INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR | 2026-11-09

AB5 Professional Services Exemption, Labor Code 2778, California 2026

When a freelancer in a listed profession escapes the ABC test and is judged under the more flexible Borello standard instead.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

In California, the line between employee and independent contractor is the line between having wage, overtime, and reimbursement rights and having almost none. Labor Code section 2778 decides whether a freelancer in a listed profession is judged under the strict ABC test or the more flexible Borello

Why Worker Classification Decides Everything

Whether a California worker is an employee or an independent contractor controls almost every right the law provides. Employees get minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest breaks, workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance, expense reimbursement, and anti-discrimination protection. Independent contractors get none of those by default. That is why the test for classification is one of the most consequential questions in California employment law, and why the professional-services exemption in Labor Code § 2778 draws so much attention.

The classification question is not answered by what the parties call the relationship. A contract that labels a worker an independent contractor does not make it so. California courts and agencies look at the substance of the relationship, applying whichever legal test the Legislature has assigned to that type of work. For most workers that default test is strict, but for a defined list of professional occupations the Legislature restored a more flexible standard.

The stakes run both ways. For workers, misclassification can mean years of unpaid overtime and unreimbursed expenses that they never realized they were owed. For businesses, getting classification wrong across a workforce can generate crushing back-pay, tax, and penalty exposure, often magnified by class or representative actions. Understanding which test applies, and why, is therefore the first and most important step in any classification analysis.

The ABC Test and the Dynamex Decision

The default standard is the ABC test, codified in Labor Code § 2775. It came from the California Supreme Court’s decision in Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) 4 Cal.5th 903, which held that a worker is presumed to be an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three of these elements: (A) the worker is free from the control and direction of the hirer in connection with the performance of the work; (B) the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and (C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.

The ABC test is demanding because the hiring entity must satisfy every prong. Prong B in particular defeats many arrangements: a delivery driver for a delivery company, or a seamstress for a clothing company, performs work squarely within the hirer’s usual business and therefore cannot be a contractor under that prong. The Legislature codified Dynamex in AB 5, and the resulting disruption to entire industries is what prompted the carve-outs that followed.

It is worth emphasizing that the burden sits entirely on the hiring entity. The worker does not have to prove they are an employee; the law presumes it. The company must come forward with evidence satisfying each of the three prongs, and a failure of proof on any one of them means the worker is an employee as a matter of law. That burden allocation is what makes the ABC test so difficult for businesses to overcome.

How AB 2257 Created Labor Code 2778

AB 5 swept in occupations that had long operated as freelancers, and the backlash was immediate. In response, the Legislature enacted AB 2257, which refined and expanded the exemptions and placed the professional-services carve-out in Labor Code § 2778. For occupations that fall within § 2778 and meet its conditions, classification is governed not by the rigid ABC test but by the older, multifactor Borello standard.

The practical effect is a two-track system. If a worker’s occupation is listed in § 2778 and the enumerated conditions are met, the hiring entity gets to argue classification under the more forgiving Borello test. If the occupation is not listed, or the conditions are not met, the arrangement falls back to the ABC test of § 2775, where independent-contractor status is much harder to sustain. Getting the track right is the first analytical step in any classification dispute.

The statute is best understood as a legislative compromise. The Legislature wanted to stop businesses from disguising ordinary employees as contractors, but it did not want to destroy genuine freelance professions where self-employment is the norm. Section 2778 is the line it drew: narrow, occupation-specific exemptions available only when the worker truly operates as an independent business. The precision of that line is both its strength and the source of most disputes about it.

Which Occupations the Professional-Services Exemption Covers

Labor Code § 2778 enumerates a specific list of professional-services occupations. Among them are marketing professionals, human-resources administrators, travel agents, graphic designers, grant writers, fine artists, enrolled agents, and certain freelance writers, editors, translators, and photographers, as well as licensed estheticians, barbers, cosmetologists, and manicurists, among others. The list is specific by design — an occupation not named does not get the professional-services track simply because it feels professional.

Because the list is exact, classification counsel reads it closely. A content strategist may fit the marketing category; a software engineer generally does not fit this particular exemption and must look elsewhere in the statute or fall back to the ABC test. The precision of the enumerated list is both a safe harbor for listed occupations and a trap for hiring entities that assume a worker qualifies without checking the statutory language.

