DUTY DRAWBACK | 2026-10-20
Harbor Maintenance Fee (HMF) Drawback: When HMT Can Be Recovered on Exports Under 19 U.S.C. § 1313(j)
What the Harbor Maintenance Tax is, why it is not charged on exports, which drawback claims can include it under 19 C.F.R. part 190, and how the 99 percent rule applies
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
The Harbor Maintenance Fee (HMF), known in the statute as the Harbor Maintenance Tax (HMT), is charged at 0.125 percent of the value of commercial cargo unloaded at covered U.S. ports. For importers that bring goods in by ocean vessel and later export them, a recurring question is whether that...
What Is the Harbor Maintenance Fee?
The Harbor Maintenance Fee is the trade community's common name for the Harbor Maintenance Tax imposed by 26 U.S.C. § 4461. The statute imposes a tax on any port use equal to 0.125 percent of the value of the commercial cargo involved, and the proceeds fund the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund, which pays for maintenance and dredging of federally authorized channels and harbors. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) administers the charge under 19 C.F.R. § 24.24, which describes it as a port use fee of 0.125 percent (.00125) of the value of commercial cargo loaded on or unloaded from a commercial vessel at a covered port, subject to listed exemptions and special rules.
For imported cargo, the importer is the party liable for the charge under 26 U.S.C. § 4461(c), and it is reported and paid with the entry summary along with duties and other fees. A few practical points follow from the way the charge is defined:
- It is tied to vessel cargo at covered ports. The charge applies to commercial cargo moved by commercial vessel through ports listed in the regulation. Merchandise that arrives by air, truck, or rail does not incur HMT at the border.
- It is calculated on value. Because the rate is ad valorem, the charge grows with the value of the shipment. On $10 million of ocean-imported merchandise, HMT at 0.125 percent is $12,500.
- It has exemptions and special rules. Section 24.24 contains exemptions and special rules, including rules for passengers and for merchandise admitted into a foreign trade zone. Whether a particular movement is covered should be confirmed against the current text of the regulation.
Although the amount on any single entry may look small, importers with steady ocean volume can pay significant HMT over a five-year period. That is the period that matters most for drawback, as discussed below.
Why HMT Is Not Charged on Exports: United States v. United States Shoe Corp.
As originally enacted, the Harbor Maintenance Tax applied to exports as well as imports. In United States v. United States Shoe Corp., 523 U.S. 360 (1998), the Supreme Court unanimously held that the HMT, as applied to goods loaded at U.S. ports for export, violates the Export Clause of the Constitution, which prohibits taxes on articles exported from any state. The government had argued that the charge was a permissible user fee. The Court rejected that argument because the HMT is assessed on the value of the cargo rather than on the extent or cost of the port services actually used, so it does not fairly match the benefits provided and operates as a tax on exports.
Since that decision, the HMT is not collected on export shipments. That matters for drawback in two ways. First, there is no HMT on the export side of a drawback transaction to offset. Second, it explains why HMT paid on the import side became the focus of drawback litigation: an importer that pays HMT when goods arrive and then exports those goods has borne a charge that an exporter of domestic goods does not bear.
The Legal History of HMT Drawback: Texport, the 2004 Amendment, and Aectra
Texport Oil Co. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 1999)
Drawback under 19 U.S.C. § 1313 has always been a refund of charges connected to importation. Before 2004, the unused merchandise drawback provision in § 1313(j) allowed drawback of duties, taxes, and fees imposed "because of" importation. In Texport Oil Co. v. United States, 185 F.3d 1291 (Fed. Cir. 1999), the Federal Circuit read that phrase to require a link to importation itself. The court concluded that the HMT, which applied in a nondiscriminatory way to all shipments using covered ports, was not imposed because of importation and therefore was not eligible for drawback. The Merchandise Processing Fee (MPF), which is explicitly tied to import activity, was treated differently and held eligible.
The Miscellaneous Trade and Technical Corrections Act of 2004
Congress responded in the Miscellaneous Trade and Technical Corrections Act of 2004, Pub. L. No. 108-429, § 1557. The amendment changed the language of § 1313(j) so that drawback reaches any duty, tax, or fee imposed under federal law "upon entry or importation," replacing the "because of importation" test that Texport had applied. Courts have described the purpose of the amendment as overturning Texport and eliminating the distinction between charges that discriminate against imports and those that do not. The amendment applied to drawback claims filed on or after the date of enactment, December 3, 2004, and to earlier drawback entries whose liquidation was not yet final on that date.
