WORKER CLASSIFICATION | 2026-11-09

Franchisor Liability After Patterson v. Dominos in California (2026)

When the national brand, not just the local franchisee, can be held responsible as an employer under California law.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

When something goes wrong at a franchised business, workers often ask whether the national brand can be held responsible or only the local owner. In California the answer turns on control, and the California Supreme Court’s decision in Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza draws the line between a

Is the Franchisor the Employer? The California Rule

When a worker at a franchised business is harassed, fired, or underpaid, a natural question follows: can the national brand on the sign be held responsible, or only the local franchisee who signs the paychecks? In California the leading answer comes from Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza, LLC (2014) 60 Cal.4th 474. The California Supreme Court held that a franchisor is generally not the employer of its franchisee’s employees — and therefore is not vicariously liable for a franchisee supervisor’s misconduct — unless the franchisor has retained or assumed a general right of control over the franchisee’s day-to-day operations and personnel decisions.

That rule reflects a practical judgment about how franchising works. A franchise exists to let an independent local business operate under a shared brand and system. The brand standardizes the product and protects its name, but it does not necessarily run the local store. Patterson draws the line at control: branding and operational standards alone do not make the franchisor an employer, but actual control over daily operations and personnel can.

The question matters enormously in practice because the franchisor is usually the party with the deepest pockets and the most insurance. A worker harmed at a single-location franchise may find that the local owner has limited assets, while the national brand could satisfy a judgment. Patterson decides when, and whether, that national brand can be pulled into the case at all, and the answer turns on control rather than on how famous the name on the door happens to be.

What Happened in Patterson v. Domino’s

Patterson arose from allegations that a supervisor at a franchised Domino’s store sexually harassed a young employee. The employee sued not only the franchisee but Domino’s Pizza itself, arguing the franchisor should be vicariously liable as an employer. The question for the court was whether the franchisor’s comprehensive system of brand standards made it the employer of the franchisee’s workers.

The California Supreme Court said no on those facts. It recognized that franchisors impose detailed requirements — recipes, store appearance, operating hours, equipment, and marketing — to maintain uniformity and protect the brand. But imposing a comprehensive operating system is not the same as controlling the hiring, firing, supervision, and discipline of the franchisee’s employees. Because the franchisor had not retained that general right of control over personnel, it was not the employer and could not be held vicariously liable for the supervisor’s harassment.

The decision was closely divided and carefully reasoned, and it reflects a balance the court was trying to strike. It wanted to protect workers from genuine employers that hide behind franchise structures, but it did not want to make every national brand automatically liable for the misconduct of every employee at thousands of independently owned stores. The general-right-of-control standard is how the court reconciled those competing concerns.

The General Right of Control Standard

The heart of Patterson is the general right of control. A franchisor becomes a potential employer only when it has retained or assumed control over the day-to-day aspects of the franchisee’s business that bear on the employment relationship — in particular, hiring, firing, discipline, scheduling, wages, and the supervision of workers. The inquiry looks past the franchise contract’s labels to what the franchisor actually controls in practice.

The distinction is between controlling the brand and controlling the workforce. A franchisor can dictate that every pizza be made a certain way and every store look a certain way without ever deciding who gets hired, who gets fired, or how a supervisor treats a subordinate. It is only when the franchisor crosses into managing the franchisee’s personnel that the general right of control exists and employer liability can attach.

Courts applying Patterson look for concrete indicia of control over people rather than products. Did the franchisor set individual employees’ schedules or wages? Did it participate in decisions to hire or terminate specific workers? Did it discipline a franchisee’s employee directly? Did it dictate how supervisors managed their subordinates? When the answer is no, the franchisor stays on the branding side of the line; when the answer is yes, it may have assumed the kind of operational control that makes it an employer.

Why a Comprehensive Brand System Is Not Enough

Franchising depends on uniformity, and Patterson was careful not to punish that uniformity. A franchisor that provides detailed operations manuals, mandates training programs, specifies products and suppliers, and audits stores for compliance is protecting the value of its brand, not becoming the boss of the local crew. If routine brand standards converted every franchisor into an employer, the franchise model could not function.

The court therefore held that a comprehensive brand-standards and operations system, standing alone, does not create an employment relationship between the franchisor and the franchisee’s employees. The focus stays on whether the franchisor meaningfully controls personnel decisions. Plaintiffs who point only to thick operations manuals, without evidence that the franchisor controlled hiring, firing, or supervision, generally cannot establish franchisor employer liability.

This principle has real consequences for how a case is investigated. A worker’s lawyer cannot simply attach the franchise manual and declare the franchisor an employer, because the manual by itself proves brand uniformity, not personnel control. The investigation has to go further, looking at who actually made employment decisions day to day. Where that evidence is missing, the franchisor is typically dismissed, and the case proceeds against the franchisee alone.

