MESOTHELIOMA | 2026-11-03
Trying Asbestos Cases Together — or Apart: Consolidation and Severance in California
Whether several asbestos cases are tried together or separately can decide their outcome. California courts balance efficiency against the real risk that consolidation prejudices a defendant or confuses a jury.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
Asbestos litigation presents courts with a case-management problem few other areas share: large numbers of plaintiffs, overlapping defendants, decades-old exposures, and medical and historical evidence that is expensive to present. One response is to try cases together through consolidation. Consoli
How asbestos cases are packaged for trial is not a mere procedural detail; it can shape the result. Courts handling asbestos dockets face dozens or hundreds of cases involving overlapping defendants and similar proof, and trying each one entirely separately would be enormously costly and slow. The alternative — consolidating cases so that common evidence is presented once to one jury — promises efficiency, but it also raises the danger that a jury hearing several plaintiffs’ stories at once will blur the distinctions among them, to the prejudice of one or more defendants. California’s framework for consolidation and severance, anchored in Code of Civil Procedure § 1048 and refined by asbestos case law, is how trial courts manage this tension. For both plaintiffs and defendants, understanding it is essential to shaping the trial that will decide the case.
The Statutory Framework: Code of Civil Procedure § 1048
The authority to combine or separate cases comes from Code of Civil Procedure § 1048. Subdivision (a) authorizes a court, when actions involving a common question of law or fact are pending before it, to order a joint hearing or trial of any of the matters in issue, to order the actions consolidated, and to make orders that avoid unnecessary costs or delay. Subdivision (b) gives the court the complementary power, in furtherance of convenience or to avoid prejudice, to order a separate trial of any cause of action or issue. Section 1048 thus holds both tools — consolidation and severance — in a single grant of discretion.
The statute’s touchstones are efficiency and the avoidance of prejudice. Consolidation serves the first when cases share common questions; severance serves the second when trying matters together would be unfair or confusing. Because § 1048 commits the choice to the trial court’s discretion, appellate courts review these decisions deferentially, reversing only for an abuse of that discretion. The practical consequence is that the consolidation decision is made, and largely settled, at the trial level, which is why the parties fight hard over it before trial.
Why Consolidation Is Attractive — and Risky
The appeal of consolidation in asbestos cases is obvious. Many cases share the same product-identification evidence, the same corporate-history proof about what a defendant knew and when, the same industrial-hygiene and medical science about asbestos disease, and the same expert witnesses. Presenting that common material once, to one jury, rather than repeating it across many separate trials, saves the parties and the court substantial time and money and conserves scarce trial resources. For plaintiffs, consolidation can also allow cases to reach trial sooner, which matters acutely when plaintiffs are gravely ill.
The risk runs the other way. When several plaintiffs with different exposure histories, different diseases, different work sites, and different defendants are tried together, a jury may struggle to keep the evidence separate. Proof that is powerful against one defendant in one plaintiff’s case may spill over and unfairly taint another defendant whose connection to that plaintiff is weak. A sympathetic plaintiff may lend emotional weight to a co-plaintiff’s weaker claim. Defendants argue that these spillover and confusion effects deprive them of a fair trial on the individual merits of each case — the core objection consolidation must answer.
The Cottle Factors
California’s leading asbestos consolidation decision, Cottle v. Superior Court (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th 1367, arose from the management of a large asbestos docket and addressed the trial court’s broad authority to manage such cases, including through case-management orders and the structuring of trials. In the asbestos context, courts weigh a set of factors to decide whether consolidation is appropriate, considering how similar or different the cases are across the dimensions that matter to a fair trial.
Those factors typically include: the commonality of worksites and exposure; the similarity of the disease or injury alleged; whether the plaintiffs are living or deceased; the time span of the exposures; the occupations of the plaintiffs; and whether the cases share the same defendants and counsel. The more the cases resemble one another along these dimensions, the stronger the case for consolidation, because a jury can more readily apply common evidence without confusion. The more they diverge — different diseases, different eras, different trades, different defendants — the greater the risk of prejudice and the stronger the argument for separate trials. The court weighs these factors together, not mechanically, to decide whether trying the cases jointly can be done fairly.