Aectra Refining & Marketing, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2009)
In Aectra Refining & Marketing, Inc. v. United States, 565 F.3d 1364 (Fed. Cir. 2009), a petroleum company had timely filed drawback claims in the late 1990s that sought refunds of import duties only, not HMT or MPF. After the 2004 amendment, it sought to recover those fees on the same transactions. The Court of International Trade found the request untimely, and the Federal Circuit affirmed, reading the 2004 amendment's retroactive reach narrowly. The practical lesson is direct: HMT and MPF must be claimed within the normal drawback filing deadline. A claimant that leaves eligible fees off a claim should not assume it can add them years later.
Which Drawback Claims Can Include HMT Under 19 C.F.R. § 190.3
The Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act of 2015 (TFTEA), signed into law on February 24, 2016, modernized drawback. CBP's implementing regulations, the Modernized Drawback rule codified at 19 C.F.R. part 190, were published in the Federal Register on December 18, 2018. Since February 24, 2019, all new drawback claims must be filed electronically in ACE under the TFTEA framework in part 190.
Section 190.3 lists the duties, taxes, and fees that are and are not subject to drawback. It allows drawback of Harbor Maintenance Tax (cross-referencing 19 C.F.R. § 24.24) and of Merchandise Processing Fees (cross-referencing 19 C.F.R. § 24.23) only in two situations:
- Unused merchandise drawback under 19 U.S.C. § 1313(j), which covers both direct identification claims under § 1313(j)(1) and substitution claims under § 1313(j)(2); and
- Drawback for substitution of finished petroleum derivatives under 19 U.S.C. § 1313(p)(2)(A)(iii) or (iv).
In all other cases, HMT and MPF are listed as not subject to drawback. That means HMT is generally not recoverable on manufacturing drawback claims under § 1313(a) (direct identification) or § 1313(b) (substitution), even though those claims can recover customs duties. Many published summaries state that HMT is drawback-eligible across all drawback types; under the current regulation, that is not correct.
Rejected merchandise drawback under § 1313(c) is not one of the provisions listed for HMT. Merchandise that is rejected because it does not conform to specifications or was shipped without the importer's consent can sometimes also satisfy the requirements for unused merchandise drawback under § 1313(j). Where both provisions could apply, the choice of drawback provision can determine whether HMT is recoverable, so it should be analyzed before the claim is filed.
| Drawback provision | Customs duties | HMT and MPF |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing, direct identification (§ 1313(a)) | Eligible | Not eligible under § 190.3 |
| Manufacturing, substitution (§ 1313(b)) | Eligible | Not eligible under § 190.3 |
| Rejected merchandise (§ 1313(c)) | Eligible | Not listed; consider whether § 1313(j) also applies |
| Unused merchandise, direct identification (§ 1313(j)(1)) | Eligible | Eligible |
| Unused merchandise, substitution (§ 1313(j)(2)) | Eligible | Eligible |
| Finished petroleum derivatives (§ 1313(p)(2)(A)(iii) or (iv)) | Eligible | Eligible |
Other charges have their own rules. Antidumping and countervailing duties, for example, are not refundable through drawback under 19 U.S.C. § 1677h. Every charge on an entry should be classified for drawback purposes rather than assumed to follow the treatment of ordinary duties.
Unused Merchandise Drawback: The Main Path to HMT Recovery
Because HMT recovery generally depends on § 1313(j), it helps to understand what unused merchandise drawback requires.
Direct Identification Under § 1313(j)(1)
Under § 1313(j)(1), when imported merchandise on which a duty, tax, or fee was paid upon entry or importation is exported or destroyed under CBP supervision within five years of importation, and is not used in the United States before that exportation or destruction, 99 percent of the amount of each duty, tax, or fee paid may be refunded as drawback. Common examples include goods imported into a California distribution center and later shipped to customers in Canada, Mexico, or Asia; goods returned to a foreign supplier; and goods destroyed under CBP supervision because they cannot be sold.
The merchandise must be identified as the same merchandise that was imported, which typically requires inventory records that trace the specific goods from the import entry to the export. Certain operations that do not amount to use, such as testing, inspecting, repacking, or relabeling, may be performed without disqualifying the merchandise, but the boundaries of what counts as "use" should be checked against the statute, regulations, and CBP rulings for the product involved.
