TRADE REMEDIES | 2026-11-09

Constructed Value and Cost of Production in Antidumping Cases: What California Importers Must Know About 19 U.S.C. 1677b

How Commerce builds a surrogate price when home-market sales fail the cost test, and why the constructed-value margin can decide your duty rate

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

When the U.S. Department of Commerce cannot find enough viable home-market sales to measure normal value, it stops comparing prices and starts building one. That constructed value, assembled from a foreign producer’s cost of manufacturing plus statutory amounts for selling expenses and profit, often

Antidumping duties are supposed to measure a simple thing: the difference between what a foreign producer charges in its home market and what it charges in the United States. But that comparison breaks down whenever home-market prices are unreliable, unrepresentative, or made at a loss. When it does, the Department of Commerce turns to two of the most consequential tools in the entire trade-remedy system: the cost-of-production test and constructed value. Both are governed by 19 U.S.C. 1677b, and both can transform a modest case into a crushing one for a California importer.

Normal Value: The Starting Point Under 19 U.S.C. 1677b(a)

The antidumping statute defines the "normal value" of imported merchandise as, ordinarily, the price at which the foreign like product is first sold for consumption in the exporting country, in the usual commercial quantities and in the ordinary course of trade. This home-market price is then compared against the U.S. export price or constructed export price to derive the dumping margin. The entire framework rests on the premise that genuine, arm’s-length home-market sales exist and can serve as a yardstick.

That premise fails in three common situations. First, the producer may not sell enough of the product at home to form a viable comparison market; Commerce generally requires that home-market sales equal at least five percent of U.S. sales by volume. Second, the home market may be distorted. Third, and most important for this article, the home-market sales may have been made at prices below the cost of producing the goods. When sales are made below cost over an extended period and in substantial quantities, and at prices that do not permit recovery of costs within a reasonable period, the statute directs Commerce to disregard them.

The Cost-of-Production Test Under 19 U.S.C. 1677b(b)

Section 1677b(b) authorizes Commerce to investigate whether home-market sales were made at prices below the cost of production. The cost of production, defined in 1677b(b)(3), is the sum of the cost of materials and fabrication, plus selling, general, and administrative (SG&A) expenses, plus the cost of packing. If Commerce determines that below-cost sales were made within an extended period of time (normally one year) in substantial quantities, it disregards those sales in calculating normal value.

The statute defines "substantial quantities" with precision. Below-cost sales are made in substantial quantities if the volume of below-cost sales equals or exceeds twenty percent of the volume of sales under consideration, or if the weighted-average per-unit price is below the weighted-average per-unit cost of production. When more than twenty percent of a producer’s home-market sales of a given product fail the test, Commerce throws them out. What remains may be too thin to support a price-to-price comparison, and that is precisely when constructed value enters the picture.

This is the hinge on which many cases turn. A California importer whose supplier sells aggressively at home, or whose home market is in a downturn, can find that the very sales that would have shown little or no dumping are statutorily erased. The producer is then measured against a cost-built surrogate that bears no relationship to the prices it actually charged.

Constructed Value Under 19 U.S.C. 1677b(e)

When Commerce cannot determine normal value from home-market or third-country sales, 1677b(e) instructs it to use constructed value. Constructed value is the sum of four components: (1) the cost of materials and fabrication employed in producing the merchandise; (2) selling, general, and administrative expenses; (3) the cost of all containers, coverings, and other packing expenses; and (4) an amount for profit.

The statute requires that the amounts for SG&A and profit ordinarily be based on the actual amounts incurred and realized by the specific producer in connection with the production and sale of the foreign like product, in the ordinary course of trade, for consumption in the foreign country. That caveat, "in the ordinary course of trade," is critical: if the below-cost test has already stripped away most home-market sales, the pool of transactions from which SG&A and profit can be drawn may be distorted, and Commerce must then resort to the alternative methodologies in 1677b(e)(2)(B).

Those alternatives give Commerce broad discretion. It may use the weighted-average amounts realized by other producers subject to the investigation, or "any other reasonable method," subject to a profit cap. The choice among these surrogate-profit methodologies is frequently the single most litigated issue in an antidumping case, because a few percentage points of imputed profit can swing a margin from de minimis to prohibitive.

The Major-Input Rule and Transactions Between Affiliates

Section 1677b(f) layers additional rules onto the cost calculation. Costs are normally calculated based on the records of the producer, provided those records are kept in accordance with the generally accepted accounting principles of the exporting country and reasonably reflect the costs of production. But 1677b(f)(2), the transactions-disregarded rule, allows Commerce to disregard a transaction between affiliated parties if the price does not fairly reflect the amount usually reflected in the market.

