NON-COMPETE & TRADE SECRETS | 2026-11-15
Idea Submission and the Desny Claim for Employees in California 2026
California lets you sue to be paid for an idea you disclosed and someone used, through an implied-in-fact contract even without a signed agreement.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California recognizes a legal right to be paid for a valuable idea you disclosed to someone who used it, even without a signed contract and even though ideas themselves are not property. The vehicle is the Desny claim, built on an implied-in-fact contract to pay for an idea that is conditioned on pa
Getting Paid for an Idea: The Desny Claim Explained
California recognizes something many states do not: a legal right to be paid for a valuable idea you disclosed to someone who used it, even without a signed contract and even though ideas themselves are not property. The vehicle is the Desny claim, named for the California Supreme Court's landmark decision in Desny v. Wilder (1956). The case arose in Hollywood, where a writer pitched a story premise over the phone to a producer's office, the studio allegedly used it, and the writer sued. The Court held that an implied-in-fact contract to pay for the idea can arise when the discloser conditions the disclosure on payment and the recipient, knowing that condition, voluntarily accepts the disclosure and uses the idea.
Although Desny was an entertainment case, its doctrine reaches far beyond scripts. Employees and prospective employees who submit ideas, inventions, product concepts, process improvements, or business plans can invoke it when an employer takes the idea and refuses to pay. This article explains the elements of a Desny claim, how it interacts with California's trade-secret statute and employee-invention protections, and the practical steps that make an idea-submission claim viable.
The Core Problem: Ideas Are Not Property
The starting premise is harsh for idea holders. Under both copyright law and California property principles, an idea in the abstract is not owned by anyone. Copyright protects the expression of an idea, not the idea itself, and once you tell someone an idea, you cannot sue for the mere taking of it as if it were stolen property. That is why the Desny claim is framed in contract, not property. The law does not protect the idea; it protects the deal. If the parties, by their words and conduct, formed an implied agreement that use of the idea would be paid for, that agreement is enforceable like any other contract.
This contract framing is essential to understanding the doctrine's limits. A person who blurts out an idea with no expectation of payment, or discloses it freely, has no claim. The right arises only where the circumstances show an understanding that the disclosure was conditioned on compensation if used.
The Elements of a Desny Claim
To prevail on an implied-in-fact contract theory under Desny, the discloser generally must prove four things. First, the discloser clearly conditioned the offer to convey the idea on an obligation to pay for it if used. Second, the recipient, knowing that condition before the idea was disclosed, voluntarily accepted the disclosure. Third, the recipient actually used the idea. Fourth, the idea had value. The critical timing element is that the recipient must understand the payment condition before learning the idea; an after-the-fact demand for payment does not create a contract because the recipient never had the chance to reject the disclosure on those terms.
Use and Access: Proving the Defendant Took Your Idea
A Desny plaintiff must show the defendant actually used the submitted idea, which typically requires proof of access and similarity. Grosso v. Miramax Film Corp. (9th Cir. 2004) is the leading modern authority applying Desny. In Grosso, a writer alleged a studio used his submitted screenplay material, and the Ninth Circuit confirmed that a Desny implied-contract claim survives even where a copyright claim fails. The court reasoned that the implied promise to pay for use of an idea is an extra element beyond mere copying, so the claim is not equivalent to a copyright claim and therefore is not preempted.
Grosso matters because defendants routinely argue that federal copyright law preempts any state-law idea claim. The answer, under Grosso, is that a genuine implied-in-fact contract claim is different in kind: it enforces a bargain, not a property right in expression. Proving use still demands evidence that the decisionmakers had access to the idea and that the end product reflects it, which is why documenting the submission and the recipient's subsequent conduct is so important.
Copyright Preemption and Why Desny Survives
The preemption question turns on whether the state claim contains an extra element not required by copyright. A bare claim that the defendant copied protected expression is preempted. But the Desny bargain adds the promise to pay, which copyright does not require. Because the implied contract protects the expectation of payment rather than the work itself, courts following Grosso hold that Desny claims escape preemption. This distinction is the doctrinal engine that keeps idea-submission claims alive in California when parallel copyright theories collapse.
The Trade-Secret Overlay: CUTSA
Many idea submissions also qualify, or are argued to qualify, as trade secrets. California's Uniform Trade Secrets Act defines a trade secret in Civ. Code § 3426.1 as information that derives independent economic value from not being generally known and that is the subject of reasonable efforts to maintain secrecy. If an employee discloses a genuinely secret concept under circumstances creating a duty of confidence, misappropriation under CUTSA may provide a remedy distinct from the Desny contract theory.
But CUTSA carries a trap. Civ. Code § 3426.7 supersedes common-law claims that are based on the same nucleus of facts as a trade-secret misappropriation claim. Courts have used this supersession provision to dismiss common-law idea claims that are really trade-secret claims in disguise. The interaction is delicate: a Desny implied-contract claim premised on a confidential submission can be challenged as superseded if it merely restates misappropriation. Pleading the contract theory carefully, grounded in the bargain rather than the secrecy, helps preserve it alongside or instead of a CUTSA claim.
