NON-COMPETE & TRADE SECRETS | 2026-11-18

Forfeiture-for-Competition Clauses Are Void Under Section 16600 in California 2026

Why California voids clauses that strip deferred pay or pensions from employees who join a competitor.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

California has the nation's strongest pro-mobility policy, and Business and Professions Code section 16600 voids most restraints of trade. Employers have long tried to reach the same result indirectly through forfeiture-for-competition clauses that strip deferred pay, equity, or pensions from a work

Why forfeiture-for-competition clauses collide with California policy

California has the strongest pro-employee-mobility policy in the nation, and it is written into statute. Business and Professions Code § 16600 declares that, with narrow exceptions, every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void. Most people think of this rule in terms of outright non-compete agreements, but employers have long tried to achieve the same result indirectly, through a forfeiture-for-competition clause. Such a clause does not forbid the employee from competing; it instead says that if the employee competes, the employee forfeits something valuable, typically deferred compensation, a pension benefit, unvested equity, or a bonus. California treats these indirect restraints the same way it treats direct ones. This article explains why forfeiture-for-competition provisions are void, the leading cases, the 2024 statutory additions, and what it means for employees and employers.

Section 16600 and the rule against restraints of trade

The text of Business and Professions Code § 16600 is deceptively simple and the California Supreme Court has read it broadly. The statute does not ask whether a restraint is reasonable in time or geography, the test used in most states; it voids restraints outright unless they fall within a statutory exception, such as the sale of a business or the dissolution of a partnership under Business and Professions Code § 16601 and § 16602. The core principle is that California has chosen to protect the right of its citizens to pursue the work of their choice over the interest of a former employer in avoiding competition.

Muggill and the forfeiture-for-competition doctrine

The controlling authority on forfeiture clauses is Muggill v. Reuben H. Donnelley Corp. (1965). There the California Supreme Court confronted a pension plan that provided the employee would lose his retirement benefits if he went to work for a competitor. The Court held that the forfeiture provision was void under Business and Professions Code § 16600 because it restrained the employee from engaging in a lawful business. The reasoning is central: a clause that penalizes competition by stripping away earned compensation operates as a restraint of trade just as surely as a clause that forbids competition outright. The label does not matter; the effect does. After Muggill, an employer cannot use the threat of losing deferred pay to deter an employee from joining a competitor.

It is important to distinguish a true forfeiture-for-competition clause from a benefit that was simply never earned or that lapses for a reason unrelated to competition. A clause that conditions a benefit on continued employment, so that leaving for any reason ends further accrual, is different from a clause that singles out competition for a penalty. The vice Muggill identified is the targeting of competitive activity.

Edwards v. Arthur Andersen and the rejection of a narrow-restraint exception

For years some courts, borrowing from federal decisions, suggested that § 16600 might tolerate a narrow restraint that only slightly limited an employee's ability to work. The California Supreme Court closed that door in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008). The Court held that § 16600 means what it says and that California does not recognize a narrow-restraint exception; a covenant that restrains a former employee from practicing a profession or soliciting clients is void even if the restraint is limited. Edwards confirmed that the analysis is not about reasonableness but about whether the provision restrains the pursuit of a lawful calling. The combination of Muggill and Edwards leaves little room for employers to engineer indirect restraints.

The 2024 additions: sections 16600.1 and 16600.5

Effective January 1, 2024, the Legislature strengthened § 16600 through two 2023 bills: AB 1076, which added § 16600.1 and codified Edwards in § 16600 itself, and SB 699, which added § 16600.5. Business and Professions Code § 16600.1 makes it unlawful for an employer to include a void non-compete clause in an employment contract or to require an employee to enter one, and it imposes an affirmative notice duty: employers were required, by February 14, 2024, to notify current employees and former employees employed after January 1, 2022 that any non-compete clause in their agreement is void. Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 declares that a non-compete that is void under California law is unenforceable regardless of where and when the contract was signed, bars an employer from enforcing or attempting to enforce such a provision, creates a private right of action, and provides that a prevailing employee may recover reasonable attorney fees and costs. These provisions put real teeth behind the old rule and reach agreements signed in other states by employees who later work in California.

How a forfeiture clause is analyzed

When a dispute arises, a court asks a straightforward question: does the provision penalize the employee for engaging in lawful competitive work. If the answer is yes, the clause is void under Business and Professions Code § 16600 regardless of how it is drafted or labeled. A plan that says deferred compensation is forfeited if the former employee competes is void. A plan that recaptures already-paid bonuses upon competition is void. By contrast, a plan that vests benefits on a fixed schedule and does not single out competition is generally enforceable, because it is not a restraint on the pursuit of a trade.

The interaction with trade secret protection

Employers that cannot restrain competition still may protect genuine trade secrets. California allows an employer to sue for misappropriation of trade secrets under the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act even though it cannot enforce a non-compete. But the two must not be confused: an employer cannot use a forfeiture clause or a confidentiality agreement as a backdoor non-compete. Courts scrutinize overbroad confidentiality and non-solicitation provisions that function to prevent competition, and under the 2024 reforms such attempts carry fee exposure. The lawful path is to protect specific secret information, not to penalize the act of working for a rival.