The statute also contains separate exemptions outside § 2778 for specific relationships, such as the business-to-business exemption and the professional-practice exemptions for doctors, lawyers, accountants, and similar licensed professionals. A worker who does not fit the professional-services list in § 2778 may still fall under one of those other provisions, so the full classification analysis requires checking every applicable exemption before defaulting to the ABC test.

The Enumerated Conditions That Must Be Met

Being in a listed occupation is necessary but not sufficient. Labor Code § 2778 requires the individual to satisfy a set of conditions before Borello applies. The worker must maintain a business location separate from the hiring entity, which may include the worker’s residence; must have a business license where required; must be able to set or negotiate their own rates; must set their own hours outside project completion dates; must be customarily engaged in the same type of work with other clients or be able to hold themselves out to other potential customers; and must exercise discretion and independent judgment in performing the services.

Every one of those conditions is a potential fault line. A freelance graphic designer who works exclusively for one company on that company’s premises, at set hours, at a rate the company dictates, is not free, independent, or holding out to other clients — and therefore does not get the Borello track even though graphic designer appears on the list. The conditions exist precisely to prevent the exemption from being used to disguise ordinary employment.

Documentation of these conditions should exist in fact, not merely on paper. A genuine freelancer typically has a business bank account, invoices multiple clients, carries their own insurance, uses their own equipment, and markets their services publicly. A worker who has none of those indicia, and who looks and functions exactly like the employees sitting beside them, will not satisfy § 2778 no matter how the contract is worded, and the arrangement will be tested under the far stricter ABC standard.

The Borello Multifactor Test

When § 2778 applies, classification is decided under S.G. Borello & Sons v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341. Borello treats the most important factor as the hiring entity’s right to control the manner and means of accomplishing the work. But it is a totality-of-the-circumstances test that also weighs secondary factors: whether the worker is engaged in a distinct occupation, whether the work is usually done under supervision, the skill required, who supplies the tools and workplace, the length of the relationship, the method of payment, and whether the parties believe they are creating an employment relationship.

No single secondary factor is decisive under Borello, which is both its flexibility and its unpredictability. A worker with genuine independence — own tools, own clients, own judgment — is more likely to be a true contractor under Borello than under the near-automatic employee presumption of the ABC test. That is the whole point of the professional-services exemption: to let bona fide freelancers remain freelancers.

Borello also considers the degree to which the service is an integral part of the hiring entity’s business and whether the worker has a meaningful opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill. A freelancer who bids projects, manages their own costs, and can earn more or less based on how efficiently they work looks like an entrepreneur; a worker paid an hourly rate to do the company’s core work under its direction looks like an employee. Those entrepreneurial indicia frequently decide close cases.

Who Bears the Burden, and What It Means

Under the ABC test, the hiring entity bears the burden of proving all three prongs, and the worker is presumed an employee until it does. Under Borello, the analysis is more balanced, but the hiring entity that chose to treat the worker as a contractor still has to justify that choice against the multifactor standard. In either framework, misclassification exposes the business to significant liability.

That liability includes unpaid overtime and minimum wage, missed meal and rest premiums, unreimbursed business expenses under Labor Code § 2802, unpaid payroll taxes, and penalties. A worker who has been treated as a contractor but functions as an employee may be sitting on substantial unpaid wages, and the misclassification analysis often opens the door to the broader wage claims a worker did not realize they had.

Because classification is a threshold question, it is often litigated first. If the worker is found to be an employee, every downstream wage-and-hour right follows automatically, and the damages compound quickly across weeks and months of work. If the worker is a true contractor, most of those claims disappear. That all-or-nothing quality is why classification disputes are fought so hard and why the choice of test — ABC or Borello — so often determines the outcome.

Remedies and Enforcement for Misclassified Workers

A misclassified worker has several routes. They may file a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner, sue in Superior Court for unpaid wages and expenses, or pursue civil penalties. California also imposes penalties for willful misclassification. Because the remedies stack — unpaid wages plus premiums plus expense reimbursement plus penalties plus attorney’s fees on many claims — the exposure for a business that misclassifies a workforce can be large.

Classification problems rarely stay contained to one worker. If a company treats an entire category of workers as contractors under a mistaken view of § 2778, the dispute can expand to the whole group. Businesses that rely on franchising or layered staffing structures face related control questions, which we examine in our guide to franchisor liability under California law.