Employee Inventions: Labor Code Section 2870
When the idea holder is an employee, a separate statutory regime governs who owns the invention. Labor Code § 2870 limits the reach of employer invention-assignment agreements. It provides that an agreement requiring an employee to assign inventions is unenforceable as to any invention the employee developed entirely on his own time, without using the employer's equipment, supplies, facilities, or trade-secret information, unless the invention relates to the employer's business or actual or demonstrably anticipated research, or results from work performed for the employer. In short, inventions made truly on the employee's own time and resources, unrelated to the employer's business, belong to the employee.
Labor Code § 2871 permits employers to require disclosure of inventions so ownership can be sorted out, and Labor Code § 2872 requires that assignment agreements include a written notice of the § 2870 limitations. An employee who conceived an idea on personal time, with personal resources, outside the employer's line of business, can use § 2870 to defeat an overbroad assignment clause and retain ownership, which in turn strengthens any Desny or contract-based claim for compensation if the employer uses the idea anyway.
Statute of Frauds and the Limitations Period
Because Desny claims rest on implied contracts, timing and form matter. An oral or implied contract is generally subject to a two-year limitations period under Code Civ. Proc. § 339, running from the breach, typically when the defendant uses the idea without paying. Where a claim depends on a writing, Civ. Code § 1624 statute-of-frauds considerations may arise, though implied-in-fact idea contracts are usually oral or based on conduct. The short two-year window means an idea holder who suspects misuse should act quickly; waiting for confirmation that the product shipped can run out the clock.
What the Idea Must Be: Concreteness and Novelty
California does not require that an idea be novel or original to support a Desny claim, because the claim enforces a bargain rather than rewarding invention. If the parties agreed to pay for the idea, the discloser can recover even for an idea that is not new. That said, concreteness helps prove use: a vague notion is hard to trace into a finished product, while a specific, developed concept supports an inference of use. Novelty may still matter to valuation and to any parallel trade-secret theory, which does require that the information not be generally known.
Remedies and Valuation
A successful Desny plaintiff recovers the reasonable value of the idea as used, which the parties often frame as what a willing buyer would have paid, measured by industry custom, comparable deals, or the benefit the defendant obtained. Where a trade-secret theory applies, Civ. Code § 3426.3 allows recovery of actual loss and unjust enrichment, and in some cases a reasonable royalty, plus exemplary damages for willful and malicious misappropriation. Choosing the right theory, contract versus trade secret, affects both the measure of damages and the risk of CUTSA supersession, so the choice should be deliberate.
Practical Steps for Idea Submitters
Anyone submitting an idea to an employer or company should create a paper trail: state in writing, before disclosing details, that the submission is made in confidence and in expectation of compensation if used. Keep copies of the submission and any responses, and note who received it. If you are an employee, review your invention-assignment agreement against Labor Code § 2870 before disclosing anything developed on your own time. For related restrictions on where you can take your ideas and talent after leaving, see our guide to employee raiding, non-solicitation covenants, and trade secrets in California, and explore more on our California employment law news page.
Negotiating and Documenting Idea Submissions
The surest protection for an idea holder is to establish the payment condition in writing before disclosing the substance of the idea. A brief submission agreement, or even an email stating that the concept is offered on the understanding that the recipient will pay reasonable compensation if it uses the idea, converts a risky implied-in-fact theory into a far stronger express contract. Many sophisticated companies, aware of Desny, use submission-release forms that attempt to disclaim any obligation to pay, stating that the company accepts the idea without any confidential or contractual commitment. An idea holder confronted with such a release must understand that signing it can extinguish the very Desny rights the doctrine would otherwise provide.
For employees, the analysis is layered: the invention-assignment agreement, the employer's innovation or suggestion program, and the Labor Code § 2870 carve-out all interact. Before pitching a significant concept internally, an employee should understand which of these documents governs and whether the idea was developed on personal or company time and resources. Documenting the circumstances of conception, where, when, and with what resources, can prove decisive if a dispute later arises over ownership or compensation under Labor Code § 2870 or an express or implied agreement.
From Hollywood to the Workplace: The Doctrine's Reach
Although Desny v. Wilder arose from a radio and film pitch, nothing in its logic confines it to entertainment. The implied-in-fact contract to pay for a used idea applies wherever one party conditions disclosure of a valuable concept on payment and another accepts it knowing that condition. In the modern workplace, this reaches employees who propose new products, process improvements, marketing concepts, software features, or business strategies, as well as outside contractors and vendors who pitch ideas to companies. The key is always the same: did the circumstances show an understanding that use would be paid for, communicated before the idea was revealed?
Courts applying Desny outside Hollywood look to the same factors: the conduct of the parties, the custom of the relevant industry, the specificity of the submission, and whether the recipient had a fair opportunity to decline the disclosure. An employee who formally submits a concept through a company suggestion or innovation program, especially one that promises rewards for adopted ideas, builds a strong record for an implied or even express contract. The further the submission strays from any expectation of payment, the weaker the claim becomes.