Prejudice and Evidence Code § 352
The prejudice concern that drives severance decisions connects to a familiar evidentiary principle. Under Evidence Code § 352, a court may exclude evidence when its probative value is substantially outweighed by the probability that its admission will create a substantial danger of undue prejudice, confusing the issues, or misleading the jury. The same values animate the consolidation analysis: even relevant, admissible evidence can become unfairly prejudicial when a jury hears it in a consolidated trial and cannot reliably confine it to the case where it belongs.
Courts have tools short of full severance to manage these risks within a consolidated or coordinated trial — limiting instructions telling the jury to consider certain evidence only as to certain parties, special verdict forms that require the jury to make findings case by case and defendant by defendant, and structured presentation of evidence. Whether these measures adequately cure the prejudice, or whether the cases are simply too dissimilar to try together fairly, is the central question. A defendant seeking severance argues that no instruction can unring the bell; a plaintiff seeking consolidation argues that careful trial management preserves fairness while capturing the efficiencies.
Bifurcation and Other Structuring Tools
Consolidation and severance are not the only levers. Courts also use bifurcation — separating issues within a trial — to manage complexity. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 598 and related authority, a court may try certain issues, such as liability, before others, such as damages, or may separate particular questions for early resolution. In asbestos cases, structuring the trial so that threshold issues are decided first can streamline the proceeding and, in some configurations, reduce the prejudice that full consolidation might create.
These structuring decisions interact. A court might consolidate several cases for the presentation of common liability evidence while providing for case-specific findings on exposure, causation, and damages, attempting to capture efficiency on the shared questions while preserving individualized determination of the issues that differ. The design of the trial — what is tried together, what is kept separate, what is decided first — is thus a rich field of advocacy, and the party that shapes the structure often shapes the dynamics the jury will experience.
Strategic Stakes for Both Sides
Because the structure of the trial can influence its outcome, both sides invest heavily in the consolidation decision. For plaintiffs, consolidation can bring cases to trial faster, spread the cost of common proof, and allow the cumulative weight of a defendant’s conduct across multiple cases to be felt by one jury. For defendants, severance protects the right to be judged on the individual merits of each plaintiff’s claim, free of spillover from stronger or more sympathetic co-plaintiffs. Neither position is categorically right; the correct outcome depends on how similar the particular cases are and whether a fair joint trial is achievable.
Framing the motion well is therefore critical. A party seeking consolidation marshals the commonalities — shared defendants, worksites, products, and proof — and proposes management tools to contain any prejudice. A party seeking severance highlights the differences — distinct diseases, eras, trades, and defendants — and explains why no instruction can prevent the jury from blurring them. Because the trial court’s decision is reviewed for abuse of discretion and is difficult to overturn on appeal, the argument made at the trial level is usually decisive, and it rewards careful, factor-by-factor advocacy grounded in the specifics of the cases at hand.
Coordination of Complex Asbestos Litigation
Beyond consolidating individual cases for trial, California has mechanisms for managing large groups of related cases at a systemic level. When civil actions sharing common questions of fact or law are pending in different courts, they can be coordinated before a single judge for unified pretrial management. Coordination is distinct from consolidation for trial: it addresses the efficient handling of discovery, motions, and pretrial proceedings across many cases, without necessarily deciding that any of them will be tried together. Asbestos litigation, with its recurring defendants and overlapping proof, is a classic candidate for this kind of coordinated management.
Coordinated proceedings allow a single judge to develop expertise in the recurring issues, enter consistent case-management orders, and avoid duplicative and conflicting rulings across the many courts that would otherwise handle the cases piecemeal. For the parties, coordination brings predictability and efficiency to the pretrial phase. But coordination for pretrial purposes does not answer the trial question: whether particular cases should ultimately be tried jointly or separately remains a distinct decision under section 1048, made case by case as matters approach trial. A defendant may welcome coordinated pretrial management while still opposing consolidation of specific cases for trial, and the two issues are argued separately.
The Plaintiff’s and Defendant’s Playbooks
Experienced counsel approach the consolidation question with opposite playbooks built from the same factors. The plaintiff seeking consolidation emphasizes the commonalities: the same defendants, the same products, the same worksites or industries, the same corporate-knowledge and medical evidence, and the shared efficiency of presenting that proof once. Where plaintiffs are gravely ill, the plaintiff also presses the urgency of reaching trial promptly, arguing that consolidation serves both economy and the interest in resolving living plaintiffs’ claims while they can still participate.