The companion major-input rule, found at 1677b(f)(3), lets Commerce value a significant input purchased from an affiliate at the higher of the transfer price, the market price, or the affiliate’s own cost of producing the input. For vertically integrated producers, whose California customers often assume they are getting a transparent cost build-up, this rule can substantially raise the reported cost of production and push more home-market sales below cost, cascading into a constructed-value determination.

Why Constructed-Value Margins Run High

There is a structural reason constructed value tends to produce larger margins than price-to-price comparisons. By definition, constructed value is built to include a positive amount for profit. When a producer has been selling at home near or below cost, its U.S. prices measured against a profit-inclusive constructed value will almost always appear to be dumped, even if the producer was pricing identically in both markets. The statute, in effect, assumes that a non-dumping producer should be selling above fully absorbed cost plus profit in both markets.

California importers feel this acutely. A distributor who negotiated a price in good faith, believing it tracked the supplier’s global pricing, can be hit with a cash-deposit rate derived entirely from a constructed surrogate. Because antidumping duties are assessed retrospectively in the U.S. system, the importer of record bears the ultimate liability when the final margin is set, often long after the goods have been sold.

Challenging Constructed Value at Commerce and the Court of International Trade

The methodological choices embedded in a constructed-value calculation are reviewable. At the administrative level, respondents and interested parties file case and rebuttal briefs challenging the surrogate-profit source, the allocation of SG&A, the treatment of affiliated-party inputs, and the cost-averaging period. The Federal Circuit has repeatedly scrutinized whether Commerce’s chosen profit methodology is supported by substantial evidence and is reasonable in light of the statute. In Hyundai Steel Co. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2021), the court examined Commerce’s cost-and-constructed-value methodology and underscored that the agency’s calculations must rest on substantial evidence in the record.

If the administrative record does not change the outcome, importers and foreign producers can seek review at the U.S. Court of International Trade and, ultimately, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. These challenges are technical, record-intensive, and deadline-driven; the summons and complaint at the CIT must be filed within strict statutory windows measured from publication of the final determination. A California importer facing a punitive constructed-value margin should treat the administrative proceeding as the place to build the record, because the reviewing courts will not consider arguments that were not raised before the agency.

Practical Steps for California Importers

Importers are not helpless spectators in a constructed-value case. Even though the foreign producer submits the cost data, the importer of record carries the financial exposure and has every incentive to participate. Coordinating with the supplier to ensure complete and accurate cost reporting, scrutinizing the below-cost test for errors in the cost-recovery and substantial-quantities analysis, and challenging an inflated surrogate-profit rate can all move the margin. Equally important is managing the retrospective-assessment risk through careful entry documentation and, where appropriate, administrative-review participation to establish a company-specific rate.

Because the stakes are measured in the full value of the dumping margin applied against every entry, and because cash deposits tie up working capital for years until a review is completed, early legal analysis pays for itself. A producer that can demonstrate its home-market sales were not truly below cost, or that the cost-of-production calculation double-counted an affiliated input, may avoid constructed value altogether and preserve a price-to-price comparison that shows little or no dumping.

How the Pieces Fit Together

The architecture of 19 U.S.C. 1677b is sequential, and each step narrows the producer’s options. Commerce starts with home-market price, applies the below-cost test under 1677b(b) to discard unprofitable sales, checks whether enough viable sales remain, and if not, builds constructed value under 1677b(e) using cost of production plus SG&A plus profit. The transactions-disregarded and major-input rules of 1677b(f) can inflate the cost inputs that feed both the below-cost test and the constructed value itself. Understanding this chain is what allows a California importer and its counsel to find the pressure points where a margin can be reduced.

No single methodology choice is dispositive, but together they determine the rate. The producer that treats the cost questionnaire as a routine accounting exercise, rather than a legal submission with margin consequences, often discovers too late that an unfavorable surrogate-profit figure or a misapplied major-input adjustment has set a rate it cannot sustain. The time to engage is at the questionnaire stage, not after the preliminary determination publishes a double-digit margin.

Market-Economy Versus Nonmarket-Economy Cost Treatment

The constructed-value machinery of 19 U.S.C. 1677b(e) applies to merchandise from market-economy countries, where Commerce uses the producer’s own books and records. For goods from countries Commerce designates as nonmarket economies, a different and even more punishing framework applies under 1677b(c): Commerce disregards the producer’s actual costs and instead values the factors of production using surrogate values from a comparable market-economy country. California importers sourcing from nonmarket-economy jurisdictions therefore face a normal value built almost entirely from third-country surrogate data, which can diverge sharply from the producer’s real costs.

