NON-COMPETE & TRADE SECRETS | 2026-11-15

Employee Raiding, Non-Solicitation and Trade Secrets in California 2026

California voids employee non-solicitation covenants, yet raiding can still be unlawful when it is accomplished through misuse of protected trade secrets.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

California is the most employee-friendly state when it comes to the freedom to change jobs and compete, anchored by Business and Professions Code section 16600, which voids contracts restraining a lawful profession. Yet employee raiding, where a departing worker or competitor recruits a group of emp

California's Flat Ban on Restraints: Section 16600

California is the most employee-friendly state in the nation when it comes to the freedom to change jobs and compete. The foundation is Business and Professions Code § 16600, which declares that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void. There are narrow statutory exceptions, chiefly for the sale of a business, but as applied to ordinary employment relationships the rule is close to absolute: California does not enforce non-compete agreements, and recent legislation has made that ban even stronger.

This article addresses a recurring tension in California: the line between lawful competition, including hiring away a former employer's workforce, and unlawful trade-secret misappropriation. Employee raiding, where a departing employee or a competitor recruits a group of workers from the former employer, sits right on that line. The non-solicitation covenants companies use to prevent it are largely void, yet the underlying conduct can still cross into liability if it involves misuse of trade secrets. Understanding the difference is essential for both departing employees and the companies they leave.

The 2024 Reforms: AB 1076 and Section 16600.5

In 2024 California strengthened an already strong ban. Business and Professions Code § 16600.1, enacted by AB 1076, makes it unlawful to include a void non-compete clause in an employment contract and required employers to notify current and certain former employees that any such clauses are void. Business and Professions Code § 16600.5 goes further, providing that a non-compete that is void under California law is unenforceable regardless of where and when the contract was signed, barring employers from attempting to enforce out-of-state non-competes against California workers, and creating a private right of action with attorney's fees for a prevailing employee or former employee.

These reforms matter for raiding disputes because they foreclose a common employer tactic: using contractual non-solicitation and non-compete clauses to lock in a workforce. After AB 1076, an employer who tries to enforce such a clause may itself face liability. The practical effect is that companies can no longer rely on the contract to stop employees from leaving together; they must point to something more, usually an allegation of trade-secret misuse.

Edwards v. Arthur Andersen: No Narrow-Restraint Exception

For decades some courts tolerated contractual restraints that were reasonable or narrow. The California Supreme Court ended that in Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008). Edwards held that § 16600 means what it says: a non-compete is void even if it is narrowly drawn, and California does not recognize the federal narrow-restraint exception. The decision rejected the idea that a modest or partial restraint on competition could survive. Edwards cemented California's policy favoring employee mobility and open competition, and it is the baseline against which every restraint, including employee non-solicitation covenants, is now measured.

AMN Healthcare: Employee Non-Solicitation Covenants Are Void

The most important development for raiding disputes is AMN Healthcare, Inc. v. Aya Healthcare Services, Inc. (2018). There, a staffing company sought to enforce a covenant barring former recruiters from soliciting its traveling nurses to work elsewhere. The Court of Appeal held that this employee non-solicitation covenant was void under § 16600 because it restrained the former employees from engaging in their chosen profession of recruiting. AMN rejected the older, more permissive approach and applied Edwards with full force to covenants that restrict soliciting a former employer's workforce.

AMN also narrowed Loral Corp. v. Moyes (1985), an older decision that had upheld a limited no-raiding covenant under a reasonableness test. After AMN, the reasonableness approach of Loral is widely regarded as inconsistent with Edwards, and employee non-solicitation covenants are generally unenforceable. The upshot is that a departing employee in California is ordinarily free to recruit former colleagues, and a competitor is ordinarily free to hire a former rival's workforce, so long as no trade secrets are misused in the process.

Where the Line Falls: Lawful Competition Versus Trade-Secret Misuse

The freedom to compete and to hire is not a license to steal. California's Uniform Trade Secrets Act remains fully in force alongside § 16600. The two bodies of law coexist: contracts restraining competition are void, but misappropriation of trade secrets is actionable. Raiding becomes unlawful not because employees moved together, but when the move is accomplished through the taking or use of protected confidential information, such as customer lists, pricing data, compensation structures, or strategic plans that qualify as trade secrets.

