INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR | 2026-11-17
Real Estate Salesperson as a Statutory Nonemployee in California 2026
A licensed real estate salesperson paid by commission under a written independent-contractor agreement is a statutory nonemployee, but only when the conditions are met.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California presumes most workers are employees, but licensed real estate salespersons are a legislative carve-out. When a licensed salesperson is paid by commission under a written contract stating that the salesperson will not be treated as an employee for state tax purposes, statutes exclude the salesperson from employment for unemployment and tax purposes, and the Borello test, not the stricter ABC test, governs other Labor Code disputes.
Real Estate Salespersons as Statutory Nonemployees in California
California draws a sharp line between most workers, who are presumed employees, and a short list of occupations the Legislature has carved out. Licensed real estate salespersons are one of those carve-outs. When a salesperson is paid by commission under a written contract stating that the salesperson will not be treated as an employee for state tax purposes, a cluster of statutes treats the salesperson as a nonemployee for key purposes, the same idea federal tax law captures with the term statutory nonemployee in Internal Revenue Code § 3508, and for other Labor Code purposes the classification test is the multifactor Borello standard rather than the stricter ABC test. This article explains how that framework fits together, what conditions a brokerage must satisfy, where the nonemployee treatment stops, and what a salesperson should know about rights that survive the classification.
The subject matters because real estate is one of the few fields where the usual presumption of employment is displaced by specific statutes. A salesperson who understands those statutes can tell the difference between a lawful independent-contractor arrangement and a misclassification that strips away wage protections the law never meant to remove.
The Default Rule and Why Real Estate Is Different
California's default classification rule, codified at Labor Code § 2775, applies the ABC test to most workers. Under that test a worker is an employee unless the hiring entity proves the worker is free from control, performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business, and is customarily engaged in an independent trade. The ABC test is demanding, and for most occupations it pushes workers into employee status.
Real estate salespersons sit outside that default. Labor Code § 2778(c)(1) exempts real estate licensees from the ABC test and provides that their status is governed by Business and Professions Code § 10032(b). If that section is not applicable, status is governed by Unemployment Insurance Code § 650 for unemployment insurance, by Labor Code § 3200 and following for workers compensation, and, for all other Labor Code purposes, by the multifactor test of S.G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989). The exemption does not automatically make a salesperson an independent contractor; it changes the rules used to decide. Under Borello the central question is the hiring entity's right to control the manner and means of the work, considered alongside secondary factors.
Business and Professions Code § 10032
The real estate framework starts in the Business and Professions Code. Section 10032(a) provides that a broker's and salesperson's obligations to the public under the Real Estate Law apply whether they call their relationship independent contractor or employer and employee. Section 10032(b) allows a broker and salesperson to contract with each other as independent contractors or as employer and employee, a choice that governs their relationship with and obligations to each other, while their status for withholding-tax and unemployment purposes is governed by Unemployment Insurance Code § 650 and §§ 13000 to 13054, and for workers compensation by Labor Code § 3200 and following.
Three conditions appear in Unemployment Insurance Code § 650, the statute that creates the tax and unemployment treatment: the person must hold a real estate license, substantially all of the remuneration must be directly related to sales or other output rather than hours, and the services must be performed under a written contract providing that the individual will not be treated as an employee for state tax purposes. Miss any of the three and the statutory nonemployee treatment is in jeopardy. A salesperson paid an hourly wage, or working with no written contract, cannot be shoehorned into the carve-out.
Unemployment Insurance Code § 650
The nonemployee treatment also appears in the unemployment insurance context. Unemployment Insurance Code § 650 excludes services performed as a licensed real estate broker or salesperson from the definition of employment when substantially all remuneration is directly related to sales or other output and the services are performed under the requisite written contract. Business and Professions Code § 10032(b) points to § 650 for these purposes, and the two provisions work together to place compliant salespersons outside the ordinary employment-tax and unemployment framework.
These statutory exclusions are narrow and conditional. They do not declare that every person with a real estate license is a nonemployee in all circumstances. They exclude a specifically defined arrangement, and a broker who departs from the defined terms loses the protection the statutes provide.
