TRADE REMEDIES | 2026-11-01

Adverse Facts Available in Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Cases: How 19 U.S.C. § 1677e Can Saddle a California Importer With a Punitive Rate

How Commerce applies facts available, when it draws an adverse inference under the “best of its ability” standard, the corroboration requirement, and what importers can do

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

A California importer can do everything right at the border and still be hit with a crushing antidumping or countervailing duty rate because of something a foreign supplier did — or failed to do — in a Commerce Department proceeding thousands of miles away. The mechanism is “adverse facts available,

Why adverse facts available matters to importers

Antidumping and countervailing duties are set in administrative proceedings run by the U.S. Department of Commerce, not at the port. Commerce calculates a dumping margin or a subsidy rate based on detailed data it requests from foreign producers and exporters: cost of production, home-market sales, factors of production, government-program benefits, and more. When a respondent gives Commerce what it needs, the margin is calculated from that data. When a respondent does not — because it refuses, misses deadlines, withholds information, or submits data Commerce cannot verify — Commerce turns to 19 U.S.C. § 1677e. The rates that come out of that provision are frequently the most punitive on the record, and because the importer is the party that actually pays the duties, the importer bears the consequence of a supplier's conduct in a case it may not even have known was underway.

Step one: "facts otherwise available" under § 1677e(a)

Section 1677e(a) is the neutral first step. It authorizes Commerce (and the International Trade Commission) to use "facts otherwise available" to fill a gap in the record when necessary information is missing, when a party withholds requested information, fails to provide it by the deadline or in the form required, significantly impedes the proceeding, or provides information that cannot be verified. At this stage the statute is gap-filling, not punitive. Commerce is simply choosing substitute data to complete its analysis because the ideal information is not usable. A respondent that made an honest error or had a genuine inability to produce a data point may land here without any adverse consequence beyond the use of substitute facts. The distinction between this neutral step and the punitive one is the single most important thing an importer should understand, because a supplier can be subject to facts available for a genuine reason and still avoid the crushing adverse inference if it cooperated.

Step two: the adverse inference under § 1677e(b)

The punitive step is § 1677e(b). It allows Commerce to use an inference that is adverse to the interests of a party — "adverse facts available," or AFA — but only if Commerce finds that the party "failed to cooperate by not acting to the best of its ability to comply with a request for information." The adverse inference lets Commerce select from among the facts on the record the one least favorable to the non-cooperating party, which in practice often means the highest margin alleged in the petition or the highest rate calculated for any respondent. The two steps are distinct: a party can be subject to neutral facts available under (a) without being hit with an adverse inference under (b). The adverse inference requires the additional finding of a failure to cooperate.

The "best of its ability" standard

The Federal Circuit defined the cooperation standard in Nippon Steel Corp. v. United States, 337 F.3d 1373 (Fed. Cir. 2003). The court held that "failure to act to the best of its ability" does not require intentional wrongdoing or bad faith, but it does require more than an inadvertent mistake. A respondent must do the maximum it is able to do: it must take reasonable steps to keep and produce the records Commerce needs and to cooperate fully, and it is held to a standard of ordinary care and reasonable diligence. Commerce may draw an adverse inference when a respondent fails to put forth its maximum effort, even without finding that the failure was willful. The practical upshot is that "we tried" is not enough; a respondent that did not maintain adequate records or did not respond with reasonable completeness and timeliness risks AFA.

The corroboration requirement

AFA is not a license for Commerce to pick any number it likes. When Commerce relies on secondary information — information drawn from the petition or from a prior segment of the proceeding rather than from the respondent's own verified data — § 1677e(c) requires Commerce to corroborate that information "to the extent practicable" using independent sources reasonably at its disposal. Corroboration asks whether the selected rate is reliable and relevant to the respondent. The Federal Circuit has required Commerce to show that a petition-derived margin used as AFA has some basis in commercial reality rather than being an arbitrary punitive figure. The TPEA amendments of 2015 gave Commerce additional latitude — for example, it is not required to estimate what the rate would have been with full cooperation, and it may apply the highest rate on the record — but the corroboration obligation for secondary information remains a real constraint that importers and respondents can press on judicial review.