What Qualifies as a Trade Secret

Civil Code § 3426.1 defines a trade secret as information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process, that derives independent economic value from not being generally known to the public or to others who could obtain value from its disclosure, and that is the subject of reasonable efforts under the circumstances to maintain its secrecy. Both prongs are essential. Information that is publicly available, or that the employer failed to protect with reasonable measures such as confidentiality agreements and access controls, is not a trade secret, and using it is lawful competition.

In raiding cases, employers often claim that employee compensation data, staffing rosters, or client relationships are trade secrets. Whether they are depends on the facts. General knowledge, skill, and experience an employee acquired on the job are not trade secrets and travel with the employee freely. A protected customer list compiled through substantial effort and kept confidential can be a trade secret; a list of names readily ascertainable from public sources is not.

Proving and Remedying Misappropriation

Misappropriation under CUTSA includes acquiring a trade secret by improper means, or using or disclosing it without consent where a duty of confidentiality existed. An employer alleging raiding by trade-secret misuse must identify the specific secret, show it took reasonable steps to protect it, and prove the departing employees acquired, disclosed, or used it improperly. Civil Code § 3426.3 authorizes recovery of actual loss plus unjust enrichment, or a reasonable royalty, and Civil Code § 3426.2 permits injunctive relief against actual or threatened misappropriation. Where misappropriation is willful and malicious, the court may award exemplary damages and attorney's fees.

The Inevitable-Disclosure Doctrine Is Rejected

Some states enjoin a former employee from working for a competitor on the theory that the employee will inevitably use the former employer's trade secrets. California rejects the inevitable-disclosure doctrine, consistent with its strong pro-mobility policy under § 16600. An employer cannot obtain an injunction merely by arguing that a departing employee knows secrets and will probably use them. It must show actual or threatened misappropriation. This rejection is a critical protection for employees: knowing confidential information does not, by itself, bar you from taking a competing job or recruiting colleagues.

Confidentiality Agreements That Survive

Not every restrictive clause is void. A properly drafted confidentiality or nondisclosure agreement that protects genuine trade secrets, without functioning as a disguised non-compete, is generally enforceable, because it restrains misuse of secret information rather than lawful competition. The danger for employers is overreach: a confidentiality clause so broad that it effectively prevents the employee from working in the field can be struck down as a de facto non-compete under Edwards and the AB 1076 reforms. The surviving agreements are those tied to actual, identifiable trade secrets protected by reasonable secrecy measures.

Practical Guidance for Departing Employees

An employee planning to leave and recruit colleagues in California should compete clean. Do not take, copy, download, or email the employer's confidential files, customer lists, or compensation data. Rely on memory and general skill, which travel with you, not on documents, which can trigger a CUTSA claim. Recruiting former coworkers is lawful; soliciting them using the former employer's secret information is not. Employees facing an attempt to enforce a void non-compete should know that under § 16600.5 they may have their own claim, with attorney's fees, against the employer that tried to enforce it.

Practical Guidance for Employers

Employers can no longer rely on non-solicitation or non-compete covenants to retain staff in California, and attempting to enforce them risks liability under AB 1076. The protection that remains is trade-secret law. Employers should identify and label genuine trade secrets, restrict access, use enforceable confidentiality agreements, and conduct exit interviews that remind departing employees of their confidentiality obligations. When a raid occurs, the viable claim is CUTSA misappropriation, not breach of a void covenant. For how idea and invention rights interact with these protections, see our guide to idea submission and Desny claims for California employees, and find more analysis on our California employment law news page.