The Borello Test That Applies When the Carve-Out Is Contested
When § 10032(b) does not resolve the question, and the classification is challenged for a Labor Code purpose other than unemployment insurance or workers compensation, courts apply the Borello multifactor test that Labor Code § 2778(c)(1)(C) directs for this occupation. That subdivision adds that a responsible broker's statutory supervision duties under Business and Professions Code § 10015.1 are not factors in the Borello analysis. The principal factor is the right to control the manner and means of accomplishing the work. Secondary factors include whether the worker is engaged in a distinct occupation, whether the work is usually done under the principal's direction or by a specialist without supervision, the skill required, who supplies the tools and workplace, the length of the engagement, the method of payment, and whether the parties believe they are creating an employment relationship. For a different classification question arising from licensure, compare our analysis of the licensed vocational nurse overtime exemption.
No single Borello factor is dispositive. A brokerage that exercises heavy day-to-day control, dictates hours, forbids outside work, and treats the salesperson like staff can lose under Borello even if a written contract recites independent-contractor language. The written contract and commission structure help, but substance governs form.
The Underlying License Statutes
The real estate license requirement is not a formality. Business and Professions Code § 10131 defines the acts that require a real estate license, and § 10137 makes it unlawful for a broker to employ or compensate an unlicensed person for performing licensed acts. These provisions underpin the statutory nonemployee scheme, because the carve-out presupposes a licensed salesperson operating under a licensed broker. A person performing licensed real estate acts without a license cannot claim the nonemployee treatment and may expose the broker to separate liability.
Where the Nonemployee Treatment Stops
The statutory carve-out is powerful but bounded. It addresses state tax, unemployment insurance, and the classification test, but it does not convert the salesperson into a person with no rights. A genuine independent contractor's earned commissions are enforceable under the written agreement, and a broker cannot use the nonemployee label to justify withholding commissions the contract says are earned. If the salesperson is in fact an employee, earned commissions are wages: Labor Code § 221 bars an employer from collecting back wages already paid, and § 2751 requires a written commission agreement for employees whose pay involves commissions.
Anti-fraud and misclassification provisions also remain available. Labor Code § 226.8 prohibits the willful misclassification of an individual as an independent contractor and imposes substantial civil penalties. A brokerage that labels a salesperson a nonemployee while failing to satisfy the statutory conditions, and that does so to avoid obligations, risks liability under § 226.8 notwithstanding the real estate carve-out.
Misclassification Risk for Brokerages
The carve-out invites a specific kind of mistake. A brokerage may assume that because real estate salespersons can be nonemployees, every person in the office can be treated that way. Unlicensed assistants, transaction coordinators, and administrative staff are not covered by the real estate carve-out and are analyzed under the ordinary ABC test of Labor Code § 2775. Classifying those workers as independent contractors because they happen to work at a brokerage is a common and costly error that § 226.8 is designed to punish.
Even for licensed salespersons, a brokerage that pays by the hour, omits the written contract, or exercises control inconsistent with independent-contractor status cannot rely on the carve-out. The three conditions are not technicalities; they are the price of the special treatment.
What a Salesperson Should Watch For
A licensed salesperson should keep a signed copy of the independent-contractor agreement, confirm that compensation is genuinely commission-based, and track earned commissions carefully. If a broker withholds earned commissions, imposes employee-style controls while claiming contractor status, or tries to recover paid commissions through offsets, the salesperson may have claims notwithstanding the nonemployee label. Where the facts show the arrangement does not meet the statutory conditions and control looks like employment, a Borello analysis can support reclassification for purposes the carve-out does not reach.
Practical Compliance Steps
Brokerages should verify the license, pay by commission, execute a written independent-contractor agreement that satisfies Business and Professions Code § 10032(b) and Unemployment Insurance Code § 650, and avoid exercising control that would fail Borello. They should classify unlicensed office workers under the ABC test rather than sweeping them into the carve-out, and document earned-commission terms in writing. Salespersons who suspect misclassification or commission theft should gather their contract, commission statements, and evidence of how the office actually operated. For more California classification and wage coverage, visit our California employment law news page.
How the Three Conditions Are Tested in Practice
The three statutory conditions in Unemployment Insurance Code § 650, a current license, output-based pay, and a written contract, are tested by substance, not labels. The license condition is usually the easiest to verify through the Department of Real Estate record. The pay condition asks whether substantially all of the salesperson's remuneration is directly related to sales or other output rather than hours; a flat hourly wage defeats it. The written-contract condition requires an actual agreement providing that the salesperson will not be treated as an employee for state tax purposes. A contract that is missing, unsigned, or silent on independent-contractor status leaves the arrangement exposed.
