NON-COMPETE & TRADE SECRETS | 2026-11-14
Garden Leave and Non-Compete Restrictions in California (2026)
California voids post-employment non-competes, and garden leave is lawful only while the employment relationship actually continues.
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
California has the strongest anti-non-compete policy in the country, and in recent years the Legislature has made it even stronger. Employers who relocate here, or who import contract templates from other states, routinely try to bind California workers with non-competes, garden-leave clauses, and b
California's Baseline Rule on Restraints of Trade
The foundation of California's approach is Business and Professions Code § 16600, which declares that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void. Unlike most states, California does not ask whether a non-compete is reasonable in time, geography, or scope. It starts from the premise that the restraint is void, subject only to narrow statutory exceptions tied to the sale of a business or the dissolution of a partnership or limited liability company. For the ordinary employee, a post-employment covenant not to compete is unenforceable, full stop. This policy rests on a long-standing California judgment that the state benefits most from open competition and the free movement of skilled workers between employers.
Edwards and the Rejection of a Narrow-Restraint Exception
For years some employers argued that a limited or narrow restraint should survive even if a broad one would not. The California Supreme Court closed that door in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen (2008), which held that § 16600 means what it says and rejected the so-called narrow-restraint exception that some federal courts had read into California law. After Edwards, a non-compete is not saved by being modest; if it restrains the employee from practicing a trade or profession after employment ends, it is void. This is the case every California worker handed a non-compete should know about, because it forecloses the argument employers most often make, which is that their particular clause is reasonable and therefore enforceable.
The 2024 Amendments: SB 699 and AB 1076
The Legislature recently went further. Business and Professions Code § 16600.1 and Business and Professions Code § 16600.5, added through SB 699 and AB 1076 effective in 2024, do more than restate that non-competes are void. They make it unlawful for an employer to include a void non-compete in a contract or to attempt to enforce one, they reach agreements signed out of state and regardless of where they were signed, and they required employers to give written notice to current and certain former employees that any non-compete they signed is void. An employer that violates these provisions can face liability, including attorney's fees, and a worker subjected to an unlawful restraint now has an affirmative claim rather than only a defense. That shift, from shield to sword, is the single biggest practical change in this area in a generation, because it gives workers a reason to come forward rather than simply hope the clause is never enforced.
What Garden Leave Actually Is
Garden leave is a practice borrowed from English and East Coast employment law. During a notice period, the employer keeps the departing employee on payroll but relieves them of duties and, often, keeps them away from clients, systems, and the market. The phrase comes from the idea that the employee stays home and tends the garden while still employed. The attraction for employers is obvious: a well-paid employee sitting out a notice period cannot immediately start helping a competitor, and sensitive information the employee holds grows stale while they are benched. Employers in finance, technology, and senior executive roles are the ones most likely to propose it.
Why Garden Leave Is Lawful Only During Employment
The crucial point in California is timing. Garden leave is lawful only while the employment relationship genuinely continues, because while you are employed your duty of loyalty and the employer's control over your time are legitimate. An employer may lawfully pay an employee to stay home and do no competitive work, because the person remains an employee. The moment the employment relationship ends, any restriction on where you can work becomes a post-employment restraint, and § 16600 voids it. An employer cannot relabel a post-termination non-compete as garden leave and make it enforceable. If the employer is not actually keeping the worker employed and paying full wages and benefits, and instead is trying to bench a former employee, the arrangement is a void restraint dressed up in a friendlier name.
A lawful garden-leave arrangement therefore requires that the person remain a current employee in fact, continue to receive pay and benefits, and be free to work elsewhere once the employment truly ends. Employers who want the protection of garden leave must accept the cost and the limits that come with keeping someone on the payroll, and they cannot stretch a notice period into a disguised non-compete that outlasts employment.
Trade-Secret Protection Under CUTSA
Because California denies employers the blunt instrument of a non-compete, legitimate protection must come from trade-secret law. The California Uniform Trade Secrets Act, Civil Code § 3426 through § 3426.11, lets a business protect information that derives independent economic value from not being generally known and that is the subject of reasonable efforts to maintain secrecy. CUTSA provides injunctive relief and damages for actual or threatened misappropriation, and in cases of willful and malicious misappropriation it allows exemplary damages and attorney's fees. This is the lawful path: an employer cannot stop a former employee from competing, but it can stop that employee from stealing or using the employer's trade secrets. The protection attaches to the information itself, not to the person, which is why it does not run afoul of § 16600.
The Rejection of Inevitable Disclosure
Some states let an employer block a former employee from a new job by arguing that the employee will inevitably disclose trade secrets. California rejects the inevitable-disclosure doctrine. An employer cannot use the mere risk that an employee might someday use confidential information as a backdoor non-compete. The employer must show actual or threatened misappropriation, not speculation about what a knowledgeable employee might do in a new role. This rejection is central to how California keeps trade-secret law from swallowing the right to change jobs, because almost any skilled worker carries useful knowledge in their head, and allowing inevitable disclosure would effectively reinstate non-competes under another name.