How This Connects to the Joint-Employer Test

Patterson sits alongside the broader California test for who is an employer, set out in Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35. Martinez held that to employ means to exercise control over wages, hours, or working conditions, to suffer or permit to work, or to engage, thereby creating a common-law employment relationship. Multiple entities can be joint employers of the same worker if each exercises the requisite control.

Franchisor liability is thus a specific application of these general employer principles. A franchisor that exercised control over the franchisee employees’ wages, hours, or working conditions — or that suffered or permitted them to work — could qualify as a joint employer under Martinez even in a franchise setting. The classification question that drives franchisor liability is the same control-centered inquiry that governs independent-contractor and staffing disputes, as discussed in our guide to the AB5 professional-services exemption.

The Martinez definitions matter because they are broader than the narrow vicarious-liability question in Patterson. A franchisor might not be a traditional employer responsible for a supervisor’s harassment, yet still be a joint employer for wage-and-hour purposes if it controlled wages or hours. A thorough analysis checks the franchisor’s role against each Martinez definition separately, because an entity can be an employer under one branch of the test without satisfying another.

Labor Code 2810.3 and Contracted Labor

Separate from franchising, Labor Code § 2810.3 addresses a related problem: businesses that obtain workers through labor contractors and staffing agencies. The statute makes a client employer share civil legal responsibility with a labor contractor for the payment of wages and for the failure to secure valid workers’ compensation coverage for workers supplied to perform labor within the client’s usual course of business. It prevents a company from escaping wage liability simply by routing workers through an intermediary.

Section 2810.3 is not a franchise statute and does not override Patterson in the franchise context, but it reflects the same legislative instinct: a business that benefits from and controls contracted labor should not be able to disclaim all responsibility for it. Workers and businesses analyzing responsibility in layered arrangements need to distinguish the franchise analysis of Patterson from the contracted-labor analysis of § 2810.3, because the triggers and remedies differ.

The statute has important limits. It applies to wage and workers’ compensation obligations, not to every employment claim, and it carves out certain smaller businesses and specific arrangements. Still, for workers supplied by a staffing agency to a larger client, § 2810.3 can provide a second responsible party when the labor contractor fails to pay, and it is a tool that should be considered whenever contracted or supplied labor is involved.

What a Worker Must Show to Reach the Franchisor

A worker seeking to hold a franchisor liable must develop evidence of actual control over the franchisee’s personnel, not just brand standards. Useful proof includes franchisor involvement in hiring or firing specific employees, franchisor-set wage or scheduling decisions enforced on individual workers, franchisor discipline of franchisee staff, a franchisor hotline or manager that directed day-to-day supervision, or franchisor software that controlled labor at the individual level.

Absent that kind of operational control over people, the claim usually stops at the franchisee. That is why early investigation matters: the worker and counsel must look behind the franchise agreement to how the stores were really run. Where the franchisor stayed on the branding side of the line, Patterson protects it; where it crossed into running the workforce, the general right of control can be shown and liability can follow.

Discovery is often decisive. Internal communications, scheduling systems, training records, and corporate directives can reveal whether the franchisor reached into personnel decisions or merely enforced brand standards. Depositions of both franchisor and franchisee managers can establish who actually made the calls on hiring, discipline, and supervision. Because this evidence is in the defendants’ hands, a worker rarely knows the full picture at the outset, and the claim’s strength emerges as the facts are developed.

Why the Franchisee Still Matters Most

Even when the franchisor is out of the case, the franchisee remains fully liable as the direct employer. The franchisee is responsible for wage-and-hour compliance, for providing a workplace free of harassment and discrimination, and for the conduct of its supervisors. Workers should not assume that a franchisor’s dismissal from a case ends their claim; the local employer is usually the primary defendant and the main source of recovery.

Practically, this means a harassment or wage claim at a franchised store proceeds against the franchisee regardless of whether the national brand can be reached. The franchisor analysis under Patterson is about adding a deeper-pocketed defendant, not about whether the worker has a claim at all. The underlying rights — to be paid correctly and to work free of harassment — attach to the employment relationship itself.

Workers should therefore pursue the franchisee vigorously even while testing the franchisor’s potential liability. A well-documented claim against the direct employer stands on its own, and the possibility of reaching the franchisor is an additional avenue rather than a prerequisite. Framing the case this way protects the worker’s recovery whether or not the control evidence against the brand ultimately pans out.

Practical Guidance for Workers and Franchise Businesses

For workers, document who actually directed your work. Note whether anyone from the national company ever hired, disciplined, scheduled, or supervised you, and preserve any communications showing franchisor involvement in personnel matters. That evidence is what distinguishes a brand that merely set standards from one that controlled the workforce under Patterson.