What Employers Can Still Lawfully Protect

The death of the non-compete does not leave California employers defenseless. Several protections survive § 16600 because they restrain misconduct rather than lawful competition. Trade-secret protection under Civ. Code § 3426.1 remains fully available. Properly scoped confidentiality and nondisclosure agreements, tied to genuine secret information, are enforceable. An employer may protect against the physical taking of documents and data through computer-use policies and, where applicable, claims under computer-fraud statutes. During employment, the employee's duty of loyalty forbids actively soliciting coworkers or diverting business for a competitor while still on the payroll, a restriction that ends at separation but can support a claim for pre-departure disloyalty. And the sale-of-business and partnership exceptions preserve legitimate non-competes in genuine ownership transactions.

What employers cannot do is use any of these tools as a pretext to achieve what § 16600 forbids. A confidentiality agreement so sweeping that it bars the employee from using general skills, or a duty-of-loyalty theory stretched to prevent lawful post-employment recruiting, will be struck down. The surviving protections are real but bounded: they guard secrets and punish disloyalty, not the employee's freedom to compete once the employment ends. Employers who invest in genuine secrecy measures, clear confidentiality agreements tied to identified information, access controls, and well-documented exit procedures, are far better positioned when a raid occurs than those who relied on now-void covenants. The shift from contractual restraint to trade-secret protection rewards diligence in guarding information and penalizes companies that tried to lock in workers with unenforceable paper.

Why California Chose Mobility Over Restraint

California's hostility to restraints on competition is not an accident of drafting; it reflects a deliberate economic and public-policy judgment dating back more than a century. The state has long concluded that the free movement of talent fuels innovation, entrepreneurship, and economic dynamism. Scholars frequently credit this policy, embodied in Business and Professions Code § 16600, with contributing to the rise of California's technology economy, where engineers and executives move freely between firms and startups spin out of established companies. The courts enforce this policy robustly, construing the few statutory exceptions narrowly and refusing to import the reasonableness balancing that other states apply to non-competes.

Understanding this policy backdrop helps explain why California rejects doctrines like inevitable disclosure and why the 2024 reforms went so far as to penalize employers merely for including or trying to enforce void clauses. The Legislature and the courts share a view that restraints chill mobility even when they are never litigated, because employees often assume a signed non-compete is enforceable and stay put out of fear. The notice requirement in Business and Professions Code § 16600.1 directly targets that chilling effect by forcing employers to tell workers the truth: the clause is void.

The Narrow Sale-of-Business and Partnership Exceptions

Section 16600's ban is not quite absolute; the Legislature carved out limited exceptions, all of which involve the sale or dissolution of an ownership interest rather than ordinary employment. Business and Professions Code § 16601 permits a non-compete tied to the sale of the goodwill of a business or of an owner's entire interest, within a specified geographic area. Business and Professions Code § 16602 allows a non-compete among partners in connection with dissolution or dissociation, and § 16602.5 addresses members of a limited liability company. These exceptions are construed narrowly and do not rescue an ordinary employee non-compete. A worker who holds no meaningful ownership stake cannot be bound by a restraint dressed up as a sale-of-business covenant; courts look to substance, not labels.

Trade-Secret Identification With Reasonable Particularity

A company that sues for raiding on a trade-secret theory faces an early procedural hurdle unique to California. Code Civ. Proc. § 2019.210 requires a party alleging trade-secret misappropriation to identify the claimed trade secret with reasonable particularity before commencing discovery. This requirement prevents plaintiffs from using vague allegations as a fishing expedition to harass departed employees and learn a competitor's methods. The employer must describe what the secret actually is, not merely assert that secrets were taken. For employees defending a raiding claim, insisting on a proper § 2019.210 statement is often the first and most effective line of defense, because many claims collapse once the employer must specify exactly what confidential information was supposedly misused.

Customer Lists, Compensation Data, and Skill

The heart of most raiding disputes is whether particular information qualifies as a trade secret under Civ. Code § 3426.1. Customer lists occupy contested ground. A list that merely compiles publicly available names is not protectable, but a list reflecting substantial effort to identify specific customers, their needs, their decisionmakers, and their purchasing patterns, kept confidential, can be a trade secret. Compensation and staffing data may qualify where it is genuinely secret and valuable to competitors. By contrast, the general knowledge, skill, training, and professional relationships an employee builds over a career are not trade secrets and leave with the employee. Drawing this line carefully determines whether a workforce move is lawful competition or actionable misappropriation.