When any condition is absent, the unemployment and tax exclusion does not apply, and for other Labor Code purposes the relationship is analyzed under the Borello test that Labor Code § 2778(c)(1) directs for real estate licensees when § 10032(b) is not applicable. Because Borello centers on the broker's right to control the manner and means of the work, a brokerage that satisfies the paperwork but micromanages the salesperson's daily activities can still find the relationship recharacterized where the carve-out conditions are not fully met.
Control Factors That Undercut Contractor Status
Under Borello, certain brokerage practices weigh toward employment. Requiring set office hours, mandating floor-duty shifts, forbidding the salesperson from working with other brokerages, dictating the scripts and methods used with clients, closely supervising day-to-day activity, and providing all tools and office space can collectively show the right to control that defines employment. Conversely, a salesperson who sets their own schedule, bears their own business expenses, markets independently, and controls how the work is accomplished looks like a genuine independent contractor. Because Borello weighs many factors and no single one controls, the overall picture of control governs, and a written contract reciting contractor status cannot rescue an arrangement that functions as employment in substance.
This is why the real estate carve-out is best understood as changing the test rather than guaranteeing a result. It removes the demanding ABC test and substitutes the more flexible Borello analysis, but a brokerage that behaves like an employer can still lose under Borello when the statutory conditions are not cleanly satisfied.
Earned Commissions as Protected Wages
However the classification shakes out for tax and unemployment purposes, commissions that the salesperson has earned are protected. For a salesperson who is an employee, an earned commission is a wage that the employer cannot collect back under Labor Code § 221, and the employer must provide the written commission agreement required by Labor Code § 2751; for a genuine independent contractor, the same commission is a contract right. Common disputes involve commissions on deals that close after the salesperson leaves the brokerage, chargebacks for transactions that later fall through, and offsets the broker imposes against future commissions. The governing document is the written agreement, and its terms determine when a commission is earned, but the broker cannot rewrite those terms after the fact or seize earned commissions through self-help.
Penalties for Willful Misclassification
The carve-out does not immunize a brokerage that abuses it. Labor Code § 226.8 prohibits the willful misclassification of an individual as an independent contractor and authorizes civil penalties that can be substantial for each violation, with higher penalties for a pattern or practice. A brokerage that sweeps unlicensed assistants, transaction coordinators, or administrative staff into independent-contractor status, or that labels a salesperson a contractor while failing to meet the statutory conditions and controlling the work like an employer, risks liability under § 226.8. The willful-misclassification penalty exists precisely to deter employers from exploiting classification carve-outs to avoid payroll taxes, workers compensation coverage, and wage protections.
Comparing the ABC Test and the Borello Test
Understanding why the real estate carve-out matters requires seeing what it replaces. Under the ABC test of Labor Code § 2775, a hiring entity must prove all three prongs, and the second prong, that the worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business, is nearly impossible for a brokerage to satisfy because selling real estate is the brokerage's core business. If the ABC test applied, virtually every salesperson would be an employee. By routing real estate licensees to § 10032(b) and, where that section does not apply, to Borello through Labor Code § 2778(c)(1), the Legislature substituted a flexible, totality-of-the-circumstances inquiry that can accommodate a genuine independent-contractor relationship. Borello asks about the right to control and a set of secondary factors, and it does not impose the rigid outside-the-usual-course requirement that would otherwise doom contractor status. This is the single most important practical effect of the carve-out: it is the difference between a test the brokerage almost always loses and a test it can win when the relationship is genuinely independent.
The carve-out therefore rewards brokerages that structure real independence and punishes those that keep the form while exercising employer-like control. A brokerage that wants the benefit of Borello must actually allow the salesperson the autonomy that Borello treats as the hallmark of contractor status.