Express Versus Implied Contracts for Ideas
Idea claims can rest on either an express contract or an implied-in-fact contract. An express contract exists where the parties actually discuss payment terms, whether orally or in writing. The Desny doctrine is important precisely because it reaches the far more common situation where no one spelled out the terms, yet the surrounding conduct shows a mutual understanding that use would be compensated. California courts infer the contract from the parties' behavior: the way the idea was pitched, industry custom, the recipient's acceptance of the disclosure, and the context of the relationship. An implied-in-fact contract is just as enforceable as an express one; the only difference is how its existence is proven.
This distinction also separates the implied-in-fact contract from a so-called implied-in-law or quasi-contract theory. A quasi-contract is not a real agreement at all but a remedy the law imposes to prevent unjust enrichment. Desny rests on a genuine, if unspoken, meeting of the minds, which is why the timing of the payment condition, before disclosure, is indispensable: without it, there was never a real bargain to enforce.
The Confidential-Relationship Theory
Beyond contract, an idea submitter may sometimes rely on a confidential relationship. Where the parties stood in a relationship of trust, or where the disclosure was expressly made in confidence, the recipient may owe a duty not to exploit the idea for its own benefit. Breach of that duty can give rise to liability independent of any promise to pay. In the employment setting, a confidential relationship frequently exists between an employee and employer, which strengthens the argument that an idea shared internally was not a free gift but a disclosure the employer was bound to treat with restraint. As with other common-law theories, however, a confidential-relationship claim that merely restates trade-secret misappropriation risks supersession under Civ. Code § 3426.7.
Drafting Around the CUTSA Supersession Trap
Because Civ. Code § 3426.7 displaces common-law claims resting on the same facts as a trade-secret misappropriation claim, pleading strategy is critical. A Desny claim framed around the bargain, the agreement to pay for use of the idea, is conceptually distinct from a claim that the defendant wrongfully acquired or used secret information, and courts have allowed such contract claims to proceed alongside or instead of CUTSA. The danger arises when the complaint describes the wrong as the taking of confidential information rather than the breach of a promise. Keeping the two theories doctrinally separate, contract for the promise, CUTSA for the secret, preserves the plaintiff's options and avoids an early dismissal.
Who Owns Ideas Developed on Company Time
The flip side of Labor Code § 2870 is that inventions developed on company time, with company resources, or that relate to the employer's business, generally belong to the employer when a valid assignment agreement exists. The statute draws the line at whether the employee used the employer's time, equipment, supplies, facilities, or trade-secret information, and whether the invention relates to the employer's business or anticipated research or resulted from work performed for the employer. An employee cannot develop a concept using the employer's laboratory and proprietary data and then claim a personal Desny right to be paid for it; that invention falls outside § 2870's protection and is assignable. The statute's careful boundaries make documentation of when and how an idea was conceived essential to any ownership dispute.
Litigating an Idea Case: Proof of Access and Independent Creation
At trial, the central battle is usually whether the defendant used the plaintiff's idea or arrived at the same concept independently. Independent creation is a complete defense: if the defendant developed the product without reference to the plaintiff's submission, there is no use and no breach. Plaintiffs counter with evidence of access, showing the decisionmakers received or had the opportunity to review the submission, combined with striking similarity between the submission and the final product. Circumstantial proof, such as the timing of the defendant's project relative to the submission and internal documents referencing the idea, often carries the day. Because memories fade and documents disappear, preserving the submission record early is vital.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If a company used your idea, invention, or concept without paying you, California's Desny doctrine and the Labor Code may give you a path to compensation even without a signed contract. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm evaluate idea-submission and employee-invention disputes across California and can advise whether a contract or trade-secret theory fits your facts. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation before the limitations period runs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be paid for an idea if I never signed a contract?
Yes, potentially. Under Desny v. Wilder, an implied-in-fact contract to pay for an idea can arise when you condition the disclosure on payment, the recipient knows that condition before learning the idea and voluntarily accepts the disclosure, and the recipient then uses the idea. No signed writing is required.
Does copyright law block idea-submission claims?
Not if the claim is a genuine implied contract. Grosso v. Miramax held that a Desny claim includes an extra element, the promise to pay, that copyright does not require, so it is not preempted. A bare claim that the defendant copied your expression, by contrast, would be preempted by copyright.
Does my idea have to be novel or original?
No. Because a Desny claim enforces a bargain rather than rewarding invention, California does not require novelty. If the parties agreed to pay for the idea, you can recover even for an idea that is not new, though concreteness helps you prove the defendant actually used it.
Who owns an invention I developed on my own time?
Under Labor Code § 2870, an invention you develop entirely on your own time, without the employer's equipment or trade secrets, and unrelated to the employer's business or your work for it, belongs to you, and an assignment clause cannot reach it. Labor Code § 2872 requires employers to include written notice of this limitation.
How long do I have to sue for misuse of my idea?
An implied-contract idea claim is generally subject to a two-year limitations period under Code Civ. Proc. § 339, running from when the defendant used your idea without paying. The window is short, so if you suspect misuse you should seek advice promptly rather than waiting for confirmation.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301