Tortious Interference and Related Claims

Employers sometimes supplement a trade-secret theory with claims for intentional interference with contractual relations or with prospective economic advantage, arguing that the raider lured away employees or customers improperly. These claims face a high bar in California, because interference with at-will employment is generally lawful and because § 16600 protects competition. To prevail on interference with prospective advantage, the plaintiff must prove an independently wrongful act, such as trade-secret misappropriation, fraud, or defamation, apart from the competition itself. Lawful recruiting of at-will employees is not independently wrongful, so these ancillary claims usually rise or fall with the trade-secret allegation at their core.

The Federal Defend Trade Secrets Act Overlay

California trade-secret claims increasingly travel alongside federal claims under the Defend Trade Secrets Act, 18 U.S.C. § 1836, which created a federal civil cause of action for misappropriation of trade secrets used in interstate commerce. The federal statute parallels CUTSA in many respects, defining a trade secret at 18 U.S.C. § 1839 and authorizing injunctions and damages. For a raiding dispute, a plaintiff may plead both the California claim under Civ. Code § 3426.1 and the federal claim, giving access to federal court. Importantly, the federal statute, like California law, does not override § 16600; it protects secrets, not market position, so lawfully recruiting a competitor's at-will workforce without misusing secret information remains permissible under both regimes. The federal law also contains a whistleblower immunity provision protecting disclosure of trade secrets to report suspected legal violations.

Garden Leave and Other Attempts to Evade the Ban

Employers have tried various devices to restrain mobility without a formal non-compete: forfeiture-for-competition clauses that strip earned compensation if the employee competes, overbroad confidentiality agreements that function as de facto non-competes, and so-called garden leave arrangements. California courts look through form to substance. A clause that penalizes an employee for competing, even if styled as a forfeiture rather than a prohibition, can be void under § 16600 and Edwards if its effect is to restrain the employee's profession. The 2024 reforms reinforce this skepticism, and § 16600.5 gives employees a weapon against employers who attempt to enforce these disguised restraints.

Talk to a California employment lawyer. Whether you are leaving to compete, building a new team, or trying to protect your workforce and trade secrets, California law draws a sharp line between lawful competition and misappropriation. The attorneys at Trembach Law Firm advise employees and employers on non-solicitation, raiding, and trade-secret disputes across California. Call (213) 645-2246 for a confidential consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my employer stop me from recruiting my coworkers after I leave?

Generally no. Under AMN Healthcare v. Aya Healthcare and Business and Professions Code § 16600, employee non-solicitation covenants are void as unlawful restraints on your profession. You are ordinarily free to recruit former colleagues, as long as you do not use the former employer's trade secrets to do it.

Are non-compete agreements enforceable in California?

No. Under § 16600 and Edwards v. Arthur Andersen, non-competes are void even if narrowly drawn. The 2024 reforms, Business and Professions Code § 16600.1 and § 16600.5, go further by requiring notice, voiding out-of-state non-competes against California workers, and giving employees a claim with attorney's fees.

When does hiring a former employer's staff become illegal?

When it involves trade-secret misappropriation. Moving workers and competing are lawful, but using the former employer's confidential, protected information, such as a true customer list or secret compensation data, to recruit or compete can violate CUTSA under Civil Code § 3426.1 and expose you to damages under Civil Code § 3426.3.

Can my employer sue me just because I know its secrets?

No. California rejects the inevitable-disclosure doctrine. An employer cannot enjoin you from a competing job merely because you know confidential information; it must show actual or threatened misappropriation. Your general knowledge, skill, and experience travel with you freely.

What should I avoid when leaving to compete in California?

Do not take, download, copy, or email the employer's confidential files, customer lists, or compensation data. Rely on memory and general skill, which are yours to keep, not documents, which can trigger a trade-secret claim under CUTSA. Recruiting colleagues is lawful; using stolen information to do it is not.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301