reliance exception. For employers, the practical consequence is stark: good-faith reliance on pre-2018 classification practice does not immunize pre-2018 conduct from the ABC test in cases that were still pending when Dynamex came down.
This is why misclassification audits should account for exposure stretching back before 2018 wherever claims remained live, rather than assuming that older periods are automatically closed.
The Scope of AB 5 Exemptions
AB 5, as expanded by AB 2257, exempts a long list of occupations and relationships from the ABC test, returning them to the Borello multifactor analysis. The exemptions span specified professional services, certain creative and media roles, licensed professionals, and qualifying business-to-business contracting relationships, each with detailed conditions set out across Labor Code § 2776 through § 2784. The business-to-business exemption, for example, requires the contracting business to meet numerous criteria showing genuine independence, and the failure of any required criterion defeats the exemption. Because the exemptions are narrow and element-specific, an employer that wants to rely on one must satisfy every condition, not merely resemble the general category. A relationship that falls just short of an exemption is governed by the ABC test under Labor Code § 2775 with all the retroactive exposure that implies.
Documenting a Defensible Contractor Relationship
For relationships that genuinely qualify for an exemption and are governed by Borello, employers should build a record that supports independence under the control-focused multifactor test: a worker who sets their own schedule and methods, supplies their own tools and workspace, serves multiple clients, holds any required licenses, markets an independent business, and is paid by the project rather than by time. None of these factors is individually decisive under Borello, but together they paint the picture of a true independent business. For relationships governed by the ABC test, no amount of documentation substitutes for satisfying the three prongs, and the most important reality check remains prong B: whether the worker performs the core work of the hiring entity's business.
Interaction With PAGA and the Labor Commissioner
Misclassified workers have more than one forum. They may file a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner, bring a civil action for unpaid wages and penalties, or pursue a representative action under the Private Attorneys General Act to recover civil penalties on behalf of the state. Because an employer's classification decision typically applies across an entire category of workers, PAGA is a natural vehicle, allowing an aggrieved employee to seek penalties for Labor Code violations affecting other employees as well. The willful-misclassification penalties in Labor Code § 226.8 can be pursued alongside the underlying wage recovery, and derivative violations, such as inaccurate wage statements under Labor Code § 226 and failure to reimburse expenses under Labor Code § 2802, flow automatically once the worker is recognized as an employee. The breadth of these overlapping remedies, combined with Vazquez retroactivity, is what makes misclassification one of the costliest mistakes a California business can make, and why early, accurate classification is far cheaper than defending a representative action years later.
Talk to a California employment lawyer about misclassification. If you were treated as an independent contractor but did work that was part of a company's core business, you may have been misclassified, including for periods before 2018 under Vazquez. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate your ABC-test and wage claims. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the ABC test apply to work I did before 2018?
Yes, if your case was not yet final when Dynamex was decided. Vazquez v. Jan-Pro (2021) held that the Dynamex ABC test applies retroactively, so pre-2018 misclassification can be measured against the ABC test.
What are the three prongs of the ABC test?
A worker is an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three: freedom from control, work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business, and that the worker is customarily engaged in an independent trade. The test is codified at Labor Code § 2775.
When does the older Borello test apply instead?
Borello applies to relationships that fall within an AB 5 exemption under Labor Code § 2776 through § 2784 and certain claims outside the wage orders. It uses a multifactor, control-centered analysis.
What can I recover if I was misclassified?
Potential recovery includes unpaid minimum wage and overtime, meal- and rest-period premiums, unreimbursed expenses under § 2802, wage-statement and waiting-time penalties, and penalties under § 226.8 and PAGA.
Is a signed independent-contractor agreement a defense?
No. California looks to the economic and practical reality of the relationship, not the contractual label, so a signed contractor agreement does not defeat the ABC test.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301