Notice and the chance to cure under § 1677m

Before Commerce resorts to facts available, the statute builds in procedural protections at 19 U.S.C. § 1677m. Under § 1677m(d), if Commerce determines that a response to a request is deficient, it must, to the extent practicable, notify the respondent of the deficiency and give it an opportunity to remedy or explain it. Under § 1677m(e), Commerce must consider information that is submitted but does not meet all its requirements if the information was timely, can be verified, is not so incomplete that it cannot serve as a reliable basis, the party acted to the best of its ability, and the information can be used without undue difficulties. These provisions matter because a respondent that receives a deficiency notice and cures the problem can avoid both facts available and the adverse inference. A respondent that ignores a deficiency notice, by contrast, hands Commerce the cooperation finding it needs for AFA.

How an adverse rate reaches the California importer

The chain from a Commerce proceeding to an importer's bank account is direct. When Commerce assigns an AFA rate to a producer or exporter, that rate becomes the cash-deposit rate for entries of that company's merchandise. The importer posts cash deposits at that rate on every entry while the order is in effect. At the end of an administrative review, Commerce issues final assessment rates, and if the AFA rate stands, the importer owes final duties at that rate, with CBP collecting any shortfall (plus interest) between the deposits and the final assessment. For merchandise from a company hit with a punitive AFA margin, the difference between the ordinary rate and the AFA rate can be the difference between a viable product line and an unsellable one. Because the importer is jointly exposed, a supplier's non-cooperation is an importer's financial risk. The timing compounds it: entries are made and deposits posted long before a review concludes, so when the review finalizes at the punitive rate, CBP issues assessment instructions covering a year or more of entries at once, and the importer faces a lump-sum liability — the gap between deposits already posted and the higher final rate, plus interest — on goods it has usually already sold.

All-others and non-selected companies

AFA most directly affects the mandatory respondents Commerce individually examines. Companies that are not individually examined generally receive the "all-others" rate, which is normally built from the calculated margins of cooperating respondents and excludes margins based entirely on AFA. But the interplay is complex: when every mandatory respondent is uncooperative and receives AFA, the rate available to non-selected companies can also climb, and separate-rate analysis in non-market-economy cases adds further layers. An importer sourcing from a smaller supplier that relies on the all-others or separate rate should understand that the rate it depends on is itself a product of whether the examined companies cooperated.

The 2015 TPEA amendments in detail

The Trade Preferences Extension Act of 2015 amended § 1677e to expand Commerce's discretion when it applies an adverse inference, and the changes matter because they made AFA rates harder to challenge on certain grounds. Under the amended statute, when Commerce uses an adverse inference it may select a rate from any of several sources, including the highest rate in the petition or any rate calculated in the current or a prior segment of the proceeding, and it is expressly not required to estimate what the dumping margin or subsidy rate would have been if the non-cooperating party had cooperated. Commerce is also not required to demonstrate that the selected rate reflects an alleged commercial reality of the party, and it may apply the highest rate even to a cooperating party's transactions in certain circumstances. These amendments shifted the balance toward Commerce, and reviewing courts now give Commerce considerable latitude in rate selection. What the amendments did not erase is the threshold cooperation finding under § 1677e(b) and the corroboration obligation for secondary information under § 1677e(c); those remain the principal footholds for a respondent or importer contesting an AFA rate.

AFA in countervailing-duty (subsidy) cases

Although the examples above focus on antidumping, the same framework applies in countervailing-duty cases, where the question is whether a foreign government provided a countervailable subsidy. In the CVD context, AFA often arises in two directions: against a foreign government that fails to respond fully about its subsidy programs, and against a company respondent that does not supply the benefit data Commerce requests. When a government fails to cooperate, Commerce may use an adverse inference to find that a program is countervailable and to select a high subsidy rate, and that rate flows to the exporters whose merchandise the importer brings in. Because subsidy questions depend heavily on information only the foreign government controls, a government's non-cooperation can produce an adverse rate that a diligent company respondent could not have prevented — yet another way the importer's exposure turns on conduct outside its control. The corroboration requirement applies here as well when Commerce relies on secondary information to set a program rate.