For franchisors, the lesson is to protect the brand without seizing the franchisee’s personnel functions. Setting product and operational standards is safe; dictating individual hiring, firing, discipline, and supervision risks crossing into employer status and the vicarious liability that follows. For franchisees, full compliance with wage-and-hour and anti-harassment law is essential, because they are the direct employer and bear primary responsibility regardless of how the franchisor is structured.

Ostensible Agency and Vicarious Liability

Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza (2014) addressed whether a franchisor is the employer of a franchisee’s workers, but a separate theory sometimes lets an injured party reach a franchisor through ostensible agency. Where a franchisor’s branding leads the public reasonably to believe the franchisee is acting as the franchisor’s agent, vicarious liability can follow in some contexts. That theory, however, generally governs third-party and tort exposure rather than the employment relationship between the franchisee and its own staff, which Patterson analyzed under a control standard.

Keeping these theories distinct matters. A worker’s wage-and-hour or harassment claim against a franchisor rises or falls on the general right to control the day-to-day aspects of employment, not on brand recognition, so a plaintiff cannot substitute the franchisor’s marketing power for the control the employment test actually requires.

The ABC Test Does Not Rewrite Patterson

The ABC test adopted in Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) decides whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor; it does not decide which of two entities is the employer. Patterson answers the different question of whether a franchisor, as opposed to the franchisee that directly hires and supervises, is an employer of the franchisee’s workers. A franchisee’s employees are usually plainly employees of someone; the live issue is whether the franchisor shares that status, and for that the general-control standard, not the ABC test, governs.

Labor Code § 2810.3 adds a parallel route in some supply arrangements by making a client employer share responsibility for wages and workers’ compensation for workers supplied by a labor contractor, but it is framed around labor contracting rather than the franchise relationship. A worker seeking to hold a franchisor responsible must therefore match the theory to the facts: control-based employer status under Patterson, contractor-supply liability under § 2810.3, or ordinary employer liability against the franchisee that actually ran the store.

Practical Steps Before Pursuing a Franchisor

A worker considering a claim against a franchisor should first map out who actually controlled the terms and conditions of the job. That means gathering the franchise materials that bear on day-to-day employment, such as any operations manual provisions that dictate hiring, scheduling, discipline, or pay, and distinguishing brand-standard requirements from genuine control over the workforce. Under Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza (2014), it is the general right to control the means and manner of the work, not adherence to a brand system, that determines whether the franchisor is an employer, so the evidence must speak to control rather than consistency of product.

At the same time, the worker should preserve the claim against the franchisee that directly employed her, because that entity is almost always liable and is frequently the primary, most provable defendant. Pursuing the franchisor is best understood as an effort to add a deeper-pocketed, jointly responsible party where the facts support it, not as a substitute for the straightforward claim against the business that actually ran the store and signed the paychecks.

Finally, a worker should consider whether a labor-contracting theory under Labor Code § 2810.3 fits, since that statute can make a client business share wage and workers’ compensation responsibility for workers supplied through a labor contractor, a path that is sometimes available even where the Patterson control test is not satisfied.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue the national franchise company for what happened at the local store?

Only if the franchisor had a general right of control over the franchisee’s day-to-day operations and personnel decisions. Under Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza, a franchisor is generally not the employer of a franchisee’s workers unless it controlled hiring, firing, and supervision.

Does a detailed franchise operations manual make the franchisor my employer?

No. Patterson held that a comprehensive brand-standards and operations system, by itself, does not create an employment relationship. The franchisor must actually control personnel decisions, not just set uniform brand requirements.

What is the connection to the joint-employer test?

Franchisor liability applies the broader employer definition from Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35, under which an entity employs a worker by controlling wages, hours, or working conditions, or by suffering or permitting work. A franchisor that exercises that control could be a joint employer.

What does Labor Code 2810.3 have to do with this?

Labor Code § 2810.3 makes a client business share liability with a labor contractor for wages and workers’ compensation for supplied workers. It is a contracted-labor statute, not a franchise rule, but it reflects the same principle that a business controlling and benefiting from labor should bear responsibility.

If the franchisor is dismissed, do I still have a case?

Usually yes. The franchisee remains your direct employer and is fully responsible for wage-and-hour and anti-harassment compliance. The franchisor analysis is about reaching an additional defendant, not about whether your underlying claim exists.

How do I prove the franchisor controlled my workplace?

Through evidence of actual personnel control — franchisor involvement in hiring, firing, discipline, scheduling, or wages, or direct supervision of workers. Much of this comes out in discovery, so the full picture often develops as the case proceeds.

If you were harassed, fired, or underpaid at a franchised business in California and want to know whether the national brand can be held responsible, Trembach Law Firm can investigate who actually controlled your workplace. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation. Keep up with changes on our employment law news page and read our related guide to the AB5 professional-services exemption under Labor Code 2778.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301