Non-Solicitation Clauses After Section 16600
Employers often fall back on non-solicitation provisions, promising that a departing worker will not solicit customers or coworkers. California courts increasingly treat broad customer non-solicitation clauses as void restraints under § 16600, especially after Edwards and the 2024 amendments, because a clause that bars a worker from seeking business from the people they know is a restraint on their trade. Employee non-solicitation, or no-poach, clauses face similar scrutiny and have been struck down as improper restraints in recent decisions. A business can still protect against actual trade-secret misuse, such as a former employee using a stolen customer list to target clients, but a flat ban on competing for business or recruiting former colleagues stands on very weak ground.
Choice-of-Law and Forum Traps Under Section 925
Out-of-state employers frequently try to escape California law by inserting clauses that apply another state's law or require litigation elsewhere. Labor Code § 925 blocks that tactic for California employees. For employees who primarily reside and work in California, an employer generally cannot require, as a condition of employment, a provision that would deprive the worker of California law's protections or force litigation outside California, unless the employee was individually represented by counsel in negotiating the agreement. Section 925 lets a worker void such a clause and recover attorney's fees. The practical effect is that a Texas or New York choice-of-law clause often cannot rescue a non-compete against a California worker, and an employer that tries it may add a § 925 violation to its problems.
Practical Guidance for Workers and Employers
Workers presented with a non-compete or garden-leave clause should not assume it is enforceable, and should keep a copy of the agreement and the statutory notice the employer was required to send. Workers threatened with enforcement may have an affirmative claim under the 2024 amendments, and they should resist the temptation to simply comply with a void clause out of fear. Employers should scrub their templates, remove void non-competes, send the required notices, and shift their protection strategy to genuine trade-secret safeguards, narrowly drawn confidentiality agreements, and lawful garden-leave structures that keep the worker truly employed and paid. For more on California's worker-protective framework, see our employment law news, and for how classification issues arise when talent departs through an entity, read our analysis of loan-out company worker classification in California.
The Sale-of-Business and Partnership Exceptions
Section 16600 is not absolute. The Business and Professions Code recognizes narrow exceptions for the sale of a business and for the dissolution or disassociation of partnerships and limited liability companies. When a person sells the goodwill of a business or sells all of their ownership interest, the buyer may lawfully obtain a reasonable covenant not to compete within the geographic area where the business operated, because the buyer is paying for goodwill it is entitled to protect. Similar provisions permit reasonable restraints among partners and members on dissolution. These exceptions are genuinely limited; they do not transform an ordinary employee into a seller, and an employer cannot manufacture the exception by handing a worker a token equity interest and then calling a departure a sale. Courts examine whether a real sale of goodwill occurred before enforcing any restraint under these provisions.
Confidentiality Agreements That Survive
Because non-competes are void, the lawful backbone of employer protection is a narrowly drawn confidentiality or nondisclosure agreement. Such an agreement can validly bar a departing worker from using or disclosing the employer's genuine trade secrets and confidential information. The key is that it protects information, not the worker's right to compete. A confidentiality clause written so broadly that it effectively prevents the employee from working in the field, by defining confidential information to include the worker's own general skills and knowledge, risks being treated as a disguised non-compete and void under § 16600. Employers who want enforceable protection should define confidential information precisely, tie it to actual trade secrets, and avoid language that would stop the worker from practicing their trade at all.
Forfeiture-for-Competition and Deferred Compensation
Employers sometimes try an indirect route: they let the worker leave and compete, but they strip away deferred compensation, bonuses, or equity if the worker goes to a competitor. California courts have been skeptical of these forfeiture-for-competition schemes, treating a clause that penalizes competition as a restraint of trade even when it is framed as a compensation condition rather than an outright prohibition. The question is whether the provision operates to restrain the worker from engaging in their profession. If a worker loses substantial earned compensation solely because they chose to work for a competitor, the arrangement functions as a penalty on competition and sits in the same voidable territory as a direct non-compete.
How Trade-Secret Litigation Actually Works
When an employer has a genuine misappropriation concern, the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act, Civil Code § 3426 through § 3426.11, provides the remedy. To prevail, the employer must identify the trade secret with reasonable particularity, show that it took reasonable measures to keep the information secret, and prove actual or threatened misappropriation. Courts can issue injunctions to stop the use or disclosure of a trade secret and can award damages for actual loss and unjust enrichment, with exemplary damages and attorney's fees available for willful and malicious misappropriation. Crucially, an injunction protects the secret; it does not bar the former employee from competing generally. An employer that cannot point to a specific, protected secret, and instead complains that a skilled worker simply knows too much, will not obtain relief, because that is the inevitable-disclosure argument California rejects.