Challenging an AFA determination

AFA determinations are reviewable by the U.S. Court of International Trade, which examines whether Commerce's decision is supported by substantial evidence and in accordance with law. Common grounds include that Commerce failed to give the § 1677m(d) deficiency notice, that it ignored usable information under § 1677m(e), that the "best of its ability" finding is not supported, or that a secondary-source rate was not properly corroborated under § 1677e(c). Because the importer is the party paying, importers sometimes participate in reviews and appeals to protect their exposure, either alongside the foreign supplier or, where their interests diverge, on their own behalf. The deadlines for participating in a review and for appealing are strict and jurisdictional, so an importer facing an AFA rate should act well before the window closes.

Why the importer's interest can diverge from the supplier's

It is tempting to assume the foreign supplier will protect the importer's interest in a Commerce proceeding, but the two interests are not identical. A supplier that has exited the U.S. market, that has many customers, or that simply decides the cost of full participation is not worth it may let a review lapse into AFA, indifferent to the fact that a single California importer will bear a punitive assessment on entries already made. The importer, by contrast, has everything riding on the rate. That divergence is the reason an importer with meaningful exposure should not rely solely on the supplier's lawyers: by entering an appearance, the importer receives Commerce's notices directly, can press the supplier to respond, can submit factual information where permitted, and preserves its own standing to appeal. An importer that stays passive often learns of an AFA rate only when the assessment arrives, by which time the review is closed and the options have narrowed to a difficult appeal.

Practical steps for a California importer

  • Know whether your merchandise is subject to an AD/CVD order and which producer/exporter's rate applies to your entries.
  • Build cooperation commitments into supplier contracts: require your supplier to participate fully and timely in any Commerce review and to share questionnaire responses and deadlines with you.
  • Monitor the Federal Register and Commerce's schedule for reviews that affect your supplier, so a non-cooperation problem does not surprise you at liquidation.
  • Where your exposure is large, consider entering an appearance in the administrative review so you receive notices and can protect your interests.
  • Treat a supplier's missed Commerce deadline as a live financial risk to you, not merely the supplier's problem.
  • Preserve the option to challenge a corroboration or cooperation finding at the Court of International Trade, and calendar the jurisdictional deadlines.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between "facts available" and "adverse facts available"?

Facts available under § 1677e(a) is a neutral gap-filler when information is missing or unusable. Adverse facts available under § 1677e(b) adds a punitive inference and is allowed only when Commerce finds a party failed to cooperate to the best of its ability.

Does AFA require proof the supplier acted in bad faith?

No. Under Nippon Steel, 337 F.3d 1373, the "best of its ability" standard does not require intentional wrongdoing, but it requires more than inadvertent error — a respondent must use its maximum effort and reasonable diligence.

Why am I paying for my supplier's conduct?

Because AD/CVD duties are paid by the importer of record. A supplier's AFA rate becomes the cash-deposit and assessment rate on your entries of that supplier's goods.

Can Commerce pick any rate as AFA?

Not freely. When it uses secondary information such as a petition rate, § 1677e(c) requires corroboration to the extent practicable using independent sources, so the rate has some basis in commercial reality.

What is the deficiency-notice protection?

Under § 1677m(d), Commerce must, to the extent practicable, notify a party of a deficient response and give it a chance to remedy or explain before relying on facts available.

Can an importer participate in the Commerce proceeding?

Yes. An importer can enter an appearance in an administrative review to receive notices and protect its interests, and can appeal an adverse determination to the Court of International Trade.

Does AFA affect the all-others rate?

The all-others rate is normally built from cooperating respondents' calculated margins and excludes pure AFA rates, but when all mandatory respondents are uncooperative the rate available to other companies can rise.

How do I challenge an AFA rate?

Through the Court of International Trade, arguing that Commerce lacked substantial evidence or acted contrary to law — for example by skipping the deficiency notice, ignoring usable information, or failing to corroborate a secondary-source rate.

Related guides

For related reading, see our overview of international trade and customs law and our guides on antidumping margin calculation and AD/CVD compliance for California importers. Reading those alongside this guide shows how a Commerce proceeding translates into the duties you ultimately pay.

Speak with a California trade attorney

If your merchandise is subject to an AD/CVD order and you are facing an adverse rate driven by a supplier's non-cooperation, Trembach Law Firm can help you assess your exposure and your options in the review and on appeal. Call (213) 645-2246 to discuss your situation. Anatolii Trembach holds an LL.M. and is admitted to the California Bar.

This article is general legal information and not legal advice. How § 1677e applies depends on the specific proceeding, record, and merchandise. Consult a qualified attorney about your particular circumstances.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301