Remedies when an employer tries to enforce a void clause

An employee faced with a forfeiture-for-competition clause has strong remedies. The clause is void and unenforceable, so the forfeited benefit must be paid. Under Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 the employee may bring an affirmative action and, if successful, recover attorney fees and costs. An employer that includes or attempts to enforce a void clause may also face claims under Business and Professions Code § 16600.1. Because the statute reaches out-of-state agreements, an employee who relocated to California and is told a clause signed elsewhere still binds them has a clear answer under § 16600.5.

Guidance for employees weighing a move

An employee considering a competitive move should read every deferred-compensation, equity, bonus, and pension document carefully, because the trigger for any penalty is what matters. If a benefit is forfeited only upon competition, that trigger is void in California, but the employee should still obtain counsel before acting, both to confirm the clause is a true competition penalty and to document the position. Keeping records of what has vested and when, and avoiding any actual misuse of the former employer's trade secrets, keeps the employee on firm legal ground. The right to take a better job with a competitor is one California protects strongly.

Guidance for employers drafting compensation plans

Employers should audit their incentive and retirement plans to remove any provision that forfeits earned compensation upon competition, because such provisions are void and, since 2024, expose the employer to fee-shifting liability and the notice obligations of Business and Professions Code § 16600.1. Legitimate retention tools, such as time-based vesting that applies regardless of where the employee goes next, remain available. Employers that operate in multiple states must remember that Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 voids these clauses for California employees even when the agreement was signed and is governed by another state's law. For the companion topic of how California actually does let employers protect confidential information, see our discussion of trade secret misappropriation under CUTSA, and read more employer and employee analysis on our California employment law news page.

The narrow statutory exceptions to section 16600

Business and Professions Code § 16600 is not absolute; the Legislature carved out a few specific situations where a covenant not to compete may be enforced. Under Business and Professions Code § 16601, a person who sells the goodwill of a business or substantially all of its operating assets, or an owner who sells or disposes of all of their ownership interest, may agree not to compete within the geographic area where the business operated. Business and Professions Code § 16602 permits a reasonable non-compete among partners in anticipation of dissolution, and a parallel provision addresses members of a limited liability company. These exceptions are construed narrowly and apply to owners and sellers, not to ordinary employees, so they do not rescue a forfeiture clause imposed on a rank-and-file worker.

Non-solicitation of customers and employees

Employers frequently substitute customer and employee non-solicitation covenants for outright non-competes, but California treats many of these as void restraints as well. A clause barring a former employee from soliciting the employer's customers is generally void under Business and Professions Code § 16600 because it restrains the employee from pursuing their trade, although some courts have suggested a narrow allowance where enforcement is necessary to protect a trade secret. Employee non-solicitation, or no-raid, clauses that prevent a departing worker from recruiting former colleagues have also been held to restrain trade and are vulnerable. A forfeiture clause tied to any of these activities carries the same infirmity as one tied to competition itself.

Choice of law and the limits of out-of-state contracts

Employers headquartered elsewhere often insert choice-of-law and forum-selection clauses designed to apply another state's more permissive non-compete law. California counters this in two ways. Labor Code § 925 bars an employer from requiring a California-based employee, as a condition of employment, to agree to adjudicate claims outside California or under another state law where the claim arose in California, for contracts entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017, unless the employee was individually represented by counsel in negotiating the forum or choice-of-law term. And Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 declares that a non-compete void under California law is unenforceable regardless of where or when it was signed. Together these provisions sharply limit an employer's ability to escape California policy through drafting.

Deferred compensation, equity, and pensions in practice

Forfeiture-for-competition clauses hide in many forms of pay. Stock option and restricted stock unit plans may provide that unvested or even vested equity is clawed back if the holder joins a competitor. Deferred compensation and supplemental retirement plans may condition payout on refraining from competition. Bonus and commission plans may purport to recapture amounts already earned. Under Muggill v. Reuben H. Donnelley Corp. (1965), any such provision that forfeits earned compensation because the employee competes is void under Business and Professions Code § 16600. The key inquiry is always the trigger: a benefit lost because of competition is void, while a benefit that simply had not yet vested on a neutral schedule is not.

The 2024 notice obligation and its consequences

The 2024 legislation did more than restate the rule. Business and Professions Code § 16600.1 required employers to send individualized written notice to current employees, and to former employees employed after January 1, 2022, by February 14, 2024, informing them that any non-compete clause in their agreement is void. Failing to provide that notice is itself an act of unfair competition, exposing the employer to liability. Combined with the private right of action and fee-shifting in Business and Professions Code § 16600.5, these provisions shifted the risk calculus: an employer that keeps void clauses in its contracts or tries to enforce them now faces affirmative liability rather than mere unenforceability.