Substitution Under § 1313(j)(2)
Section 1313(j)(2) allows drawback when domestic or imported merchandise that is substitutable for the imported merchandise is exported or destroyed unused within the statutory period. Under TFTEA, substitutability for unused merchandise claims is generally determined by classification under the same eight-digit subheading of the Harmonized Tariff Schedule, with special rules where that subheading begins with the term "other." Substitution is valuable for businesses that commingle imported and domestic inventory or that cannot practically trace individual units.
Because HMT is eligible for unused merchandise drawback, a substitution claim can include HMT paid on the designated import entries, subject to the calculation limits discussed in the next section.
How the 99 Percent Rule and the "Lesser Of" Limit Apply to HMT
Drawback is generally capped at 99 percent of the eligible duties, taxes, and fees paid. For a direct identification unused merchandise claim under § 1313(j)(1), the statute itself provides for refund of 99 percent of each duty, tax, or fee paid. If an importer paid $12,500 of HMT on merchandise that is later exported unused and fully designated on a valid claim, the maximum HMT drawback would be $12,375, the remaining 1 percent being retained by the government.
Substitution claims are more complex. Under TFTEA and 19 C.F.R. § 190.32(b), drawback on a substitution claim for an exported article is generally limited to 99 percent of the lesser of (1) the duties, taxes, and fees paid on the imported merchandise designated for the claim, or (2) the amount of duties, taxes, and fees that would apply to the exported article if it were imported. Parallel rules apply to destroyed merchandise, and certain claims, including some petroleum derivative claims, have their own calculation rules. Because HMT is calculated on value and applies only to vessel cargo at covered ports, applying the "lesser of" comparison to HMT requires care, and the calculation for a specific claim should be confirmed against the current regulations and CBP guidance before filing.
In short, the 99 percent figure is a ceiling, not a guarantee. The amount actually refunded depends on the drawback provision used, the quantity of merchandise designated, the substitution calculation where applicable, and whether CBP accepts the supporting documentation.
Merchandise Processing Fees Follow the Same Limits
The Merchandise Processing Fee, which CBP assesses on formal entries under 19 C.F.R. § 24.23 subject to minimum and maximum amounts, is treated the same way as HMT under § 190.3: it is eligible for unused merchandise drawback under § 1313(j) and for the finished petroleum derivative substitution provisions, and otherwise is not subject to drawback. Because MPF on a formal entry is subject to a per-entry minimum and maximum, allocating MPF to a portion of an entry that is designated for drawback requires a consistent, documented methodology. A claimant reviewing whether HMT is being captured should review MPF at the same time.
Deadlines and Timing for HMT Drawback Claims
Timing rules are where eligible HMT is most often lost. Under TFTEA, a drawback claim generally must be filed within five years after the date the merchandise on which drawback is claimed was imported, under 19 U.S.C. § 1313(r)(1). For unused merchandise drawback, the merchandise must also be exported or destroyed within the five-year statutory period, and 19 C.F.R. § 190.42 provides that drawback will be denied on merchandise exported or destroyed after that period. Claims that are not completed within the statutory period are treated as abandoned.
Before TFTEA, many of these windows were three years. The five-year period gives importers more room, but it does not reopen claims that were already untimely, and, as Aectra shows, fees omitted from a timely claim may not be recoverable later. Building HMT into the claim at the time of filing is the safest approach. Our article on the five-year drawback statute of limitations explains these deadlines in more detail.
Documenting HMT in a Drawback Claim
An HMT drawback claim is only as strong as its records. CBP may request documentation during review of a claim, and the claimant must be able to support each element.
- Import side. Entry summaries showing the HMT paid on each designated entry, the port of unlading, and the entered value. Because HMT applies only to vessel cargo at covered ports, records should confirm that the designated entry actually incurred HMT.
- Traceability or substitution. For direct identification, inventory records that link the imported goods to the exported or destroyed goods. For substitution, records establishing that the substituted merchandise meets the classification standard and that quantities designated do not exceed the merchandise available on the import entry.
- Non-use. Evidence that the merchandise was not used in the United States before export or destruction, including a description of any permitted handling.
- Export or destruction. Proof of export, such as electronic export information and commercial shipping documents, or records of destruction under CBP supervision.
- Calculation. A worksheet showing how HMT was allocated to the designated quantity and, for substitution claims, how the "lesser of" limitation was applied.
Federal law requires drawback records to be kept for a set period. Under 19 U.S.C. § 1508(c)(3) and 19 C.F.R. § 190.15, records that pertain to a drawback claim must be kept for 3 years after the claim is liquidated, or longer if another law requires it, which can be many years after the underlying import. Record-keeping systems should be set up with that horizon in mind. Our article on drawback claim documentation covers record-keeping practices more broadly.