Teams, Dual Agency, and Shared-Commission Arrangements
Modern brokerages often organize salespersons into teams led by a senior agent, with commissions split among team members and the brokerage. These arrangements raise their own classification and wage questions. A team lead who directs, schedules, and supervises junior members may be exercising the kind of control that, combined with the brokerage's own practices, affects the Borello analysis for those members. Commission splits must be documented, and a junior salesperson who earns a share of a transaction has an enforceable interest in that share once the commission is earned under the governing agreements. Disputes over how a split is calculated, when it vests, and whether a departing member keeps a share of pending deals are resolved by the written agreements, and for employees by the earned-wage principle protected by Labor Code § 221, not by the team lead's unilateral decision. The framework of Business and Professions Code § 10032 addresses the salesperson-brokerage relationship; it does not resolve every intra-team dispute, which is governed by the contracts the parties actually signed.
What the Nonemployee Label Does Not Waive
Workers often assume that signing an independent-contractor agreement waives every protection the Labor Code provides. It does not. Labor Code § 2804 and the broader structure of the wage laws reflect a strong public policy against an employee waiving statutory rights, so if the relationship is in substance employment, a private agreement cannot defeat protections the Legislature made non-waivable. The real estate carve-out changes the classification rules and the tax and unemployment treatment; it does not strip a licensee of the right to earned commissions, and a licensee who is actually an employee keeps the right to a written commission agreement under Labor Code § 2751 and to be free from unlawful chargebacks under Labor Code § 221. A salesperson pressured to sign away these rights, or told that contractor status means the brokerage can keep whatever it likes, should recognize that the label has limits and that the governing agreement plus the Labor Code, not the brokerage's say-so, define what is owed.
This boundary is especially important when a salesperson leaves one brokerage for another. Disputes over commissions on pending transactions, referral fees, and post-termination deals are resolved by the written agreement and the earned-wage principle, not by a blanket assertion that an independent contractor has no wage rights. The nonemployee designation addresses certain state purposes; it is not a universal disclaimer of everything the Labor Code guarantees.
Tax, Benefits, and Workers Compensation Consequences
Classification as a statutory nonemployee carries practical consequences beyond the wage laws. A compliant salesperson is generally responsible for self-employment taxes rather than having payroll taxes withheld, is typically not covered by the brokerage's unemployment insurance under Unemployment Insurance Code § 650, and has workers compensation status decided separately under Labor Code § 3200 and following. These trade-offs are part of the bargain the carve-out contemplates, and a salesperson who genuinely operates as an independent contractor plans for them. The flip side is that a brokerage that claims the carve-out while treating the salesperson as an employee, controlling the work and dictating the terms, cannot have it both ways; if the arrangement functions as employment and the statutory conditions are not met, the worker may be entitled to the employee protections the brokerage tried to avoid, and the brokerage may owe the back taxes, coverage, and penalties that go with misclassification.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If a brokerage withheld your earned commissions, misused the nonemployee label, or misclassified you or your coworkers, you may have claims for unpaid wages, penalties, and attorney fees. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm handle California independent-contractor and commission disputes. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are all real estate salespersons independent contractors in California?
No. Business and Professions Code § 10032(b) lets broker and salesperson choose their relationship, and Unemployment Insurance Code § 650 excludes a salesperson from employment only when the person is licensed, paid by output, and working under a written contract stating no employee treatment for state tax purposes. A salesperson paid hourly or without that contract may not qualify.
Which classification test applies to a real estate salesperson?
Labor Code § 2778(c)(1) exempts real estate licensees from the ABC test, applies Business and Professions Code § 10032(b) first, and otherwise uses the multifactor Borello test from S.G. Borello & Sons (1989) for Labor Code purposes other than unemployment insurance and workers compensation. Borello focuses on the broker's right to control the manner and means of the work.
Can my broker refuse to pay commissions I already earned?
Generally no. Commissions earned under your agreement are enforceable as a contract right, and if you are in fact an employee they are wages that Labor Code § 221 protects. The nonemployee label does not allow a broker to withhold or claw back commissions you have earned under your agreement.
Does the carve-out cover unlicensed office staff at a brokerage?
No. The real estate carve-out covers licensed salespersons only. Unlicensed assistants and administrative staff are analyzed under the ordinary ABC test in Labor Code § 2775, and misclassifying them can trigger penalties under § 226.8.
What if my broker controls my work like an employee but calls me a contractor?
Heavy day-to-day control can defeat independent-contractor status under Borello even with a written contract. Where the statutory conditions are not met and control resembles employment, you may be reclassified for purposes the carve-out does not reach, and willful misclassification can violate § 226.8.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301