Enforcement does not depend solely on private lawsuits. The Labor Commissioner, the Employment Development Department, and other agencies can audit a business and assess back taxes and penalties for misclassification independently of any worker complaint. A single determination that contractors were really employees can trigger assessments across the whole workforce, which is why prudent businesses audit their arrangements proactively rather than waiting for a claim.

Practical Guidance for Workers and Businesses

Workers who suspect misclassification should gather their contracts, pay records, schedules, and any instructions they received about how to do the work. The more the hiring entity controlled the manner and means — dictating hours, methods, and tools — the weaker the contractor label, whichever test applies. Even a worker in a listed occupation may be an employee if the § 2778 conditions were never met.

Businesses should audit each contractor arrangement against the correct test. For a worker outside the enumerated occupations, the ABC test governs and prong B is usually decisive. For a listed professional, the conditions of § 2778 must be documented in fact, not just in the contract: a real separate business location, genuine rate negotiation, actual other clients, and true independent judgment. A paper label without those facts will not survive scrutiny.

Occupations Governed by Their Own Statutes

Labor Code § 2778 is only one of several exemptions the Legislature wrote after Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) and AB 5. Related provisions carve out other relationships and occupations, including a business-to-business exemption for bona fide contracting between legitimate businesses and separate exemptions for specified professions. A worker or hiring entity analyzing a classification question must identify which exemption, if any, actually applies, because each comes with its own list of conditions that must all be satisfied.

The structure rewards precision. An arrangement that looks like it should be exempt will still be governed by the ABC test unless it fits squarely within the conditions of a specific exemption, and partial compliance is not enough.

When an Exemption Applies, Borello Still Controls

Qualifying for the professional-services exemption does not make a worker an independent contractor by default. It changes the test. Instead of the demanding ABC test from Dynamex, the relationship is evaluated under the multifactor standard of S. G. Borello and Sons v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989), which weighs the right to control the work along with secondary factors like who supplies tools, the method of payment, the skill required, and whether the work is part of the hiring entity’s regular business. A worker can meet every condition of an exemption and still be an employee under Borello if the hiring entity controls the manner and means of the work.

This two-step reality is often missed. Businesses sometimes treat an exemption as a safe harbor that ends the inquiry, when in fact it only moves the question to the Borello analysis, where genuine control over how the work is done can still produce employee status.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between the ABC test and the Borello test?

The ABC test, from Dynamex and codified in Labor Code § 2775, presumes employment and requires the hiring entity to prove all three prongs, including that the work is outside its usual business. The Borello test is a flexible, multifactor analysis centered on the right to control. Labor Code § 2778 decides which test applies to a given worker.

Does being a graphic designer automatically make me a contractor?

No. Graphic designer is a listed professional-services occupation, but you also have to meet every condition in Labor Code § 2778 — a separate business location, your own rates, your own hours, other clients, and independent judgment. If those conditions are not met, the strict ABC test applies instead.

Which test is harder for the employer to satisfy?

The ABC test is generally much harder because the hiring entity must prove all three prongs and the worker is presumed an employee. The Borello test, which applies when § 2778 is satisfied, gives a bona fide freelancer a more realistic path to contractor status.

What can I recover if I was misclassified?

Depending on the facts, you may recover unpaid minimum wage and overtime, meal and rest break premiums, unreimbursed expenses under Labor Code § 2802, and penalties, often with attorney’s fees. Misclassification frequently reveals additional unpaid-wage claims you did not know you had.

Can a contract call me an independent contractor and make it true?

No. California looks at the substance of the relationship, not the label. A contract calling you a contractor does not control if the facts show an employment relationship under the applicable test.

Is a software engineer covered by the Labor Code 2778 exemption?

Generally not under the professional-services list in § 2778, which names specific occupations. A software engineer may qualify under a different exemption, such as the business-to-business provision, or may fall under the ABC test. The right analysis checks every applicable exemption before defaulting.

If you believe you have been misclassified, or you are a business trying to classify your workforce correctly under Labor Code § 2778, Trembach Law Firm can analyze which test applies and what it means for your rights and exposure. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246. Stay current through our employment law news page, and see our related discussion of franchisor liability in California.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301