Practical Considerations for California Importers and Exporters
California's ports handle a large share of the nation's ocean imports, and many California businesses import by vessel through the San Pedro Bay ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach, or through Oakland or San Diego, before distributing goods domestically and abroad. Those businesses pay HMT on every covered ocean entry. Several situations deserve attention:
- Distributors and re-exporters. Companies that import finished goods and later ship some of them to foreign customers may have unused merchandise drawback claims that can include HMT, MPF, and duties.
- Returns to foreign suppliers. Defective or non-conforming goods sent back abroad may qualify under § 1313(j) or § 1313(c). The provision chosen affects whether HMT is included.
- Manufacturers. A company that imports components and incorporates them into exported products may recover duties through manufacturing drawback, but HMT on those components is generally not recoverable under § 190.3.
- Mixed programs. Companies with both manufacturing and unused merchandise exports should categorize each export correctly, because the same imported entry may support different claim types with different fee eligibility.
- Foreign trade zones. Merchandise admitted to a foreign trade zone is subject to special HMT rules under § 24.24, and drawback treatment of zone merchandise has its own requirements. See our article on drawback and FTZ merchandise.
Drawback software and broker data feeds should be checked to confirm that HMT and MPF amounts are captured at the entry level and are applied only to eligible claim types. A program that adds HMT to manufacturing claims risks claim adjustments; a program that omits HMT from eligible unused merchandise claims leaves recoverable money unclaimed. For background on how TFTEA changed drawback overall, see our article on TFTEA drawback modernization.
Frequently Asked Questions About Harbor Maintenance Fee Drawback
What is the Harbor Maintenance Fee rate?
The rate is 0.125 percent of the value of the commercial cargo involved, under 26 U.S.C. § 4461 and 19 C.F.R. § 24.24. For imported cargo, the importer is liable for the charge.
Is the Harbor Maintenance Tax charged on exports?
No. In United States v. United States Shoe Corp., 523 U.S. 360 (1998), the Supreme Court held that applying the HMT to goods loaded at U.S. ports for export violates the Export Clause of the Constitution.
Can HMF be recovered on manufacturing drawback claims?
Generally no. Under 19 C.F.R. § 190.3, HMT and MPF are subject to drawback only for unused merchandise drawback under 19 U.S.C. § 1313(j) and for substitution of finished petroleum derivatives under § 1313(p)(2)(A)(iii) or (iv). Manufacturing drawback under § 1313(a) and § 1313(b) can recover duties but not HMT.
How much HMF can be recovered through drawback?
For eligible claims, drawback is capped at 99 percent of the HMT paid on the designated merchandise. On substitution claims, the refund is generally limited to 99 percent of the lesser of the amount paid on the imported merchandise or the amount that would apply to the exported article if it were imported, under 19 C.F.R. § 190.32(b).
What is the deadline to file an HMF drawback claim?
Under TFTEA, a drawback claim generally must be filed within five years after the date of importation of the merchandise designated for the claim, and unused merchandise must be exported or destroyed within the five-year statutory period.
Can I add HMF to a drawback claim I already filed?
Do not assume so. In Aectra Refining & Marketing, Inc. v. United States, 565 F.3d 1364 (Fed. Cir. 2009), a claimant that had filed timely claims for duties only was not permitted to recover HMT and other fees on those transactions years later. Eligible fees should be included when the claim is filed and within the statutory deadline.
Is the Merchandise Processing Fee also eligible for drawback?
Yes, on the same limited basis as HMT. Section 190.3 allows MPF drawback for unused merchandise claims under § 1313(j) and for the finished petroleum derivative provisions, and not for other drawback types.
Does HMF apply to goods imported by air or truck?
No. The charge applies to commercial cargo loaded on or unloaded from a commercial vessel at a covered port, so air, truck, and rail imports do not incur HMT and have no HMT to recover.
Talk With Trembach Law Firm About HMF and Duty Drawback
If your business imports by ocean vessel and exports or destroys some of that merchandise, Trembach Law Firm can review whether your claims are capturing HMT and MPF where the law allows, whether your claim types and documentation support those fees, and how the five-year deadlines affect past and future transactions. Attorney Anatolii Trembach is a member of the State Bar of California and holds an LL.M. from the USC Gould School of Law. Learn more on our duty drawback attorney page and our international trade and customs page, or call (818) 514-7680 for a free consultation.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301