The distinction matters because the two regimes create different advocacy opportunities. In a market-economy case, the fight is over the producer’s accounting, the allocation of SG&A, and the surrogate-profit source. In a nonmarket-economy case, the fight is over surrogate-country selection and the surrogate values assigned to each input of production. Importers who understand which regime governs their goods can direct their resources to the arguments that actually move the margin, rather than contesting figures the statute does not let Commerce use.

Even within market-economy cases, the choice of what counts as the ordinary course of trade shapes the entire calculation. Sales to affiliated customers, sample sales, and sales outside normal commercial quantities can be excluded, narrowing the pool from which both the below-cost test and the constructed-value profit are drawn. Each exclusion is an opportunity for argument, because removing the wrong transactions can distort the surrogate in the government’s favor.

The Retrospective Assessment System and Cash-Deposit Exposure

The United States is one of the few jurisdictions that assesses antidumping duties retrospectively rather than at the time of entry. When merchandise enters, the importer posts a cash deposit at the current margin rate, but the final duty liability is not fixed until Commerce completes an administrative review covering that period, which can occur years later. If the review produces a higher margin than the deposit rate, the importer owes the difference plus interest; if lower, it receives a refund. Constructed value sits at the center of this exposure, because a review that shifts a producer onto constructed value can raise the final assessed rate dramatically.

For California importers, this means a constructed-value determination is not a one-time event but a recurring risk across every review period in which the order remains in place. Prudent importers budget for the gap between deposit and potential final liability, preserve their right to participate in each administrative review, and consider requesting a review to establish a company-specific rate rather than defaulting to an all-others or adverse rate. The retrospective system rewards sustained engagement and punishes importers who treat the initial cash deposit as the end of their obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between cost of production and constructed value?

Cost of production under 19 U.S.C. 1677b(b)(3) is the manufacturing cost plus SG&A plus packing, and it is used to test whether home-market sales were made below cost. Constructed value under 1677b(e) adds a statutory amount for profit on top of those costs and is used as a surrogate normal value when viable home-market sales do not exist.

When does Commerce disregard home-market sales as below cost?

Commerce disregards below-cost sales when they are made within an extended period (normally one year), in substantial quantities (at least twenty percent of volume, or a weighted-average price below weighted-average cost), and at prices that do not permit recovery of costs within a reasonable period, as set out in 19 U.S.C. 1677b(b)(1) and (2).

Why do constructed-value margins tend to be higher?

Because constructed value always includes a positive amount for profit, a producer selling near or below cost at home will almost always appear to be dumping when its U.S. price is compared against a profit-inclusive surrogate, even if its pricing was consistent across both markets.

Who pays the antidumping duty, the foreign producer or the importer?

The U.S. importer of record pays. Antidumping duties are assessed against entries, and because the U.S. operates a retrospective assessment system, the final liability is set after an administrative review, often well after the goods have been sold. California importers therefore bear the ultimate financial exposure.

Can an importer influence the cost data if the supplier submits it?

Yes. Although the foreign producer files the cost response, the importer has a direct financial stake and can coordinate with the supplier to ensure accurate reporting, retain counsel to review the submission, and participate as an interested party in the proceeding to protect its interests.

What is the major-input rule?

Under 19 U.S.C. 1677b(f)(3), when a producer buys a significant input from an affiliated supplier, Commerce may value that input at the highest of the transfer price, the market price, or the affiliate’s cost of producing it, which can raise the reported cost of production and push more sales below cost.

How is the profit amount in constructed value determined?

Ordinarily it is the producer’s actual profit on home-market sales of the foreign like product made in the ordinary course of trade. When those sales are unavailable, Commerce may use the profit of other respondents or any other reasonable method, subject to a statutory profit cap under 1677b(e)(2)(B).

Can a constructed-value margin be challenged in court?

Yes. After exhausting arguments before Commerce, importers and foreign producers can seek review at the U.S. Court of International Trade and the Federal Circuit, which examine whether Commerce’s methodology is supported by substantial evidence and consistent with the statute. Strict filing deadlines apply.

Related Guides

If your California business is facing an antidumping proceeding, a punitive constructed-value margin, or a cost-of-production questionnaire from the Department of Commerce, the trade attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can help you analyze the methodology and build the administrative record. Call (213) 645-2246 for a consultation on your antidumping and countervailing duty exposure.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301