The defendant seeking severance emphasizes the differences and the risk of spillover: distinct diseases, different exposure eras and trades, varying strength of product identification, and the danger that a sympathetic or strong co-plaintiff will lend unearned weight to a weaker claim against the defendant. The defense argues that limiting instructions and verdict forms cannot reliably prevent a jury from blurring the cases, and that the constitutional interest in an individualized determination outweighs the efficiency gains. Because the trial court’s decision is reviewed only for abuse of discretion, each side’s task is to build a concrete, factor-by-factor record at the trial level — the plaintiff showing that a fair joint trial is achievable, the defendant showing that it is not. The side that marshals the specific facts most persuasively usually prevails, and the decision, once made, is difficult to disturb on appeal.
Both playbooks ultimately turn on the same question the court must answer: can these particular cases be tried together fairly? That is not a question of categories but of specifics. Two mesothelioma cases involving the same shipyard, the same era, the same handful of insulation products, and the same defendants may be excellent candidates for a joint trial, because a jury can apply the common evidence without confusion and little turns on distinctions between the plaintiffs. By contrast, joining a living mesothelioma plaintiff who worked in one trade in the 1960s with a deceased lung-cancer plaintiff who worked in a different trade in the 1980s, against partly overlapping defendants, invites exactly the confusion and spillover that severance exists to prevent. The court’s task is to look past the label of "asbestos case" to the concrete features of the cases before it.
For litigants, the lesson is that generalities do not win these motions. A plaintiff who simply asserts that asbestos cases are routinely consolidated, or a defendant who simply asserts that consolidation is always prejudicial, will lose to an opponent who walks the court through the actual worksites, products, diseases, exposure periods, and defendants at issue. The consolidation decision rewards specificity, and the party who does the work of mapping the cases against the governing factors — showing concretely why a fair joint trial is or is not achievable — gives the court the record it needs to rule in that party’s favor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is consolidation in asbestos litigation?
Consolidation is the trying of several cases together before one jury, authorized by Code of Civil Procedure § 1048(a) when the actions share a common question of law or fact. It saves time and cost by presenting common evidence once rather than repeating it across separate trials.
What is severance?
Severance is the opposite — ordering separate trials of causes of action or issues. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 1048(b), a court may order separate trials in furtherance of convenience or to avoid prejudice, keeping cases or issues apart when trying them together would be unfair or confusing.
Why is the consolidation decision so important?
Because it can affect the outcome. Consolidation lets a jury feel the cumulative weight of a defendant’s conduct and brings cases to trial faster, while severance protects a defendant’s right to be judged on each plaintiff’s individual merits without spillover from stronger co-plaintiffs.
What factors do California courts weigh?
Courts consider commonality of worksites and exposure, similarity of the disease, whether plaintiffs are living or deceased, the time span of exposures, the plaintiffs’ occupations, and whether the cases share defendants and counsel. The more similar the cases, the stronger the case for consolidation.
What did Cottle v. Superior Court address?
Cottle v. Superior Court (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th 1367 arose from the management of a large asbestos docket and addressed the trial court’s broad authority to manage such cases through case-management orders and the structuring of trials.
How does Evidence Code § 352 relate to consolidation?
Evidence Code § 352 lets a court exclude evidence whose probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of undue prejudice or jury confusion. The same concern drives severance: even admissible evidence can become unfairly prejudicial when a jury cannot confine it to the right case in a consolidated trial.
Can a court manage prejudice without full severance?
Yes. Courts use limiting instructions, special verdict forms requiring case-by-case and defendant-by-defendant findings, bifurcation of issues under Code of Civil Procedure § 598, and structured presentation of evidence to reduce prejudice while preserving some efficiencies of joint trial.
Can a consolidation decision be appealed?
Consolidation and severance are committed to the trial court’s discretion and reviewed only for abuse of discretion, so they are difficult to overturn on appeal. That is why the argument made at the trial level is usually decisive.
Related Guides
- Mesothelioma & Asbestos Litigation
- Proving Asbestos Causation
- Asbestos Wrongful Death and Statutes of Limitation
Speak With a California Mesothelioma Attorney
How your case is structured for trial — tried with others or on its own — can affect its outcome. Trembach Law Firm represents California asbestos and mesothelioma clients through these decisions and the trial they shape. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation. Anatolii Trembach holds an LL.M. and is admitted to the California Bar.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Case-management decisions are discretionary and fact-specific; consult a qualified attorney about your particular case.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301