The Federal Defend Trade Secrets Act
Trade-secret claims are not confined to state law. The federal Defend Trade Secrets Act, 18 U.S.C. § 1836 and following, provides a parallel federal cause of action for misappropriation of trade secrets related to interstate commerce, with its own remedies including injunctive relief and damages. A California employer may pursue both state and federal theories, but neither federal nor state trade-secret law can be used to impose a post-employment non-compete. The federal statute, like CUTSA, protects the information rather than restraining the person, so an employer cannot use it to accomplish indirectly what § 16600 forbids directly.
Remedies a Worker Has Under the 2024 Amendments
The 2024 amendments gave workers more than a defense. Under Business and Professions Code § 16600.5, an employee, former employee, or prospective employee may bring an action for injunctive relief, actual damages, or both, and a prevailing worker is entitled to recover reasonable attorney's fees and costs. That means a worker who is threatened with a void non-compete, or whose job offer is withdrawn because a new employer fears a former employer's non-compete, may have an affirmative claim. The notice requirement added by AB 1076 compounds the exposure for employers who failed to tell current and former employees that their non-competes are void. An employer that keeps sending threatening letters based on an unenforceable clause is accumulating liability with each attempt.
Why California Chose This Policy
California's hostility to non-competes is not an accident of drafting; it reflects a deliberate economic philosophy. The Legislature and the courts have long concluded that the state as a whole prospers when skilled workers can move freely to the employer who values them most, when startups can hire experienced talent from incumbents, and when competition is decided by who serves customers best rather than by who can lock up the labor market with restrictive contracts. Many observers credit this policy, embodied in Business and Professions Code § 16600, with helping California build dynamic industries where talent and ideas circulate rapidly. Understanding this rationale helps workers and employers see why California courts read the exceptions so narrowly and treat attempts to evade § 16600 with such suspicion; the rule is a feature of the state's economy, not a technicality to be engineered around.
A Practical Checklist Before You Sign
A California worker handed an agreement with restrictive covenants should take several concrete steps. Read the whole document and identify any clause that limits where, for whom, or in what field you may work after you leave. Note any choice-of-law or forum clause pointing outside California, which Labor Code § 925 may let you void. Keep a copy of the agreement and any statutory notice the employer sent. Do not assume a void clause binds you, but do not breach a valid confidentiality obligation or misappropriate trade secrets, because those are lawful and enforceable. If an employer threatens enforcement, or a prospective employer hesitates because of a prior non-compete, get advice promptly, because the 2024 amendments may give you an affirmative claim rather than merely a shield.
Common Employer Tactics and Why They Fail
Employers determined to restrain California workers have tried many workarounds, and California courts have rejected them one after another. Labeling a non-compete a confidentiality clause does not save it if the clause in substance prevents competition. Calling a post-termination restriction garden leave does not save it if the employment relationship has actually ended. Inserting an out-of-state choice-of-law clause does not save it against a California employee protected by Labor Code § 925. Framing the restraint as a forfeiture of earned compensation does not save it if the provision penalizes the worker for competing. Arguing that disclosure of secrets is inevitable does not save it because California rejects that doctrine. The common thread is that courts look past the label to the practical effect, and if the practical effect is to restrain a lawful profession, trade, or business, Business and Professions Code § 16600 voids it. An employer serious about protection should abandon these tactics and invest instead in legitimate trade-secret safeguards under Civil Code § 3426 through § 3426.11 and in careful onboarding and offboarding that keeps confidential information secure. Exit interviews that remind departing employees of their genuine confidentiality obligations, prompt deactivation of system access, and clear documentation of what information the employer treats as a trade secret all stand on solid legal ground. None of these measures restrains the worker from competing, and that is precisely why they survive where a non-compete fails. The lesson for employers is that California rewards protecting information and punishes restraining people, and the sooner a business aligns its practices with that reality the less exposure it carries under § 16600.
Talk to a California employment lawyer. If you were handed a non-compete or garden-leave clause, threatened with enforcement of a void restraint, or need to protect real trade secrets lawfully, the attorneys at Trembach Law Firm can evaluate the agreement under § 16600 and the 2024 amendments and protect your rights. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are non-compete agreements enforceable in California?
Almost never. Business and Professions Code § 16600 voids contracts that restrain a lawful profession, trade, or business, and Edwards v. Arthur Andersen (2008) rejected any narrow-restraint exception for ordinary employees.
Is garden leave legal in California?
Only while the employment relationship genuinely continues and the worker is paid and employed. Once employment ends, a restriction on where the person can work becomes a void post-employment restraint under § 16600.
Can my employer make me sign a non-compete under another state's law?
Labor Code § 925 generally bars requiring a California employee to accept out-of-state law or forum clauses as a condition of employment, unless the employee was individually represented by counsel, and lets the worker void the clause and recover attorney's fees.
How can an employer protect its information if non-competes are void?
Through the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act, Civil Code § 3426 through § 3426.11, which protects genuine trade secrets against actual or threatened misappropriation, and through narrowly drawn confidentiality agreements.
Can my old employer stop me from a new job by arguing that disclosure is inevitable?
No. California rejects the inevitable-disclosure doctrine. The former employer must prove actual or threatened misappropriation, not merely that disclosure might happen.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301