Severance releases and the employee's decision

An employee presented with a severance agreement that reaffirms a forfeiture or non-compete clause should not assume signing forecloses their rights. A release cannot make an otherwise void restraint enforceable, and a provision that penalizes future competition remains void under Business and Professions Code § 16600 even if embedded in a settlement. That said, releases can waive known accrued claims, so the interaction is nuanced and worth a careful review. An employee who has already been denied deferred pay because they joined a competitor has a direct affirmative claim and should preserve records of what was earned and when the forfeiture was imposed.

How an employee recovers forfeited compensation

When an employer invokes a forfeiture-for-competition clause and withholds earned pay, the employee remedy is to enforce the right to that compensation on the ground that the forfeiture provision is void under Business and Professions Code § 16600. The employee may sue to recover the withheld deferred compensation, unvested or clawed-back equity, or pension benefits, and may also invoke the private right of action in Business and Professions Code § 16600.5, which authorizes recovery of reasonable attorney fees and costs to a prevailing employee. Because unpaid earned wages can also implicate Labor Code remedies, an employee improperly denied compensation should preserve plan documents, vesting schedules, and the employer's written explanation for the forfeiture.

Why California differs from most other states

Most states evaluate non-competes and forfeiture clauses under a reasonableness test, asking whether the restraint is limited in time, geography, and scope and whether it protects a legitimate business interest. California rejected that approach long ago. Under Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) and the plain text of Business and Professions Code § 16600, the question is not whether a restraint is reasonable but whether it restrains a lawful profession, trade, or business at all. This makes California an outlier, and it is precisely why multistate employers so often try, and fail, to import another state's more permissive law through choice-of-law clauses that Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 and Labor Code § 925 neutralize.

Drafting lawful retention tools

Employers are not left without options to retain talent. Time-based vesting that applies regardless of where the employee goes next is lawful, because it does not single out competition. Signing and retention bonuses with neutral clawbacks tied to length of service, rather than to refraining from competition, are generally enforceable. Genuine trade secret protection through the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act remains available. The line an employer must not cross is any provision whose trigger is the act of competing or soliciting, because Muggill v. Reuben H. Donnelley Corp. (1965) and Business and Professions Code § 16600 render such triggers void, and the 2024 reforms attach affirmative liability to their use.

Garden leave and paid-notice provisions

Some employers attempt to restrain competition through garden-leave or extended-notice provisions that keep a departing employee on the payroll but idle, delaying their move to a competitor. In California these arrangements are scrutinized, because a provision that effectively prevents an employee from working for a rival can operate as a restraint of trade under Business and Professions Code § 16600 even when the employee continues to receive pay. The key question remains whether the provision restrains the pursuit of a lawful calling. A short, genuine notice period tied to transition duties is different from a lengthy forced idleness designed to blunt competition, and the latter risks being void just like a forfeiture clause under Muggill v. Reuben H. Donnelley Corp. (1965).

How section 16600 and trade secret law divide the field

California policy strikes a deliberate balance: an employer may not restrain a former employee from competing, but it may protect its genuine trade secrets. Business and Professions Code § 16600 voids restraints on the pursuit of a trade, while the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act at Civil Code § 3426.1 and following lets an employer sue when a departing worker actually takes and uses protected secret information. The two doctrines are complementary, not interchangeable. An employer that tries to convert trade secret protection into a general bar on competition, or that uses a forfeiture clause as a stand-in for a non-compete, oversteps and invites liability. The lawful course is to protect the specific secret, not to penalize the act of working elsewhere.

Talk to a California non-compete lawyer. If you were told you will lose deferred pay, equity, or a pension because you joined a competitor, or you are an employer unsure whether your compensation plan is lawful, the rules under Business and Professions Code § 16600 are strict and the 2024 reforms added penalties. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm advise employees and employers on restraints of trade throughout California. Call (213) 645-2246 for guidance before you act.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a clause that takes away deferred pay for competing enforceable in California?

No. Under Muggill v. Reuben H. Donnelley Corp. (1965) and Business and Professions Code § 16600, a provision that forfeits earned deferred compensation or a pension because the employee goes to work for a competitor is a void restraint of trade, even though it does not expressly forbid competition.

Does it matter that the restraint is narrow or short?

No. In Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) the California Supreme Court held that § 16600 does not recognize a narrow-restraint exception. The question is whether the provision restrains a lawful profession or trade, not whether the restraint is reasonable in scope.

What did the 2024 amendments add?

Business and Professions Code § 16600.1 bars employers from including void non-competes and imposes a notice duty, while Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 voids such clauses regardless of where the contract was signed, creates a private right of action, and allows a prevailing employee to recover attorney fees.

Can an out-of-state agreement allow a former employer to enforce a forfeiture?

Generally no for a California employee. Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 provides that a non-compete void under California law is unenforceable regardless of where and when it was signed, so a clause valid in another state typically cannot be enforced against someone working in California.

Can an employer still protect its confidential information?

Yes, but through trade secret law, not a forfeiture clause. An employer may pursue misappropriation claims under the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act, but it may not use a forfeiture-for-competition provision or an overbroad confidentiality clause as a disguised non-compete.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301